Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Cooper on May 12, 2016, 01:54:22 PM

Title: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 12, 2016, 01:54:22 PM
Hey! I was looking for a list of most occuring reeds with their specifics. Lots of it is probably subjective, but i would like to sieve out the general idea. Specifics could be,..responsiveness, volumerange (soft to loud), stability, sound, aging, availablity, usefulness in style x? etc.

Salpa tipo a mano
Salpa a mano
Binci tipo a mano
Binci a mano
Antonelli tipo a mano
Antonelli a mano
Dix tipo a mano
Dix a mano
Ciccarelli tipo a mano
Ciccareli a mano
Cagnoni tipo a mano
Cagnoni a mano
Hohner
any more?

I would like to try and make a semi-objective list so people can choose reeds according to their likings

I have not a lot of different reeds that i have tried...but i will start. And as always, it is difficult to take the effect from reeds on playing and sound and seperate that from build of the box etc...i know that,...And i also know that many reeds can be tweeked and worked on until they work much better than before,...that's why i would like as many different opinions as possible, trying to remove the factors "box" or "amount of tweek" by large numbers ;-)

Salpa TaM; found in older Castagnaris i believe, no longer available. Still the most pleasant reeds to play on for me. Good sound in the middleground (not very dark, nor very bright), very responsive, stable, not too loud.

Antonelli TaM; they bought Salpa. quite responsive, bit less then Salpa TaM, the same sound as the Salpa's, a bit louder, stable

Binci a mano; a lovely dark sound, very very responsive, very wide volumerange, not that stable, not that punchy for a lot of push-pull stuff.

Antonelli a mano:  Good sound in the middleground (not very dark, nor very bright), very responsive, not too loud, less stable than the TaM version, and less punchy, but a lot more stable and punchy than the Binci a mano

Ciccralli a mano, only played once; seemed bright, loud, very responsive, stable and punchy.

Please concur, contradict, add at leisure and will :-)
 
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 12, 2016, 02:14:33 PM
On the history of Salpa and Antonelli I believe you are confused.
Around the year 2000 Salpa and Antonelli merged, I don't know if one took over the other or if it was more a equal partnership.  The new company had a new name Voci Armoniche.
I have only seen Antonelli and Voci Armoniche reeds in Castagnari. I don't think they used Salpa.

Other reed makers still in production, Arigiana and the Czech maker Harmonicas of Louny.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: rees on May 12, 2016, 04:12:40 PM
Harminikas make DIX reeds. I think there is only one grade of DIX with a choice of aluminium, zinc or brass shoes.
Harmonikas also make three grades of A Mano and one of Tipo a Mano.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Lars on May 12, 2016, 04:42:30 PM
Ciccarelli is, according to himself, out of the business again. A shame, I liked the reeds (including the Bombarde reeds he made, I don't know of anyone else making that specific type).
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: diatonix on May 12, 2016, 05:27:50 PM
One should distinguish between reed producers (larger factories) and reed finishers such as Ciccarelli who gets (with some luck...) his raw reeds and frames from his former employer Artigiana Voci. The Bincis too are said to be not entirely autonomous and may depend on the good will of some of the better equipped factories. Lots of stuff going on behind curtains, such as Ciccarelli at times working for Binci...
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: boxer on May 12, 2016, 06:20:35 PM
I wonder whether the setup of the reed, the shape and substance of the block, not to mention the overall build of the instrument, might influence things like response and sound to some extent.

As an extreme example of the build thing, I don't think that putting the reeds from a Pokerwork into something like a Tommy would necessarily give you an expensive, but more compact, Pokerwork.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 12, 2016, 06:59:39 PM
And Carini have in their catalogue a long list of reed frames, tongues and rivets, but they don't say who makes them. 
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: sticky fingers on May 12, 2016, 07:01:32 PM
Super Durall!, whatever they are!
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Rob2Hook on May 12, 2016, 07:42:05 PM
As an extreme example of the build thing, I don't think that putting the reeds from a Pokerwork into something like a Tommy would necessarily give you an expensive, but more compact, Pokerwork.

It's been done!  And the result was a nice one - not quite Hohner, but definitely not Castagnari either.

Rob.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: forrest on May 12, 2016, 07:57:55 PM
Cooper, thanks for this interesting thread. Could you please define "stable" as you have used it above...... :||:
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 13, 2016, 11:10:30 AM
Thx for all the replies people! I wasn't surprised that i had some things wrong, lie that salpa thing etc,.. was just hearsay. :-)
And thx for all the additional information and possible reeds too!

But i haven't had many people actually giving opinions on the reeds, and that's what most important to me!

(btw, if you are certain of some things, don't hesitate to quote my first mail, and adjust what was wrong)

As for "stable",..i was afraid someone might ask that,...i find it difficult to put my finger on it,...What i am thinking of is this: when you do really fast push-pull-sequences with some reeds they don't make sound right away. Those are plain bad reeds imo,assuming they are tweaked as best as they could, and the box is fine. But there are also reeds that react right away, but don't carry "body" right away. Or something like that, it takes some time to really be present or something like that. I have that with Binci a mano reeds (on several boxes). They react very well, i can play very soft and very loud, but for those faster movement thingies,...well they make sound right away, but i dont like the way they sound in those instances. Once a longer note is played they just sound their lovely self again. That's one aspect. Another thing i notice that,...i use small dynamics within notes now and then, and they work way better on my antonelli reeds (all three boxes) then on my binci boxes, it seems the difference in pressure works more in volume for the Antonelli/VA reeds, whereas the difference in pressure on the binci seems to work more on frequency/sound quality. (this can also be interesting btw, but not what i look for)

As for build of the box having lots of influence...yes, i spoke of that in the original question, thats why i would love as much different boxes/players/playstyles to respond with their findings.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 13, 2016, 11:21:19 AM
adjusted a bit according to the comments from above.

Hey! I was looking for a list of most occuring reeds with their specifics. Lots of it is probably subjective, but i would like to sieve out the general idea. Specifics could be,..responsiveness, volumerange (soft to loud), stability, sound, aging, availablity, usefulness in style x? etc.

Salpa tipo a mano
Salpa a mano

Antonelli tipo a mano
Antonelli a mano

Binci tipo a mano
Binci a mano

Voci Armoni TaM
Voci Armoni a Mano

Dix Alu/Zinc/Brass

Harmonikas a mano
Hrmonikas TaM

Ciccarelli tipo a mano
Ciccareli a mano

Cagnoni tipo a mano
Cagnoni a mano

Hohner

super dural (isnt that a standard reed or something?)

any more?

I would like to try and make a semi-objective list so people can choose reeds according to their likings

I have not a lot of different reeds that i have tried...but i will start. And as always, it is difficult to take the effect from reeds on playing and sound and seperate that from build of the box etc...i know that,...And i also know that many reeds can be tweeked and worked on until they work much better than before,...that's why i would like as many different opinions as possible, trying to remove the factors "box" or "amount of tweek" by large numbers ;-)

Antonelli TaM; found in older Castagnaris i believe, no longer available. Still the most pleasant reeds to play on for me. Good sound in the middleground (not very dark, nor very bright), very responsive, stable, not too loud.

Voci Armoni TaM; merge from Salpa and Antonelli. quite responsive, bit less then Antonelli TaM, the same sound, a bit louder, stable

Voci Armoni a mano:  Good sound in the middleground (not very dark, nor very bright), very responsive, not too loud, less stable than the TaM version, and less punchy, but a lot more stable and punchy than the Binci a mano

Binci a mano; a lovely dark sound, very very responsive, very wide volumerange, not that stable, not that punchy for a lot of push-pull stuff.

Ciccralli a mano, only played once; seemed bright, loud, very responsive, stable and punchy.

Please concur, contradict, add, adjust at leisure and will :-)

What does Cairdin use btw?

Could you perhaps quote the previous mentions of a reed, and then add your own thoughts about them?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 13, 2016, 11:25:52 AM
Much of what you are calling stability is down to how well the reeds are set and tuned. My experience of all the makes of a a Mano reeds is that they can be set up to make a stable sound, but it depends critically on really precise setting if the individual reeds so that with two voice the two reeds start at precisely the same moment.  Most new boxes from big makers are not set up for the ultimate reed response.  There is one exception that is the a Mano reeds found in some Saltarelles.  They are unbranded but have all the visible signs of true a Mano reeds (hand clenched rivet, blue edged reed head) but the playing quality is poor even with the most careful setting.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 13, 2016, 11:38:50 AM
Much of what you are calling stability is down to how well the reeds are set and tuned. My experience of all the makes of a a Mano reeds is that they can be set up to make a stable sound, but it depends critically on really precise setting if the individual reeds so that with two voice the two reeds start at precisely the same moment.  Most new boxes from big makers are not set up for the ultimate reed response.  There is one exception that is the a Mano reeds found in some Saltarelles.  They are unbranded but have all the visible signs of true a Mano reeds (hand clenched rivet, blue edged reed head) but the playing quality is poor even with the most careful setting.

All my boxes are setup by the same tuner/tweaker, so there is no difference there, for me the Binci's work like described, and the others dont. And i tried someone else once to try and improve it, but with the same result. But please, add your findings too :-) i might be the odd man out.

Good to know about the saltarelle reeds. Is that their own brand then?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 13, 2016, 11:55:29 AM
Saltarelle are not manufacturers.  They commission other people to make their boxes including reeds and other hardware.  They don't say who they get their reeds from, and I think they use several different reed makers.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: TomB on May 13, 2016, 11:58:14 AM
On their website, Cairden do not specify a make of reed used. That allows them to change reed make as and when.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 13, 2016, 12:42:52 PM
Saltarelle are not manufacturers.  They commission other people to make their boxes including reeds and other hardware.  They don't say who they get their reeds from, and I think they use several different reed makers.
But in your opinion they are all just as bad?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 13, 2016, 01:02:45 PM
Saltarelle are not manufacturers.  They commission other people to make their boxes including reeds and other hardware.  They don't say who they get their reeds from, and I think they use several different reed makers.
But in your opinion they are all just as bad?

No they seem to vary some much better than others.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Phil B on May 13, 2016, 01:10:59 PM
Saltarelle reeds, "But in your opinion they are all just as bad?" In my experience no, I have had one Saltarelle that was very disappointing and another that is a real dream to play . As I believe, it has been said before, they are very variable
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: rileycat on May 13, 2016, 05:27:58 PM
I have a Saltarelle Nuage with retro - fitted Binci Professional reeds (marked as such).  Not sure where they lie on the list, but it plays superbly in every respect after a tweak - way better than any other Nuage I've tried - in fact better than anything I've tried (and MAD has taken its toll on my bank account over the years!).  Only an Oakwood with Salpas and a DB Oakwood with Bincis comes close to it for my use, so i guess the advice for Satarelle's is open them up first to see what's fitted. Same applies to the Salpas in my Marc Savoy (C), which are also very responsive - others may be less so.  The only new box I've ever owned is my  recent Rees-made Corvette in D with Binci's (not sure which grade), but it is playing in to be a brilliant instrument across the board.

With Hohner, I have had 2 Erika's fitted with Hohner 235 Model reeds from the 30's (I think).  They're very nice and make a lovely balance between volume, response and tone (again subjective, of course) and seem a step up from the Club type reeds normally used in this model. They suit song usage rather than out and out power playing, but they ain't too far off ! I think they were also fitted to Hohner Morinos, too in the 30's, but I could be wrong.  Mike Rowbotham and Theo would know this. They make an Erika into an even nicer player, once properly fettled, and I think that last bit is very important - a good tuner really can transform an instrument well beyond the initially apparent limitations of the standard reed-set.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Graham Spencer on May 13, 2016, 07:41:08 PM
Saltarelle reeds, "But in your opinion they are all just as bad?" In my experience no, I have had one Saltarelle that was very disappointing and another that is a real dream to play . As I believe, it has been said before, they are very variable

I've had my Saltarelle a LONG time, and the reeds fitted from new have given me no problems whatever - sweet, responsive, loud when needed and still full-sounding when played quietly; in short, everything you'd want. They have no maker's mark, but the (well known and respected) dealer I bought it from told me they were Binci TAM. They may be, they may not be - but I'm not really bothered as, whatever they are, they do everything I want a melodeon reed to do.  A few years back I played a Connemara II belonging to a friend, and it and my Pastourelle II were like chalk and cheese. So yes, they do vary from batch to batch - probably depending on what sort of a deal they can get at any given time.

Graham
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 14, 2016, 12:42:55 AM
Much of what you are calling stability is down to how well the reeds are set and tuned. My experience of all the makes of a a Mano reeds is that they can be set up to make a stable sound, but it depends critically on really precise setting if the individual reeds so that with two voice the two reeds start at precisely the same moment.  Most new boxes from big makers are not set up for the ultimate reed response. ...
But what i am really interested in, as you say, all a Mano reeds can be made as "stable" as the other, after tweaking, so that is something they all have in common. But what do you think makes them al different? What makes a Binci a Binci and a VA a VA, and a Dix a Dix?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 14, 2016, 08:18:33 AM
Mainly the fifference is in the sound quality   and that is well known to be difficult to put into words.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 14, 2016, 02:29:08 PM
Mainly the fifference is in the sound quality   and that is well known to be difficult to put into words.
I completly agree,...but...would you mind trying? :-)
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 14, 2016, 02:56:12 PM
Mainly the fifference is in the sound quality   and that is well known to be difficult to put into words.
I completly agree,...but...would you mind trying? :-) I mean, i am looking for the right words as well,...perhaps we can find some common ground?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: rees on May 14, 2016, 04:17:57 PM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 15, 2016, 03:36:50 PM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?
Hmmm, are you being serious? Because that actually might help :-)
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: rees on May 15, 2016, 06:03:05 PM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?
Hmmm, are you being serious? Because that actually might help :-)

Totally serious. As Theo said it's difficult to put into words so I used my imagination and came up with the band analogy.
I tried to do it with flowers, tastes, colours, birds, etc. but the bands worked best for me.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Pearse Rossa on May 15, 2016, 10:59:08 PM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?
Hmmm, are you being serious? Because that actually might help :-)

Totally serious.

Useful perhaps, if you are au fait with their music. I'm not. Seriously.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: blunderbox on May 16, 2016, 04:37:37 AM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?

I find that analogies are harder to decipher than descriptions.  To my ears, stones records are mixed/mastered with a fair degree of 500 - 1k 'honk' whereas pink floyd records tend to have a pronounced mid range scoop, emphasizing the low end and crispy highs.  Tattoo you and dark side of the moon for example, same era, different sound.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Theo on May 16, 2016, 08:33:11 AM
I'm sorry Cooper, I can't put it into words in any useful way. Motorcycle engine analogy maybe:
Binci - Brough Superior
Antonelli - Indian Four
VA - 1950s BSA twin
Dix - BMW
Cagnoni - Norton Commando.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Winston Smith on May 16, 2016, 09:03:45 AM
It's about now that Graham Chapman would burst onto stage, dressed as an army officer, and stop the proceedings as the lines were getting "Too silly!"
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 16, 2016, 10:16:46 AM
I'm sorry Cooper, I can't put it into words in any useful way. Motorcycle engine analogy maybe:
Binci - Brough Superior
Antonelli - Indian Four
VA - 1950s BSA twin
Dix - BMW
Cagnoni - Norton Commando.

crap now i need to get into motorcycles :-) i've always steered away from those, lol.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: baz parkes on May 16, 2016, 02:48:49 PM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?

So....Binci...bitter, VA...mild...DIX...Dublin Porter.... :|glug??
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Anahata on May 16, 2016, 06:45:27 PM
Now you're talking!  :|glug
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: rees on May 16, 2016, 07:11:37 PM
Hohner ...... scrumpy cider!
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Henry Piper on May 16, 2016, 07:24:38 PM
Hohner ...... scrumpy cider!

Proper Job !!
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: MartinW on May 17, 2016, 12:04:09 AM
motorcycles :-) i've always steered away from those, lol.
If only all road users where so considerate.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on May 17, 2016, 12:51:13 PM
Trouble with analogies is that only works if people know the stuff you compare it to.

How about food,...

Binci  good mushrooms in a nice sauce
VA Fresh carrots and cucumber
Ciccarelli Fresh lettuce with balsamic
Hohner, potatoesoupe

:-)
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Hasse on May 18, 2016, 08:46:28 PM
Binci are like The Rolling Stones, VA are like the Beatles and DIX are like Pink Floyd - does that help?
;D Like that comparision!

Only I would put in Ciccarrelli as Tiger Army or Metallica. Because that's a reed with strong and powerful edge, that can also be smooth as hell!  >:E
So sad to hear he is not making reeds any longer   :'(

Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: Cooper on August 25, 2016, 09:07:28 PM

Yes, I use Binci Pro.

John Spiers was on my stall at FolkEast yesterday comparing the two. His comments were that the DIX are more "spongy" than the Binci  ::)
In other words, the Binci reeds build to maximum sonority very quickly with a small increase in pressure, whereas the DIX reeds follow a more gentle curve.

My comments - Binci, hard and loud. DIX, colourful, harmonious, pliable and slightly Hohner-ish. Both are very delicious reeds indeed.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: JohannPascher on October 31, 2017, 07:08:39 PM
On the history of Salpa and Antonelli I believe you are confused.
Around the year 2000 Salpa and Antonelli merged, I don't know if one took over the other or if it was more a equal partnership.  The new company had a new name Voci Armoniche.
[]


Salpa Antonelli and Siva= VA (Not for sure i was around  2000 in Castelfidardo and Salpa was still working, on a location that is closed down now. I don't know where the facility's from Antonelli und Siva have been at this time but the location where VA is now did not look new as i did get there the fist time a few Years later.

As for reeds from Harmonikas i have had all type of reed the produce. Now the have reeds with Italian Nastrino steel tongs as well. Shoes are made with spark eroding. DIX in Brass i fitted as well. I also had reeds from all other reed makers in Italy except Binci (binci i only know by testing boxes with binci reeds). At the moment i fit again two sets of reeds from Ciccarelli to two boxes. I don't see any difference in steel quality independent if the are from Harmonikas or from other makes. Ladisalv Titelbach says his stell is the same as the steel used in Italy and comes from the same supplier. Still there is a major diffidence if the are reworked by hand. The surface of tongues are harder as the body if the are machined.  If the final process is a sanding by hand or with a small tape sander as Ciccarelli and others are doing this the harder surface is removed. The new nastrino a mano from Harmonikas are outstanding if one looks for something special, but difficult to handle if tuned. Very loud reeds. Full dynamic. Still the sound is more like the older sound i am used to from boxes made in Vienna, but definitely also different as it is the case with the new DIX reeds the are nice but not equal in sound to the old DIX reeds. Lower pitched DIX reeds are not preferable because the don't give the same punch as comparable other reeds. One major diffidence might be found in the shoes. Older shoes-slots and newer are different because the way the are made varies. Harmonikas and Cagnoni, and VA (not quite sure if for all reeds) use now nearly equal machinery. Binci and Atigiana still relay on the old machines what results in tapperd slots. VA orders some Shows at Harmonikas. So in the end not all that comes from Italy is completely made in Italy. In the end reed sets are never exactly the same so quality from the same factory and with the same grad varies. So it is nearly impossible to compare. No objective data is available. Reed tolerance is only presented by one Factory.
Best regards, Johann   

PS: " His comments were that the DIX are more "spongy" than the Binci " i would add more spongy as any others. What means spongy? DIX reeds dot have as much spring stiffness as others. This results in a different behavior. If stiffness of reeds is lower as with other comparable reeds one of the major difference is that with more air pressure the pitch of the tone lowers but less stiffens lead to better response at low pressure. DIX reeds are not suitable for people that only want a very loud box, for gently playing the DIX reeds are perfect.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: squeezy on October 31, 2017, 09:46:07 PM
Hi Johann ... it was my comment that the reed was "spongy" ... I was not referring to the material that makes the reed, but the way it feels to me when played.  When you apply pressure to the bellows in an instrument with new DIX reeds, it takes a much bigger force to get the increase in volume I am used to in an instrument with Binci reeds - so as a player, DIX reeds make the bellows feel more spongy to me.

However you could also argue that this same effect in the DIX reeds gives extra subtelty and control over reed volume ... it all depends what you want the reeds to do as a player.
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: JohannPascher on November 01, 2017, 07:03:47 AM
On the history of Salpa and Antonelli I believe you are confused.
Around the year 2000 Salpa and Antonelli merged, I don't know if one took over the other or if it was more a equal partnership.  The new company had a new name Voci Armoniche.
[]


Salpa Antonelli and Siva= VA (Not for sure i was around  2000 in Castelfidardo and Salpa was still working, on a location that is closed down now. I don't know where the facility's from Antonelli und Siva have been at this time but the location where VA is now did not look new as i did get there the fist time a few Years later.

As for reeds from Harmonikas i have had all type of reed the produce. Now the have reeds with Italian Nastrino steel tongs as well. Shoes are made with spark eroding. DIX in Brass i fitted as well. I also had reeds from all other reed makers in Italy except Binci (binci i only know by testing boxes with binci reeds). At the moment i fit again two sets of reeds from Ciccarelli to two boxes. I don't see any difference in steel quality independent if the are from Harmonikas or from other makes. Ladisalv Titelbach says his stell is the same as the steel used in Italy and comes from the same supplier. Still there is a major diffidence if the are reworked by hand. The surface of tongues are harder as the body if the are machined.  If the final process is a sanding by hand or with a small tape sander as Ciccarelli and others are doing this the harder surface is removed. The new nastrino a mano from Harmonikas are outstanding if one looks for something special, but difficult to handle if tuned. Very loud reeds. Full dynamic. Still the sound is more like the older sound i am used to from boxes made in Vienna, but definitely also different as it is the case with the new DIX reeds the are nice but not equal in sound to the old DIX reeds. Lower pitched DIX reeds are not preferable because the don't give the same punch as comparable other reeds. One major diffidence might be found in the shoes. Older shoes-slots and newer are different because the way the are made varies. Harmonikas and Cagnoni, and VA (not quite sure if for all reeds) use now nearly equal machinery. Binci and Atigiana still relay on the old machines what results in tapperd slots. VA orders some Shows at Harmonikas. So in the end not all that comes from Italy is completely made in Italy. In the end reed sets are never exactly the same so quality from the same factory and with the same grad varies. So it is nearly impossible to compare. No objective data is available. Reed tolerance is only presented by one Factory.
Best regards, Johann   

PS: " His comments were that the DIX are more "spongy" than the Binci " i would add more spongy as any others. What means spongy? DIX reeds dot have as much spring stiffness as others. This results in a different behavior. If stiffness of reeds is lower as with other comparable reeds one of the major difference is that with more air pressure the pitch of the tone lowers but less stiffens lead to better response at low pressure. DIX reeds are not suitable for people that only want a very loud box, for gently playing the DIX reeds are perfect.

Thank for replay. It surly also makes a difference in witch box the reeds are fitted. But if i think about you because you are used to Binci reeds you are then happy with reeds that are on the top end if it come to volume only, reeds from Harmonikas with professional nastrno a mano wold top the volume.  DIX aren't comparable in this case the never produce the same or nearly the same Volume and if you try to use the reeds the same way it feels like you have described  - to push the bellows much harder. But if you do, the sound quality is really bad and you produce a sound that trops in pitch to much for most ears. On the other hand if the type of Musik and the way the instrument is played differ a lot so the musician may very much prefer the DIX reeds. It always depend on the viewpoint and that is also way there is never a absolut good or bad if it comes to reeds. Sure some reeds nearly every one would dislike but in most cases it depends what one wants or what one is used to. In most cases reeds don't behave the same all over the pitch range. Old reeds and DIX or other brass reeds never use the same thickness for shoes. Thinner Aluminium or brass on low pitch also results in less volume on the opposite thinner on high pitch reeds results in higher Volume. So if the same thickness of Aluminium or Brass as on DIX is used this also leads to a different balance from low to high pitch notes. There are even more differences if it comes to sound quality aspects.   Best regards Johann
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: blafleur on November 02, 2017, 12:48:28 PM

[/quote]

As for reeds from Harmonikas i have had all type of reed the produce. Now the have reeds with Italian Nastrino steel tongs as well. Shoes are made with spark eroding. DIX in Brass i fitted as well. I also had reeds from all other reed makers in Italy except Binci (binci i only know by testing boxes with binci reeds). At the moment i fit again two sets of reeds from Ciccarelli to two boxes. I don't see any difference in steel quality independent if the are from Harmonikas or from other makes. Ladisalv Titelbach says his stell is the same as the steel used in Italy and comes from the same supplier. Still there is a major diffidence if the are reworked by hand. The surface of tongues are harder as the body if the are machined.  If the final process is a sanding by hand or with a small tape sander as Ciccarelli and others are doing this the harder surface is removed. The new nastrino a mano from Harmonikas are outstanding if one looks for something special, but difficult to handle if tuned. Very loud reeds. Full dynamic. Still the sound is more like the older sound i am used to from boxes made in Vienna, but definitely also different as it is the case with the new DIX reeds the are nice but not equal in sound to the old DIX reeds. Lower pitched DIX reeds are not preferable because the don't give the same punch as comparable other reeds. One major diffidence might be found in the shoes. Older shoes-slots and newer are different because the way the are made varies. Harmonikas and Cagnoni, and VA (not quite sure if for all reeds) use now nearly equal machinery. Binci and Atigiana still relay on the old machines what results in tapperd slots. VA orders some Shows at Harmonikas. So in the end not all that comes from Italy is completely made in Italy. In the end reed sets are never exactly the same so quality from the same factory and with the same grad varies. So it is nearly impossible to compare. No objective data is available. Reed tolerance is only presented by one Factory.
Best regards, Johann   

[/quote]

I had completely forgotten about this thread.  That is the report I was hoping for.  Johann, what do you mean "but difficult to handle if tuned"?
Title: Re: Reeds, different makes
Post by: JohannPascher on November 02, 2017, 03:06:15 PM
Johann, what do you mean "but difficult to handle if tuned"?

Because the precision is much higher as on other reeds and the the shoes - frame slots are not tapered each little scratch on the edge of a tongue leads to blocked tongues, especially if one need to higher the pitch. So in most cases i have to use very fine grade sanding paper that i stick to a wooden stick with double sided tape instead of using files. Scratches to lower the pitch work as usual. Tuning work is all together a little bit more difficult as with less expensive reeds.  Also keep in mid that in changed temperature in colder environment the reeds tend to block more easily.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal