Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on June 20, 2009, 08:27:46 PM
-
Is this cheating? (http://www.thomann.de/gb/ekart_selbstspielende_steirische.htm)
AL
-
Almost certainly ;D
-
Cool huh? The worst thing about it is that it costs nearly £2500!
AL
-
Why would you want to?
NNY
-
Well...it could be fun for about five minutes ;D
But who could forgive themselves for paying that kind of money on a cheap trick!???
-
It would be HILARIOUS for 5 minutes. Then it would get pushed into a corner and never "played" again.
-
Trouble is, you'd have to wear lederhosen, and yodel, to get away with it... ::)
-
I see a clear advantage, in that you could concentrate on your charm and demeanor, and not have to think much about whether or not you are pressing the right buttons.............. 8)
-
So, in effect, it's just a novelty mechanical music box - much like a portable street organ is. As I've previously encountered many people making money from such organs, either for charity or profit, I don't see why an imaginative indivual couldn't pull off the same trick with one of these. As for the lederhosen thing - yes, most probably.
-
Trouble is, you'd have to wear lederhosen, and yodel, to get away with it...
What's wrong with lederhosen?
AL ;D
-
So, in effect, it's just a novelty mechanical music box - much like a portable street organ is. As I've previously encountered many people making money from such organs, either for charity or profit, I don't see why an imaginative indivual couldn't pull off the same trick with one of these. As for the lederhosen thing - yes, most probably.
But is this 'arising like a professional'?
-
So, in effect, it's just a novelty mechanical music box - much like a portable street organ is. As I've previously encountered many people making money from such organs, either for charity or profit, I don't see why an imaginative indivual couldn't pull off the same trick with one of these.
I saw a chap playing a concertina version of this at Adderbury day if dance. He was very enthusiastic about it, and spent a lot of time "playing" it, mainly collecting for charity. His only complaint was the rather germanic nature of the tunes he could get - guess that's the price you pay for not being in control of the music you want to play.
He obviously got a lot of fun out of it, and was very open about how it worked, and given that a lot of other people were enjoying it, I'm not sure I'd call it cheating, just different!
Trevor
-
So, in effect, it's just a novelty mechanical music box - much like a portable street organ is. As I've previously encountered many people making money from such organs, either for charity or profit, I don't see why an imaginative indivual couldn't pull off the same trick with one of these.
I saw a chap playing a concertina version of this at Adderbury day if dance. He was very enthusiastic about it, and spent a lot of time "playing" it, mainly collecting for charity. His only complaint was the rather germanic nature of the tunes he could get - guess that's the price you pay for not being in control of the music you want to play.
He obviously got a lot of fun out of it, and was very open about how it worked, and given that a lot of other people were enjoying it, I'm not sure I'd call it cheating, just different!
Trevor
Yep, that doesn't surprise me. I can think of fair few children's entertainers, clowns and walkabout artists who would be easily able to incorporate this into their shows, presenting it in a similar sort of way.
As I've seen before in other contexts, it's easy for people that are involved in skilled entertainment-related activities to lose sight of the purpose of being an entertainer in the first place. By the sounds of things, the chap mentioned above was putting on a better show than some proper players might have managed. As such, I could easily imagine an event booker choosing to hire an entertaining 'cheat' over a boring technician.
-
Reminds me of that guy who "plays" trumpet with his ears and nose... it's only fun for about 3 minutes until you realize that the sounds are recorded...
-
His only complaint was the rather germanic nature of the tunes he could get...
That's what I was meaning when I mentioned the lederhosen, and the yodelling! ;)
-
Well if you've got a Streb, couldn't you play a midi backing track through it as you played?
-
In the USA they sell fake bugles with a built-in gizmo that plays Taps, apparently the number of living and available buglers is on a fast decline...
-
Well if you've got a Streb, couldn't you play a midi backing track through it as you played?
It's a mighty fine line between playing and not playing isn't it?
-
Is this cheating? (http://www.thomann.de/gb/ekart_selbstspielende_steirische.htm)
AL
I've heard reports of someone in Birmingham busking with one of these (or similar)
-
I've heard reports of someone in Birmingham busking with one of these (or similar)
I've heard some Romanian gypsy kids busking that could badly do with one, though some of the adults are superb PA players... :o
-
It's a "PA" - pianola accordion!
Triskel - we got musically-challenged buskers here too - although I thought I caught a snatch of The Birdy Song last week, or it coulda been Bohemian Rhrapsody? Tony.