Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Andy Next Tune on August 05, 2016, 10:53:49 PM

Title: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on August 05, 2016, 10:53:49 PM
A nice bottle of red wine stimulated a discussion with my wife about the boring styling of most melodeon gig bags - basically rucksacks in any colour as long as it is black.

It culminated in an offer/proposal to make me something different and better!!!!

So what should it be made of, and what features should it have? My initial thoughts were Harris tweed with tankard clips and big pockets for all those really essential items we always carry.

What do you think? What would your ideal gig bag look like?

Cheers, Andy

Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: playandteach on August 05, 2016, 11:01:44 PM
That's a really nice idea. I've a roll of really nice material in the loft left over from some upholstery and I am ok with a sewing machine. The straps would take more skill and specialised material though.
I'd like one that was snug, but opened out fully. I have just realised in my many black bags that I can't find anything in the pockets - so I'd like a light coloured lining. It would have generous straps and a carry handle. And a decent music pocket. Plus serious vecro on the outside to add extra bags like a music stand holder.
Above all it would have no logos.
There is a leather worker in Hexham - and I've considered getting him to make a table tennis bat case - if money was no object, I'd commission a stiff leather melodeon case from him and forget everything else I've said.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: LadyEleanore on August 05, 2016, 11:15:37 PM
Having purchased my first melodeon on Thursday this week, my thoughts naturally turned to the matching handbag and I thought exactly the same thing - incredibly boring.  I also witnessed the decanting of a van load of kit from about 20 Morris teams at Sheringham which involved man holding yet another black or red melodeon bag aloft to find that no-one instantly recognised theirs.   So with that in mind:

1. Waterproof, or straps underneath to secure a rolled up cape like hiking rucksacks
2. Decent sized front pocket with a transparent window that can show owner info.
3. Tankard strap
4. No logos
5. Well padded adjustable straps
6. Camera bags have a padded insert that can be lifted out and used in alternative bags. Something similar would be good as then one could simply transfer padded inner sac to another outer bag - perhaps in a different colour for those with more than one Morris team  :P

Tartan would be lovely....
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 05, 2016, 11:21:36 PM
I would prefer the bag to not open fully, or the zips go all the all the way down. That way, when I undo the zip, the box doesn't roll out out and when I'm replacing it, I can drop it in to a "pocket" without having to fiddle about to get the zip to close.
Enough room for a fleece or waterproof and a bottle of water.
Padded bottom, so if the box gets put down heavily it's not damaged.
In fact, I put an inch of foam spongy stuff in the bottom of my gig bags for that reason.
Tankard hook where it doesn't rattle or beat me to death.
Decent shoulder straps.
And not too heavy.
No bloody velcro.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Jack Campin on August 06, 2016, 12:49:38 AM
Washable?

I was once at a session in Whitby when a somewhat sozzled woman attempted to climb out of a wedged-in position behind a table covered with full glasses.  The resulting snooker-like cascade ended with a full pint getting potted into an open melodeon case.  The melodeon player didn't attempt to put his instrument back in it.

I don't like the idea of a bottle of water sharing a case with something expensive and not waterproof.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 06, 2016, 07:33:46 AM
Huh! That's nothing Jack. At Sidmouth a few years ago in a pub somebody knocked several pints over my melodeon case with box in it. They said " oh my God, oh my God!" My reply? .... Look it's managed to survive two world wars, one of them in action, I'm sure it could survive this even if it was bombed by the British"
  Personally I prefer a hard case and at festivals or gigs I would open the case at the beginning of the session and then carry the box around all day. I find a gig bag or case is an embuggerance if you are moving from place to place.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Julian S on August 06, 2016, 07:38:49 AM
Hardwearing and waterproof essential ! I keep a large waterproof pack sack inside mine to put the box in when it rains - I don't trust the zip (and finish) to keep the water out. I also sometimes wonder whether a bigger gigbag would be better so I could fit the whole hard case in (paranoid perhaps!)
Ideally of course the bag would emulate Terry Pratchett's 'Luggage' - little feet (clogs ?)and capable of following the owner around. Infinite capacity and with an aggressive disposition when needed... ::)
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: benammiswift on August 06, 2016, 08:54:40 AM
My ideas gig bag is pretty much the ones that acorn instruments sell. Nice, Simple and hard-wearing case that shields my Handry from any knocks. My only few tiny niggles 1. that the pocket isn't very deep but it still has lots of room so not terrible. 2. No Tankard Clip  :( 3. It's seems to let my Handry roll over forward if you don't put it down flat, I don't know why haha.

Apart from that I love the case and its about the only one I'd trust with a big box like the Handry

Benammi
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 06, 2016, 09:19:29 AM
The problem I always find with a tankard clip is that the beer tends to fall out.......  ;) :|glug
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Lester on August 06, 2016, 09:26:11 AM
Still trying to find a bag with enough room for a Primus, some water, cooling for milk, protection for bone china teapot, teacup and saucer.
The tribulations of being teetotal  8)
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 06, 2016, 09:28:48 AM
I have had three. Experience

Straight drop in bag was the best for carrying other things, especially as hand baggage on planes for a "no luggage" weekend somewhere. BUT it hung from the shoulder rather than slingable over it. The latter feels better

A large pocket is very useful for music, passport etc.

The rebate for the keybord is perfect for bottle of wine or whiskey IF the instument goes in on its side. I also get a couple of shirts in there , as above. I see Lester has the same issue, if from a different perspective ;)

Long side zips … mine scare my that the precious accordion might tumble out!

My 3rd bag was cheap, but the seams have already gone (risk as per above) so you get what you pay for
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 06, 2016, 09:41:47 AM
I bought mine on eBay, but I can't remember who from (sorry -from whom!); it's your standard black zip-round-three-sides model; this one, in fact http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Scarlatti-MELODEON-BAG-Carry-Gig-soft-case-fits-most-1-2-rows-From-Hobgoblin-/381664708160?hash=item58dcfd4640:g:dmwAAOSw9eVXWWh1 (http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Scarlatti-MELODEON-BAG-Carry-Gig-soft-case-fits-most-1-2-rows-From-Hobgoblin-/381664708160?hash=item58dcfd4640:g:dmwAAOSw9eVXWWh1).  It's had to have a little attention to the zip stitching (but so did the maroon rucksack-type jobbie I had from Hobgoblin some years ago and which now houses two HA114s). It's fine as carry-on on aircraft, and as Chris says, you can squeeze in a surprising amount of stuff to see you over a weekend. It's not perfect, but it's the best one I've had and much more comfortable to carry around than a hard case, though obviously offers less protection.

Graham
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 06, 2016, 12:40:37 PM
Hard cases have to go in the hold (unless you go business class), and as such get "handled" by the same gorillas as handle your suitcase, and as such offer no protection from drops.

I watched Ryanair load a plane at Liverpool and one in 20 cases bounced off the elevator, falling 2m+ onto concrete. The guy in Copenhagen was throwing them nearly 3m into a large container. To be fair … he never missed.  But that is no consolation when you try to play and all you get is fresh air and a loud rattle :-\

Soft bags are a must for air travel.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Lester on August 06, 2016, 01:10:32 PM
I have taken hard cases as cabin baggage many times (when commuting weekly to Vienna) with no problems.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Jack Campin on August 06, 2016, 01:11:15 PM
This gave me an idea.  My wife has been thinking of getting into making bags - she has a LOT of sewing experience and an enormous stash of tweed fabric.  She was thinking of handbags but melodeon cases use the same technology.  What would people pay for a custom tweed melodeon bag?  We'll be at Whitby if anyone wants to talk about it.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Winston Smith on August 06, 2016, 01:41:06 PM
"Soft bags are a must for air travel."

I've taken my Hohner on in my carry-on case, as the "workings" are all inside, so the other stuff in there couldn't become entangled and spoil anything. My International was a different kettle of fish however. Having the exposed pallets, I was afeared that the levers might get bent, or otherwise damaged in some way, so I made a box to fit (obviously out of stuff which was to hand or other people's rubbish!) which would fit into the BA secondary carry-on bag gauge. At only 6 inches depth allowance, I struggled, but managed. There's no padding, but the instrument fits perfectly, and cannot move.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 06, 2016, 04:01:57 PM
That's fantastic Edward, I love the matching reinforcements on the outside up of the case: very thoughtful.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve C. on August 06, 2016, 04:35:51 PM
The Fuselli Professional bags are nice.  When my Hohner rucksack finally gives up, that's what I'm try next.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve C. on August 06, 2016, 04:41:48 PM
Lester, I hear you and I am working on it.  Pokerwork sits on bottom, tea pot and stove above, fixins in the pockets, biscuits too....
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Theo on August 06, 2016, 04:46:28 PM
I wish people wouldn't stuff other things in the bag with their instrument.   I've seen too many damaged grills from hard items laid on top.  Your instrument needs protection so please don't put bottles, flasks, microphones, whistles or anything else with hard surfaces in beside or on top of your melodeon.  If you must then at least wrap the extra items in something well padded.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: pete /acorn on August 06, 2016, 04:57:18 PM
Hi
The ones we have are the Fuselli Pro range with no logo

Will have plenty at Whitby

Pete
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 06, 2016, 05:12:17 PM
I have taken hard cases as cabin baggage many times (when commuting weekly to Vienna) with no problems.

Me too, mainly between UK and Czech Republic - never been asked to check a hard case into the hold.

Graham
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 06, 2016, 05:16:48 PM
I wish people wouldn't stuff other things in the bag with their instrument.   I've seen too many damaged grills from hard items laid on top.  Your instrument needs protection so please don't put bottles, flasks, microphones, whistles or anything else with hard surfaces in beside or on top of your melodeon.  If you must then at least wrap the extra items in something well padded.

I agree entirely -when I referred to squeezing weekend stuff in I was thinking mainly of clothing; toiletries etc always go in the front pocket. Socks, underwear & T-shirts go in with the box. Fine going out - not so much fun for the airport authorities if they ask you to open it up on the way back........  ;D

Graham
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on August 06, 2016, 05:24:02 PM
I wish people wouldn't stuff other things in the bag with their instrument.   I've seen too many damaged grills from hard items laid on top.  Your instrument needs protection so please don't put bottles, flasks, microphones, whistles or anything else with hard surfaces in beside or on top of your melodeon.  If you must then at least wrap the extra items in something well padded.

You're absolutely right Theo,
At a Bourne River Morris gig for a rotary club in Bournemouth there was a lot of food left over including whole cooked chickens.
Just don't do it! The box smelled of chickens for several years until Tubby Reynolds threw in the river Sid.
 >:E
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Julian S on August 06, 2016, 07:08:43 PM
Further thoughts re flying...I hit on the idea of fitting my hard case into an ideally sized travel pack - with handy removable shoulder straps. Managed to fit all gear for a week away into pack(in compression bags) with pastourelle 2 in case as well, just within Ryanair hand luggage limits on size and weight. Reckon it's the best compromise for ease of carry and protection - I much prefer this to putting soft gigbag into overhead locker - particularly as hand luggage can end up being put in hold if there is insufficient space...
But it all depends on size and weight of box/case...
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 06, 2016, 07:36:02 PM

At a Bourne River Morris gig for a rotary club in Bournemouth there was a lot of food left over including whole cooked chickens.
Just don't do it! The box smelled of chickens for several years until Tubby Reynolds threw in the river Sid.
 >:E
I normally carry at least one large plastic bag in the gig bag. The primary purpose is a rain cover for the box. Other purposes might be available.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 06, 2016, 08:22:42 PM
Pete 's bags are very nice. Not only substantial  zips but straps across the top too so no chance of zip failure. Check out reviews,  one is mine !
Q
Satisfied owner .
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 06, 2016, 11:02:27 PM
Pete 's bags are very nice. Not only substantial  zips but straps across the top too so no chance of zip failure. Check out reviews,  one is mine !
Q
Satisfied owner .

Another vote from me for Pete's bags. They are very good indeed; the best I've ever come across, in fact.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,18802.msg229300.html#msg229300

Choose your sizes here:
http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?accessories
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 06, 2016, 11:45:47 PM
I have a Tatonka back pack for travelling incognito. Obtained at a very favourable price as it has a non-essential buckle missing, but they're not that expensive on Amazon etc.

It is actually a baby nappy changing out-and-about kit. The main compartment zips go about half way down, so the box drops in and doesn't fall out, it has a changing mat which is very handy when you want to sit down somewhere when you're wearing whites, also useful as a pad between the box and your back.

There is an an insulated pouch, about right for two 500ml cans, numerous pockets, and two external bottle pouches so bottles are accessible but away from the box.
The base is slightly padded. I keep a couple of bar towels there as well, so I can wipe the box down as needed in damp weather. I can get a fleece or other clothing above and around the melodeon, it isn't too bulky overall, and it doesn't announce that there is a musical instrument inside.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Guy on August 07, 2016, 11:03:30 PM
I wish people wouldn't stuff other things in the bag with their instrument.

I wish I'd heard this advice some time ago! I was playing at a festival in Spain, and part of the deal was free wine with the meals. As it was the main concert later, I thought I'd keep a clear head and save my bottle so stuffed it into the nearest handy receptacle....the melodeon (well padded, expensive) shoulder gig bag. As I was on my way, gig bag happily over my shoulder, I felt something trickling down the back of my leg...as it was bright red, my first thought was that I'd cut myself, then realised the awful truth...the top had come off the bottle. I discarded it in a nearby bin, and luckily was very near the hotel,so squelched across the foyer leaving a trail of red footprints on the light carpet and stood in the lift with other guests, reeking of alcohol. I emptied the case over the bath, dried the instrument as best I could with the hotel towels, threw my clothes into the bath as well, changed hastily and then rushed to the gig just in time to get on stage, with no idea whether the box would play or not. I didn't dare tell the rest of the band....
Fortunately all was ok, and it went very well, but my stress levels sufferered a lot! The melodeon dried out fine, but there were tell tale red wine stains left on the grille cloth...and the other hotel guests were firmly convinced that I was an unreconstructed alcoholic. As the room stank of stale wine for the next few days, I expect the staff did too....
I've never put anything in a gig bag or case since....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: robotmay on August 08, 2016, 07:19:21 AM
I've yet to find a gig bag I actually like. There seems to be some general consensus among bag designers that you should look a bit of a tit whilst wearing it, and that on no account should you be able to fit more than one A4 music book in the pocket. God forbid you have a spiral bound book.

I have my own design for what I'm deeming a "festival" bag, which I haven't gotten around to actually making yet. The idea being that it would have space for carrying a few other bits, as well as being more water-resistant and a bit tougher. Hopefully I'll get some time to make the sodding thing sometime soon, as well as an octagonal wooden case for my maccann concertina ::)
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Sage Herb on August 08, 2016, 07:20:39 AM
Pete 's bags are very nice. Not only substantial  zips but straps across the top too so no chance of zip failure. Check out reviews,  one is mine !
Q
Satisfied owner .

Another vote from me for Pete's bags. They are very good indeed; the best I've ever come across, in fact.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,18802.msg229300.html#msg229300

Choose your sizes here:
http://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?accessories
Absolutely - I recently bought two and they are excellent.
Steve
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 08, 2016, 09:01:53 AM
One thought about an anonymous black gig bag - it is anonymous!
Whilst it might be difficult to distinguish yours amongst a van full of others following a bag drop after a Morris processional, their anonymity to my mind is their advantage.

On a Morris tour around a town or in a crowded pub they blend in and don't stand out in the bag dump. Without that well known logo across the red bags ( and yes I have a small one ) they become another ruckie bag in a pile of others.
To a thief the dont shout ' I'm an expensive instrument, take me'!

I have a friendship bracelet woven in Morris team colours made by my daughter attached to both my bags on their top handles. They are 2-3" of bright colour to help me identify my bag against the others.
Whilst a personalised bag of my chosen fabric would be nice, it might attract unwanted attention from others.
Just a thought!
Q
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 08, 2016, 09:23:11 AM
... as well as an octagonal wooden case for my maccann concertina ::)

Beware of making a case which stores the instrument with its axis in a vertical orientation. This causes the downward facing valves to droop under gravity and can eventually end up with a permanent set which causes leakage and other problems. Hexagonal cases such as were supplied with Lachenal concertinas were notorious for this reason, even though they look nice. Wheatstone concertinas were (AFAIK) always supplied with an orthorhombic case in which the concertina laid with its axis horizontal, thus obviating the droopy valve risk. Modern concertina cases are nearly always like that too. If you really must have an octagonal case, make sure you design it so that it can be laid down horizontally.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: NickF on August 08, 2016, 11:26:06 AM
Yet another recommendation for the bags Pete supplies. Very sturdy & well made!
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: robotmay on August 08, 2016, 12:23:57 PM
... as well as an octagonal wooden case for my maccann concertina ::)

Beware of making a case which stores the instrument with its axis in a vertical orientation. This causes the downward facing valves to droop under gravity and can eventually end up with a permanent set which causes leakage and other problems. Hexagonal cases such as were supplied with Lachenal concertinas were notorious for this reason, even though they look nice. Wheatstone concertinas were (AFAIK) always supplied with an orthorhombic case in which the concertina laid with its axis horizontal, thus obviating the droopy valve risk. Modern concertina cases are nearly always like that too. If you really must have an octagonal case, make sure you design it so that it can be laid down horizontally.

Aye, that's the plan! The old cube-ish case for mine is a bit knackered. Planning to build one that opens in half along the long edge, with a shoulder strap and handle attached to both parts of the case, so it can't open accidentally. Honestly most concertina cases are really poorly designed; they nearly all rely on the lock not opening :-\

It's a bit of a big concertina, but having it horizontal on a shoulder strap should be comfortable enough. Probably!
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Clive Williams on August 08, 2016, 12:48:43 PM
One thought about an anonymous black gig bag - it is anonymous!
Whilst it might be difficult to distinguish yours amongst a van full of others following a bag drop after a Morris processional, their anonymity to my mind is their advantage.

I quickly learned at Gennetines that the instrument shelter (a manned saferoom you can store your instruments in, fantastic idea) was *full* of black melodeon cases, that looked just like mine. Next year I'd put a brightly coloured insulation tape strip down each end of the case - then I could simply ask for the black box with the yellow strip.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Clive Williams on August 08, 2016, 12:50:55 PM
Yet another recommendation for the bags Pete supplies. Very sturdy & well made!

Yes, ditto. His Mory rucksack bag is versatile, strong, and fits my Mory perfectly. And it goes in an overhead flight bin on a plane. For gigs where there's a lot of other people's stuff (and people) on stage though, if possible I prefer to use a hard case.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 08, 2016, 01:29:06 PM
I think without doubt a hard case gives better protection, but they pull my arms out lumping a hard case around a festival all day.
Something on your back is for me much more portable.
Q
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Clive Williams on August 08, 2016, 01:43:58 PM
I've been known to carry around a second melodeon in another hard case that I hardly use simply to balance the weight when carrying it - carrying a Mory in a hard case unbalanced is a recipe for severe shoulder issues! A rucksack bag is a much better solution! :-)
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on August 09, 2016, 12:22:41 AM
I bought a cheapish one from Hobgoblin, which fairly quickly split at the top seams. Hobgoblin replaced it with no questions, but the replacement split in exactly the same places. I replaced this with a Music Room one (thank you Ron) which has since gone every where with me. Packed carefully, I find that I can even get a melodeon in it. The two straps at the top will quite happily keep a coat under them and one can also be used as a pot holder. I have recently had to debeer it and go back to using the Hobgoblin one - not a pleasant experience at all.

Chris B.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve C. on August 09, 2016, 01:29:44 PM
Not to get off the subject, but Steve F, does this mean storing a box on it's feet or on it's side? Which side?
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: jonm on August 09, 2016, 03:55:50 PM
.... and I presume you mean storing concertinas on an edge rather than an end?
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 09, 2016, 04:07:03 PM
I always store my English concertina on its flat sides, thumb straps parallel with the ground.
I.e. In the playing position but on the ground
I have always adopted the habit of either playing it or leaving the concertina in its box in the position described.
My first decent concertina was a Lachenal Edeophone, the 12 sided model. I was told they had a habit of rolling if put on their flats, and as the flat sides are uneven they would roll then topple over onto their buttons and thereby knock out the ebony fretwork.

My melodeon is always standing on its feet, as recommended by Loffet and several others here.
The general concensus here is that in any other position the flaps can develope a set as Steve Freereeder describes.
Q
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 09, 2016, 10:01:24 PM
.... and I presume you mean storing concertinas on an edge rather than an end?
Yes - that's what I mean by storing the concertina with the axis horizontal. (good)
Storing it on an end means the axis is vertical. (bad)
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 09, 2016, 10:12:40 PM
Not to get off the subject, but Steve F, does this mean storing a box on it's feet or on it's side? Which side?

Melodeons are best stored on their feet (if they have them; not all do, especially one-rows). In other words with the bass end plate downwards and the keyboard upwards, and the axis of the bellows vertical. In this position the reed valves are also normally vertical* and thus the droop risk is minimised.

*Some melodeons (including, e.g. Castagnari Lily; some one-rows) have flat-mounted reed blocks which would theoretically be more likely to develop valve droop when stored in an upright position but I've never noticed this being a significant problem in these instruments. Perhaps concertina valves are more fickle and susceptible to gravy?   
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 09, 2016, 11:58:43 PM

 Perhaps concertina valves are more fickle and susceptible to gravy?
Only when played with Bisto...


But concertina valves are typically very thin leather, melodeon/accordion much thicker leather from those I've seen, or plastic of course.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 10, 2016, 12:36:12 AM

 Perhaps concertina valves are more fickle and susceptible to gravy?
Only when played with Bisto...


But concertina valves are typically very thin leather, melodeon/accordion much thicker leather from those I've seen, or plastic of course.

Oh bu**er, that should have said gravity! Whoops  :|bl
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Bob Ellis on August 10, 2016, 12:44:46 AM
Oh bu**er, that should have said gravity! Whoops  :|bl

You also seem to have difficulty spelling 'butter', Steve!   >:E
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 10, 2016, 08:52:02 AM
 ;D
Q
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 25, 2016, 07:37:12 PM
Beware of making a case which stores the instrument with its axis in a vertical orientation. This causes the downward facing valves to droop under gravity and can eventually end up with a permanent set which causes leakage and other problems. Hexagonal cases such as were supplied with Lachenal concertinas were notorious for this reason, even though they look nice.

Surely an octagonal box can be laid horizontally?  Then the remaining issue is to ensure the rotational orientaion is correct - mark one side "TOP"?  The best cure for these problems is to play the thing regularly so that the valves are sucked back into place before they take on a set...

I have a 30 button Stagi in a homemade octagonal case.  I'm sure it's worth more than the 'tina.

Rob.
Title: Re: What's your ideal gig bag?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 25, 2016, 09:37:48 PM
Beware of making a case which stores the instrument with its axis in a vertical orientation. This causes the downward facing valves to droop under gravity and can eventually end up with a permanent set which causes leakage and other problems. Hexagonal cases such as were supplied with Lachenal concertinas were notorious for this reason, even though they look nice.

Surely an octagonal box can be laid horizontally?  Then the remaining issue is to ensure the rotational orientaion is correct - mark one side "TOP"?  The best cure for these problems is to play the thing regularly so that the valves are sucked back into place before they take on a set...

Yes - that's the standard advice for an octagonal box: lay it on its side. The rotational thing doesn't seem to be an issue, especially with Lachenal concertinas which have the reed pans arranged radially.

Regular playing is always good for any instrument.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal