Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: playandteach on January 18, 2017, 07:47:01 AM

Title: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: playandteach on January 18, 2017, 07:47:01 AM
Just noticed someone's tag line (too old to be a Morris Minor) and got to thinking...

I used to have a Riley 1.5 1962 car for everyday transport in the late 90s. I also have a few wind up watches and several nice clocks.
Is there a connection between the love of mechanical simplicity combined with craftsmanship and beauty and melodeons?
Is a 2 row 8 bass, specifically, the Morris Minor?
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Richard Shaul on January 18, 2017, 09:29:28 AM
Maybe more VW beetle, as it was made in Germany but had to be converted to right hand drive to meet UK requirements
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: george garside on January 18, 2017, 10:07:53 AM
The Morris Minor is far to modern for such an analogy!

 May be the one row  could be the De Dion-Bouton  (1883) of the musical world.  the simple 2 row the Ford model T (1907-27 )  and the 'fancy 2.5 and 3 row boxes the Ford Eight 1933 - 53 .

Alternatively the simple 2 row could be the Jowett Bradford of the musical world- two good thumps ( twin cylinder) and capable of taking anything anywhere)

George (long standing member of the Jowett Car Club founded 1923!) ;D
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Stiamh on January 18, 2017, 12:12:02 PM
Maybe it's the Morris Minor of the accordion family, but when you set the melodeon against all instruments, as your title does, the analogy breaks down because most instruments are far less mechanical.

I would say that if the violin is a scalpel and the trombone an axe, the melodeon is a front-end loader  >:E
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on January 18, 2017, 12:13:47 PM
The Morris Minor is far to modern for such an analogy!

But the Morris 1000 came out about the same time as the Hohner Erica....mid-1950s
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Winston Smith on January 18, 2017, 12:32:52 PM
Ahhh, but the Minor (pre-Morris Minor 1000, with the low headlamps) surely was a child of the 40's? And the VW Beetle analogy would certainly have been more appropriate to the Klingenthalers; although still well liked by a strange crowd, they were mass produced and horrible, with no redeeming features whatsoever! The Hohners would sit well alongside a BMW or even a Mercedes Benz.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: george garside on January 18, 2017, 12:37:48 PM
Morris Minor a Oct 1948
g
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Winston Smith on January 18, 2017, 12:39:32 PM
Thank, you Mr G, I wasn't quite sure of the actual year.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Phil Howard on January 18, 2017, 12:48:38 PM
It's certainly true that some Minor enthusiasts get MMAD... unfortunately I suspect many of the general public hold the MM in greater fondness than the melodeon though!

Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 18, 2017, 02:02:01 PM
... the VW Beetle analogy would certainly have been more appropriate to the Klingenthalers; although still well liked by a strange crowd, they were mass produced and horrible, with no redeeming features whatsoever!

I'd have thought the East-German papier-mâché Trabant suited your description much better than Dr. Ferdinand Porsche's revolutionary 1930's Volkswagen design Edward. They were even manufactured by VEB in Saxony, like the Klingenthalers!

And the modest "Trabi" is certainly "still well liked by a strange crowd", who even write songs about it - Trabant- Fahrer- Hit. Das Original! (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8UuOOSt2sRw)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 18, 2017, 02:20:22 PM
Previous threads, comparing various marques of melodeon to various cars ...

  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7945.msg98685.html#msg98685

  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2052.0.html

There are references to 'Morris Marina' and even 'Morris Box' but this is new! 

I assume you are not alluding to eg the tune Idberry Hill ... in Morris minor key?  ;)
 
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: playandteach on January 18, 2017, 04:41:35 PM
I like the Beetle idea (I had one of those in the early 80s). I can imagine a Woody Allen character wakin up from a cryogenic sleep long in the future - fleeing to a cave to find a mothballed Hohner which starts first time.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Stiamh on January 18, 2017, 05:05:03 PM
Another one: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=12962.msg159401#msg159401
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Matthew B on January 18, 2017, 06:24:23 PM
I would say that if the violin is a scalpel and the trombone an axe, the melodeon is a front-end loader  >:E

Well Stiamh, if your versatile semitone box is a front-end loader, my quint rig must be a skidder. 
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: AirTime on January 18, 2017, 09:13:11 PM
Yeah, OK. But that would make the modern Costalotti like one of them fancy, expensive, souped-up new Minis.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Huw Adamson on January 18, 2017, 09:53:15 PM
I have always considered my Pokerwork to be a bit of a Ford model T. I'm sure you can all conjure up tenuous analogies to support this. About the same original price for a start.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Broadland Boy on January 18, 2017, 11:36:51 PM
The noble Pokerwork must surely equate with the equally noble Series 1 Landrover, given their durability and all the off road all weather conditions they have played in for Morris (dancing) - one of our number is reputed to have even Forded one through the River Sid  (without a canvas cover!) and you can mend both with glue and a hammer - although it has to be said, the answer to 'what's the difference between a Pokerwork and a Series 1 LR?' has to be 'You can fine tune a Pokerwork' :||:

I'll leave those with experience of the more expensive 'suck-squeeze-bang-fart marques' to compare them with the Rolls Royce, Jaguar and other i/c vehicle makes but will put in a vote for the Streb being associated with the Tesla  ;)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 20, 2017, 12:14:44 AM
From family experience, I would suggest that George's choice of car would be more of an equivalent to the Vienna, and if it were a bike, it would be a Bantam.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Winston Smith on January 20, 2017, 07:48:24 AM
Not this sort of Bantam, then? (Commer/Karrier Bantam; very popular as bin wagons.)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 20, 2017, 11:10:41 AM
Gosh! Not seen one of those since I lived on the S Yorkshire coal field in the 1950s, (still in short trousers)!  ::)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: playandteach on January 20, 2017, 01:04:05 PM
Chris are you telling us that you're still in short trousers?
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: george garside on January 20, 2017, 01:52:53 PM
Not this sort of Bantam, then? (Commer/Karrier Bantam; very popular as bin wagons.)

does this have connotations of certain boxes being a load of  SHoneT!

george
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Winston Smith on January 20, 2017, 02:09:46 PM
That wasn't my intention, but the Karrier Bantam certainly was! They were beyond awkward to work on, and horrid in every way. I couldn't comment on the bikes, though.

Although some boxes may well be classed as firewood, or this unmentionable stuff of George's, we shouldn't forget that they have also given untold pleasure to many thousands, even possibly setting some on course for a career in music.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 20, 2017, 10:36:10 PM
Chris are you telling us that you're still in short trousers?

Dur. Please see my post and apply standard rules of Engish grammar ::)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Jack Campin on January 20, 2017, 11:51:07 PM
Quote
Morris Minor - Oct 1948

The LP was introduced in June that year.  (The cassette was introduced in 1963).

The Shand Morino was introduced in 1939 and we all know where that led.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Huw Adamson on January 20, 2017, 11:59:02 PM
While we are on the subject of car/melodeon comparison I'm sure we can all agree these images are a baffling spot-the-difference.

(http://img0107.psstatic.com/155917538_black-accordion-childs-musical-toy-kids-squeeze-box-.jpg)

(https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/f4/43/0c/f4430ca16098903db95185407cccc7c6.jpg)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: playandteach on January 21, 2017, 12:28:50 AM
Number 8 bass
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Pete Dunk on January 21, 2017, 02:41:35 PM
You're all bloody mad, you do know that don't you?  >:E
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Broadland Boy on January 21, 2017, 11:28:06 PM
Do they do those Routemasters in BbEb ?
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: playandteach on January 22, 2017, 12:00:55 AM
Had a closer look: definitely Ab tyre.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: vof on January 22, 2017, 12:45:59 AM
Theo - as the key mod around here, please put a stop to this bellowing stream of shocking puns I'm having to reed, none of them fit for my pallet...  >:E
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 22, 2017, 07:27:20 AM
Yes! Theo does moderate keys... it's called fettling  ::)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 22, 2017, 08:11:13 AM
Had a closer look: definitely Ab tyre.

Whoop!  ::) I believe this may be the first time the words "Morris" and "Ab" might have appeared together in a melnet post  :D  There is hope yet 8)

Whereas for some reason "C. Sharp" ….they can't get enough of?
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 22, 2017, 06:44:06 PM
Strangely enough, the BSA Bantam was introduced in 1948 as well as the Moggie! Unlike the Commer however, it's a doddle to work on. I also found that certain skills used on my last one were transferable to melodeon work. I sold my last one because it wasn't being ridden. I am suffering from withdrawal pains, but I promised ....  :Ph
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 23, 2017, 01:18:27 AM
Had a closer look: definitely Ab tyre.

Had a closer look: definitely photoshopped...  8)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 23, 2017, 01:49:33 AM
Strangely enough, the BSA Bantam was introduced in 1948 as well as the Moggie!

Not so strange really, when you consider how long it took industry to get going again after WW2 - and many serving in the British Armed Forces didn't even get demobbed until 1947!

And (not surprisingly under the circumstances) the VW "Beetle", the "Bantam" and the Morris Minor (sorry, a "Moggie" is a Morgan car to me - they came first!  ;)) were all basically "pre-war" designs, just as many of the accordions (that started to be made again in 1946 in Italy, and 1947 in Germany) were as well. Indeed there were stong parallels between accordion design and car design at the time too, with streamlining all the rage on both, and I'd compare the "faired-in" style of headlamps, on the Beetle and Minor, with the "faired-in" style of feet that you'd find on many Italian accordions of the era too (like the Paolo Soprani "grey boxes"!) instead of seperate ones that were screwed on...
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Jack Campin on January 23, 2017, 02:08:58 AM
Was there ever a Hohner with a diamante inscription "This machine annexes the Sudetenland"?
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 23, 2017, 04:40:15 PM
Was there ever a Hohner with a diamante inscription "This machine annexes the Sudetenland"?

Like an anti-Woody Guthrie "This machine kills fascists" guitar you mean?  ???
 
Mind you, Hohner did make a couple of models of harmonica with rather dodgy names taken from the lyrics of the (banned since WW2) Horst Wessel song...
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 24, 2017, 01:24:08 AM
My dad said that the Horst Wessel Lied was a smashing song, if you didn't know what the words meant. But he only heard it after he went on his holidays in 1944, starting in Normandy and coming home by Holland, via Czechoslovakia. Sadly he didn't think that his soon to be begotten male offspring might like a few German accordions!  :|glug
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 24, 2017, 08:08:13 AM
It's a fantastic tune, just ignore the connotations . Anyone know who wrote it?
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: george garside on January 24, 2017, 09:04:19 AM
Strangely enough, the BSA Bantam was introduced in 1948 as well as the Moggie!

Not so strange really, when you consider how long it took industry to get going again after WW2 - and many serving in the British Armed Forces didn't even get demobbed until 1947!

And (not surprisingly under the circumstances) the VW "Beetle", the "Bantam" and the Morris Minor (sorry, a "Moggie" is a Morgan car to me - they came first!  ;)) were all basically "pre-war" designs, just as many of the accordions (that started to be made again in 1946 in Italy, and 1947 in Germany) were as well. Indeed there were stong parallels between accordion design and car design at the time too, with streamlining all the rage on both, and I'd compare the "faired-in" style of headlamps, on the Beetle and Minor, with the "faired-in" style of feet that you'd find on many Italian accordions of the era too (like the Paolo Soprani "grey boxes"!) instead of seperate ones that were screwed on...

the BSA ban'tam was  more or less a  copy of the pre war 125cc German DKW the design of which was given to BSA as part of the 'reparations'. 

george
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 24, 2017, 10:52:02 AM
Strangely enough, the BSA Bantam was introduced in 1948 as well as the Moggie!

... the VW "Beetle", the "Bantam" and the Morris Minor ... were all basically "pre-war" designs ...

the BSA ban'tam was  more or less a  copy of the pre war 125cc German DKW the design of which was given to BSA as part of the 'reparations'. 

george

Exactly!  ;)
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 24, 2017, 11:19:47 AM
... there were stong parallels between accordion design and car design at the time too, with streamlining all the rage on both, and I'd compare the "faired-in" style of headlamps, on the Beetle and Minor, with the "faired-in" style of feet that you'd find on many Italian accordions of the era too (like the Paolo Soprani "grey boxes"!) instead of seperate ones that were screwed on...

The "faired-in" style of feet on this c.1939 Scandalli that I got recently, with their aluminium tips looking like lenses, would especially remind me of "faired-in" car headlamps:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Scandalli%201940s%20feet.jpg)

Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 24, 2017, 03:43:51 PM
We can't let that pass on a melodeon website!

         (http://chrisryall.net/img/morrisminor.jpeg)

If we are to talk Poker I 'see' your 1939 Scandalli, and 'raise' you an 1941 4-stroke
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: Winston Smith on January 24, 2017, 06:03:55 PM
1941, Chris? I would have thought that they were still on side valves then. Not that I'm anywhere near old enough to remember, of course.
Title: Re: Is the Melodeon the Morris Minor of instruments
Post by: triskel on January 24, 2017, 11:27:48 PM
We can't let that pass on a melodeon website!

Sadly, Scandalli seem to have stopped making diatonic accordions by the late 1930s, though they made some beauties previously, but the streamlined styling of their pioneering 1938-39 models was very influential on the design of streamlined Italian button boxes at the time, including the Paolo Soprani "grey boxes" (as I've said), and even more so on the likes of my 4-voice Casali C/C# (now C#/D) - but that comparison really deserves a seperate thread of its own.

Quote
If we are to talk Poker I 'see' your 1939 Scandalli, and 'raise' you an 1941 4-stroke

I'll raise you the 1939 "floor pedals"  ;) ...

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Scandalli%201940s%20couplers.jpg)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal