Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: martin p on October 16, 2016, 10:18:14 PM
-
Question for my musical friends. If one is playing a tune in Em, should one use Em, Am and Bm chords to get the 3 chord trick of CGD and similar for other home keys?
-
Others will guide you, but you may want to consider B major instead of minor - depending on lots of factors.
-
Why B major? I have boxes with B major and B minor chords. The B minor chord is never out of place when played against a D note, but the B major chord sounds discordant, presumably because the D# in the chord clashes with the D note.
-
The thing with minor keys is there is more than one minor scale and more than one convention with chords.
In many folk tunes in what most people would call E minor, the next chord you need is D, and if the tune has a C# in it you are unlikely to need any A minor chords at all.
Then your "E minor" tune has a good chance of straying into G in the second half. Many do...
(Executive Summary: there's isn't a universal "three chord trick" for minor keys.)
Why B major? I have boxes with B major and B minor chords. The B minor chord is never out of place when played against a D note
But some E minor tunes have D# in them, and then a B minor chord doesn't work but B major does..
-
Why B major? I have boxes with B major and B minor chords. The B minor chord is never out of place when played against a D note
But some E minor tunes have D# in them, and then a B minor chord doesn't work but B major does..
What Anahata said...
Bob - you are fortunate to have choice of both B major and B minor chords. But generally speaking, most of us don't and hence we are back to the long-standing debate of which one to have. It's worth repeating for newcomers to the forum...
If, like most of us, you only have one B chord available it is far more versatile to have it tuned as B major rather than B minor. The D# is there in the chord for when you need it. When the music calls for B minor, the easy and effective fudge of Bm7 is always possible: push B bass with push D chord.
You can't do it the other way round: if your chord is tuned to B minor, it is not possible to fudge B major in the same way when you need it.
-
It's not obvious when you start playing a DG box why you would need a B major chord, but when you discover a tune where it works its is such a delicious discovery.
-
What Anahata and Steve said ... there is a whole spectrum of 'minor scales' and one way to explore is to play Em 'on the D row' and then find Em again on your G row. The push pull pattern is different and you might find it easier to cross finger E,F,G,A,B,C finishing off D,E on either row.
Different feel? The D one is called Dorian Em and comes from (obviously) D scale reservoir with it's C#. The other is from G reservoir and a C natural - softer? More mellow? It is variously called 'relative' 'church' 'Neapolitan' minor. Importantly the chords In the 'trick' also come from these reservoirs and in particular dorian wants A major rather than A minor.
Many others but Anahata alludes to 'harmonic' which is what a lot of European and classical music is based on. It is the G based 'mode' but changes the D to a D# as well - which is why our B (B+D#+F#) chord is major.
In practice we cheat quite a lot - eg just tap B bass if the chord jars to your ear. And most UK folk music doesn't go 'harmonic' anyway (as Theo alludes). B bass + push D chord (=Bm7) is another standard and very useful fudge.
More on https://chrisryall.net/modes/ if you want it
-
It really depends on the type of music you want to play and which variety of minor key you most frequently come across.
The Salterelle which I've now been playing for more than 20 years came with a Bm chord* and I've never missed the B major. Maybe this is because I play folk tunes, maybe because I'm unencumbered by a knowledge of music theory, maybe it's just what I'm used to. On the other hand, I do play in B minor quite often, where having the 'proper' chord really helps. On my other boxes which do have the equivalent major chord I'm invariably fudging it. I'm sure that Theo is right and that there are tunes where a major is delicious but I seem to manage without it.
*I'm not sure why, as it has a stop to remove the thirds so could easily have had both.
-
Howard, that sounds like a case of not missing what you never had a chance to try. I really like an occasional taste of chocolate. I would not like to never have tried it (:)
-
Question for my musical friends. If one is playing a tune in Em, should one use Em, Am and Bm chords to get the 3 chord trick of CGD and similar for other home keys?
Simple answer... usually, yes. Em, D, C, Bm are most common... and quite often the bass runs down like that in the tune. If you're feeling flash you might get a G major or Am in there too. If your B chord is tuned major, use B bass + D chord instead to get something 'close enough'. For Am, use A bass + C chord.
Cheers,
Clive
-
It really depends on the type of music you want to play and which variety of minor key you most frequently come across.
The Salterelle which I've now been playing for more than 20 years came with a Bm chord* and I've never missed the B major. Maybe this is because I play folk tunes, maybe because I'm unencumbered by a knowledge of music theory, maybe it's just what I'm used to. On the other hand, I do play in B minor quite often, where having the 'proper' chord really helps. On my other boxes which do have the equivalent major chord I'm invariably fudging it. I'm sure that Theo is right and that there are tunes where a major is delicious but I seem to manage without it.
*I'm not sure why, as it has a stop to remove the thirds so could easily have had both.
If you have never felt the need for B major then you are secure in folk/modal music territory and don't have need of theory. If the tune is 'harmonic minor' then the lead D# truly sticks out lick a sore thumb due to the 1½ interval from its neighbour, C. No worries.
You might be playing a C against Em dorian tunes however. It's technically wrong (Em dorians have a C#) but half of Ireland (IME) and most of England do that … it has arguably become 'traditional'.
Do try a D, G or even A instead - you might like it :|glug
-
Thanks all for your learned input. I see many hours of experimentation ahead. Might surface as a Tune of the Month contribution eventually, although I hate recording. Have we done Jigs in minor keys as ToTM?
-
Above all "Trust your ears"
-
Have we done Jigs in minor keys as ToTM?
Not yet, but if you don't mind, I might pinch that idea :-)