Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Melissa Sinclair on January 16, 2017, 03:41:05 PM

Title: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 16, 2017, 03:41:05 PM
OK, I'm beginning to really understand what i like and don't like... I was listening to some Erica and Pokerwork boxes and I just don't like the sound of them. I can hear the beats and they sound out of tune. I know it's supposed to sound that way - as they are wet tuned, but my ears find it harsh and grating.

Again... I'm probably super sensitivity to things being out of tune in a band or orchestra. I once had to donate the 3 tenors christmas CD because the singers and orchestra were out of tune in several pieces. I have perfect pitch or near perfect pitch and that beating between notes quite literally hurts my ears. It's probably why I had a good sound as a French Horn player... technically horrible, but had a very good sound (or so I was told by professors).

I cannot explain it, but I find my body stiffening up to listening to instruments that are wet tuned for the melodeon, out of tune for every other instrument.. it's not a "I'm better than you, can't you sing/play in tune?" but more of a "Oh my goodness, make that racket stop so my ears don't bleed". 

So... with this new knowledge of what wet and dry tuning are - what are some recs for instruments that are dry tuned? At most Swing tuned. 

I did find this very helpful:

Quote
2. Tuning and tremolo
Beats

As already mentioned, a 2-voice instrument will typically have its two sets of reeds tuned slightly apart from each other, which creates the characteristic, pulsating tremolo sound. These pulses are known as ‘beats’, and are caused by the sound waves from each reed alternately reinforcing and diminishing each other. The number of beats per second is equal to the difference in frequency between the two reeds; for example, for the note A, if one reed is tuned to concert pitch at 440 Hz (Hz = Hertz, the number of vibrations per second) and the other reed is tuned slightly sharp at 444 Hz, the resultant rate of beating will be 444 minus 440 = 4 beats per second.

Amount of tremolo: dry and wet tuning

If the two sets of reeds are tuned exactly the same as each other, there will be no beating and hence no tremolo. This is known as ‘dry’ tuning. All other tuning will give a certain amount of tremolo. A marked tremolo – say 5 beats per second or more is usually described as ‘wet’ tuning, and of course there are all sorts of degrees of wetness in between. Different manufacturers and different nationalities will describe the tremolo in different ways, usually with a certain amount of overlap; but mainly can be summarised thus:

Wet: 5 or more beats per second ( >20 cents at A=440)
Tremolo: around 4 beats per second (15 cents at A=440)
Demi-swing: about 2 to 3 beats per second (8 - 12 cents at A=440)
Swing: a light tremolo of 1 to 1½ beats per second (4 - 6 cents at A=440)
Light swing: very light tremolo, slower than 1 beat per second ( <4 cents at A=440)
Dry: no beats at all
Musette tuning generally refers to three-voice instruments tuned M- M M+ with a wide spread of tremolo (5 beats or more per second).

The amount of tremolo is a very personal thing; some people like the warmth and fatness of sound of a wet-tuned instrument, and believe that it helps the sound carry better in an outdoor situation. Others prefer the much ‘purer’ or even austere sound of swing or dry tuning. As a rough guide, most factory-tuned two-voice Hohners e.g. Pokerwork, Erica, Corona, etc., tend to be wet-tuned at 5 or more beats per second, Castagnaris swing-tuned at around 1 – 2 beats per second, and Saltarelles, Dino Baffettis, etc., somewhere in between, in the demi-swing to tremolo range. The M reeds of one-row four-stop Cajun and Quebecois instruments are often tuned dry (no tremolo) or just a light swing. However, it is sometimes possible to specify the degree of tremolo when ordering an instrument, otherwise a reputable tuner will be able to tune your instrument according to your particular wishes.

Remember that the values quoted above refer to the tremolo for the note A4 = 440 Hz. Rather than having a constant rate of tremolo over the range of the instrument, the lower notes are often tuned with much less tremolo, and the higher notes with more tremolo, the rate gradually increasing as you go up in pitch. Why? To most people, it simply sounds better that way.

However, if you are not sure what you want, listen to as many different instruments as you can, either on recordings, or preferably live; and if you are able, try them out for yourself.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Theo on January 16, 2017, 03:52:44 PM
Any instrument can be tuned dry/swing or full tremolo.   If you buy from someone who renovates old instruments you can get it tuned the way you want.   If the seller says they can't/won't tune an instrument dry because for example "its wrong for a Hohner to be dry tuned"  then go elsewhere!

Dry or swing tuning is popular nowadays, in the past tremolo was more popular, so a lot of the nice old Hohners we have talked about have a strong tremolo, but as I started off by saying – that can be changed.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 16, 2017, 03:56:58 PM
Any instrument can be tuned dry/swing or full tremolo.   If you buy from someone who renovates old instruments you can get it tuned the way you want.   If the seller says they can't/won't tune an instrument dry because for example "its wrong for a Hohner to be dry tuned"  then go elsewhere!

Dry or swing tuning is popular nowadays, in the past tremolo was more popular, so a lot of the nice old Hohners we have talked about have a strong tremolo, but as I started off by saying – that can be changed.

True..., but some instruments sound better wetter than dryer, right? (or so my research is telling me).
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Theo on January 16, 2017, 03:59:31 PM
Yes up to a point, but you just need to get a box to start on, don't try to investigate every detail or you will never get started.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: arty on January 16, 2017, 04:03:38 PM
This may help you. A Hohner Pokerwork in three different tunings, wet, swing and dry, demonstrated by Marc Serafini...... http://www.mondiato.com/D2915%20video.htm
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 16, 2017, 04:08:46 PM
Yes up to a point, but you just need to get a box to start on, don't try to investigate every detail or you will never get started.

Ha! Yes... but it has to be on an instrument that doesn't make my ears bleed. I won't practice on something that hurts my ears.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: AirTime on January 16, 2017, 04:09:33 PM
Here's the thing: almost any accordion can be tuned drier or wetter. The fashion for the last couple of decades is for boxes to be tuned drier. This means most "modern" melodeons - like Castagnaris & Saltarelles for instance - are tuned with much less tremolo than was typical for boxes in the past. Most Hohners you hear will have a lot of tremolo - what's often called Hohner "factory tuning" - but they can be tuned a bit, or even a lot "drier". An excellent example of this can be found on melnet member Forrest's youtube site ... for example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1OUDkLvJFs

Vintage Hohners tuned with less tremolo (& I believe in Forrest's case with no 3rds ... another story) have a wonderful resonance & a rich bass sound that cannot be beat by modern instruments costing many times more. This is one of the reasons so many people will recommend starting with a simple Hohner, they are solid instruments with a great sound that remains relevant & appealing even if you move on to more "sophisticated" modern boxes.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 16, 2017, 04:11:27 PM
This may help you. A Hohner Pokerwork in three different tunings, wet, swing and dry, demonstrated by Marc Serafini...... http://www.mondiato.com/D2915%20video.htm

THis was helpful - Musette - didn't like. Swing was OK, Dry was great!
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 16, 2017, 04:14:51 PM
Here's the thing: almost any accordion can be tuned drier or wetter. The fashion for the last couple of decades is for boxes to be tuned drier. This means most "modern" melodeons - like Castagnaris & Saltarelles for instance - are tuned with much less tremolo than was typical for boxes in the past. Most Hohners you hear will have a lot of tremolo - what's often called Hohner "factory tuning" - but they can be tuned a bit, or even a lot "drier". An excellent example of this can be found on melnet member Forrest's youtube site ... for example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1OUDkLvJFs

Vintage Hohners tuned with less tremolo (& I believe in Forrest's case with no 3rds ... another story) have a wonderful resonance & a rich bass sound that cannot be beat by modern instruments costing many times more. This is one of the reasons so many people will recommend starting with a simple Hohner, they are solid instruments with a great sound that remains relevant & appealing even if you move on to more "sophisticated" modern boxes.

Gorgeous tone/sound...

OK, recs for such an older honer that will give those nice resonance and rich base?
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Tufty on January 16, 2017, 04:38:05 PM
If you want an example of how good a basic Hohner can sound here it is;
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OMGzgRx6ow
Also worth listening to "Accordeon Diatonique" by Jean Blanchard, all on a dry tuned Erica.
I have top end Italian boxes but still keep three Hohners and the only box I regret selling was an old Erika (2.5 row) that had been tuned by Theo. Unless they have won the lottery I would always advise someone to start off with a Hohner Erica and spend a bit of cash getting it tuned to your liking and having the button travel limited.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Theo on January 16, 2017, 04:44:51 PM

Gorgeous tone/sound...

OK, recs for such an older honer that will give those nice resonance and rich base?

That one is BbEb, you also like the French stuff on GC, so I think you have definitely established that you want a lower pitch box, and not a DG.

There is now way to recommend an old Hohner by model/type, they vary so much, both in how they sounded when new, and how they have been tuned if renovated recently.  You have to look at individual examples.   If you see something for sale that is in the right key then ask the vendor for a recording.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: playandteach on January 16, 2017, 05:33:51 PM
This is a Soundcloud recording of an old Hohner Erika  (https://soundcloud.com/playandteach/waltz-for-marc)which I had dry tuned. If that helps to know what they can sound like with different tuning.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Dazbo on January 17, 2017, 04:38:45 PM
I have perfect pitch or near perfect pitch and that beating between notes quite literally hurts my ears

Then perhaps the melodeon is not the instrument for you >:E

Most (if not all?) melodeons tuned with any tremolo seemed to be tuned in the factories with one reed at pitch and the other sharp to what ever degree of wetness is required.  You can (as i have) get your melodeon tuned so one reed is as flat as the other is sharp.  this has the benefit of giving wetness but sounding on pitch.

I wouldn't recommend getting a completely dry tuning (unless you go for a Lilly or similar with only one reed) as they do sound flat (I don't mean musical pitch).  The best thing I can recommend is to try as many boxes as you can get your hands on and get the one you like the best - even same make, model and wetness can, and do, sound and play differently to each other.

Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 17, 2017, 04:46:33 PM
I have perfect pitch or near perfect pitch and that beating between notes quite literally hurts my ears

Then perhaps the melodeon is not the instrument for you >:E

Most (if not all?) melodeons tuned with any tremolo seemed to be tuned in the factories with one reed at pitch and the other sharp to what ever degree of wetness is required.  You can (as i have) get your melodeon tuned so one reed is as flat as the other is sharp.  this has the benefit of giving wetness but sounding on pitch.

I wouldn't recommend getting a completely dry tuning (unless you go for a Lilly or similar with only one reed) as they do sound flat (I don't mean musical pitch).  The best thing I can recommend is to try as many boxes as you can get your hands on and get the one you like the best - even same make, model and wetness can, and do, sound and play differently to each other.

Flat is in the eye of the beholder.. to you it sounds "flat". To me it sounds "pure".  I'm Ok with some tremolo... a bit of it adds flavor, and has a place. But when it gets very wet, to me personally, it sounds like when a singer sings with too much vibrato... too much of a good thing is too much.

Wth that said, there is a place even for the wettest sound, but not in my living room for practicing.  ;D
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: sticky fingers on January 18, 2017, 07:39:51 PM
Stick to the dry Mel!, to me, boxes made of wood seem to sound softer too!, as opposed to perloid or such like!, although i am no expert in these matters!, its just an opinion! i only play the damn things, among other instruments!, best wishes, Sf.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: boxer on January 18, 2017, 07:57:10 PM
I've often wondered how people with perfect pitch cope with the (usually) even-tempered scales of fixed-pitch instruments like the box.

Given the difficulties you anticipate with anything less than perfectly dry tunings, do you think the tempered scale of the box would be a problem for you?
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Andrius on January 18, 2017, 10:02:30 PM
pay attention to octave tuning. It's my favorite. Example:
https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2/project-octavia-2
lot of different tuned instruments by microbot on his channel:
https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2

2 boxer:
some of my instruments are a little "de-tempered" - few sounds are lowered to get nice, "untempered" sound. Few very old instruments (~1925) were tuned in this way, some others tuned especial.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Gromit on January 18, 2017, 11:08:12 PM
This sounds nice https://soundcloud.com/microbot-2/3-voice-mmm-hohner-cd-ericadouble-ray
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: squeezy on January 18, 2017, 11:23:48 PM
I've often wondered how people with perfect pitch cope with the (usually) even-tempered scales of fixed-pitch instruments like the box.

Nice point! ... and talking about it until you're blue in the face means you don't have enough time to enjoy good music anyway!

My advice would be to get something you like the sound of.  When you get down to the nitty-gritty there are so many variables to consider with melodeons (which is why we spend so much time discussing it here!) - however there's no way you'll know what you want as a player until you begin playing the instrument.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: IanD on January 20, 2017, 11:43:35 AM
I've often wondered how people with perfect pitch cope with the (usually) even-tempered scales of fixed-pitch instruments like the box.

Given the difficulties you anticipate with anything less than perfectly dry tunings, do you think the tempered scale of the box would be a problem for you?

They get used to equal temperament, but *really* don't like traditionally tremolo-tuned boxes with one reed concert and one sharp, where the octaves aren't true and the two ends are out of tune. When I first got my Oakwood tuned flat/sharp (Viennese tuning, or Dedic tuning as many call it nowadays) our fiddle player Penny (with perfect pitch) said "Wow, finally a melodeon that's in tune with itself -- I won't have to cringe when playing along any more!"
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 20, 2017, 12:44:16 PM
I'm not sure that it's the case that a well-tuned dry box is at all unsuitable for someone with perfect pitch (which I'm not).  If you check the notes you are getting against an electronic tuner on a recently and professionally tuned box, you will find all of them remarkably close to concert pitch.  If you can just have one voice sounding on your box, check by playing the octaves - you may well find you can't hear any beats at all anywhere, they will be tuned so well.  I'd like to think that this is down to the supreme skill of the tuners (and I'm sure that's partly the reason!), but it seems it's also a feature of the free reed as a sound source.

Whereas wind instruments are often way out, and also highly variable with air temperature.  (And violins played by all but the best musicians don't usually even come close!)  A well-tuned, well set-up guitar can also give good intonation, but again, it needs constant checking, and varies with temperature.

As a player of the fretless bass, I find it amazing that violinists can come close to the right pitch, with such a short scale length - I think it can only be done with years of experience of precision fingering, a very good ear, a dollop of vibrato, and a technique that allows finger adjustments immediately after the note is struck.  It helps if you only have to play short notes!  My fretless bass is of the lined variety, and if I want to play it well, I have to check my finger position visually the whole time, notwithstanding the much longer scale length - half a mm error is easily detectable to the ear for one of the low frets, and for a high fret, would give a seriously out-of-tune sound.

When our band is tuning up, tuning the other instruments to a single voice box note is just as accurate as tuning to the electronic piano, I find.

But I also agree with the OP's view on wet-tuning.  Sorry everyone, but I don't like it much, either, and I don't understand why it became standard in the past.   (I'm not sure this is necessarily to do with perfect pitch, which I think is an absolute thing, rather than a relative one, to do with combination of notes.)    If anything Musette is a better tuning, because it results in a mush, rather than an obvious discord.  If (as usual) a box is wet-tuned by raising the second voice, the result can be seriously sharp compared with other instruments, particularly flutes.  To such an extent that I'd say playing a factory Hohner with a flute really doesn't work.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: playandteach on January 20, 2017, 01:02:15 PM
I think there's some double understanding of perfect pitch. Possibly a language thing, too. It's like the regular confusion between opaque, translucent and transparent.
Perfect pitch is (in my understanding, anyway) the ability to pick a note out of thin air: if a radiator hums, it will immediately register with the possessor of perfect (or absolute pitch) as the reference note - in other words it will scream 'F#' at them without having to work it out. Playing by ear is simple for these lucky folks.
This is a superb gift, and sometimes a bugbear, for example when listening to Baroque recordings on period instruments. It is also a real pain for transposing instruments - and may affect Melissa's ability to switch boxes comfortably.
Having a strong sense of relative pitch is a wonderful ability, so that having heard an G - and knowing that it is a G by reference, the musician will then comfortably be able to identify other notes in that context.
That won't affect transposing instrument use.
It also means that playing by ear is simple.
I think tremolo is more of a deeply held taste thing. I have neither an advanced relative pitch, nor of course perfect pitch, but tremolo gets me right between the eyes.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 20, 2017, 01:12:38 PM
thanks p&t, for an insight into another world!

I remember hearing an interview on R4 with a lady violinist who as a young teenager went to the Yehuidy Menhuin ( sp?) school of music. Every morning at 7.30am before breakfast they would have a half hour of notes being played to them ( no instrument in hand ) and they had to identify each one, as you desribe.
I find such an ability truly amazing.
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 20, 2017, 01:25:33 PM
I agree, p&t.  I think you're saying there's three different things here, aren't you?:

First, the ability to know the pitch of a given note, and whether it's in concert pitch, just by hearing it.  This is usually what 'perfect pitch' means, and I believe it's quite rare, even amongst musicians;

Second, knowing relative pitch, in the sense of hearing intervals (which is a lot easier than the first one , I think).  This skill as you say is probably the most useful one in playing 'by ear', and is learnable;  and:

Third, hearing discords, where two or more notes of slightly different pitch are playing.  I think most of us can do this naturally, and it's perhaps the main issue here.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 20, 2017, 01:48:04 PM
Regarding perfect pitch, I certainly don't have it, but there is a bit of a trick for instrument players - you do actually get to learn the approximate pitch of certain notes on your instrument by constant playing of them.  For example, the low E on a guitar is something I can to some extent hear in my mind, because it happens also to be close to the lowest note I can comfortably sing.  Therefore, once I've got that in my mind, I can recall it reasonably well, and then mentally hear other notes relatively speaking.   In the Yehudi Menuhin school, my guess is that once they had one pitch defined at the beginning, they could work out intervals of other notes, without having 'perfect pitch' as such.  Once a given pitch is established as the key, we do usually all have the ability to remember it for a short time at least, otherwise nobody would be able to sing in tune.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 20, 2017, 02:26:31 PM
Now I feel like a fraud of sorts. Perfect pitch (or near perfect pitch), for me, is a bit of a misnomer - which makes sense, sort of, as the definition is a bit loose. I CANNOT tell you, "that note is an A". However, I can and do, pick the same "pitch" of what I've heard when I am asked to repeat it. Like, there is a piece we played in high school - nearly 30 years ago. I still will pull up the same key to repeat that phrase I remember. Now, if am asked to repeat, say, "White Christmas" I may not pull up the same pitch as what Bing Crosby sang, because I've heard that piece by many artists and in different keys.

Part of the reason I cannot "name the note" is because to do that, you have to have studied music well enough to really learn the names of notes. The ONLY music I've had (as I was from a poor family) was music in school in band. Where I played the horn in the key of F. So, even if I could tell you what note I heard. Like if you play a middle C on the piano, I would hear it as G. And that is where "nearly" comes in. WIth naming a note - I would say I have relative pitch (like many do)... I "used to be able to hear" the Bb concert scale in my head for the Horn (starting on the right pitch in my head) and would then need to work myself up/down to the right note in my head to tell you the right note... as it would be on the Horn.  See, not so useful.

But it was extremely useful in playing the horn and that is why I had such a good sound (though being technically horrible). The horn is a hard instrument to play well because it is hard to play with good sound because of all the tubing and twists and turns. Besides the tuning of a bajillion slides, there's also the cupping of the hand n the bell and adjustment of the mouth's embouchure for each note too. It's also hard to land precisely on the pitch too. Which is really interesting as you would think it's the same for all brass instruments, but it's not. I picked up trumpet in HS to be able to play in the pep band and it is easier to hit a note "solid" unlike on the horn which is easy to jump to the wrong pitch with the same fingering. My son played tuba and I test that out too... easy to land on a given pitch too... yet they are also 3 button instruments.

So, I am very sensitive to pitch, but with that said, I "know" that the sound of an accordion is supposed to be somewhat dissonant. That is different than listening to two out of tune violins playing together. And some wetness/tremolo is tolerable, it's only the very wet sound. Seems many people who play the Hohner Erica have it tuned very wet. and it seems most Tejano music is very wet, but it WORKS in that setting/style of music because the music is written to work with that wet sound and it's usually played outside at a big event, or in a big hall for dancing. That sound there wouldn't bug me too much. I wouldn't enjoy it terribly, but I wouldn't hate it either. However, playing that in my house in a closed room... my ears would start to tire quickly from the grating sound... kind of like listening to a drill or other machines go on and on... it eats at you after awhile.

And I don't think it will be difficult to switch between boxes - as I will know it's a step down or up I need to play.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Chris Brimley on January 20, 2017, 02:47:35 PM
There is perhaps also a different issue going on in the sound of an accordion, and that is the way the overtones on a given note sound.  It may be that what you're finding unpleasant is not so much a clash in frequencies as harsh overtones in the particular model of box that you have.  I'm afraid the more expensive boxes do tend to sound 'sweeter' in this respect.  There's been quite a lot of past discussion about the influence (or lack of influence) of the type of wood used in construction on the sound of a box - however it seems without question that there's big differences in the sound of different boxes.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 20, 2017, 03:04:23 PM
There is perhaps also a different issue going on in the sound of an accordion, and that is the way the overtones on a given note sound.  It may be that what you're finding unpleasant is not so much a clash in frequencies as harsh overtones in the particular model of box that you have.  I'm afraid the more expensive boxes do tend to sound 'sweeter' in this respect.  There's been quite a lot of past discussion about the influence (or lack of influence) of the type of wood used in construction on the sound of a box - however it seems without question that there's big differences in the sound of different boxes.

I think this is quite true - and worrisome for my pocketbook. I have listened now to hundreds of youtube videos and while I know many of you adore your Ericas, I have yet to hear one that sounds good to the ear, no matter how it is tuned (though I did hear one that was OK).  I just heard the bergflodt. How sweet a sound it makes - even when played in different styles - soft melodic tune or powerful, bouncy, dance tune.

Though, I've heard a few wet tuned Castagnaris that just sound bad, where they usually sound good.


Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: playandteach on January 20, 2017, 07:03:54 PM
One thing to be aware of is there are Ericas and Erikas. I have a sweetly tuned Erika, (but I do find the bass buttons way too stiff). You're correct, there are many here who love Ericas.

Pitching on a brass instrument is partly to do with where in the harmonic series you are trying to pitch - as the notes get much closer together (therefore easier to miss) as you play higher. It could be that you are starting from a higher point relative to the fundamental bass of the instrument on the horn than on the trumpet. It is also mouthpiece shape dependent.

I personally think that tone production has little to do with pitch sense, much more to do with physical attributes, the ability to naturally access your own resonators (such as chest cavity, mouth shape etc) and the tiny subtleties at the business end (embouchure). Most people simply don't feed enough air to the instrument (that's not about volume, either). And the air needs to be from the right place - if it starts from too near your throat the support won't be there (not to mention that it'll be full of spit).
It's good you made a good sound. It's the hardest thing to achieve if it's not there relatively naturally.
I'm sure most of us are keen to hear the sound of your new box, and that it is everything you want it to be.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 20, 2017, 07:37:02 PM
One thing to be aware of is there are Ericas and Erikas. I have a sweetly tuned Erika, (but I do find the bass buttons way too stiff). You're correct, there are many here who love Ericas.

Pitching on a brass instrument is partly to do with where in the harmonic series you are trying to pitch - as the notes get much closer together (therefore easier to miss) as you play higher. It could be that you are starting from a higher point relative to the fundamental bass of the instrument on the horn than on the trumpet. It is also mouthpiece shape dependent.

I personally think that tone production has little to do with pitch sense, much more to do with physical attributes, the ability to naturally access your own resonators (such as chest cavity, mouth shape etc) and the tiny subtleties at the business end (embouchure). Most people simply don't feed enough air to the instrument (that's not about volume, either). And the air needs to be from the right place - if it starts from too near your throat the support won't be there (not to mention that it'll be full of spit).
It's good you made a good sound. It's the hardest thing to achieve if it's not there relatively naturally.
I'm sure most of us are keen to hear the sound of your new box, and that it is everything you want it to be.

Ah, yes... very astute! You are correct and on point with each thing you said.  Interestingly, my son started on trumpet. He was AWFUL. He simply couldn't control any higher notes - at all. They switched him to tuba based solely that he is tall. He was actually pretty good at tuba naturally. He jumped from worst trumpet to top tuba (and it was a HUGE school with many tuba players) in just a few months. His mouth could just work it and he had good lung support.

And super yes, nothing can make a horn (or probably any instrument) sound flat faster than lack of good, controlled breath support.

Now... I will STINK at the squeeze box as I'm a technically bad player with reading music (relied too much on the ear) and I've never used my body to play an instrument before (just my mouth and lungs)... as a non-athletic, non-dancer, very "stiff" person in general (but flexibly minded!) this will probably not be my area of giftedness... but it's about relaxation, enjoyment, and learning something new. And as I stink at this, my awe and appreciation of those who can play it poetically, will increase exponentially.

Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 20, 2017, 09:37:09 PM
Hmmm.....It sounds like you actually have a good combination of skills ready built in. A good ear, ability to sight read, albeit limited ( but I suspect better than most box players ),and you cruise YouTube listening to music with a discerning ear.
Believe it or not, that is a very healthy set of abilities to bring to the box!

Once you get to grips with the mechanics - where the notes are, which bass goes with which melody note, air button control etc, you'll be in a good place to make progress.
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Gromit on January 20, 2017, 11:16:46 PM
Quote
I'm a technically bad player with reading music (relied too much on the ear)
For playing folk tunes learning by ear is best IMHO, I can read music but not sight read and learn most of my tunes by ear, listening to recordings and sessions
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: stevejay on January 20, 2017, 11:48:48 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AwVuHJ-126Q

This is as dry as it gets on a GC.
I like it, but prefer two voices.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 21, 2017, 01:08:40 AM
....
Now... I will STINK at the squeeze box as I'm a technically bad player with reading music (relied too much on the ear) and I've never used my body to play an instrument before (just my mouth and lungs)... as a non-athletic, non-dancer, very "stiff" person in general (but flexibly minded!) this will probably not be my area of giftedness... but it's about relaxation, enjoyment, and learning something new. And as I stink at this, my awe and appreciation of those who can play it poetically, will increase exponentially.
I came to the melodeon from the background of an orchestral clarinettist (as did Playandteach, only far more expert and professional than me (:)). I was (still am) a proficient reader, but I have to say that in my experience the melodeon does not at first lend itself to playing from written music due to the push-pull nature of the instrument - different notes on the push and pull. At first, it is much more amenable to playing by ear. I found that I had to get a tune 'into my head' before I could successfully translate it into the peculiar combination of bellows directions and keyboard buttons. I think many of us on this forum will recognise this early stage of learning the melodeon.

As with many things, with practice and experience, playing the melodeon from written music becomes easier and intuitive. But playing by ear remains a valid approach taken by many good melodeonists.

One other tip for when you do finally get your instrument: Learn to play both treble and bass sides together, right from the start. As a melodeon teacher, I have come across quite a few instances where beginners have said something like 'I can play the tune all right but when I try to put the basses and chords in, it all goes to pieces!' It's because they started out just playing the treble end on its own, thinking that they could add the bass end 'when they got a bit better'. Bad mistake! Don't do it! Use both hands together right from the very beginning. It may be a steep learning curve at first, but I promise you it gets easier quite quickly, and soon becomes intuitive.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: gettabettabox on January 21, 2017, 01:35:49 AM
I'm on the rampage tonight.
You will be advised on here, things that perhaps suit a certain style/ a genre of playing.
Where I come from, we wouldn't be too bothered about the left hand on the box/melodeon. It's nice of course, used in moderation, but it is very limited. ....and maybe best used sympathetically. These are, after all, only a few defined bits of metal vibrating in a draught? The treble side however, in semi-tone systems, has all the orchestral notes. (Wait for it?)
Do you seek the tune..or something else?
I do not have perfect pitch....and I find the "melodeon" to be quite disturbing at times.
I just had to join in.


Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Huw Adamson on January 21, 2017, 02:16:56 AM
One other tip for when you do finally get your instrument: Learn to play both treble and bass sides together, right from the start. As a melodeon teacher, I have come across quite a few instances where beginners have said something like 'I can play the tune all right but when I try to put the basses and chords in, it all goes to pieces!' It's because they started out just playing the treble end on its own, thinking that they could add the bass end 'when they got a bit better'. Bad mistake! Don't do it! Use both hands together right from the very beginning. It may be a steep learning curve at first, but I promise you it gets easier quite quickly, and soon becomes intuitive.
Hear hear! I often wonder how much better I'd be by now had I taken this advice in my carefree youth  (:)
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 21, 2017, 03:03:36 AM
One other tip for when you do finally get your instrument: Learn to play both treble and bass sides together, right from the start. As a melodeon teacher, I have come across quite a few instances where beginners have said something like 'I can play the tune all right but when I try to put the basses and chords in, it all goes to pieces!' It's because they started out just playing the treble end on its own, thinking that they could add the bass end 'when they got a bit better'. Bad mistake! Don't do it! Use both hands together right from the very beginning. It may be a steep learning curve at first, but I promise you it gets easier quite quickly, and soon becomes intuitive.

Oh, this is quite good to know! As, I was going to do exactly what you are advising against. Or at least that's what my intuition was telling me to do - I would have come here to ask or done a search here for recs.  Thanks for the tip!
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 21, 2017, 03:06:24 AM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AwVuHJ-126Q

This is as dry as it gets on a GC.
I like it, but prefer two voices.

Want to know how much I've googled and searched around here... I knew by your description it was probably a Castagnari Lilly - one voice and dry... and, I've seen this video already too.  I've been a bit obsessed - and that is so not in my character!!!
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 21, 2017, 08:29:41 AM
I'm on the rampage tonight.
You will be advised on here, things that perhaps suit a certain style/ a genre of playing.
Where I come from, we wouldn't be too bothered about the left hand on the box/melodeon.....
However, where very many of the rest of us come from, the LH side of a melodeon plays an essential and characteristic role in the styles we play. So we use it. (And anyway, we've paid for all those reeds so we jolly well make sure we get our money's worth out of them).

A thought occurs to me - you could always remove the LH side of the box and replace it with a blank piece of plywood with a drawer handle fixed to it - and maybe the air button could be retained too. It would save on weight and no more need to worry about those pesky bass and chord buttons. And you could sell the unused LH reeds for spares....
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 21, 2017, 08:53:38 AM
Steve has given possibly the single most important advice - start with both ends at once.
If you look at a keyboard diagram, certain melody notes are available in both directions by using one or other of the two rows. Some chords on the left hand are only available one way.
Therefore the chord ( in that musical key )dictates which row melody note to use.

A friend a couple of years into learning only plays melody and 'I'll learn chords later'.
She's now realising she will have to either re- learn her tunes to get in the basses or not bother which defeats the point of the melodeon.

Getting both hands working initially is difficult but stick to the job and somehow the brain sorts it.
Once you've cracked it then off you go!
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: playandteach on January 21, 2017, 09:31:23 AM
As someone who has been advised to play a one row for a bit to learn some core techniques I missed out on (which I am gradually retro-learning and am bidding on a one row auction ending today) I find that the tune has to be completely relevant if I want to play it with the 'right' chords. The fact that you can play most notes in the keys of your box in either direction but can only play 2 of your left hand chords in bith directions  (in your case an F chord and a G chord) means learning tunes without chords will cause problems later.
But Steve F is really talking about coordination and independence of hands.
I'll put up a video or two on basic coordination things when you're ready.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Theo on January 21, 2017, 10:30:31 AM
I find that the tune has to be completely relevant if I want to play it with the 'right' chords. The fact that you can play most notes in the keys of your box in either direction but can only play 2 of your left hand chords in bith directions  (in your case an F chord and a G chord) means learning tunes without chords will cause problems later.


A very very valuable technique (that you may not have learned yet)  is when the music can be enhanced by NOT playing the bass or chord.   This can be forced on you by the design of the instrument, but can also be a deliberate choice for the musical effect.  How much you leave out can range from one note to many bars.  I clearly remember a concert where Andy Cutting playing a Quebecois tune on a one-row. The A part is in the key of D where he played a steady LH, but the key changes in the B part to Bm and there he only played the RH.  This built up tension in the B music and enhanced the glorious crash back to major when returning to the start of the tune.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 21, 2017, 11:12:39 AM
Another good point for later on, less is sometimes more.....
Someone went to one of Andy's workshops and he said he'd never sacrifice a good clean/ clear melody line if the accompniament got in the way.
Food for thought later on!
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 21, 2017, 11:56:25 AM
A very very valuable technique (that you may not have learned yet)  is when the music can be enhanced by NOT playing the bass or chord.   This can be forced on you by the design of the instrument, but can also be a deliberate choice for the musical effect.  How much you leave out can range from one note to many bars.  I clearly remember a concert where Andy Cutting playing a Quebecois tune on a one-row. The A part is in the key of D where he played a steady LH, but the key changes in the B part to Bm and there he only played the RH.  This built up tension in the B music and enhanced the glorious crash back to major when returning to the start of the tune.

ACK! Another reason the club type of melodeon appealed to me. That doesn't apply there, does it? (still so much to learn!!!) 

OK...off now to the Women's March in Washington.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: vof on January 21, 2017, 05:00:23 PM
OK...off now to the Women's March in Washington.

Bravo!   V
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: boxcall on January 21, 2017, 07:56:09 PM
What vof said!! 
And say hi to my wife she'll be wearing a pink pussy hat ;)
Proud of all the women !! Enjoy the box when it arrives.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Caroline on January 22, 2017, 07:08:31 AM
As someone who has been advised to play a one row for a bit to learn some core techniques I missed out on
But Steve F is really talking about coordination and independence of hands.
I'll put up a video or two on basic coordination things when you're ready.

I too missed out on core techniques many years ago and am suffering the consequences.
Yes please do some videos on basic coordination soon.  I fear if we wait for Melissa to get her box it will be a very long time (apologies Melissa 😊).   Perhaps a new thread?
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 22, 2017, 09:18:56 AM
Yes, coordination is the real thing.
My friend here, playing for ~ 40 years told me to start with both hands then followed up the comment with ' when you can um- pah properly, then stop it!'
I.e. Don't be a slave to it. Coordination is the key and real purpose of the exercise.
Once co ordinated you can do other things with the left hand - bass only, chord only, none, bass runs etc.
It opens up variation to your playing depending on the tune, but it starts with using both hands at once.
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 22, 2017, 12:44:03 PM
Thanks for all the tips! As I said - this site is amazing and if someone wants to start (if they haven't already) a thread on the bellow thing and left hand, I'll all for it!

And thanks for the encouragement about the March. It was amazing! I blogged about it a little bit last night. (which is linked on the side here under my profile picture).
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 22, 2017, 12:55:30 PM
I think all my Morris friends in Boston and NY marched ( some going to DC to join in ) and several in London too judging by FB pictures.
Well done!
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 22, 2017, 01:34:35 PM
"But Steve F is really talking about coordination and independence of hands.
I'll put up a video or two on basic coordination things when you're ready."

I'm ready now, P&T! After a recent afternoon teaching session with a famous player whom I respect hugely, the main thing I learned was that I was utterly useless at the coordination thing. I was at the point where I was saying to myself, "If the Irish don't need basses, then why should I bother?"
One contributing factor might be that I don't much like the "Oom-Pah" bass style in the first place. Who knows?

(BTW, might it be possible to lay off the political posturing, or am I out of step with the mainstream, again?) 
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: IanD on January 22, 2017, 01:57:32 PM
"But Steve F is really talking about coordination and independence of hands.
I'll put up a video or two on basic coordination things when you're ready."

I'm ready now, P&T! After a recent afternoon teaching session with a famous player whom I respect hugely, the main thing I learned was that I was utterly useless at the coordination thing. I was at the point where I was saying to myself, "If the Irish don't need basses, then why should I bother?"
One contributing factor might be that I don't much like the "Oom-Pah" bass style in the first place. Who knows?

(BTW, might it be possible to lay off the political posturing, or am I out of step with the mainstream, again?)
If you don't like the "oom-pah" bass style, don't play it -- I don't, and neither do many other people who don't ignore the bass end. It seems a shame not to use the basses since you've got them, assuming you're playing a single-row or D/G (or similar) box -- it's very different for Irish players on a B/C or C/C#, they've got an excuse since they rarely have the right basses to fit the tune.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: playandteach on January 22, 2017, 02:04:23 PM
OK, I'll get on with it. Don't expect the holy grail. And please can I get one caveat completely clear:
I am not a skilled player. So this is not expert advice.

On the other hand, I do understand practice, breaking things down, and learning processes.

Last thing I want to do is put in a stack of time to get a thumbs down for not being advanced enough to have the temerity to teach. On the other, other hand I really delight in helping people along - rather than 'instructing' them.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: IanD on January 22, 2017, 02:08:07 PM
I would strongly agree with the "learn both hands together from the start" advice though, it's what I've told everyone I've taught -- adding the bass end on afterwards is very difficult, you can spot people who learned this way by the fact that they don't play it...
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: arty on January 22, 2017, 02:25:22 PM
I wouldn't completely rubbish the Oom Pah Pah style of playing basses. After all, if you do that, you deny the world the vast majority of Stephane Delicq's wonderful music.
Everything, every style has it's place and no ideas should be discouraged. The thing is variation...don't learn to Oom Pah Pah and then use it for absolutely everything.
But hey....what do I know, I'm a beginner too :-)


On the other hand, I do understand practice, breaking things down, and learning processes.


I would be very interested in a video, or series of videos, on the learning process P&T. How you, a professional musician, goes about learning a new piece, breaking it down and later, adding ornaments, grace notes and even a little invention.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 22, 2017, 03:23:44 PM
"Don't expect the holy grail."

Of course that's what we'll expect! (What we won't expect is the Spanish Inquisition!!!!)

arty, I wouldn't rubbish anything on the melodeon, and I come across many tunes where the Oom Pahs really fit in. However, I mostly play folk songs and hymn tunes, and they just don't seem suited to that style of bass. Perhaps my ear has been tainted by years of singing unaccompanied or with a lovely Harrison organ as accompaniment.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 22, 2017, 04:33:08 PM
I think the thing is to use the om-pah as a starting point and a good learning tool.
It is the starting point and sets up the hands to allow coordination.
Once achieved, don't be a slave to it. Yes it is appropriate in some tunes and gas a good effect, but you don't have to do it on every tune, there might be interesting alternatives.
That was my point really.....
Q
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: AirTime on January 25, 2017, 04:39:15 PM
May I add another (most likely controversial) point to the discussion about tuning?

One of the other keys to getting a "pure" sound from a vintage Hohner, aside from reducing the tremolo, is to eliminate the 3rds on the bass end. I would suggest Melissa listens to some online examples to understand what this means.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: diatonix on January 26, 2017, 12:01:36 PM
One of the other keys to getting a "pure" sound from a vintage Hohner, aside from reducing the tremolo, is to eliminate the 3rds on the bass end. I would suggest Melissa listens to some online examples to understand what this means.

If "pure sound" is a major concern, rather than castrate the chords, I'd prefer lowering the major thirds by 14 c and raise the minor third by the same amount.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 26, 2017, 12:31:20 PM
One of the other keys to getting a "pure" sound from a vintage Hohner, aside from reducing the tremolo, is to eliminate the 3rds on the bass end. I would suggest Melissa listens to some online examples to understand what this means.

If "pure sound" is a major concern, rather than castrate the chords, I'd prefer lowering the major thirds by 14 c and raise the minor third by the same amount.
Yes - I know why you are stating this - at least about the major thirds. Flattening the thirds in the major chords by 14-15 cents puts it into mean temperament and gives a lovely sweet chord, but you risk the third clashing with the equivalent notes on the RH treble end if they are tuned more like equal temperament. It's less of a problem when there is a reasonable amount of tremolo on the RH side, but if the box is tuned dry or with a slow tremolo, then I think such a flattening of the LH thirds clashes too much for my ears.

I wouldn't raise the minor thirds by the same amount though. The tuning of minor thirds is always more problematical and more ambiguous to most ears. In mean temperament they are about 7 cents sharp of ET, not as much as 14 cents which seems excessive to me and would clash with the RH side again. 
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: squeezy on January 26, 2017, 12:34:28 PM
One of the other keys to getting a "pure" sound from a vintage Hohner, aside from reducing the tremolo, is to eliminate the 3rds on the bass end. I would suggest Melissa listens to some online examples to understand what this means.
If "pure sound" is a major concern, rather than castrate the chords, I'd prefer lowering the major thirds by 14 c and raise the minor third by the same amount.

I have played such boxes and the sweeter tempered chords do sound nicer.  They work very well when the melody is to be played on top of short rhythmic chords on the left hand in a traditional oom-pah style ... however my experience is that I get audible beating with those notes if the melody is played over held chords with the right hand is tuned to equal temperament.

I agree that "castrated" chords (nice term) - feel weak in comparison ... the thirds add the cajones to the chord precisely because they do beat and sound less pure than an open fifth.  But for pads under the melody which is quite common on the melodeon - thirdless chords tend to be more appropriate.  A box with a third removing stop is the ideal solution.
Title: Re: Narrowing it down - dry tuned box?
Post by: Andrius on January 26, 2017, 05:37:06 PM
some of my instruments are a little "de-tempered" - few sounds are lowered to get nice, "untempered" sound. Few very old instruments (~1925) were tuned in this way, some others tuned especial.

it was about the same  (:)
Nice sound from both right and left sides  :||:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal