Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on September 04, 2016, 08:11:23 PM

Title: Does this model have a name?
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on September 04, 2016, 08:11:23 PM
Vendor says, circa 1950

Sir John
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 05, 2016, 12:56:53 AM
Could be an early Trichord in BCC#, but if so, the bass/chord buttons should be off-set across the rows, and these are not.

So perhaps it is an early Corona, probably in either GCF or ADG. Does the vendor state the keys?
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 03:13:46 AM
... perhaps it is an early Corona, probably in either GCF or ADG.

Some people, these days, might call this a "pre-Corona" - but Hohner would have described it simply as a No. 3522 (or No. 3522/31/12/2 to give its full specification).

They were first made like this c.1939-42, then from 1947-56 (until they were replaced with the new "streamlined" Corona), and the rounded treble keyboard ends (instead of "two-point" ones), combined with the presence of the two strips of decorative trim around each corner, wouid seem to suggest a "middle period" date, so late 1940's, or "circa 1950", may be about right.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 06:20:18 AM
Is it OK to jump into this thread to catch the knowledgeable unawares and ask which model this is, too? Any help appreciated, thanks.

 
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Bill Young on September 05, 2016, 11:25:03 AM
Referring to John's original post, that is probably what is referred to in this list of Hohner models from 2010 (http://de.playhohner.com/fileadmin/hohner_group/hohner/01_instruments/02_accordion_instr/10_accordion_year_of_manufacture/Hohner_Accordion_Model_Year_of_Maufacture.pdf) as a Dreirehrer (Three-row) available in 2- or 3-voice, starting in 1939.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 12:06:46 PM
Is it OK to jump into this thread to catch the knowledgeable unawares and ask which model this is, too? Any help appreciated, thanks.

No. 1600, of similar vintage to the 3-row in the original post.

Some people these days might refer to it as a "pre-Erica" - but that gets especially confusing in this context because Erika/Erica had already been used, as a name for a small Club Model, only a few years earlier...
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 12:08:38 PM
Thank you, Stephen, most appreciated.

But.........after looking at the list I dug up on another site (sorry, cannot remember which one now!) I cannot find any reference to a 1600 in order to try to date it. Any idea....Stephen....anyone?

Is there a definitive resource anywhere (I thought I'd found it!) so that I wouldn't have to keep asking inane questions of people who, undoubtedly, have better things to do than look for answers for me?
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 12:25:27 PM
Referring to John's original post, that is probably what is referred to in this list of Hohner models from 2010 (http://de.playhohner.com/fileadmin/hohner_group/hohner/01_instruments/02_accordion_instr/10_accordion_year_of_manufacture/Hohner_Accordion_Model_Year_of_Maufacture.pdf) as a Dreirehrer (Three-row) available in 2- or 3-voice, starting in 1939.

It probably is, though it also goes to show how incomplete the listings for button boxes/melodeons are there - seeing that they'd already been making 3-row boxes, in numerous models, for many years previously.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Theo on September 05, 2016, 12:48:17 PM
That list of Hohner models was first published in the book about Hohner "History Unfolds" published in I think 2011 to show 100 years of Hohner accordion production.  I can't find my copy just now but I recall that the model list is described as being compiled from catalogues held in the Hohner museum in Trossingen. It goes on to explain that the catalogue collection is incomplete, so there can be models that are not included in the list at all, and date ranges can be longer than those shown in the list.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 05, 2016, 01:31:14 PM
Indeed, I notice a few omissions in the listing....

No mention of a Preciosa Club 21 + 3, nor of a Koch 21/8 or a Modell I Club 19 + 2, all of which I have in my collection.

And I seem to recall seeing a Liliput 21/8 (no Club inner row) offered on this site some years back, again no mention, nor of the Shand Morino or the Gaelic as far as I can see.

Probably lots of others....

Maybe just short runs to test the market, or was Hohner accepting "one off" commissions back in the day?
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Bill Young on September 05, 2016, 02:17:08 PM
Yes, that list, and an earlier version dated 2006, has a lot of omissions. It's particularly galling that the Shand Morino, considered so important in Scotland, doesn't merit a mention. Visitors to Trossingen in recent years have found that it doesn't raise a blip on the Hohner corporate radar. They apparently did accept "one off" commissions at one time; the forerunner Hohner Special was one for Jimmy Shand in 1939.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 04:28:30 PM
I cannot find any reference to a 1600 in order to try to date it. Any idea....Stephen....anyone?

I was answering your question while you were asking it Edward, and my reply is already in the edit of my original post.

But I'll add that model numbers, or names, are often of relatively little help in dating instruments - so that, in this case, No. 1600 has been the model number for celluloid covered 2-row Hohners from the 1930s right up until today...

I'd rely more on constructional details - like, for example, grilles or feet. In fact the deciding factor, for whether one- or two-row "Vienna style" boxes of this era are of pre- or post-war construction, seems to be whether they have feet that are integral with swivelling catches (that engage with the screws) on the bass board, like this;

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/p10100012-2.jpg)

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/p10100013.jpg)

or they are seperate from the screws (the same as you'd find on a new one), like this;

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Hohner2815bassendpostwar.jpg)

Quote
Is there a definitive resource anywhere (I thought I'd found it!) so that I wouldn't have to keep asking inane questions of people who, undoubtedly, have better things to do than look for answers for me?

I'm afraid the best resource is probably my collection of old Hohner catalogues...  :(
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: melodeon on September 05, 2016, 04:34:38 PM
To the OP.

Yes, referred to as pre Corona.  I have owned a couple. Fine  boxes.

Reed blocks interchangeable with Coronas.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 04:49:04 PM
Righty-ho! This beastie has the swivel type of feet, so it's pre-war? (That's rhetorical, of course!)
But my Club 11, which from the 2007 list was only produced between 1934 and 1939, but has the other feet, is actually more likely to be post war, but we cannot really tell when?
It's all a bit confusing, I might just go for a lie down, and stop digging.
Thanks again, btw.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 04:49:54 PM
That list of Hohner models was first published in the book about Hohner "History Unfolds" published in I think 2011 to show 100 years of Hohner accordion production.

My copy is dated 2004, which would tally with the "100 years" - in fact it looks very much like the Hohner sons must have been itching to start making accordions, and only waiting for "the old man" to go... (And there seems to have been a similar situation at Wheatstone's, around the same time, over the making of Anglo concertinas!)  ::)

Quote
It goes on to explain that the catalogue collection is incomplete, so there can be models that are not included in the list at all, and date ranges can be longer than those shown in the list.

I'd reckon there are lots, and LOTS, of pre-war button box/melodeon models missing.  :(
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Theo on September 05, 2016, 04:56:12 PM
Stephen, thank you for the correction on the date, I was going on memory, which was never completely reliable, and is now heading for completely unreliable. ;-)
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 04:58:33 PM
Stephen, thank you for the correction on the date, I was going on memory, which was never completely reliable, and is now heading for completely unreliable. ;-)

I wasn't meaning you're wrong Theo - your copy could be a reprint or a later edition, I don't know. But I bought mine (in Germany) when it first came out.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 05:06:40 PM
But my Club 11, which from the 2007 list was only produced between 1934 and 1939, but has the other feet, is actually more likely to be post war, but we cannot really tell when?

Then I'd say it's either 1934-42 or 1947-52 - the latter because Hohner, like many other firms post-WW2, didn't start manufacturing again until 1947, and I have Canadian Hohner catalogues from the early 1950s that show the Club IIB, still in the square "pre-war" style in 1952, but fully streamlined by 1953.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 05:16:58 PM
I feel ever so guilty taking up your day like this; but is this not "fully streamlined"?
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 05:23:35 PM
I feel ever so guilty taking up your day like this; but is this not "fully streamlined"?

No, that's "square".

https://www.google.ie/search?q=hohner+club+iib&client=firefox-b&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiTjLme0fjOAhUJuI8KHRQfAgkQ_AUICCgB#imgdii=fPGthBEgZOWlsM%3A%3BfPGthBEgZOWlsM%3A%3BFUQRiYLujEgLaM%3A&imgrc=fPGthBEgZOWlsM%3A (https://www.google.ie/search?q=hohner+club+iib&client=firefox-b&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiTjLme0fjOAhUJuI8KHRQfAgkQ_AUICCgB#imgdii=fPGthBEgZOWlsM%3A%3BfPGthBEgZOWlsM%3A%3BFUQRiYLujEgLaM%3A&imgrc=fPGthBEgZOWlsM%3A)
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 05:37:35 PM
That's what my grandchildren think I am!
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 06:35:47 PM
That's what my grandchildren think I am!

I was tempted to put "daddy-o" after it!  ;)

But I hope you followed my link to the Google Images search, to see the fully-streamlined ones there.

But looking at your photo, I'd wonder if your Club II isn't pre-war anyway, with that dark brown varnished finish (you hadn't mentioned that). Post-war ones were celluloid in the catalogues, whilst (not being very familiar with them in this country) I don't know that even any of the smaller Club Models ever employed those swivelling catches - the larger ones and the 3-rows certainly didn't anyway...
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 06:44:23 PM
... I don't know that even any of the smaller Club Models ever employed those swivelling catches - the larger ones and the 3-rows certainly didn't anyway...

Ah, yes - I've a catalogue photo of a Club IB that shows it with the swivelling catches! (But not the other models.)
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Theo on September 05, 2016, 06:55:10 PM
Stephen, thank you for the correction on the date, I was going on memory, which was never completely reliable, and is now heading for completely unreliable. ;-)

I wasn't meaning you're wrong Theo - your copy could be a reprint or a later edition, I don't know. But I bought mine (in Germany) when it first came out.

It was a genuine thank you with no irony intended.   I too bought my copy when it first came out.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 07:09:17 PM
Thank you for adding to my confusion!!!!!!! To coin a phrase, I think I'm now back as far as the new Hohner manufacturers (Chinese?).
Dear Stephen, it seems to me that you're competing with Psugmogg Volbenz for the member with the most enviable resources, even though they're obviously very different.
I think I'll offer this one for sale, before it melts my brain altogether!
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2016, 07:13:22 PM
Post-war ones were celluloid in the catalogues ...

In fact a rare wartime French Hohner catalogue from September 1941 reveals the Club II was already celluloid-covered by then so, with that "Christmas tree" grille and the varnished finish, I'd suspect yours is most likely from 1938-9 Edward.  :Ph
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 07:41:13 PM
Well, well, well! You see? I probably couldn't have found that out in a month of Sundays.
Many many thanks for your efforts; a result! (And from the authoritative source!)

I'll just add that I don't like the look of the "streamlined" things. Judging by the design of almost all of the popular, expensive, boxes (Casta and the other Costallotis) it would seem that I'm not alone in that. Give me the old square things, any day. (Daddy-oh!)
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Microbot on September 05, 2016, 09:32:43 PM
Hi Ed, Steve and all,

... reverting back to an earlier question + picture from Ed, below is the model I've tended to call a 'pre-Erica' ... and I think it warrants the description.

I know the term 'pre-Erica' can be confusing when it is spoken, because of the 1930s Club Model Erika ...But the distinctive thing about the model in the photo below - where it differs from Ed's and where it is similar to the modern Erica - is the curved shape of the grill & the fact that the treble end isn't 'boxed around' with wood ... the treble soundboard is more exposed and you can actually see the edge of the treble pallets in the photo below. Like the modern Erica ... these can really deliver!

and just underlining Steve and Theo's point about to the list of Hohner ommited models ... this is a 12-bass version.

cheers

Mike R
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 05, 2016, 09:53:58 PM
I have an eight bass version of this, post war according to the feet, a really nice box. In that gorgeous red.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 05, 2016, 11:08:16 PM
That 12 bass one is startlingly pretty! I've often fancied trying to link a 12 bass left hand end to my 1140. As a long-time bass singer (not all that good, nor all that bass, to be perfectly honest) I really feel that I could (eventually) manage to knock out a proper bass line to run alongside a melody. All I would need to do then, is to get my hands working independently!
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: JNM SY on September 06, 2016, 02:24:15 PM
"... this is a 12-bass version."

Mike, is the clear perspex at the top of the grill effective at equalising the sound, or is it for something else?
 I,m thinking of trying some kind of baffle on the trichord at for the outside row which in noticably sharper in tone than the rest.
Any info on evening out the sound would be appreciated.
                                    Cheers,JNM SY

PS, sorry for drifting off topic, I,m new to posting stuff.
                                           
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on September 09, 2016, 01:22:31 PM
Well it's arrived, and it's not in bad nick, (bit of bellows wear) but having been led to believe it might be Bb Eb Ab, (the vendor wasn't sure, so I took a chance) it turns out to be G C F.
It plays with the usual clack one expects from a Hohner. The tuning needs refining, and something inside rattles, but all in all not a bad wee box.
So it's going up on sale again. £250 incl UK postage would give me my money back. So if anybody's interested?
Will put it in the proper section, once I have taken some photo's.

Sir John
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Theo on September 09, 2016, 09:02:48 PM
Is it OK to jump into this thread to catch the knowledgeable unawares and ask which model this is, too? Any help appreciated, thanks.

No. 1600, of similar vintage to the 3-row in the original post.

Some people these days might refer to it as a "pre-Erica" - but that gets especially confusing in this context because Erika/Erica had already been used, as a name for a small Club Model, only a few years earlier...

Here is a picture of a two voice club box with the name Erica with an "c".  Never sen for the first time today.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: triskel on September 10, 2016, 04:16:45 AM
No. 1600 ...

Some people these days might refer to it as a "pre-Erica" - but that gets especially confusing in this context because Erika/Erica had already been used, as a name for a small Club Model, only a few years earlier...

Here is a picture of a two voice club box with the name Erica with an "a".  Never sen for the first time today.

That one (with its wooden grille) looks like an early version Theo, but I have two different German Hohner catalogues (both from as late as 1938) that show the same 214 model with the metal grille, but one has the "Erica" spelling on it, and the other says "Erika"...  :o

I've more to say, but I'll have to come back to this thread when I have more time.
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: Winston Smith on September 10, 2016, 11:37:20 AM
As with many of your postings, we'll be waiting with bated breath!
Title: Re: Does this model have a name?
Post by: MarioP on October 14, 2017, 01:33:13 AM
I thought this only cane in 2 voice but a three voice I wonder if those reedblocks would be interchanchable with the Corona 3?

Thanks

Also who plays CFB? I’m searching for that key and I get a lot
Of Russian /Slovakian / folks playing some honky funky boxes :)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal