Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on June 23, 2009, 03:55:17 PM

Title: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 23, 2009, 03:55:17 PM
Hi - last night my old Hohner Erica C/F just would'nt play for me - something choking it up on the bass end. So I got out the Hohner Trichord BCC# - given my newness to the instrument/system not really much of a fail-safe. In fact, I'd seriously been considering selling the trichord on and getting something with a bit more wumph and a lot more basses.  But last night I changed my mind - or more correctly it changed my mind. It played (with a certain raspishness that comes with aged Hohners) like a beserk concrete mixer - and it was such fun. So, I've changed my mind - this little trichord is great fun. I've booked it in for some TLC (Theo Loving Care) and am really looking forward to playing this little beaut a lot, lot more. I also discovered that the best way of dealing with the lack of bass buttons is to bluff it. It didn't really matter that it does'nt have an Eb or a Cmin7 chord - I just bluff it or skip it. And anyway, with it being a BCC# I've all I need on the treble side to help fake it.

Anybody else  changed their mind about a box they've had...?
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Quebecois on June 23, 2009, 04:31:43 PM
<snip> I also discovered that the best way of dealing with the lack of bass buttons is to bluff it. It didn't really matter that it does'nt have an Eb or a Cmin7 chord - I just bluff it or skip it. And anyway, with it being a BCC# I've all I need on the treble side to help fake it.

Anybody else  changed their mind about a box they've had...?
I play on various boxes, interchangeably, but I agree about the bass thing, we are often a little too obsessed with producing all basses in the same 'om-pah' way and forget that sometimes no bass is OK for short passages in a tune and what matters is the resulting melody, bass and treble sides combined.
 
This happens when I play a tune on the 2-row that I learned on the 3-row; missing basses must be compensated for and the tune sounds different, yet fine.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: rees on June 23, 2009, 05:05:42 PM
I constantly change my mind as to which is my favourite melodeon - that's how I ended up with a melodeon shop!
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: george garside on June 23, 2009, 06:19:25 PM
Quote from: jb link=topic=1900.msg18872#msg18872 
(I defo agree about the bass stuff though. Less is very often more, and necessity is the mother-in-law of invention.)
[/quote

Indeed , one of the simplest (& entirely free of charge) ways of ornementing a tune is to stop playing the bass, particlarly when there is a fussy bit of treble with lots of little notes in quick succession. stopping the bass instantly throws the emphasis on the faancy bit of treble & has the bonus of stopping things going mushy!

As far as the trichord is concerned 12 stradella is enough to provide half decent harmony and a fair bit of rhythm in CGDA- its a question of making the  most of what you've got rather than  worrying about  some strange chord that the punters arn't going to realise you havn't played. 

and don't forget there is rarely such a thing as 'correct' bass for most traditional/ folk tunes as they were written for melody instruments.  Any bass notation  attached to a version of the dots is  only what someone has added later - get another book with the same tune in & it may well have a very different bass line.  Also  what can sometimes be taken by some individuals as 'accordion bass' are in reality guitar chords so why torture yourself trying to play something you can't!

george - keep it simple!
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 23, 2009, 08:08:43 PM
Anybody else  changed their mind about a box they've had...?

Oh gosh, yes! Just received my Gaillard (after nearly 3 years) and changed my mind on two counts ..

D3R


Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: GbH on June 23, 2009, 11:11:49 PM
Yes, I guess I went through such a change last year.  At some point around the start of 2008, someone asked if I wanted to meet up and play some folk tunes, as he'd just purchased a mandolin and tenor banjo and was just going through the initial stages of figuring out how to play them.  Other than the few tunes I sometimes played on my Giordy (as an incidental part of my juggling act), I hadn't really thought about playing folk-related music in quite a while, and even then, it was not something I'd ever done properly. 

So, I had to figure out what sort of instrument I was going to be playing myself.  It was obvious at that point that the Giordy wasn't going to be a lot of use - its range would clearly have been too small.  Although I owned a 'proper' box (a 2-row D/G) to use, it had sat on the shelf unplayed since being purchased on a whim some years before.  As a result, other than just replicating what little I could do on the Giordy, I had no idea how to play it at all.  So, I did the obvious thing and started playing my old piano box instead*  :-\ .  I continued like this into last summer, making steady enough progress, enjoying what I was doing and even obtaining a new instrument.  However, for some reason that I can't completely explain, I'd had a nagging feeling that I really should be playing melodeon.  It just seemed like a more appropriate instrument for what I thought we might be doing.  So, as is now obvious, despite logic telling me otherwise, I eventually decided to make the switch and start going down the diatonic route, pretty much having to start again from scratch.

Since finding this site, I've learned a lot more about these instruments and it was perhaps inevitable that I'd want to upgrade to a 2.5 or 3 row instrument at some point.  So, the Mengascini was ordered and arrived at Christmas and I've not really felt the need to worry about buying other instruments since.  Hopefully I'll now stay MAD-free and remain happy using what I have.



Guy

* Some years before, I'd tried make use of what little skill I'd gained from childhood piano lessons by attempting to teach myself how to play the p.a. from an Italian classical tutor book.  I made some progress, but inevitably it got forgotten about after a while.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 23, 2009, 11:43:47 PM
I am not wealthy enough to keep an array of different boxes, especially since I play pipe and tabor as well and need pipes in various keys. I started with a Hohner Erica and became dissatisfied with that after a few years, so I bought a two-and-a-half row Castagnari Mory. What a mistaka to maka!  :'( I never made much use of the slides and the box was far too heavy for me, especially when standing up playing for Morris. I traded the Mory for a smaller box - a Castagnari Dony - but I was still ending up with back ache, so I sat down at the computer and worked out what I really really wanted from a melodeon. The result was a small three-row that Castagnari made specially for me (thanks, Rees!). It was based on a Benny and cost no more than a standard Benny - to my surpise and delight. I have been playing this for about four years now and I love it. I am now completely cured of MAD! The only downside is that if I pick up a conventional box I struggle to remember which notes are on which buttons.

While I would not dream of changing to another box, I find that I am revisiting quite a few of the tunes that I have played for several years and changing the fingering of them so that I can include more ornamentation and greater variation in the bass accompaniment. I tried pointing out some of these changes to my wife, but she said that she couldn't hear any difference. Bloody Philistine! I won't be changing my box, but I am not so sure about my wife.  >:E
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: ladydetemps on June 24, 2009, 09:46:31 AM
well I started with the concertina....and now I've been converted to melodeon.
For me its like when I went form PC to Mac...everything got much quicker.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Lester on June 24, 2009, 09:57:20 AM
well I started with the concertina....and now I've been converted to melodeon.
For me its like when I went form PC to Mac...everything got much quicker.

Have you fessed up on C.Net ??   ::)
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on June 24, 2009, 10:23:06 AM
My start (in free reeds) was English concertina. Then I found a Hohner single row in G (4 bass) - why did I sell it :-[ Then an unnamed B/C with 12 stradella bass, in a junk shop for £11 (cheap even back then) and found I clicked with the system. So I decided I needed a three row BCC# because of the basses - John K had a lot to do with that idea! So I got, and eventually sold, the Hohner Echo III. Another mistake to part with that - fairly light and easy! Never got away with D/G's so no regrets there I'm afraid, even tried D/G/A. Had a couple of Trichords, including a BCC# with "melodeon" basses, but stick with 12 stradella (stradellae?) on those. I like them but feel restricted on the bass end. Only felt comfortable in a cajun/tex-mex band using no basses - even played on a bill with Flaco once - he tried mine and you shoulda seen his face :o D'you know what he he said? "If it works for you ....."
My Gaelic IV was too big and had to go. Got a couple of Hohner 4stops (C and D) and a Paulo Soprani 80bass now, but might have to part with it on account of back trouble. Always wanted a BCC# with 48 in a 4x12 format, so have been looking carefully at the frankenstein threads here. Maybe I  should re-visit the D/G thingy? Find out properly about cross fingering?
So - to the question on this thread - Mmmm, yes?
Tony.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: ladydetemps on June 24, 2009, 10:27:19 AM
well I started with the concertina....and now I've been converted to melodeon.
For me its like when I went form PC to Mac...everything got much quicker.

Have you fessed up on C.Net ??   ::)
sort of...I"m not giving concertina up completely...just focusing on melodeon more.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 24, 2009, 11:06:23 AM
Quote
well I started with the concertina....and now I've been converted to melodeon.
For me its like when I went form PC to Mac...everything got much quicker.

And its such a nicer environment!
 ;D
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: ladydetemps on June 24, 2009, 11:14:21 AM
Quote
well I started with the concertina....and now I've been converted to melodeon.
For me its like when I went form PC to Mac...everything got much quicker.

And its such a nicer environment!
 ;D
the only downside being compatability....and having to convert stuff ;)
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Sebastian on June 24, 2009, 12:26:44 PM
the only downside being compatability....and having to convert stuff ;)
That's why I switched back from MacOS to Linux.

But I even prefer the concertina to the melodeon ...
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: pipives on June 24, 2009, 01:58:05 PM
I've arrived late in the thread... again!

I started on the anglo concertina aged 6, then realised the delights of the melodeon. Since being at University I've found my love for the anglo concertina again and play it all the time now

I still however play the melodeon quite a lot at home (D/G) and have been trying to work out the C#/D system. This hasn't gone entirely to plan though.

Thats the short story of changing my mind. The long version would fill a book the size of an encyclopedia!
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Dazbo on June 24, 2009, 04:53:02 PM
well I started with the concertina....and now I've been converted to melodeon.
For me its like when I went form PC to Mac...everything got much quicker.

Me too ;D although I have since bought an English and it's sitting there waiting to be learnt but too much stuff to learn for the melodeon :-\
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on June 24, 2009, 06:50:28 PM
I tried with Linux too, but it wouldn't run on the concertina - ah well, back to windows.

Pipives - doesn't C#/D look as if it should be absolutely the way to go? Except it makes the key of G harder than on a B/C, and D is pretty easy (and faster than playing on the row) on a B/C anyway. Let's know how you get on. I guess A and E are the equivalent "easy" keys on C#/D?
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: pipives on June 25, 2009, 12:42:55 PM
This is exactly where I'm going with my playing- Anglo concertina and C#/D, which I can play fluently in A,D,G major, am currently working on E and B major too. F major seems a real pain though.

And I still have access to two D/G's if the urge/need takes me!
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: waltzman on June 26, 2009, 02:02:54 PM
I tried with Linux too, but it wouldn't run on the concertina - ah well, back to windows.

Pipives - doesn't C#/D look as if it should be absolutely the way to go? Except it makes the key of G harder than on a B/C, and D is pretty easy (and faster than playing on the row) on a B/C anyway. Let's know how you get on. I guess A and E are the equivalent "easy" keys on C#/D?

Is it generally agreed that it's easier to play most tunes in the key of D faster on a B/C than 'on the row'?
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on June 26, 2009, 06:31:29 PM
Ooooh, you spotted a bit of an unconsidered generalisation on my part - too subjective :-\. Didn't mean to be contentious. Shoulda said I find it faster because of not changing the bellows so much. Maybe I need a CBA? T.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on June 27, 2009, 06:39:05 PM
I tried with Linux too, but it wouldn't run on the concertina - ah well, back to windows.
Windows on a concertina - awesome!
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on July 02, 2009, 02:43:07 PM
Windows on a concertina - awesome!
[/quote]
Has the advantage that you can check the reeds without a screwdriver. Need an anti-virus though, to keep worms out of the woodwork. T.
Title: Re: Have you ever changed your mind...?
Post by: Quebecois on July 02, 2009, 03:25:04 PM
Windows on a concertina - awesome!
Not! Imagine having to install a security patch every 20 minutes for the rest of your life...
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal