Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Malcolm Austen on July 12, 2009, 10:55:51 AM
-
This is one of the tunes that inspired my to start this mad adventure and every now and then I go back to it and this time I am going to win.
Is there a trick to playing this that I am missing or is it played as it is written in D using the G#. I have never been able to get it to flow and sound right. So is it just practice, practice and more practice or is there a trick?
Help please.
malcolm
-
This is the version I sort of half know as written down by our local musical know-it-all, fits a melodeon well!
X: 339
T:Primrose Polka
K:G
d2|Bc^cd edcd|b2g2 b2g2|Bc^cd edcd|A6 A2|
ABcd ed^cd|a2f2 f2e2|defe dcAB|B6 d2|
Bc^cd edcd|b2g2 b2g2|Bc^cd edcd|A6 A2|
ABcd ed^cd|a2f2 f2e2|defe dcAB|G6 d2||
B4 Bc^cd|b6 a2|gdBd gfag|f2e2 e4|
A4 ABcd|f6 e2|defe dcAc|c2B2 B2d2|
B4 Bc^cd|b6 a2|gdBd gfag|f2e2 e4|
c'bab c'2c'2|baga b2b2|agfg adef|g2b2 g2b2||
bagf g2d2|bagf g2d2|e^def g2e2|d6 B2|
cBcd e2c2|BABc d2B2|^c2c2 cABc|d2e2 f4|
bagf g2d2|bagf g2d2|e^def g2e2|d6 B2|
e^deg c'2e2|d^cdg b2g2|fd^cd e2f2|g6|]
-
This is one of the tunes that inspired my to start this mad adventure
Great isn't it? Shand's version of 'Bluebell Polka' was the one that got me on board this crazy ship! Wonder how many other flowery polkas there are?
AL
-
for what its worth Shands version of the primrose polka is in F ( the sheet music I have of it price 20pence in 1953 states as recorded by Jimmy Shand on parlo-phone records) Like many tunes it can be played in whatever key you want or have available.
george
-
This is one of the tunes that inspired my to start this mad adventure and every now and then I go back to it and this time I am going to win.
Is there a trick to playing this that I am missing or is it played as it is written in D using the G#. I have never been able to get it to flow and sound right. So is it just practice, practice and more practice or is there a trick?
Help please.
malcolm
I find there are very large differences from tune to tune in how easy they are to make them 'sound right' on the melodeon. Part of that, I'm sure, is because I'm new to the melodeon but I think there is a lot of truth in the term 'melodeon friendly'.
-
The composer of the Primrose Polka was a great 3-row player from near here [ Angus/ Perthshire] called Bobby Brown. He played in one of the great Scottish dance bands, namely Adam Rennie. The first recordings they did on Parlophone in the late 40s early 50s, Bobby played a 3-row Casali, and they played some difficult stuff brilliantly [ fiddle/box/piano/bass] they did another batch on Nixa label later on and by this time Bobby had one of the first Shand Morino's. Bobby wrote and played the Primrose Polka in F as George said and it was published in the key of F, again as pointed out by George. Shand himself actually played it in D and G on a 78 and broadcasts as he didn't play much in the flats as he got more bite from C,G,D,and A for our type of music. He did play a few waltzes and barn dances and 2 steps in flats tho'. Continental and modern stuff as well now I come to think of it. I have a recording of Carl Jularbo from Sweden playing a very similar tune to the Primrose [ pre-dates it as well !]
Ian.
-
Thanks Drumkilbo! I always wondered who wrote Primrose Polka. It's one of my favourite tunes.
I learnt it from the playing of Barry Callaghan (my sadly-missed friend and fellow musician from Lizzie Dripping* who taught me a lot about playing the melodeon for dancing).
For Lizzie Dripping we used to play it 3 times, twice in G and once in D. I later modified it after hearing John Kirkpatrick's Brass Monkey version, so that the A- and B-music was in G and the C-music in D. It works nicely like that, avoiding being too squeaky in the C-music and also making it quite melodeon-friendly for the accidentals. I will now look out for the sheet music of the original Bobby Brown version, as I expect my version of the tune will have 'evolved' in the usual way, thanks to our great aural tradition of passing on music.
* a Sheffield-based womens' dance team, also affectionately known as 'The Drips' or 'The Lizzies'.
Here's my version as I currently play it for the Drips:
X:1
T:Primrose Polka
C:Composer unknown (Trad?)
N:From the playing of Barry Callaghan and John Kirkpatrick
M:2/4
L:1/16
K:G
P:A
|:Bc^cd ed^cd|b2g2b2g2|Bc^cd ed^cd|A8|
ABcd ed^cd|a2f2 f2e2|defe dcBA|1B4 c4:|2G2d2^c2=c2||
P:B
|:B4-Bc^cd|b6 a2|gdBd g3f|f2e2 e4|
|1A4-ABcd|f6 e2|defe dcBA|B4 c4:|
|2c'bab c'2a2|baga b2g2|defg ac'ba|g8||
P:C
K:D
|:fedc d2A2|fedc d2A2|BGBd g2B2|A6 dd|
cBce g2BB|AFAd f4|1eeee e2^de|g2e2c2A2:|2AA^GA f2e2|d8|]
-
Steve - I will scan the original version & email it to you tomorrow
george
-
Steve - I will scan the original version & email it to you tomorrow
george
And me please George
-
Steve - I will scan the original version & email it to you tomorrow
Brilliant!
Many thanks George!
-
Steve/Lester
- I need your email adresses to send primrose polka. ( I didn't realise they were not shown in your profiles. Let me have them georgegarside@talktalk.net
george
-
Steve/Lester
- I need your email adresses to send primrose polka. ( I didn't realise they were not shown in your profiles. Let me have them
george
Hello George,
As far as I'm aware my e-mail address IS shown on my profile.
Many thanks in anticipation....
Edited to add:
Primrose Polka received. Thanks, George!
Also to remove e-mail addresses from message, as per Theo's advice
-
Anyone who joins this forum automatically has their email address in their profile and you can send them messages by clicking on the envelope icon to the left of the message, below the users name and avatar.
This means that only members can see your email address. It is not a good idea to include your email address in the message where it can be seen by the whole word and may be harvested by spammers.
-
George has sent me the original manuscript which I have pdf'ed and can be found HERE (http://homepage.ntlworld.com/goldfrog/melodeon/Primrose_Polka.pdf)
Or I have transcribed it to ABC:
X:1
T:Primrose Polka Original
M:2/4
L:1/16
K:F
A>B=B>c d>cB>c | a2f2 a2f2 | A>B=B>c d>cB>c | G6 G2 |
G>AB>c d>c=B>c | g2B2 e2d2 | c>de>d c>BG>^G | A6 c2 |
A>B=B>c d>cB>c | a2f2 a2f2 | A>B=B>c d>cB>c | G6 G2 |
G>AB>c d>c=B>c | g2B2 e2d2 | c>de>d c>BG>A | F6 c2 :||
A4 -A>B=B>c | a6 g2 | f>cA>c f>eg>f | e2d2 d2G2 |
G4 -G>AB>c | e6 d2 | c>de>d c>BG>B |B2A2 A2c2 |
A4 -A>B=B>c | a6 g2 | f>cA>c f>eg>f | e2d2 d4 |
b>ag>a b2b2 | a>gf>g a2a2 | g>fe>f g>cd>e |1 f2a2 f2c2 :|2 f2a2 f2a2 ||
a>gf>e f2c2 | a>gf>e f2c2 | d>^cd>e f2d2 | c6 A2 |
B>AB>c d2B2 | A>GA>B c2A2 | =B>BB>B B>GA>B | c6 c2 |
a>gf>e f2c2 | a>gf>e f2c2 | d>^cd>e f2d2 | c6 c2 |
d>^cd>f b2d2 | c>=Bc>f a2f2 | e>c=B>c d2e2 |1 f6 a2 :|2 f4 c4 ||
And I have further transposed it to G for the hard of understanding (I have changed it slightly to sound righter to my ear) plus I have removed the repeats as it went on to long in my opinion?
X:1
T:Primrose Polka Original in G
M:2/4
L:1/8
K:G
B>c^c>d e>dc>d | b2g2 b2g2 | B>c^c>d e>dc>d | A6 A2 |
A>Bc>d e>d^c>d | a2f2 f2e2 | d>ef>e d>cA>B | B6 d2 |
B>c^c>d e>dc>d | b2g2 b2g2 | B>c^c>d e>dc>d | A6 A2 |
A>Bc>d e>d^c>d | a2f2 f2e2 | d>ef>e d>cA>B | G6 d2 ||
B4 -B>c^c>d | b6 a2 | g>dB>d g>fa>g | f2e2 e2A2 |
A4 -A>Bc>d | f6 e2 | d>ef>e d>cA>c |c2B2 B2d2 |
B4 -B>c^c>d | b6 a2 | g>dB>d g>fa>g | f2e2 e4 |
c'>ba>b c'2c'2 | b>ag>a b2b2 | a>gf>g a>de>f | g2b2 g2b2 ||
b>ag>f g2d2 | b>ag>f g2d2 | e>^de>f g2e2 | d6 B2 |
c>Bc>d e2c2 | B>AB>c d2B2 | ^c>cc>c c>AB>c | d6 d2 |
b>ag>f g2d2 | b>ag>f g2d2 | e>^de>f g2e2 | d6 d2 |
e>^de>g c'2e2 | d>^cd>g b2g2 | f>d^c>d e2f2 |g8 ||
If you don't like my version apply the version in F to Jens Wollschläger's ABC-Transposer (http://www.8ung.at/abctransposer/index.html)
-
I have pdf'ed and can be found HERE
Link not working for me Lester.
AL
-
I have pdf'ed and can be found HERE
Link not working for me Lester.
AL
Works OK on all my computers. You need something that can open PDFs (adobe reader 8 (http://get.adobe.com/uk/reader/))
The link is:
http://homepage.ntlworld.com/goldfrog/melodeon/Primrose_Polka.pdf
-
S'ok now - thanks - must have been a blip with my machine.
Thanks
AL
-
Thanks to all who have contributed so far.
It would seem to be simpler in G but is given in D in "Hardcore English" so my next task is to check the Bob Cann recordings and the recording on line from the English Country Music Weekend and see what key, anyone know?
-
Thanks to all who have contributed so far.
It would seem to be simpler in G but is given in D in "Hardcore English" so my next task is to check the Bob Cann recordings and the recording on line from the English Country Music Weekend and see what key, anyone know?
Every where I hear it it is in G but that's because its mostly melodeon players who have, like you, worked out it is far easier in G (:)
-
FWIW, on my only recording of Jimmy Shand playing "The Primrose Polka", he plays it in D and G - parts A and B in D, and part C in G. He plays it thus: Intro (last 4 bars of part A), A,B,A,C,A,B,A. Total 116 bars.
Since the recording is a "compilation" (vol 2 of the 2-CD set "The Bluebell Polka"), it doesn't say whether it's his Parlophone recording of 1942 or 1957. Although Jimmy Shand is featured on the cover of the published piano music, it's possible that he never played it in F as written.
-
FWIW, on my only recording of Jimmy Shand playing "The Primrose Polka", he plays it in D and G - parts A and B in D, and part C in G. He plays it thus: Intro (last 4 bars of part A), A,B,A,C,A,B,A. Total 116 bars.
Since the recording is a "compilation" (vol 2 of the 2-CD set "The Bluebell Polka"), it doesn't say whether it's his Parlophone recording of 1942 or 1957. Although Jimmy Shand is featured on the cover of the published piano music, it's possible that he never played it in F as written.
I think this is further confirmation (if we indeed ever needed it) that it is OK to play tunes in whatever key we like, to make it work nicely on our particular chosen instrument.
(Thinks: why is it that when I play a nice tune in C on my C/G anglo in a session, I get bemused looks from everyone else there?)
In the case of Primrose Polka, I will continue to play the parts in G G D, 'cos it sounds good like that. ;)
-
In the case of Primrose Polka, I will continue to play the parts in G G D, 'cos it sounds good like that. ;)
I must try that. I have always played it in D, D, G and it sounds good to my ear like that. However, I think I'll leave trying it in G, G, D till after Sidmouth and Whitby or I'll get so confused I'll fail to play it in either format!
-
Learnt this by ear from a recording by, Sidmouth Steppers on, "Magic of the Morris" vol 2 disc 1. Great tune.
-
I first started playing this tune on piano accordion when in my early twenties but in the key of 'D' all the way through. I cannot remember my source but stopped playing it when I took up the melodeon because a D/G does not have the necessary accidentals. Since getting a 2+1/2 row I've started playing it again in 'D'. It has done wonders for my cross row playing (the basses have to be right) and a vital tune for helping me get to grips with my 2+1/2 row box. I've tried it in 'G' but find that not very ear friendly (too many high notes) and it still needs accidentals. 'F' is preferable but I must say that 'D' is the most user friendly as far as I am concerned.
-
Here is the link location for a recording by Adam Rennie's Quartet playing it throughout in the key of 'G'
http://www.archive.org/details/PrimrosePolka
-
Here is the link location for a recording by Adam Rennie's Quartet playing it throughout in the key of 'G'
http://www.archive.org/details/PrimrosePolka
Since it was composed, by all accounts, by Robert "Bobby" Brown, button accordionist in Adam Rennie's Quartet, this may be the definitive version (although not necessarily the best).
-
It has speeded up somewhere in the process because they definitely played it in F, as per the published copy mentioned earlier in this thread. I have the original 78 ......somewhere. :-\
Ian.
-
Unless I'm very much mistaken you can hear them playing it in 'F' here (http://electricscotland.allcelticmusic.com/music/7e771ffe-e472-102b-803f-000f1f67beb1/Strict_Tempo_Scottish_Country_Dance_Music_from_the_1950s.html)
AL
-
You are very much correct, Al, that's more like it !
Jannette Gibb Polka and Silver Wings Polka are bonny tunes too [ both composed by Adam Rennie]
Jannette Gibb is now Mrs. Jannette Stewart and has been for a long time, married to Jock Stewart of Coupar Angus [ drummer ] who I have a tune with now and then at the local accordion club.
That whole recording that Al has given the link to was played by Bobby Brown on a 3 row Casali.
Ian.
-
This is one of the tunes that inspired my to start this mad adventure
Great isn't it? Shand's version of 'Bluebell Polka' was the one that got me on board this crazy ship! Wonder how many other flowery polkas there are?
AL
i love this tune...
another flowery polka.. the snowdrop polka. ..i think the Albion Dance Band did a version