Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ram Miller on October 13, 2016, 02:03:22 AM

Title: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Ram Miller on October 13, 2016, 02:03:22 AM
I am looking to pick up my first BC box and I am confused about how much weight to give to the bass layout.
 
The Weltmeister 86W is in my price range, and I read several good reviews on this and other sites. So this box is probably the front-runner for me.  I imagine (please correct me if I am mistaken) that it has the standard B/C bass layout (Paolo Soprani). I found some other B/C boxes that have the McComiskey bass layout.

My question is, how much of an advantage is the McComiskey bass layout? Is this something that I should learn on, or would I be better off learning on the Soprani system since my guess is that would be more ubiquitous? Should I choose a different box than the Weltmeister if that other box has a McComiskey bass?

Thanks,

Ram
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Stiamh on October 13, 2016, 03:55:11 AM
The so-called McComiskey layout makes only one change - instead of C/F on the inner bottom pair you have D/F. This then gives you the ability to play a D chord against the note of F#, which is on the push on B/C.

So it is an improvement but only an incremental one. You end up with having both D and G on two pairs of buttons.

Joe Burke's answer to that was to rearrange the two outer pairs of buttons to play G/G and D/D. Many B/C players prefer this layout.

You can see diagrams of these various systems here: http://squeezehead.com/keyboard-layouts/basses/LAYOUTS.html

I don't play B/C but I would guess that the best options for an 8-bass box are Joe Burke, McComiskey and Paolo Soprani, in descending order.

BTW You can expect an answer shortly from a well-known B/C player around these parts who will tell you that you need a 12-bass box with all unisonoric buttons.  (:)  Maybe so BUT: a) a modern 12-bass box will have a heavier l/h cabinet, which is not what you want when you are starting out on B/C and 

b) I assume you probably want to play Irish music on your B/C. If so, don't sweat too much about the bass layout on your first box. Unlike players of English and continental music, who are advised to start working on basses at the same time as melody, you are likely to be working pretty well exclusively on the right hand for a good while. When you are ready to start using the basses frequently (if you ever are ready to do so) you'll probably be ready for a new box and will have sorted out your ideas about bass systems.

Also, if you do get the Weltmeister with the Paolo Soprani layout, it wouldn't cost you much to have an accordion tech convert it to the Billy McComiskey layout. So I'd say, don't worry, get a box you like the sound of and that you can afford, and get stuck into it.
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: george garside on October 13, 2016, 08:50:14 AM
I agree with most of what Stiamh has said. 

Joe Burk layout is probably the most sensible but bass is seen as a sort of option to use 'as and when if atall!' my the majority of BC players.

Yes - don't worry about the basses until you have well and truly got the hang of the treble side.

 For the best possible and most versatile set up on a small 2 row 12 unisoric ( stradella)  offers the most usable bass but the only box I know that comes with it as standard is a version of the hohner Erica. This is quite rare the 8 bass being much more common.  AS far as playing goes the 12 bass end does not feel  any heavier than the 8 bass ( I have one of each)

if you are going for a posh bespoke box maybe Cairdene could do a 12 bass job.

george
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: JohnS on October 13, 2016, 09:31:12 AM
My starter box came as Paolo Soprani.  I had it converted to McComiskey then later to Burke.  You have to have G and D in both directions and to me it makes more sense to have those on the same button.

My dream box would be B/C with 60-bass stradella, were such a thing to be had.
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: deltasalmon on October 13, 2016, 12:58:17 PM
My dream box would be B/C with 60-bass stradella, were such a thing to be had.

Easily done by adding a C# row to the treble side!
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: george garside on October 13, 2016, 01:36:30 PM
there were some 2 row bc with 12x4 stradells 48 bass sold , I think, by klinkscale at Melrose. They played well and could have been made by Paolo Soprani .

There must be some of them available from somebody somewhere  and the 7ths can be managed without.

or you could go for a bcc# 12x4  casali , not much heavier than the 2 row and with a C# row entirely free of charge making playing in the flat keys dead easy

George

Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: george garside on October 13, 2016, 01:43:54 PM
the Bc is chromatic as it has the wherewithal to play in 12 keys. It is not however easily playable in 12 keys!

The BCC# is also chromatic but is easy to play in 12 keys so is chromatic in a practical sense.

george
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Andy on October 13, 2016, 02:17:05 PM

My question is, how much of an advantage is the McComiskey bass layout? Is this something that I should learn on, or would I be better off learning on the Soprani system since my guess is that would be more ubiquitous?

Ram
Please take this as personal opinions only

Soprani v McComiskey (BC box)

Key C:  No real difference - other than remembering to stay away from the D push if you have become accustomed to the Paolo Soprani layout.
Key G:  D push on McComiskey is occasionally handy
Key D:  D push on McComiskey is frequently an advantage
Key A:  D push on McComiskey will be an advantage but I find it hard going with either system, all the bass notes and chords are there but compared with C,G and D not so inclined to match bellows direction for treble. Having said that plenty folk can do good accompaniment in A, grabbing the bass notes as and when appropriate


My first BC box had the Soprani system although I only really started to make much use of the bass on it after I started playing BCC# with stradella. After much deliberation (between Burke and McComiskey) I got a box converted to McComiskey layout, my logic being that it would still be easier to swap between this and the Paolo Soprani layout.

I can confirm, as might be expected, that swapping between Soprani and McComiskey takes very little adjustment. I have no personal experience of jumping between Burke and Soprani but expect it would require more of an adjustment.

Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: tirpous on October 13, 2016, 04:41:18 PM
I see mentions of 12 buttons unisonoric bass.  What would be the bass notes and/or chords on these buttons ?  Is this a standard setup ??
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: george garside on October 13, 2016, 05:31:47 PM
Bass  & Maj  chords FCGDAE
 
george
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Andy on October 13, 2016, 05:36:52 PM
I see mentions of 12 buttons unisonoric bass.  What would be the bass notes and/or chords on these buttons ?  Is this a standard setup ??

Like this http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/Trichord.jpg

Can be found on most Trichords, occasionally to be found on Double Rays and  Double Ray Deluxe.

Standard small (12) Stradella also found on some small piano accordions.

George got there while I was typing but will post anyway

Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: boxer on October 13, 2016, 06:26:45 PM
the "modern Irish" bass layout as shown on this website is about the best compromise for 8 basses.

Unless you're gifted, learning to play the treble side competently will occupy your attention long enough for you to save up for a 12 bass box on which you can have the bass end re-tuned to the John Williams almost entirely (except the c/f pair) unisonoric arrangement, which as well as C,G,D,A,E and F, gives you B, which is the only important thing missing from the 8-bass arrangement.

Even with a 12-bass Williams setup, I'd be surprised if you were to bother much with the basses at all, even when you've mastered the treble side.

Good luck
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: tirpous on October 13, 2016, 06:27:22 PM
OK, thanks George and Andy !

Somehow, I keep imagining things like 12 chromatics bass notes (no chords), or 12 lowish notes to be used 2-3 at a time to make up chords (no bass)...
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Frank Bruce on October 13, 2016, 07:30:13 PM
I've got a double ray with the unisoric twelve bass but some of the advantage is definitely lost by having the big wide spaced buttons as compared with pa bass. You can't nip around and do bass runs or use, for example, the e with the c chord very easily. If I could, my choice would be pa style bass keys.
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Winston Smith on October 13, 2016, 10:01:07 PM
"12 chromatics bass notes (no chords)"

As someone who has still to come to terms with the basses, that sounds very interesting. I'm sure one of our clever clogs could fix up such a system?
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Stiamh on October 13, 2016, 10:25:27 PM
the "modern Irish" bass layout as shown on this website is about the best compromise for 8 basses.

AKA "McComiskey layout".

Ram, I hope you are not getting sinking into a mire of confusion with all this talk about 60 stradella basses, 12 unisonoric buttons, and what have you. Keep focused on the fact that you need to get an affordable B/C box with a decent action and sound and start working on the right hand.

If it has Joe Burke layout, good. If it has a McComiskey layout, fine. If it has a Soprani layout, no big deal - as I said earlier, you can easily get it modified to the McComiskey layout, but there is really no rush for you to do that.
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: george garside on October 13, 2016, 10:38:08 PM
"12 chromatics bass notes (no chords)"

As someone who has still to come to terms with the basses, that sounds very interesting. I'm sure one of our clever clogs could fix up such a system?

I think the Scottish band leader Fergie has 12 chords and no bass  notes!

george
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: gettabettabox on October 13, 2016, 10:47:01 PM
hi ram. if you're intent upon irish music?... my advice would be to follow stiamh's recommendations.
the bass and chords will come later...and if you're maybe thinking of getting good enough to  play with others in a session, you're not likely to hear much of them above the din, nor want to hear them against string produced chords.
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Gromit on October 13, 2016, 11:25:48 PM
Yes Stiamh is the man if it's Irish music you're into - take his advice he knows his stuff and he has a great series of You tube videos for C sharp D box most of which is useful for B/C.
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Ram Miller on October 15, 2016, 03:04:34 PM

Ram, I hope you are not getting sinking into a mire of confusion with all this talk about 60 stradella basses, 12 unisonoric buttons, and what have you. Keep focused on the fact that you need to get an affordable B/C box with a decent action and sound and start working on the right hand.


Thanks for the advice Stiamh. As a final (for now at least) question, would you consider a Weltmeister 86W to be a decent affordable box?

Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Stiamh on October 16, 2016, 01:57:01 AM
As a final (for now at least) question, would you consider a Weltmeister 86W to be a decent affordable box?

It certainly looks affordable. But I've never tried one or seen or heard one in the flesh, so I can't say anything about other aspects. A student of mine has a 3-v wooden-finish Weltmeister (I don't know what model, sorry) and it's a well-made, very nice-sounding machine with a good action (traditional open fingerboard though).

There was some discussion of the 86W on here a while back: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=2857.0

 
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Elouan Imbeaud on September 16, 2020, 08:34:28 PM
Hi, still alive ! 😁
I prefer reopen this topic than create a new one on the same subject.
So, I enjoy playing on the Saltarelle bc box since last week. It's hard of course, like learning how to read again but motivating. I play - bad 😁 - The Blackbird and the Kesh jig to train myself.
Anyway, I was thinking about the basses. I'm a huge user of basses on my GC and of course wandering what would be the perfect layout for the BC. I already know that 8 basses won't be enough in a few time - I actually use 18 - so 12 seems cool.
But which ones ? I want to keep the McComiskey which is pretty close to the GC 8 basses I'm familiar with, but what about the other four ?
Any advices from the Irish players ? Thanks
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Stiamh on September 16, 2020, 11:19:01 PM
Wait until you can play tunes well and are familiar enough with the demands of different tonalities before deciding. That will probably give you a few years in which to ponder the question.  :|glug

I had insufficient experience when I chose my first 12-bass layout and made one definite wrong choice and two others that were discutable.

Also see Boxer's answer above.


Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: george garside on September 17, 2020, 11:43:27 AM
I have  hohner double ray with 12 stradella bass which I find very useful but this may not be particularly suitable for Itm

george
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Elouan Imbeaud on September 17, 2020, 12:35:54 PM
The John Williams option seems great indeed.
I know that I've got time with the right hand ! 😉 But years, in plural ? Really ?
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Stiamh on September 17, 2020, 12:43:51 PM
The John Williams option seems great indeed.
I know that I've got time with the right hand ! 😉 But years, in plural ? Really ?

That depends on you! I will be delighted if you can show me that my predictions are baseless :|glug
Title: Re: Bass layout question for B/C boxes
Post by: Elouan Imbeaud on September 17, 2020, 12:52:40 PM
😁 Well, I know it's almost another box, nevertheless I'm far from a beginer.😉
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal