Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: forrest on May 11, 2016, 05:30:17 PM

Title: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: forrest on May 11, 2016, 05:30:17 PM
  A couple years back, I acquired a vintage Hohner 2915 (an "old grey" one  ;)) that I converted to D/G, with 4th button start and the extended G row, 'Anahata Layout'. At the time, I thought that this layout was (and still is) a great solution to getting more balance at the lower end of the box. I never did get along with the accidentals, though, and really missed having the low F# on the D row.

  So that set me to tinkering, and after several calculations, trials and errors, etc... I came up with a layout that was quite versatile and exciting. Then I searched the forum to see what others might have put forward, and was delighted to see that this was not new, but was already thought of and endorsed by at least two esteemed melnet contributors. It appeared in this post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,17904.msg219503.html#msg219503) from December of last year, and I wish I had noticed and read it, as it would have saved some blundering about on my part.

   I think it works best for a simple 2 voice 2 row box. A three voice certainly adds quite a lot of range and richness to D/G tuning, so would not have the same benefit, And if you can live without the accidentals, it really does open up another realm of possibilities for a simple D/G.
   Anyway, here's a chart I made of the layout for D/G as it sits on my Hohner. I would be interested in any comments about this.  Malcolm and Steve Freereeder: do you gentlemen have instruments with this layout?


Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 11, 2016, 06:23:54 PM
It looks interesting and great to lower the chin end more but you have touched on the major problem for me - I cannot do without the accidentals!
It sort of reminds me of a 2.5 row layout where the accidentals are all cleared out onto the half row.
As ever, I suppose it comes down to what you play and therefore whether you need those accidental notes.
Q
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 11, 2016, 06:29:08 PM
My "Anahada'd" Lilly is 4th start. So his low end, and accidentals.

What's the problem?,
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 11, 2016, 06:51:35 PM
The only note I know I've missed is a low Fnat, but not sufficiently to change anything from the Anahata layout. I merely cheated!
Q
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: forrest on May 11, 2016, 07:23:05 PM
My "Anahada'd" Lilly is 4th start. So his low end, and accidentals.

What's the problem?,

If you are enjoying, Chris, there is no problem. Personally, I missed the low F# on the D row, So I simply moved the G/A plate to the bottom of the G row. Then, restored my F# with a B pull (for Em) on button 2 of D row, and added low D/E on the bottom of D row. Now D row is extended a full octave, along with much of Em, and C. G row is  further extended one note below octave by using low D press on the D row. A pull is also extended. I prefer this setup to having accidentals, at least on this box, and of course its success at one style of music may hinder it in others, as is the case with melodeons in general. (:)

Edited for clarity
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Baron Collins-Hill on May 11, 2016, 10:06:43 PM
I am a huge fan or the low d scale. So many tunes don't go lower than D, so it gives you the ability to play them down the octave. I'm more familiar with it which paired with a helper row of accidentals a la Bob Ellis's layout, but I can see it being very affective on a two row if you dont need the accidentals. I agree that with this layout three voices becomes excessive.

I hope you find what you are looking for!
Baron
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: forrest on May 11, 2016, 10:35:17 PM
I am a huge fan or the low d scale. So many tunes don't go lower than D, so it gives you the ability to play them down the octave. I'm more familiar with it which paired with a helper row of accidentals a la Bob Ellis's layout, but I can see it being very affective on a two row if you dont need the accidentals. I agree that with this layout three voices becomes excessive.

I hope you find what you are looking for!
Baron

Yes, with limited space, it seems to work well. It's teaching me new tricks.  Of course if one has another partial row, then acc's are possible as well. I am still building my helper row of 4 buttons on my C/F Erika and trying to select the notes that assist on that score.
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 11, 2016, 11:28:56 PM
Has anyone tried a 5th button start? Best of both worlds, at the expense of squeaky notes a lot of people never use anyway (yes, I know, a lot of people do. but a lot don't).
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on May 12, 2016, 01:41:11 AM
Not sure which Malcolm is referred to in the original post, but the keyboard shown is indeed my favoured "non-accidental"  layout, allowing some rich low harmony possibilities.

Using two shoulder straps helps, so that I can use my thumb on certain buttons without sacrificing stability, but then I feel somehow constricted in my playing position.

I did once try a button 5 start so that I had low notes plus accidentals, but the stretch to reach the accidentals was just too great. Additionally, I missed not having the top notes that a button 4 start allows, though that could have been overcome by using a 23 button instrument rather than a 21 if I had had one available for conversion at the time.

Seems to me that the melodeon world (at least in Oz) is fairly equally divided between low note and accidental aficionados. Over the years I reckon I have done an equal number of conversions from one to the other, but that's straying off topic.

Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Harmonicatunes on May 12, 2016, 04:14:43 AM
Looks interesting. I prefer the low notes, So an entire low D an G row would be nice. I'm in Australia, part of the low note camp, but prepared to have dealing with the other mob.
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 12, 2016, 07:24:14 AM
I've heard too that a 5th button start is too much of a stretch.
I can cope with a 4th button start and regularly hit the every time accidentals on my Castagnari Hascy.
My Hohner Erika has slightly larger button spacing. Imperceptible when playing normally, but just that minute 'extra' spacing means I sometimes miss the chin accidentals. A 5th button start would be beyond me.

( Note: I have duplicated exactly the Anahata layout on the Erika, so use chin end accidentals rather than the half row, to give uniformity of keyboard layout across my boxes )
Q
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 12, 2016, 08:02:19 AM
..... Steve Freereeder: do you have instruments with this layout?

No. Not any more. I came to the realisation a long time ago that:


I attach my own personal prefereinces for a D/G 11+10 in both 'standard' Castagnari and Anahata layouts. 
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Anahata on May 12, 2016, 08:05:28 AM
Horses for courses, obviously...
I wouldn't call forrest's plan any kind of extension of my layout, it has a quite different aim of sacrificing accidentals for lots of much lower notes without too many duplicates, and I guess that low D is a good lowest note to aim for if you want to do that.

For the record, my plan was:
5th button start has been mentioned before, and Q is right that if you have mid-accidentals on the end buttons they are too far away. But I did have a 2.5 row Saltarelle (the one Kevbox is now selling) with low-octave accidentals on the end buttons, mid accidentals on the half row, and with G scale modification that was fully chromatic over 3 octaves. That seemed a logical enough scheme, with low G♯ and B♭ right next to the low G.

Edit: 'old-school' = Castagnari
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on May 12, 2016, 08:50:58 AM

So an entire low D and G row would be nice.

Not quite sure what you meant here, Tony, but it rang bells, so I looked up my workshop notes regarding my  "experimental" button 5 start....

After I decided that accidentals plus low notes didn't work for me on a button 5 start, I apparently changed the first 4 notes to give me exactly that: entire low D and G rows without having to cross row, as follows:

G/A   B/C   D/E   G/F#  (G/A  B/C  etc.)

D/E  F#/G   A/B  D/C#  (D/E  F#/G  etc.)

(Call it a button 1 start???)

It seemed a shame to waste the duplicated G and D and I was going to lower them to F and C naturals respectively, but some one wanted to buy this melodeon as it stood because he apparently had a harmonica with similar duplicated notes and range, so off it went somewhere into the NSW bush, never to be seen again....

(I think from memory I may have also put duplicate notes at the top of the next octave for him, even further reducing the range at the dusty end....)

So many potential fingerings, so little time....
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: AirTime on May 12, 2016, 03:04:38 PM
Quote
On a 11+10 two row D/G box, a 4th button start is a good way to achieve this, but that is the maximum sacrifice of high pitch (knee-end) buttons I am prepared to make. I use those top notes, especially on a LMM box with a low-octave voice switched in.

If you're going to throw in a third voice,you could equally add a helper row of accidentals for a 2 voice. With a 21/8 2 voice DG it would seem to me to be more useful to have the lower octave notes than the squeaky notes, which I think is Forrest's point ... & I notice that Forrest makes particularly good use of the low notes in his playing. The thing about the accidental buttons, is that for a tune that doesn't require them (which is the majority of tunes,) they are completely pointless, whereas having notes in the lower octave allows for embellishment or harmonies on most tunes & in terms of a DG box can make a whole repertoire of non-DG tunes accessible.

One possible solution, which few Melnetters may have considered, is having more than one box!   ;)  I notice that the Button Box currently has a 5th button start DG Serenellini Dona on offer. However, it also has a full row of accidentals PLUS a 23 button keyboard ... so it's got all the bases covered!

http://www.buttonbox.com/button-accordions-in-stock.html#three

.
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: forrest on May 12, 2016, 03:45:25 PM
  For the record, I just want to say that my intent is not to judge accidentals vs. low notes, but only a personal observation and decision for one particular box. Also, I did not originate this layout, it seems to have existed all along in the minds of others. I guess we are all united in the quest for trying to get the most versatility out of our instruments given their limitations and the variety of our tastes; what to keep and what to let go.
 
 This has to be quote of the year though...

  "One possible solution, which few Melnetters may have considered, is having more than one box!".........AirTime
 
                                                           ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: rees on May 12, 2016, 04:19:07 PM
 
 This has to be quote of the year though...

  "One possible solution, which few Melnetters may have considered, is having more than one box!".........AirTime
 
                                                           ;D ;D ;D

That's the funniest thing I've ever heard in my entire life!
Title: Re: Alternative D/G Low Note Layout for 21/8
Post by: Baron Collins-Hill on May 13, 2016, 12:18:10 AM
I play a 5th button start D/G/Acc three row, but it's pretty quirky and I wouldn't wish it upon any unsuspecting melodeonist. It gets me down to C below the low D. Layout attached:

Thanks,
Baron
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal