Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Grape Ape on April 29, 2016, 03:41:10 AM
-
Can someone explain the difference to me please?
(In as close to layman's terms as possible)
-
On a C/F box for example (the keys most likely to have a Dutch reversal or gleichton)
Find the button in the middle of the inner (F) row that plays a C on push and D on pull on the usual system.
Club system (gleichton): that button plays C both ways.
Dutch reversal: that button plays D on push and C on pull.
For a D/G box, it's the D/E button that plays D/D in club system and E/D in Dutch reversal.
It only happens on the middle button of the inner row.
For a Steirische box with more than two rows, there's a gleichton on all except the outer row.
-
D/G layout (D and G are notes) ;)
The middle D on its G row is on a D push E pull plate
D is also push on its D row, and E is also pull - not efficient!
So the "Dutch" simply turn the plate over, making many musical phrases chords, tunes even playable in both directions. It is logical, flexible, but has a cost in G row playability … as I discovered when I did it for a summer.
meanwhile, somewhere in Bavaria, maybe even in "Gleichton" (?) a different approach. The G row's E pull … was filed to play D. So D both ways. This facilitates play runs, and chord extends (eg Em7's "7" is D) on pull while leaving push play unaffected. I did this to my Lilly as my daughter hoped to play chords on it. It is a system I like, massively popular in Germany, and eminently playable without too much brain surgery. :|glug
-
I can't believe I called it a G/D box! Corrected now :|bl
-
Club system (gleichton): that button plays C both ways.
[snip]
For a D/G box, it's the D/E button that plays D/D in club system and E/D in Dutch reversal.
It only happens on the middle button of the inner row.
Also on the last (highest pitch) button on the C row the pull D is replaced with a pull C in the club system. But very few people notice.
Also on the highest pitch button on the
-
Sorry to dig up a very old thread but I've been looking into Dutch reversals after being caught out by three or four tunes in a short span of time - why is it on the G row and not the D row that the button gets shifted? Forgive me if that's a silly question, I for some reason envisioned it on the D row and quite liked the idea.
-
Sorry to dig up a very old thread but I've been looking into Dutch reversals after being caught out by three or four tunes in a short span of time - why is it on the G row and not the D row that the button gets shifted? Forgive me if that's a silly question, I for some reason envisioned it on the D row and quite liked the idea.
There's no point in reversing the G and A A and B on the D row because those reversals are already available on the G row.
And if you mean the D button in the middle of the D row, the pull note is C♯ which would be a real nuisance as a push note and you wouldn't have the push E.
-
meanwhile, somewhere in Bavaria, maybe even in "Gleichton" (?) a different approach.
Hi Chris - not sure if your reference to gleichton as a place was a joke or not, but it is actually just German for "Same Tone"! ;)
-
Long time ago now, but it looks like a witticism in the context that I said it. But … thanks for putting me right 👍
See you again in about 2029 => ? <=
-
Sorry to dig up a very old thread but I've been looking into Dutch reversals after being caught out by three or four tunes in a short span of time - why is it on the G row and not the D row that the button gets shifted? Forgive me if that's a silly question, I for some reason envisioned it on the D row and quite liked the idea.
There is only one button on the entire box where the two notes available are also available somewhere else in the same direction. An octave above these are paired with other non duplicated notes.
So with a bit of skill and practice you could do without this button entirely and that's worth persuing so you play everybody else's box. BUT reverse this button on a DG and you have access to a G6 chord with the push E and a proper D7 with the pull D. Cross rowing phrases are extended.
I wish I had done it when I started playing . I've been using it for 3 or 4 years now and I'm getting comfortable with it.
-
Long time ago now, but it looks like a witticism in the context that I said it. But … thanks for putting me right 👍
See you again in about 2029 => ? <=
Oops! Didn't see the original date!!
-
I think the "gleichton" layout is useful for a Hohner Club layout (2.5 row), for instance on a C/F, there is a C on push and pull on the F row. The standard club layout of a C/F also has a D on push and pull, one on the accidentals row and one on the C row.
For a 2 row (C/F), there usually is no gleichtone, as you do not have the extra D on push. People tend to "turn the C/D plates" on the inner row (under the 5th button). Some even do that for button number 2 and 8 on the inner row, to have the C on push and pull...
-
And then there's the other duplicate push D - button 2 (or 3 on 4th button start) on G row.
I've had that changed to E on my Dony and Mory - which have D/E reversals on the part row - incredibly useful.
Julian