Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Lizzy on June 28, 2009, 08:42:52 AM

Title: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on June 28, 2009, 08:42:52 AM
Would anyone be able to advise me whether it is worth buying the mini child melodeon for a school morris side ages between 7 and 11.
I play melodeon for the side and we have had a harmonica workshop and some children are keen to move on to melodeon. I'm just wondering if the restrictions would be too great as in limited notes, I need to justify the expense! looking to buy maybe 10. Hope this makes sense and its posted in the correct place.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lester on June 28, 2009, 09:03:05 AM
If you mean the standard Chinese mini melodeon they have a number of down sides


But as a starter melodoen they have a certain charm

*(c) Lester Bailey - Neologism to describe the button nearest your chin
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: xgx on June 28, 2009, 09:34:01 AM
Might be worth asking somewhere like Hobgoblin for a demo box with the potential to negotiate a good price for 10

their prices are on the high side ...

...anyone here have contact with the importer?
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on June 28, 2009, 12:39:16 PM
Thank you Lester,   I didn't realize the key note was nearest the chin,  and the air button sounds as if it could be an issue. I think the best thing would be for me to  wait and try one at some point over the  summer. The one I had seen was on the Hobgoblin site at £18.95 Scarlatti. I suppose the main idea is to promote interest in Morris and Music.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on June 28, 2009, 12:49:29 PM
Might be worth asking somewhere like Hobgoblin for a demo box with the potential to negotiate a good price for 10

their prices are on the high side ...

good idea I'll try that thanks javascript:void(0);
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on June 28, 2009, 12:50:11 PM
opps not sure how to put the smiley face up!
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: forrest on June 28, 2009, 08:32:19 PM
My experience with the Chinese mini boxes is that they are rarely really playable fresh out of the box. I think the most that kids can usually do is get a back and forth 'hee-haw' out of them..... :||:
   A simple tune is difficult, mainly because of lack of air due to leaky pallets, valves and bellows corners. They can be greatly improved, however, but takes a bit of hands-on.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on June 28, 2009, 09:16:49 PM

Posts: 31



View Profile Personal Message (Offline)
   
   
Re: mini melodeons
« Reply #6 on: Today at 08:32:19 PM »
   Reply with quoteQuote
My experience with the Chinese mini boxes is that they are rarely really playable fresh out of the box. I think the most that kids can usually do is get a back and forth 'hee-haw' out of them..... mel2
   A simple tune is difficult, mainly because of lack of air due to leaky pallets, valves and bellows corners. They can be greatly improved, however, but takes a bit of hands-on.

Hmm doesn't sound good. Has anyone any other suggestions that would help these lovely primary children?
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Theo on June 29, 2009, 08:23:08 PM

Hmm doesn't sound good. Has anyone any other suggestions that would help these lovely primary children?

Yes - harmonicas,  even cheaper than mini-melodeon, and fewer parts to go wrong.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Mike Gott on July 01, 2009, 07:21:03 PM
Certainly they do need a fair bit of tweaking to make them properlley playable though I was amazed to find out that they are wooden with a "pearloid" type outer covering and fitted with removable reed blocks just like a little Erika! I have one in pink, my wife bought it for me.

I think Theo has a good point about the harmonicas.

Mike
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on July 01, 2009, 08:37:05 PM
I like the sound of the wooden base..  and the colour pink..........      The cute factor would be immense if we had 10 mini melodeon players and some eight year olds dancing a jig to shep hey.  We have had a harmonica workshop and every child has their own harmonica, this is for those who want to move on to melodeon. I really appreciate the help. (:)   
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: forrest on July 01, 2009, 09:24:17 PM
Sounds like a fun project, tiny. If you go through with it, please make sure that you have a video cam present!
      Keep in mind that most of these little Chinese boxes seem to be in the key of C. To add a bit of backbone to the performance, it might be a good thing for an experienced player, yourself perhaps, playing along on a robust Hohner or such, to fill in the spaces. Best of luck!!..................jwf

 :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||: :|||: :||:
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on July 01, 2009, 09:46:20 PM
Thanks it does sound fun. The side are dancing at Bromyard Folk Festival in September, not with mini melodeons this year but who knows maybe next year.  Good idea to play along I have a C/F Erica I will dig it out and have a go.  Even if the tune is not possible for the children maybe the chord sequence would be acceptable.  We do a Mummers play at Christmas that will be the time to try it and I will definitely record it. 

Are there any other mini morris/mumming sides? maybe we could do a mini tour!  Or maybe I'm getting to excited now!!
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Theo on July 01, 2009, 11:20:18 PM
Thanks it does sound fun. The side are dancing at Bromyard Folk Festival in September, not with mini melodeons this year but who knows maybe next year.  Good idea to play along I have a C/F Erica I will dig it out and have a go.  Even if the tune is not possible for the children maybe the chord sequence would be acceptable.  We do a Mummers play at Christmas that will be the time to try it and I will definitely record it. 

Are there any other mini morris/mumming sides? maybe we could do a mini tour!  Or maybe I'm getting to excited now!!

Liam Robinson (http://www.minimorris.co.uk/) does Morris work with schools
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on July 01, 2009, 11:28:08 PM
Liam Robinson does Morris work with schools


Thank you. An interesting and useful  site.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Alison Scott on July 02, 2009, 12:41:18 AM
Liam ran the workshop (at Crawley FF) that was the first time I ever actually got to play a melodeon, and also the all-time, no question, best kids' workshop we ever went to at a festival, where we made really plausible and sturdy (as kids crafts go) hobby horses:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/bohemiancoast/22628234/
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Lizzy on January 03, 2010, 03:17:57 PM
Hi ,   
just to say that the Primary School that I help in did buy 10 mini melodeons in the autumn term, and at Christmas the children played Shep Hey for the School Morris side. Actually they took part in three concerts in the final week of term, playing as I said Shep Hey alongside me for the Morris/Mummers play, and alongside the  violin section for a concert style evening.
They played and processed into the school hall and although we were not all playing exactly the same thing! the visual effect was tremendous.
Unfortunately we could not video this due to regulations, but maybe at another event this would be possible.

I say we played Shep Hey, the children did the chords and I played the tune.  We are moving on to tunes this term.  Some youngsters can get a tune out on the melody side but the melodeons are greedy on the air, so I shall have to choose very carefully what we learn.

Any suggestions gratefully received.

Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Kautilya on January 03, 2010, 06:33:39 PM
Hi ,  
just to say that the Primary School that I help in did buy 10 mini melodeons in the autumn term, and at Christmas  Any suggestions gratefully received.

REED ORCHESTRA??
Dear Tiny - congratulations on the progress you have made!

Might I suggest that you expand your melodeon band by picking up Theo's earlier tip.  Reinforce them (as there only 10 players at one time) by buying in a bulk batch of chromatic harmonicas. Every child can have their own, (maybe parents pay a little towards the ownership cost). They remain in school bags for a quick blast at any time, any place not just school assembly or story telling time.  

Many people say harmonica is a good introduction to the melodeon or concertina, far more will participate in the music and the melodeons you have bought can do the rounds.

I would recommend the Tower (Shanghai) Chromatic (see photo with button half way down) at  
http://web.mac.com/chaitanya.bhandare/Chaitanya_Bhandare/Blog/Entries/2009/10/25_FREE_HARMONICA_LESSONS.html

In fact I keep half a dozen new Tower Chromatics in my bag; in case I am at a bash and want to form an instant orchestra of non-players playing a  tune with just a few notes.

They are made in Shanghai and can do anything one might want. The model ranges in price from three  quid to about six quid depending which way you buy, but massively cheaper than anything else in UK like this.  The sound is sweet and they are easy to play (and clean and repair). Importers here may not have them and when they do they may zap up the price anyway.

The trick is to buy direct from China. Perhaps there are HK or Mainland Chinese with kids in a school. They can get someone to buy locally and then have them hand carried to the UK.  The same model is very popular in India so the same buy local bring home procedure could work.

Or I see someone in India is selling on line at about 4 pounds at the current exchange rate but I cannot vouch for that company, and the delivery of about 8 quid has to be added. Plus, I am not sure if that is for 10 units or whatever.  ALSO, the picture they show is squashed up so it is not square but long as in the earlier URL.

http://www.indiamusicalinstruments.com/Products/Musical-Instruments-Harmonicas/Tower/Harmonica-Mouth-Organ-Tower-Brand-Scale-Changer-Model/pid-3908.aspx

I am not a fan of HERO harmonicas. I have a number of these and alas they seem to go flat and or are quite harsh in sound and they are usually just diatonic and don’t take the bashing I give the Towers (and Swans, see below).

Second option is to watch out for Lidl Aldi Asda offers. However, these are usually only in C and they are the short 'harp' size.  I find it more difficult to play on these harps as they are not so forgiving when you make mistakes. But kids' smaller gobs may mean they work fine for them.  These store offers are usually around three or four pounds. Every time they show up I just buy a couple as I can’t resist, so I have quite a few of them lying around.

My last batch of Towers I ordered from a company in Shanghai and they were delivered in HK within a few days and I had them brought back.  My thinking it is that one should start a whole school on the harmonica.  It is possible, easy and cheap.  

I have the contacts for that company if you want and the lady in marketing speaks and writes good English. Remember that harmonica in China is a widespread school instrument so such companies are used to doing school orders.

Finally -  if you have some real talent popping up, the same company also got hold of a full set of  different key Swan (Chinese again) large diatonic harmonicas for me. The G is stunning and I use it all the time to join in tunes and quietly vamp chords during sessions. I think these cost me around 10 pounds each and the equivalent euro type might be five times that cost and not necessarily as good quality.

The same company can also supply a 10 or 12 set of 'harps' in different keys and flats and sharps and mine came in a smart velvet lined carry box which travels around with me.

I trust you have also been following the USB electronic melodeon discussion -- http://www.bassmaker.co.uk/ and you might talk to the creator Lee about diy school build (he also has a guitar offering) with the IT department and whatever they call woodwork, arts and crafts department nowadays.  Likewise, there are a lot of kids out there with phones (or parents' phones) that would take the iPod concertina application, which u can see on concertina.net  The download is 99 pence or cents.
http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=10504&st=36&p=106175&hl=ipod%20app&fromsearch=1&#entry106175

All this can go into the musical pot for a simple feast and each will generate activity through the other.





  


Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: juker on January 03, 2010, 09:13:41 PM
Hi ,   
just to say that the Primary School that I help in did buy 10 mini melodeons in the autumn term, and at Christmas the children played Shep Hey for the School Morris side. Actually they took part in three concerts in the final week of term, playing as I said Shep Hey alongside me for the Morris/Mummers play, and alongside the  violin section for a concert style evening.
They played and processed into the school hall and although we were not all playing exactly the same thing! the visual effect was tremendous.
Unfortunately we could not video this due to regulations, but maybe at another event this would be possible.

I say we played Shep Hey, the children did the chords and I played the tune.  We are moving on to tunes this term.  Some youngsters can get a tune out on the melody side but the melodeons are greedy on the air, so I shall have to choose very carefully what we learn.

Any suggestions gratefully received.


Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: juker on January 03, 2010, 09:16:29 PM
Hi ,   
just to say that the Primary School that I help in did buy 10 mini melodeons in the autumn term, and at Christmas the children played Shep Hey for the School Morris side. Actually they took part in three concerts in the final week of term, playing as I said Shep Hey alongside me for the Morris/Mummers play, and alongside the  violin section for a concert style evening.
They played and processed into the school hall and although we were not all playing exactly the same thing! the visual effect was tremendous.
Unfortunately we could not video this due to regulations, but maybe at another event this would be possible.

I say we played Shep Hey, the children did the chords and I played the tune.  We are moving on to tunes this term.  Some youngsters can get a tune out on the melody side but the melodeons are greedy on the air, so I shall have to choose very carefully what we learn.

Any suggestions gratefully received.



Fantastic Tiny - well done! As a teacher myself I a most impressed. I can see why mini melodeons would be better than harmonicas. In my jurisdiction if one wants to teach students a mouth blown instrument they have to be bought new and used only for one child - not usable for another group or another year's class.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Kautilya on January 03, 2010, 10:26:20 PM


Fantastic Tiny - well done! As a teacher myself I a most impressed. I can see why mini melodeons would be better than harmonicas. In my jurisdiction if one wants to teach students a mouth blown instrument they have to be bought new and used only for one child - not usable for another group or another year's class.
[/quote]

Sorry if I was unclear.  Elf and Safety was implicit in what I said.

I said bulk buy, so each and every child in the school has its "own" low cost, easy to play, quality musical instrument (e.g. a harmonica) to carry around with them everywhere. Most schools have limited money (as in this case, with just 10 melodeons). I am sure  as a teacher you also would love to see musical inclusivity like all of us.

Why limit numbers when all can be accommodated with a simple instrument which they can play to the min or the max and, in this case, also help them learn the basics of the melodeon, or the Anglo?

Be an optimist :D and don't see it as an either / or.  .. it can be cheap but good harmonicas for all AND a limited number of not so cheap melodeons to which all boys and girls might get access from time to time, as in the icons: :||: :|||: :|||: :||:

BTW want to bet how many bogey bugs you will find on melodeon buttons if you swab 'em? Great transmission route for virus and bacteria from hep to flu and  staph to etc etc. I can just see em being passed around within a class and from class to class... not like pupils' own harmonicas.   'Not that it ever did us any harm.....but then some of us are braind dead so praps.... :o

Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Matthew B on January 05, 2010, 05:46:32 PM
  • The chinmost* button is the key note so restrict the tunes that can be played
*(c) Lester Bailey - Neologism to describe the button nearest your chin

In the interests of forum decorum, we might want to do a bit more neologging and name the one at the other end of the row as well.

Perhaps "legward"?

Back and forth
To and fro
Hither and yon
Chinmost to legward
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Rob Phillips on January 05, 2010, 06:37:08 PM
I feel justifiably proud that I can play "Speed the Plough" on my little plastic melodeon :D .  Has anybody managed "Ashokan Farewell"?
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: george garside on January 05, 2010, 07:56:47 PM
  • The chinmost* button is the key note so restrict the tunes that can be played
*(c) Lester Bailey - Neologism to describe the button nearest your chin

In the interests of forum decorum, we might want to do a bit more neologging and name the one at the other end of the row as well.

Perhaps "legward"?

Back and forth
To and fro
Hither and yon
Chinmost to legward


the navel end would be nearer to the box than the leg or on could consider using the names of other more useful organs that are  also nearer than theleg1

george ;D






Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Matthew B on January 05, 2010, 08:38:35 PM
the navel end would be nearer to the box than the leg or on could consider using the names of other more useful organs that are  also nearer than theleg1

More useful than the navel?  That's where I keep the salt when I eat celery in bed.  What could be more useful than that?

So are we agreed?  "navelwise"
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 05, 2010, 09:30:07 PM
Isn't that all about ships?  ;D
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 07, 2010, 09:44:25 PM
I actually got into town today using my Old Git's Privilege Pass and tried one of these in Hawkin's Bazaar. Where my melodeons have basses on the left-hand end, this one had three air-buttons, two of which had chords played in the background (I may have missed the proper fuction of these). The right hand had the usual single notes, but these were thoughtfully obviated by a bellows with a built in air overflow system. An extremely unusual instrument.
Title: Re: mini melodeons
Post by: Kautilya on January 14, 2010, 03:15:14 AM
I actually got into town today using my Old Git's Privilege Pass and tried one of these in Hawkin's Bazaar. Where my melodeons have basses on the left-hand end, this one had three air-buttons, two of which had chords played in the background (I may have missed the proper fuction of these). The right hand had the usual single notes, but these were thoughtfully obviated by a bellows with a built in air overflow system. An extremely unusual instrument.

CHINESE HARMONICAS
Someone PMd me about how to get these so I did them up a detailed note (5-10MB) Word file on what you might find and some contacts in China to check out prices and supply. If anyone else wants a copy of it, feel free to PM me, [Though I am just going outside and may be some time..... like next week, depending on the gritters]
The same suppliers may also have mini boxes:D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal