Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on July 06, 2009, 09:23:27 AM

Title: 12 bass survey
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 06, 2009, 09:23:27 AM
Hmm - following the deliver of new kit I find the respective Luthiers have made very different choices in both what 'extra' chords to provide, and their positioning relative to the standard 'block'. As yet my brain remains confused and fingers don't always go where intended ??? but I hope I'll get used to it

This poll invites interested 12-bass owners to say where their extras have been positioned,  to post what they've been given and perhaps comment as to utility. Can't get multiple voting to work so I've put in a 'both' choice. I'll start things off with my own boxes' layouts (perhaps posters could copy same format?) D3R



Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 06, 2009, 09:27:06 AM
Oakwood
Foot end
   G/D     C/C
   D/A     B/Em
   A/F     F#/Bm
Head end

Martyn seems to reach 'up' into keys with more #'s,  though his choices make it play superbly fluidly in all the modes of D (Em dorian F#m,b9 A myxolydian  Bm).  It's also strangely happy in C!  The G modes feel the lack of a pull G bass, as the best melodeon run of notes (think Em) in the G scales is deffo on the pull.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 06, 2009, 09:27:59 AM
Gaillard
Foot end
   Bb/F    Eb/F#  << this the only one at 'foot' end as of 7 July
   G/D     C/C
   D/A     B/Em
Head end

Bertand in contrast seems to reach 'down' into keys with more flattened notes.  One suspects Norbert Pignol might have had a lot to do with this. I've transposed the French box into D/G equivalent to aid comparison, and ignored its single note buttons. I have really not as yet explored its possibilities ...
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 06, 2009, 10:09:44 AM
Castagnari Mory
Foot end
G/D     C/C
D/A     B/Em  
Eb/F#   Bb/F
Head end

I think this is the standard factory layout. It seems logical enough to me and works fine with the push/pull directions on the RH.  The pull F# chord, is of course, F#m.  But as I have a stop to remove the thirds from the chords, I can make them 'fat' or 'thin' as needed.

My RH side is customised, however. Full layout here:
http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/mory_steve_fr_layout.jpg
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Clive Williams on July 06, 2009, 10:24:15 AM
My weapon of choice:

Castagnari Mory
Foot end
G/G     C/C
D/D     Bm/Em 
A/A     F#m/F
Head end

... or alternatively on a Castagnari Giasco, a slight variation:

Foot end
G/G     C/C
D/D     Bm/Bm 
A/A     Em/Em
Head end

Of the 2 systems, I think I prefer the Mory's.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: ganderbox on July 06, 2009, 12:36:28 PM
Castagnari Mory
Foot end
G/D     C/C
D/A     B/Em  
Eb/F#   Bb/F
Head end

I think this is the standard factory layout.

This is how my Dony came, but I wasn't really using the Eb/F# much so I changed it to A/G (to give those basses in different directions), and find them quite useful.

I once tried a box with the extra basses at the foot, but it just felt too weird! I don't think I could cope with having different boxes, some with the main block at the foot and some at the head.

 
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: EeeJay on July 06, 2009, 02:26:41 PM
Oakwood
Foot end
   G/D     C/C
   D/A     B/Em
   A/F     F#/Bm
Head end

Martyn seems to reach 'up' into keys with more #'s,  though his choices make it play superbly fluidly in all the modes of D (Em dorian F#m,b9 A myxolydian  Bm).  It's also strangely happy in C!  The G modes feel the lack of a pull G bass, as the best melodeon run of notes (think Em) in the G scales is deffo on the pull.

Actually Chris, the erratic 'F pull' was my idea, not Martyn's... seeing as the 'E pull' (and thirdless chord) was duplicated elsewhere.

Apart from that, it's the default A/D/G bass rig... and at the time I was cautious of getting anything too oddball fitted.

Ed J
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 06, 2009, 08:05:20 PM
Now my Oakwood's ectopic F chord  is explained I see three main patterns emerging (modified)


.. and some hybrids. What a mixture! I should have posted this on the what's in a name thread.  Keep them coming please. Chris
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Morrisbox on July 06, 2009, 09:03:19 PM
Salterelle Connemara 3

Foot end
G/D       C/C

D/A       Bm/Em

A/G       F#m/F
Head end



Salterelle Nordsud

Foot end
G/D       C/C

D/A       Bm/Em

A/E       F#m/Bm
Head end

Trevor
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: brianread on July 06, 2009, 09:04:18 PM
Castagnari:

Foot end
   G/D     C/C
   D/A     Bm/Em
   A/E     F#m/B
Head end

(actually this is upside down as I play it "leftily"), but i have translated it for comparison sake.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: GbH on July 06, 2009, 10:35:50 PM
Mine's set up in the same way as Mr Freereeder's box, as mentioned above.  When ordering the instrument initially, I had a hard time in deciding what I wanted, changing my mind several times.  As it turns out, I'm now very happy with the tuning I chose and have no inclination to change it.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on July 07, 2009, 07:30:58 AM
On my 12 bass Hohner Erica D/G

Foot end
   G/D     C/C
   D/A     G/G
   B/Em   E/Am
Head end

This was from the days when I played strictly up and down the treble rows rather than crossing rows.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Malcolm Austen on July 07, 2009, 09:11:09 AM
On my 12 bass Hohner Erica D/G




Did you 12 bass that yourself ?
The 12 bass erica normally has a wider cutout and stagered buttons at the bass end
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on July 08, 2009, 08:54:48 AM
Yes, I did.
Added a pair of "new" buttons at each end of the original set, re-arranged the action and extended the reed blocks. PITA of a job, which I probably will never repeat! :'( :'( :'(

MC

Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: EeeJay on July 08, 2009, 05:05:40 PM
the erratic 'F pull' was my idea, not Martyn's... seeing as the 'E pull' (and thirdless chord) was duplicated elsewhere.
Apart from that, it's the default A/D/G bass rig... and at the time I was cautious of getting anything too oddball fitted.

Well, b*gg*r me - it's never occurred to me to regard any of my bass buttons as extras. On each of my 3-rows (ADG and GCF) I have the standard setup and make pretty full use of it. On several tunes I use both the E minor and major chords (Dmin/maj on the GCF), but I take the point about duplication of the E (D) bass itself. I've made several fairly radical tuning amendments to the right-hand accidentals but the only changes I've had at the other end are in the inversions of some of the chords.

Ah, well...you see, the R/H end was C#/D/G (until Chris tweaked it a bit), so the bass end was an 'open brief'... basically I regarded it as D/G 8 'protected', plus 4 extras at the head end. Ideally, I'd have liked a G pull too (like you get on a C#/D), but, like I said, I felt better to stick closer to a 'standard'. So I was just quoting 'default A/D/G bass rig' as a point of reference.

That, and I can tolerate thirdless chords. I know some folks don't like them though...

Ed J
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: jb on July 08, 2009, 05:12:04 PM
Ideally, I'd have liked a G pull too ...
That, and I can tolerate thirdless chords. I know some folks don't like them though...
quite partial to the occasional thirdless myself. Also the occasional minor 3rd melody over major chord, or vice versa.
And yes - even just since reading this thread i've been wondering about the merits of a G pull (on the ADG).
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: ganderbox on July 08, 2009, 09:34:45 PM
[
Well, b*gg*r me - it's never occurred to me to regard any of my bass buttons as extras.

I suppose if you have a 3 row in 3 different keys (like ADG) they aren't extras, because you need all the basses to play in those keys.
If you have a 2.5 row or 3 row with a full row of accidentals, then you could manage with just the usual 8 basses, so the others are "extras".
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: ganderbox on August 15, 2009, 11:19:39 AM
How about the strange 3 row (D/G + accidentals) I came across recently?
12 basses, but with the main block of 8 being in the middle, with 2 "extras" at each end. I think they were all bass notes, but I must admit I didn't investigate too closely as it was confusing enough trying to play it at all with the 8 being where they were. 
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: tim54 on August 15, 2009, 01:09:48 PM
Hi all,

Saltarelle Pastourelle III

Foot end

G/D  C/C
D/A  B/E
A/G  F#F

Head end.

This is the factory layout I believe.

Regards,

Tim
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: IanD on August 16, 2009, 04:32:50 PM
Castagnari Dony 3-row D/G/acc (custom)

Foot end
G/D     C/C
D/A     B/Em 
Bb/F   Eb/F#
Head end

As suggested by Emmanuel Pariselle (along with RH accidental row)

Ian
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: squeezy on August 18, 2009, 01:31:08 PM
My layout for all my 12 bass boxes is the Saltarelle standard ones:

foot end
G/D  C/C
D/A  Bm/Em
A/G  F#/F
head end

the only other odd one I play is a Loffet 18 bass (not sure if this is irrelevant here though)
Same as above but with a 3rd row of all the remaining odds and sods:

foot end
G/D  C/C  E/C#
D/A  B/E  Bb/G#
A/G  F#/F  Eb/F#
head end

All of the above have "third out" chords - it isn't the standard loffet layout.

I find with extended box systems that they fall in to 2 categories - ones where the Bb is on the pull and F on the push compared with the ones where Bb is on the push and F on the pull.  Although the position on the left hand is merely a matter of preference - the direction the notes are in has to be consistent on both hands and affects the way the music sounds a lot.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: AndyShear on August 18, 2009, 02:18:56 PM
Just a question that's puzzled me since I was looking at buying a 12 bass some time ago (I ended up with a Mory D/G if you we're wondering ), and that is- why is there such a difference between the salty and casta layouts on there 2 1/2 rows .
Having played mine now for a few years with the standard factory layout I find that apart from the F the others are quite redundant . Weather this will change over time or I may change them who can say .
Anyway interested to hear your thoughts as ever
Andy
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: ganderbox on August 18, 2009, 03:12:08 PM
I found the same with my Dony. After about 8 years I had the Eb/F# changed to G pull and A push (as per Saltarelle) and use these a lot more. I left the Bb there, but it would probably have been more useful to have put the F# on there (again, as per Saltarelle), and when I get my next D/G it will have the Saltarelle layout.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Owen Woods on August 18, 2009, 04:40:48 PM
What I don't understand ?s why the F# ?sn't on the pull on the Salta standard bass layout. G?ven that C# ?s oly ava?lable on the pull...

Although I can env?sage ?t be?ng very handy on the push as well now that I th?nk about ?t.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Lester on August 18, 2009, 04:46:42 PM
What I don't understand ?s why the F# ?sn't on the pull on the Salta standard bass layout. G?ven that C# ?s oly ava?lable on the pull...

Although I can env?sage ?t be?ng very handy on the push as well now that I th?nk about ?t.

Bert

All your latest posts are appearing (on my machine at least) with "?"s instead of "i"s is this just one of your idiosyncrasies or a problem somewhere?
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Owen Woods on August 18, 2009, 04:50:31 PM
What I don't understand ?s why the F# ?sn't on the pull on the Salta standard bass layout. G?ven that C# ?s oly ava?lable on the pull...

Although I can env?sage ?t be?ng very handy on the push as well now that I th?nk about ?t.

Bert

All your latest posts are appearing (on my machine at least) with "?"s instead of "i"s is this just one of your idiosyncrasies or a problem somewhere?

Ah, yes. Th?s ?s because I am ?n Istanbul and for some reason the '?' key has no dot over ?t, mean?ng that some med?a do not support ?t. Apolog?es, I'll try to remember to press AltGr ? ?n order to get i w?th a dot over it.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Clive Williams on August 18, 2009, 04:58:38 PM
What I don't understand ?s why the F# ?sn't on the pull on the Salta standard bass layout. G?ven that C# ?s oly ava?lable on the pull...

Although I can env?sage ?t be?ng very handy on the push as well now that I th?nk about ?t.

IMHO, I think F#m makes more sense on push rather than pull - the F#'s on the D row all being on the push of course, but mainly because it allows you to use the F#m chord when playing in D exactly as you'd use Bm when playing in G - e.g the bass run G->Bm->C->D becomes D->F#m->G->A (which kind of assumes you have a G on pull and an A on push of course, but that's a different story).

Cheers,

Clive

Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: Clive Williams on August 18, 2009, 05:02:53 PM
Just a question that's puzzled me since I was looking at buying a 12 bass some time ago (I ended up with a Mory D/G if you we're wondering ), and that is- why is there such a difference between the salty and casta layouts on there 2 1/2 rows .
Having played mine now for a few years with the standard factory layout I find that apart from the F the others are quite redundant . Weather this will change over time or I may change them who can say .
Anyway interested to hear your thoughts as ever
Andy

I think I agree with you. I suspect the Casta layout is better suited for a more continental style of playing - sort the bass notes out first, then the melody, rather than fitting the basses to the treble approach that Saltarelle allows. Bottom line is the saltarelle's basses are easier to use; castagnari's more versatile. I use something similar to Saltarelle's set up myself, which just shows what a lazy sod I am... ::)

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: squeezy on August 19, 2009, 12:31:13 AM
I wouldn't say it's lazy, Clive.  Just better suited to the way most English players seem to approach the instrument.  Having the repeated pattern translated from playing in G to playing in D is as close as I've ever see the melodeon left hand come to a "system"!

The reason I think that the Castagnari type layouts which have F on the pull (RHS) and Bb on the push fit continental style better is because their tunes often veer towards the flatter keys making them more sexy /twirls moustache, whereas ours kind of go towards the sharper ones making them sound ... sharper.

There is definitely something to be said for having an F# on the pull though too as the chord is there on the right hand (without any extra rows)

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: GbH on August 19, 2009, 10:46:29 AM
The reason I think that the Castagnari type layouts which have F on the pull (RHS) and Bb on the push fit continental style better is because their tunes often veer towards the flatter keys making them more sexy /twirls moustache, whereas ours kind of go towards the sharper ones making them sound ... sharper.

I really had no idea that there was any connection between F-pull, Bb-push and the practice of moustache twirling.  Yet, from personal experience and habit, it would seem to be an entirely accurate observation.  Clearly, the business of choosing a melodeon is far deeper and more complex that I'd previously bargained for.
Title: Re: 12 bass survey
Post by: ganderbox on August 19, 2009, 11:00:00 AM
I found the same with my Dony. After about 8 years I had the Eb/F# changed to G pull and A push (as per Saltarelle) and use these a lot more. I left the Bb there, but it would probably have been more useful to have put the F# on there (again, as per Saltarelle), and when I get my next D/G it will have the Saltarelle layout.

No it won't! I've changed my mind!
When I came to think about it, I realised that in fact I do use the Bb quite a lot (playing in F for one thing) and I want to keep it. I suppose I shall now have to work on growing a moustache to twirl. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal