Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: glastenbury on June 19, 2009, 06:19:48 AM

Title: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: glastenbury on June 19, 2009, 06:19:48 AM
I just bought my first button accordion. It's  1920's Hohner 2 row with 12 bass buttons. the letters A/D are stamped in the lower end of the keyboard. The bass side doesn't appear to be tuned as a trikitixa as described in the keyboard layouts elsewhere on this site though. It's a bit hard to tell because almost all the valves have fallen off so, here I go.

I made a bunch of mylar valves for the bass side but they failed somewhat miserably. They curl when played (mouth blown) and don't settle flat for about 10 minutes. Maybe it's just the humidity from my breath.

Anyway, my main question is this: What is the correct position of the reed relative to the plate when viewed from the side?
All of my reeds are bent about 0.5 mm above the plate. It's as if someone played it really hard with the bad valves and enough air blew past to bend the reeds. I assume they should be much closer to the plate or even slightly down inside to opening in the plate.

Not only are some reeds very hard to start vibrating but, also a few sound very deadened (but appear clean and free moving) and the two center bass button give extremely low notes (about 2 or 3 octaves below the others). It sound intentional but very unexpected.

In harmonica circles its common to boil reeds for a short time to bring back dead sounding reeds. That's not acceptable for button accordions is it?

Sorry if you've all seen this question many times before. I did check the old forum also but didn't really se the specifics about reed position that I am hoping for.

Thank you.

Larry
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: LJC on June 19, 2009, 08:06:00 AM
When I came to restoring a 1930s Erika I was told to have the reeds bent above the plate a distance equal to the thickness of the reed. It works for me!

Having the reed too low so that it is flat or under the plate makes for funny sounds or notes which bend in pitch as the air pressure changes.

If any reeds are too far out from the plate then they can be hard to start moving as the air escapes from around the reed gap.

I've found that around reed 7 or 8 where the thickness of the reed and size starts to change you always seem to find a volume drop off because of the physics of the size of reed, frequency, and size of the space under the reed on the block. You'll notice that the very high reeds often have half filled reed block chambers and are put in reversed because they suffer from a similar condition.

With the very low notes of the bass, It might be that the higher octave bass notes are just not sounding (lots of different reasons) meaning that all you hear is the lower reed.

I don't know about boiling reeds, but I've seen people put them (minus the valves) in a mineral spirit/ultrasound cleaning bath to clean gunk off them. I don't know what the temperature would do to!

You can get some very good spare valve sets from Charlie at CGM which come in different sizes which are great for doing up old boxes as you can tailor the valve to the different sizes of reed. (He's on his summer holidays at the moment so you'll have to wait to order from him)
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: Theo on June 19, 2009, 08:56:21 AM
When I came to restoring a 1930s Erika I was told to have the reeds bent above the plate a distance equal to the thickness of the reed. It works for me!

This is a good starting point, but from this setting each reed needs to be checked and adjusted individually to get the optimum response.

Quote
Having the reed too low so that it is flat or under the plate makes for funny sounds or notes which bend in pitch as the air pressure changes.

And reeds set too low will choke if played hard.
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: Bill the Farmer on June 19, 2009, 11:03:56 AM
In harmonica circles its common to boil reeds for a short time to bring back dead sounding reeds. That's not acceptable for button accordions is it?
I know a chap whose aunt boils her sewing machine. He says it works too. I don't know if she oils it afterwards. There was a thread about cleaning reeds a while back here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1159.0.html).
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: Lester on June 19, 2009, 11:46:26 AM
In harmonica circles its common to boil reeds for a short time to bring back dead sounding reeds. That's not acceptable for button accordions is it?
I know a chap whose aunt boils her sewing machine. He says it works too. I don't know if she oils it afterwards. There was a thread about cleaning reeds a while back here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1159.0.html).

Would not recommend it for the whole melodeon   ;D
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: triskel on June 19, 2009, 01:02:34 PM

In harmonica circles its common to boil reeds for a short time to bring back dead sounding reeds.

I know a chap whose aunt boils her sewing machine. He says it works too. I don't know if she oils it afterwards.

I've known people who used to boil guitar strings and use them again, but sewing machines...  :o
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: Bill the Farmer on June 19, 2009, 01:29:59 PM
I've known people who used to boil guitar strings and use them again, but sewing machines...  :o
That's probably a reasonable thing to do if they're just dirty and not worn.  ;D
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: triskel on June 19, 2009, 01:50:36 PM
The bass side doesn't appear to be tuned as a trikitixa as described in the keyboard layouts elsewhere on this site though.

That's good, it shouldn't, unless you bought your accordion in the Basque Country of Northern Spain - the only place they play the trikitixa.

In many countries (including Great Britain and Ireland) 2-row diatonic accordions (melodeons) usually have only 8 basses, but in some countries (including the US) they sometimes have 4 more.
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: LJC on June 19, 2009, 02:47:28 PM
You also have to make sure that the reed is properly aligned so that there is an equal space on either side of reed between it and the plate. Having it to far either side will either cause it to rattle on the edge or just not speak at all. White spirit and a cotton bud are quite good for cleaning any major gunk off the faces of the reed and a piece of newspaper (smaller reeds) or cartridge paper (bigger reeds) can be used to dislodge any debris under the tongue, very much like flossing! 
Title: Re: Reed position in plate - basics question
Post by: Quebecois on June 19, 2009, 02:52:43 PM

In harmonica circles its common to boil reeds for a short time to bring back dead sounding reeds.

I know a chap whose aunt boils her sewing machine. He says it works too. I don't know if she oils it afterwards.

I've known people who used to boil guitar strings and use them again, but sewing machines...  :o
Voodoo! I know people who boil trumpets...
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal