Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on July 03, 2009, 07:04:32 PM
-
iv been playing at a "play around" session for a few months now and its due again tomorrow night, but I'm sick and tired of playing tunes really badly (I've been known to stop halfway after forgetting notes etc!). at home i can play the same tunes with ease and some times find myself reading the paper while i play them!!! i probally have a few too many beers which i know doesn't help, but is there any thing i can do to play in front of people better??? i will report back tomorrow!!!!
-
...... is there any thing i can do to play in front of people better???
I still struggle now with good nights, very good nights and bad nights but don't we all?
I've concluded that I need at least one pint of Guinness inside me before I feel relaxed (less tensed up) enough to lead a tune but then beware, too much alcohol can have the opposite effect by relaxing you too much!
I also need a focal point to look at (my pint of beer) and concentrate on it and no matter what, try to keep the tune going and flowing to the end even if you make one or two mistakes, although granted, it's sometimes easier said than done!
Be sure to pick a tune that you know your fellow musicians are familiar with and can help you along if you falter. There's nothing worse than starting a tune, say in an unfamiliar key or one that no-one recognises/knows and then finding yourself playing solo!
Skipy
-
Unfortunately, practicing while reading the paper makes one proficient at...playing while reading the paper. Exercising as specific as possible replicating performance environments as close as possible will no doubt improve your proficiency in those environments.
-
Skippy, for a minute i thought you were about to pick up on all my spelling mistakes!!!
there are such a diverse range of musos at my session i normally play the first few bars solo the some one chips in with a guitar, although by the end of the tune everyone will be having a go, theres all styles from folk bluegrass country blues and old jovial music hall songs, so not your typical session but i really enjoy it as you get to listen to all sorts of styles, I'm having one pint at 7.45pm then Shandy's till 10pm and then I'm gonna slosh it . should i play tunes that i know well or try to push myself??
-
should i play tunes that i know well or try to push myself??
Personally, I would stick to the tunes you know first until you can play them well enough in the session. I think Skipy's advice is spot on, the key (for me anyway) is to get the flow from brain to fingers, without the conscious mind intervening (does that make sense), and for me if I'm nervous then focussing on an object (as Skipy suggests) works a treat, I often focus on the bass end of my box. I think also good advice about limiting the drinking.
One of the best ways to pick up tunes is to sit in the session and try and join in when others play something unfamiliar, at first you might only get the odd notes, but it soon comes. That way you also end up knowing the repertoire of the session
Best of luck
Trevor
-
Skippy, for a minute i thought you were about to pick up on all my spelling mistakes!!!
Moi??? ;D
PS. Only one p in Skipy ;) ;D Snigger's...... (copyright of that Kangaroo..... remember him?)
I definitely agree with Trevor, stick to tunes you know well and are really comfortable with, that you are so comfortable with, you reach the end before you realise it. Playing a tune well and then getting a positive feedback from your audience/fellow musicians gives you so much confidence. Once you have that confidence, then start to be braver!
I only try a new tune in public once I am confident that I stand a fair chance of seeing it through, you can play it ten times through at home but when you are tensed up, with all eyes and ears on you.......... that's a different matter!
PS. Don't leave it until right at the end of the session to try out a new tune, then if you do mess it up and feel a bit down, you will still have enough time to play a familiar/comfort tune to pick you up again before you pack up.
I can imagine nothing worse than going home from a session feeling down!
Enjoy!!
Skipy
-
See the "Playing goes to pot in public" thread for lots of comments about this.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,361.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,361.0.html)
I find a lot of sessions are of the singaround/playaround type, where you have to take your turn to play something, and with a mixture of singers and different sorts of musicians, chances are you will end up virtually doing a solo, and it's very difficult unless you have one or two good accompianists in the session.
I actually find it harder than playing up on stage with a ceilidh band, or playing solo for morris.
It's much easier, and I think more rewarding, when there are a group of people who play the same sort of music and have a common repertoire. Sessions should be a social thing as well as a chance to play your tunes in public, but sometimes it feels more like a performance than a fun night out. If you stick with it, though,you should find that as you get to know people it will get easier.
Having said that, it's good experience playing in that situation. People who have music lessons with a teacher get used to playing in front of people on their own, but for those of us who have learnt on our own in the safety of our own homes it is something we have to try to get used to.
-
sorry about the two Ps !!! darn spell chequer
-
My cousin Pete has been a performer (by which I mean he has sometimes nearly supported himself by playing music) for most of fifty years. He says he has not once in all that time got up in front of strangers and not had hellacious, debilitating stage fright. But in a small batch of people whom he knows, he can carry anybody through their mistakes, and graciously ease them down to where they can play just fine -- or enjoy themselves anyway. Perhaps getting with a smaller, closer bunch of musicians would be a good intermediary step toward losing your angst.
-
Only advice I can give is stare fixedly at something and try to forget all about it.
-
I learned to play for other people by playing for other people...(I'm speaking about bluegrass/oldtime mandolin now, since I'm not yet good enough on the boxes to play it for other people like that) I think in the beginning I just tried to think that I was among friends and if I screwed up it would be ok.... I've been playing mainly in my church and then we lived a year in Ireland and played in a session where we knew people. There, they would happily listen to a Swedish tune (there i played the fiddle or sang) and it was a very friendly environment so I never felt nervous. I think my stay in Ireland and playing in sessions really got me used to playing in public, I never feel nervous now... at least not so that it disturbs my playing or singing.
I'd say the main key is to know the tune really well and to know what to do if you screw up. Like, if you miss notes, just play something else that suits until you get back to the melody. Also, I'd think it depends on the session environment.. how are the other people? Your friends? Critical to other people's playing? If they're your friends, does it matter that you screw up at times?
I don't know if anything I've said helped, but good luck anyway! And don't worry about those spelling errors. We understand you. By the way, if you think you make too many mistakes, try the session without the beers.
-
You know - most of those people want you to play well, but won't judge you if you don't. If you are playing with the type of people who would judge you, then find another session. I'd say maybe limit yourself to two giant beers and just have fun. Isn't that what sessions are about? Having fun? That's what it's all about anyway. One thing you could do is work seriously at home practicing, and when you are practicing, imagine you are there playing with all the others and they are enjoying your playing. That's what I do when I practice. I imagine I'm in front of a crowd. I think it does help to keep away the nervousness. I've been to see some very famous musicians play - who have forgotten tunes in the middle of them. In the big scope of life, it doesn't matter - so don't kick yourself for it.
Kay
-
I don't think there is any magic formula. What works for one person won't necessarily work for another. However, for what it's worth, I find it helps to concentrate on running through the tune in my head staying just a few notes ahead of my fingers so that the fingers know where to go when they get there.
-
I have been reading this thread with great interest and have been wondering how I react. When playing for morris I feel no "nerves" at all, concentration on the job in hand, yes definately, but not debilitating "nerves".
At music sessions where everyone joins in, again, not a great problem starting a tune.
At sessions where people have a turn to do a song or a tune, and no one joins but everyone listens desperately waiting for their own turn, it is a different matter. I become more and more nervous and paicky, and experience gross loss of tune memory, as my turn approaches.
I wonder if it is down to experience? The more one does something the less frightening it becomes, as long as bad stuff doesn't happen.
-
Sadly, I recognised the symptoms! No matter how long you've been playing, beer can reduce you to a mindless, numb-fingered idiot. This is more of a problem at the type of mixed session you're describing, as you have long periods of inactivity (strange how one's beer evaporates during these). When you have to play your piece, it's worse than a solo as people try to learn it on the fly, creating something between harmony and cacophony - rather distracting.
Strangely, at a morris session, where evryone knows nearly all the tunes that'll turn up, its much easier to keep going despite the inebriation (camping weekends only). But any break in the playing and I can't restart.
Yes, we all fail 'cause we're trying to play a "new" tune, so laugh it off and try again some other time.
Rob.
-
"A tune too far" councilled Steve Harrison perhaps unkindly as I cocked up the C-part of Groupa's fis schottiche. The bit where it drops down the G minor scale, having been staunchly major for 2 complete parts.
Practiced it a million times :||: and have it absolutely solid at home. But try it in a session and I can feel that Bb coming at me from about 10 bars ahead. That's just time enough for a burst of adrenalin to reach my musical brain bits and cause me to stumble.
My advice is to play firmly through it, never stop, don't apologise (they all sympathise anyway as fellow travellers), and try to keep the rhythm of the piece steady. That's more important than the actual notes anyway. If you're really lucky it becomes an improvisation. Then repeat the mistake on the second time through on purpose - to emphasise how 'cool' you are 8)
Eventually that panic reaction subsides and you can transfer your neurosis to a different new piece of music. :-\ D3R
-
I don't think there is any magic formula. What works for one person won't necessarily work for another. However, for what it's worth, I find it helps to concentrate on running through the tune in my head staying just a few notes ahead of my fingers so that the fingers know where to go when they get there.
This is very true. As an illustration, the above advice would for me make things considerably worse :P
-
We are all different, but that audience tends to be 'the same' (law of averages). Remember they are actually on your side. Don't ever stop, and keep that rhythm going. Only to 'give up' is a surrender.
You'll stumble (and mysteriously know exactly where the problem will raise its ugly head on each new tune), but do keep going. Eventually your tunes become part of you.
To press on is to put aside your inner fears and become a better player. I really believe the odd bum note doesn't matter.
-
And never apologise for cocking it up. Are you playing as best you can at the moment? Then what's to say sorry for? As was said above, just laugh it off with some comment like a heartfelt "OH STOCKING TOPS!"
Nigel
Back to practising.
-
Just back from a posh recording studio down that London Village where I played lots of bum notes, forgot the tune three times and muttered more than "stocking tops"!
Rock on. :||: :||: :||:
-
.... forgot the tune three times and muttered more than "stocking tops"!
Oh Rees and we all thought you were a 'man of the cloth', I do hope the words uttered were along the lines of 'Oh Bother' or 'Silly me' or 'Fiddlesticks', eh?? ;D
-
I have been reading this thread with great interest and have been wondering how I react. When playing for morris I feel no "nerves" at all, concentration on the job in hand, yes definately, but not debilitating "nerves".
At music sessions where everyone joins in, again, not a great problem starting a tune.
At sessions where people have a turn to do a song or a tune, and no one joins but everyone listens desperately waiting for their own turn, it is a different matter. I become more and more nervous and paicky, and experience gross loss of tune memory, as my turn approaches.
I wonder if it is down to experience? The more one does something the less frightening it becomes, as long as bad stuff doesn't happen.
I have exactly the same experience, morris is no problem (now, it was nerve-wracking at first!) or sessions, but I regularly go to a group of very friendly musicians, with a small audience. It's mainly accordions and melodeons, and most are well into their 60s (the oldest are in their 80s and 90s), but playing in the solo rounds is a very nervous thing! It does get better with practice, but with 30 seconds to go to my turn, I still get a bit wobbly! mind you the feeling of achievement when you get through without an obvious mistake more than compensates for the nerves.
Trevor
-
Stefan Grossman was once asked how he managed to play difficult guitar instrumentals in public without apparent nerves, and his answer was that you just have to have confidence in your material, which stuck in my mind.
A little trick I find works is to appear to be confident, even when you're not feeling it! Smile at everybody, sit back in your seat, chat to the others about what you're going to play. Then the audience relaxes before you start. And this works because when they relax, you do too. I'm not sure about the advice to stare at your pint, for this reason - it just separates you from everybody, and isn't the whole point of a session that everybody enjoys each others company?
-
I've accidentally ended up at a few of these recently, in my first forays into 'festival' sessions...and been completely terrified. Managed to stumble through a tune or two (with plenty of wrong everythings), and came out thinking 'so that's why everyone plays with their eyes closed'! I just stared at the floor instead - which doesn't feel at all natural to me, but it was the only way I could manage to keep going! Just a case of perseverance I suppose, although I must confess that I enjoy the 'other sort' of session more. And I'd wish they'd differentiate in name, so I could tell before walking in to the room, at which point you can't really walk straight back out again, however much you might want to ::)
-
I've accidentally ended up at a few of these recently, in my first forays into 'festival' sessions...and been completely terrified. Managed to stumble through a tune or two (with plenty of wrong everythings), and came out thinking 'so that's why everyone plays with their eyes closed'! I just stared at the floor instead - which doesn't feel at all natural to me, but it was the only way I could manage to keep going! Just a case of perseverance I suppose, although I must confess that I enjoy the 'other sort' of session more. And I'd wish they'd differentiate in name, so I could tell before walking in to the room, at which point you can't really walk straight back out again, however much you might want to ::)
if that happended to me....i'd have a heart attack..or faint...or let out a yelp and run out again.
-
some play around sessions (which I dont think of as sessions anyway) consistof each in turn in effect doing a solo spot. There is however absolutely no reason way you can't invite those who wish to join in when its your turn & then if you lose the plot just keep the air button down & mime!
The other essential play for relative newcommers to the box is to have 2 or 3 highly practiced 'sunday best' tunes for such occasions - they don't have to be unusual or fancy or fast , or with elaborate bass - just ones you can play well without getting overcome by nerves. Unfortunately we all like to keep learning new tunes but not necessarily learning to play them really well before movingon to yet another one -
george
-
some play around sessions (which I dont think of as sessions anyway) consistof each in turn in effect doing a solo spot. There is however absolutely no reason way you can't invite those who wish to join in when its your turn & then if you lose the plot just keep the air button down & mime!
george
My local session is a friendly play around type. People will definitely join in on anything they know (or don't sometimes). If I get nervous then I just stick to one of the old favourites like Princess Royal or Speed the Plough knowing that I will be accompanied after half a beat!! and that is usually a good settling start. In terms of keeping the air button down, I sometimes play through a tune with the button down as a warm up and reminder of what I hope to play. (I have to assume that I am reminding myself of the right notes!!) Fatal to accidentally let go of the air button though!!
Cheers
Sandra
(:)
-
You can always just pass when your turn comes
-
Take the opportunity this summer to take your box to friends and familys barbeques, and don't be afraid to get it out for a quick squeeze.
Doing this where you are assured of an audience that a) is supportive and b) not likely to borrow your box and show you up (!) is great for the confidence. You can also start by finding a seat a bit away from where everyone is nattering and just start up. People will soon drift over and listen/watch and probably ask questions (normally just as you are getting to the difficult bit!).
-
Take the opportunity this summer to take your box to friends and familys barbeques, and don't be afraid to get it out for a quick squeeze.
Doing this where you are assured of an audience that a) is supportive and b) not likely to borrow your box and show you up (!) is great for the confidence. You can also start by finding a seat a bit away from where everyone is nattering and just start up. People will soon drift over and listen/watch and probably ask questions (normally just as you are getting to the difficult bit!).
I've done that twice so far....problem is they like me to play songs they know....which aren't what I can actually play. :-X
last time it was Madness-Baggy Trousers that go requested
-
Take the opportunity this summer to take your box to friends and familys barbeques, and don't be afraid to get it out for a quick squeeze.
Excellent advice! I tried this a few weeks ago and there was even dancing (:)
Well O.K. the dancer was 2, but his dad was quite appreciative. I was also playing concertina on a windy Chesil Bank at the weekend. Lots of people around and they couldn't hear me . . . . which was nice for all concerned! It does help with learning how to concentrate though.
-
I'm not sure about the advice to stare at your pint, for this reason - it just separates you from everybody, and isn't the whole point of a session that everybody enjoys each others company?
We're all different and we all do things differently and I agree with you Chris about showing confidence but I remember, from not too distant memories, that when you are a novice, starting a tune for the first few times, it is very daunting, you feel that all eyes and ears are on you and any distraction from the audience or fellow musicians can be enough to make you 'lose it', which is why I recommend looking at a focal point, especially on a new tune.
Now I have gained that 'confidence' in myself, which comes in time, I find that I can now, whilst playing, look around the audience/fellow musicians for their reactions.
I also agree with, don't stop or apologise, just smile and keep playing, you can only do your best.
As for family BBQ's and Parties, I love them, I take my mp3 player (with songs/tunes that preferably have no accordions/melodeons playing in them), plugged into a small amplifier and play along to them, a bit like Melodeon Karaoke, I suppose ::) I use my young daughter as my sound man... woman... girl? She selects the song/tune and gives me a nod when she presses play.
I play my favourites tunes and songs and throw a few old favourites in as well, Molly Malone, Fields of Athenry, Daisy Daisy, Goodnight Irene. It always goes down well, people sing along, the young children always dance and touch wood, I keep getting asked along next time :o
It makes it all worthwhile and boosts your confidence no end!
Enjoy!!
Skipy
-
This is something that I did and it has had a huge impact on my confidence.
I bought myself an A5 ring-binder and some polly pockets. I picked A5 because it is small enough to fit inside my case.
Then, I made a list of all of the tunes that I needed to know for my Morris activities and collected them in, re-writing them using a music processor (Mozart 7). I printed them onto card then placed them inside the ring binder in alphabetical order.
Now, when a tune gets called, we don't get embarrassing moments waiting for somebody to whistle the tune.
If you don't read music, I still think it's worth getting a little book, possibly an address book and write down the names of the tunes that you know well in ink, those you are learning in pencil.....ink over them when you've cracked them. Then when you practise them you can run through your repetoire.
I was really surprised to find out how many tunes I knew .
Phil
-
My Grandpa did the same, partly because to his annoyance Lionel Bacon didn't present the black book in D and G. I have his "black book", which fits snugly in my melodeon case and is very useful indeed!
-
I didn't mean 'showing confidence' as a method. Yes your first few tunes are very scary, but it's lovely and uplifting how a good session will wrap itself around a novice and support him/her.
But never stopping when you play a bum note or chord is IME very good 'attitude' to develop Chris
-
I find prior preparation helps, particularly if you think a session might be a 'solo play around' rather than 'all join in'.
I try to practice two or three sets of tunes which I like and am comfortable playing - sorting out any issues (bass notes, fingering issues) and especially the changeover.
And work out how to remember them when it is time to play (see recent thread on this subject) - I try to recall a distinctive phrase or hook somewhere in the tune and take it from there.
Play the easiest set first to increase your chance of nailing them and building your confidence. Then you can raise the stakes if you want next time round.
Remember its not a music exam, everyone at a session is on your side. So just do it, 'cos it gets easier the more you do!
Andy
-
......... 'cos it gets easier the more you do!
Andy
Couldn't agree more!
Skipy
-
I find prior preparation helps, particularly if you think a session might be a 'solo play around' rather than 'all join in'.
I try to practice two or three sets of tunes which I like and am comfortable playing - sorting out any issues (bass notes, fingering issues) and especially the changeover.
And work out how to remember them when it is time to play (see recent thread on this subject) - I try to recall a distinctive phrase or hook somewhere in the tune and take it from there.
Play the easiest set first to increase your chance of nailing them and building your confidence. Then you can raise the stakes if you want next time round.
Remember its not a music exam, everyone at a session is on your side. So just do it, 'cos it gets easier the more you do!
Andy
This is all very good advice. I would recommend that people planning to go to a session that's not a beginners' session where they think they are going to be expected to start a tune should try to have a couple of sets ready (that includes practising the change though Walthamstow regulars will know how atrociously bad I am at changing in public). One should be a set that everyone is going to be able to join in with, so that if you start you will instantly have a dozen people joining in. But the problem with tunes like that is that someone else might start them before you get the chance. So have something else ready that's still fairly well known but that it's pretty unlikely anyone else will start. (My backstop is the Redowa polka, the first tune I ever learnt just for the sake of it rather than off a tutorial; I'm still invariably amazed on the rare occasions anyone else starts it).
-
Sessions are remarkable things! I can't immediately think of any other type of social event where people get together to perform a shared skill and to appreciate each other's efforts, but where too much ego is actually frowned upon, under some sort of unspoken etiquette. No wonder it is daunting for anyone to perform, novice or expert, because it is no mean feat to understand all that and then play a complicated tune without it going all wrong. And no wonder many would be musicians say they couldn't possibly ever do it!
-
Sessions are remarkable things! I can't immediately think of any other type of social event where people get together to perform a shared skill and to appreciate each other's efforts, but where too much ego is actually frowned upon, under some sort of unspoken etiquette. No wonder it is daunting for anyone to perform, novice or expert, because it is no mean feat to understand all that and then play a complicated tune without it going all wrong. And no wonder many would be musicians say they couldn't possibly ever do it!
I'm just glad I didn't know all that before I first went to one, otherwise I'd never have gone!
Alison - the Redowa Polka eh? I''ll have to learn that for next week then! ;D
-
Sessions are remarkable things! I can't immediately think of any other type of social event where people get together to perform a shared skill and to appreciate each other's efforts, but where too much ego is actually frowned upon, under some sort of unspoken etiquette.
Then you've not been to the Monday evening Knitting Club at the King's Arms Salford (http://www.myspace.com/knittingkings).
-
You're right, jb, I'm afraid I haven't. I bet it's pretty nerveracking, trying not to drop too many stitches in public!
(I was particularly impressed by the Dalek teacosy on the link, by the way.)
-
Hhhhmmm..... If I remember rightly, wasn't Ladydetemps looking for a fashionable carrying case for her box?
Problem solved, me thinks! ;D
Skipy
-
jb, isn't that what they call 'thread drift'?
Which reminds me of the sexy blonde who walks into a bar and says "I'll have a double entendre." And the barman replies "OK, I'll give you one."
-
Sessions are remarkable things! I can't immediately think of any other type of social event where people get together to perform a shared skill and to appreciate each other's efforts, but where too much ego is actually frowned upon, under some sort of unspoken etiquette.
Then you've not been to the Monday evening Knitting Club at the King's Arms Salford.
Oh, that's so sad. Huddled there, completely engrossed in themselves and wondering what to do with the third row. Bet they swap patterns mainly, although the reason I never took up knitting was that I couldn't get the tension right, and had troubles casting on. ;)
Oh no - they even have their own web site! ::)
-
Knitting groups aren't like that at all; they're fantastic fun. I think it would be more accurate to describe most of them as talking groups with knitting. My 'local' knitting shop is iKnitLondon, the only knitting shop in the UK with a bar. Edit: suddenly realise I have had a sense of humour failure. Oops.
-
Hhhhmmm..... If I remember rightly, wasn't Ladydetemps looking for a fashionable carrying case for her box?
Problem solved, me thinks! ;D
Skipy
Last time I knitted a bag I came to realise it stretched quite a bit when heavy things were put in it... ::)
-
Oh, that's so sad. Huddled there, completely engrossed in themselves and wondering what to do with the third row.
I think some melodeon players have this problem too!! ;D
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
in case it needs confirming, the King's Arms knitting group is actually pretty cool, as is the King's Arms (http://www.studiosalford.com/pages/kings.php) itself (and currently serving the excellent Ginger Nuts (4.2%) from Barnsley's Acorn brewery)
-
Oh, that's so sad. Huddled there, completely engrossed in themselves and wondering what to do with the third row.
I think some melodeon players have this problem too!! ;D
cheers
Sandy
(:)
Knit one, pearl one, knit one....
current knitting project a long doctor who style scarf. Is there a link between knitting and melodeons?
-
Is there a link between knitting and melodeons?
Not an obvious one, according to the latest scientific evidence (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1540.msg14273.html#msg14273).
-
LDT - "Knit one, pearl one, knit one....
current knitting project a long doctor who style scarf ........... "
8) Gonna be pretty long by the time you need it 8) T.
-
.. more evidence (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZkwjMexfUg)
Oh, Lord Help Us or Them, whichever you think needs it most!
-
.. more evidence (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZkwjMexfUg)
lol! Oh that's brilliant. I like it. :)
They could win Britain's Got Talent with that.
just got to make sure I don't get confused and bring my knitting rather than melodeon to the session on monday.
-
Then you've not been to the Monday evening Knitting Club at the King's Arms Salford
Jeez! it gets better and better. This from the Cyber Knitter's website ...
>>> Kenet haluaisin tavata: <<<
"who do you want to meet"
Ladies & Gentlemen of all ages and ability welcome!
A friendly evening meet for :
*people wishing to learn how to knit and crochet
*skilled knitters/crocheters - come and share your talents
*people who want somewhere cosy, comfy and friendly to get on with your project.
.. it has spotted I was in Helsiki, and greeted me in Finnish!
I promise I'll never take the p1ss out of a knitting website again.
Talk about "knit one, purl one" ... I bet melodeons.net doesn't do this?
kippis to all :D D3R
Oh, that's so sad. Huddled there, completely engrossed in themselves and wondering what to do with the third row.
I think some melodeon players have this problem too!! ;D
.. we'll be in touch Chris