Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Julian S on January 26, 2017, 08:17:07 AM

Title: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Julian S on January 26, 2017, 08:17:07 AM
I always keep the various melodeons in their boxes until it's their turn to be played. No dusting, and I havent got shelf space anyway. But I do wonder if there are disadvantages to this - maybe more chance of rusty reeds ? Views and comments ?
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 26, 2017, 08:32:48 AM
Probably a good idea to keep them in their cases, but don't fasten the bellows straps.
The straps should only be used for unboxed travelling.
I'll probably be shot down for this but I do think that's correct.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Lester on January 26, 2017, 08:36:50 AM
Probably a good idea to keep them in their cases, but don't fasten the bellows straps.
The straps should only be used for unboxed travelling.
I'll probably be shot down for this but I do think that's correct.

Why?
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 26, 2017, 08:43:18 AM
When the straps are done up the whole thing is under pressure. I was was told this by an Exeter Morris musician and it seemed to make sense.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Theo on January 26, 2017, 08:56:35 AM
Probably a good idea to keep them in their cases, but don't fasten the bellows straps.
The straps should only be used for unboxed travelling.
I'll probably be shot down for this but I do think that's correct.

Cobblers. I've never heard such nonsense. It is a good thing to keep the bellows compressed.  It makes the bellows easier to close fully when you are playing.  Nothing worse than encountering resistance in the last bit of bellows movement.  With older instruments it will make little difference.

What are bellows straps for anyway?  To prevent the bellows opening when you don't want them to – taking the instrument out of it's case is the one time when you do want the bellows to under control.

I always keep the various melodeons in their boxes until it's their turn to be played. No dusting, and I havent got shelf space anyway. But I do wonder if there are disadvantages to this - maybe more chance of rusty reeds ? Views and comments ?

Avoid extremes of temperature, avoid dampness and also avoid very low humidity, and avoid excessive dust.   Stick to those simple guidelines and your melodeon will be happy, and so will you. I can't see any reason why storing in a closed case would lead to rusty reeds, unless you put it away damp.  So don't let it get damp in the first place.

I hope we can squash these two pointless myths before they get out out. 
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 26, 2017, 10:49:38 AM
I totally concur with what Theo said.

To go back to the original question, it can be a psychological aid to practising if you keep the melodeon out of its case or gig bag at least some of the time when at home. If you haven't got the (even relatively minor) faff of taking the instrument out of its case or wrestling with the gig bag straps and zip, you are more likely to pick up the instrument and play it, even just for a short time when passing, e.g when waiting for the kettle to boil or when the adverts are on the telly. So long as the instrument is not going to get knocked or chewed by the dog, it won't come to any harm by being out of its case. You can always simply throw a clean duster over it to keep off the dust. For longer term storage it's best to keep it in its case, of course.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Winston Smith on January 26, 2017, 11:19:36 AM
"you are more likely to pick up the instrument and play it,"
Exactly! Now I just need to convince my wife of that, instead of her thinking that it's just something else that's in her way and looking unsightly.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Grumpy on January 26, 2017, 11:36:48 AM
Far better if all instruments are stored in cases out of sight, it prevents household management becoming aware of how many you have !.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Julian S on January 26, 2017, 01:13:52 PM
Far better if all instruments are stored in cases out of sight, it prevents household management becoming aware of how many you have !.

Or just buy liliputs, preciosas or better still giordys - easier to hide !


Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Steve C. on January 26, 2017, 01:29:57 PM
I think it was Lester (?) who wisely said to sit it near the kettle.  Even those 5 minute sessions has increased my playing time.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Melissa Sinclair on January 26, 2017, 01:46:46 PM
Far better if all instruments are stored in cases out of sight, it prevents household management becoming aware of how many you have !.

Another approach would be to buy all instruments that have a similar outside look. You could switch to a different key/configuration, but they would look about the same to the untrained eye. :-)

If I get into this, my husband wouldn't mind much as long as I stuck to the budget, but he would start to wonder... "why do you need 4 of the same instrument?" And I might not want to have to explain myself all the time.... though he would understand completely different keys.... but would then probably say, "then why didn't you just get one that can play all the keys so you don't have to have so many about?"

Teasing really. His passion is chess... I'm still trying to figure out why we need THREE wood chess boards of all the same size? And several sets of chess pieces - all the same size.  :D  He bought a new computer just to be able to run a chess software program because his old laptop couldn't support it. That "old" laptop was less than a year old.

Quote
Steve_Freereeder - To go back to the original question, it can be a psychological aid to practising if you keep the melodeon out of its case or gig bag at least some of the time when at home. If you haven't got the (even relatively minor) faff of taking the instrument out of its case or wrestling with the gig bag straps and zip, you are more likely to pick up the instrument and play it, even just for a short time when passing, e.g when waiting for the kettle to boil or when the adverts are on the telly. So long as the instrument is not going to get knocked or chewed by the dog, it won't come to any harm by being out of its case. You can always simply throw a clean duster over it to keep off the dust. For longer term storage it's best to keep it in its case, of course.

This is true for any project or hobby. Putting it away means forgetting about it.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Lester on January 26, 2017, 02:28:33 PM
I think it was Lester (?) who wisely said to sit it near the kettle.  Even those 5 minute sessions has increased my playing time.

Yep
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: David A on January 26, 2017, 03:11:52 PM
I always keep my Serenellini Lady in its gig bag (with the bellows straps fastened) to protect it from knocks and dust but with only the buckles of the gig bag fastened so it is easy to extract, and I leave the shoulder straps outside the gig bag so they're not being crushed. This way it only takes a few seconds to be ready to play. :||:
For me the hard case it came in is virtually  redundant as I use the gig bag when travelling by car - I'd only use the hard case if someone else was transporting my Lady, or it was going in the hold of an aircraft.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 26, 2017, 03:17:36 PM
...I'd only use the hard case if someone else was transporting my Lady, or it was going in the hold of an aircraft.
Avoid aircraft hold transport if possible. But if you must, make sure the melodeon is securely padded inside the hard case with bubble-wrap, expanded polystyrene, etc. to ensure that it doesn't move about inside the case. Aircraft baggage handlers are not renowned for their gentleness in chucking stuff around. Also, if you can, lock the clasps so they don't get accidentally caught and inadvertently opened. Failing that, stick duct-tape patches over the clasps.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Julian S on January 26, 2017, 04:10:48 PM
Excellent advice about air travel as I squeeze the Giordy into the rucksack pre ski trip... a few days without an instrument is terrible. I'm always looking out for the ultimate solid, strong,lightweight case just the right size for it.
I do wonder how much better a player I would be if I'd kept a box out of it's case- or by the kettle, all these years.(Or even better if work hadn't got in the way...!)
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: MartinW on January 26, 2017, 04:41:40 PM
Fitting into airline hand baggage is (another) very good reason why we all need a Lililput or Preciosa.
Martin.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: MikeK on January 26, 2017, 04:46:50 PM
 Mine is always left on the dressing table in our bedroom.
 I acquired another skill, on a small sewing machine,when I made a nice dust cover for it.
 The hard case is wrapped up in the garage until holiday season.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: gettabettabox on January 26, 2017, 04:49:43 PM

The Hohner single rows are an exception however...the right place is on top of the kitchen dresser!  ;)
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 26, 2017, 06:15:17 PM
Mine is always left on the dressing table in our bedroom.
 I acquired another skill, on a small sewing machine,when I made a nice dust cover for it.
 The hard case is wrapped up in the garage until holiday season.

I'd need a BIG dressing table to fit all 13 on top........
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: playandteach on January 26, 2017, 06:46:04 PM
I keep mine on the piano. Problem is that I keep everything else there too.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: MikeK on January 26, 2017, 07:59:30 PM
Mine is always left on the dressing table in our bedroom.
 I acquired another skill, on a small sewing machine,when I made a nice dust cover for it.
 The hard case is wrapped up in the garage until holiday season.

I'd need a BIG dressing table to fit all 13 on top........
/quote]


Isn't 13 considered unlucky. I think you need another.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Stockaryd on January 26, 2017, 10:20:11 PM
I have my melodeon in the sofa. I have to move it to sit down and watch TV.
There is also a guitar and an ukulele.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 27, 2017, 12:17:00 AM
Yes, pianos are really designed for musicians to put their drinks on.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: David A on January 27, 2017, 12:18:29 PM
Avoid aircraft hold transport if possible. But if you must, make sure the melodeon is securely padded inside the hard case with bubble-wrap, expanded polystyrene, etc. to ensure that it doesn't move about inside the case. Aircraft baggage handlers are not renowned for their gentleness in chucking stuff around. Also, if you can, lock the clasps so they don't get accidentally caught and inadvertently opened. Failing that, stick duct-tape patches over the clasps.

Thanks for the excellent advice about transport by air. I can't imagine when I would need that as we drive to the alps to ski and then we spend our summers going round Folk Festivals in our caravan. There's always room in the car or 'van for my Lady in her gig bag.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on January 29, 2017, 03:03:34 PM
Probably a good idea to keep them in their cases, but don't fasten the bellows straps.
The straps should only be used for unboxed travelling.
I'll probably be shot down for this but I do think that's correct.

Cobblers. I've never heard such nonsense. It is a good thing to keep the bellows compressed.  It makes the bellows easier to close fully when you are playing.  Nothing worse than encountering resistance in the last bit of bellows movement.  With older instruments it will make little difference.

I've just nipped upstairs and fixed all the straps on my boxes.😎 Mind you for me to nip anywhere is bordering on ridiculous . Thanks for the advice gang.

What are bellows straps for anyway?  To prevent the bellows opening when you don't want them to – taking the instrument out of it's case is the one time when you do want the bellows to under control.

I always keep the various melodeons in their boxes until it's their turn to be played. No dusting, and I havent got shelf space anyway. But I do wonder if there are disadvantages to this - maybe more chance of rusty reeds ? Views and comments ?

Avoid extremes of temperature, avoid dampness and also avoid very low humidity, and avoid excessive dust.   Stick to those simple guidelines and your melodeon will be happy, and so will you. I can't see any reason why storing in a closed case would lead to rusty reeds, unless you put it away damp.  So don't let it get damp in the first place.

I hope we can squash these two pointless myths before they get out out.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 30, 2017, 06:27:29 AM
Never EVER use hold transport. I've said this before but watching a Ryanair load at Liverpool I counted 1 in 20 bags tossed onto the conveyer bounce, and then fall about 1.8m onto the concrete. Add unseen in terminal ballistics, and a 2 way journey and you are looking at 12-15% of your box getting accident level sudden deceleration on a trip

Similarly in Copenhagen I WATCHED Scandanavian Air's unloader throwing cases something over 2.5m into a recepticle. This guy was a much better shot, and never missed, but … reeds in wax aren't designed to take this sort of sudden force.

I travel with a van der Aa compact (3 row). In a gig bag it fits even Ryanair's litle cage. I calculated that my full size Gaillard would have to be dismenbered, box bits on my shoulders, bellows in suitcase in hold. But are we off topic in this?

A Mexican friend told me that melodeons should be stored on their legs (right end), never on their sides, that otherwise wax will creep, reeds will move.  Not noticed this in 30 years m'self. Is there any truth ….even 'alternative truth' in this?
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Howard Jones on January 30, 2017, 09:54:15 AM
...Add unseen in terminal ballistics...

The company I used to work for was involved in building a new terminal at Manchester Airport and I was taken on a "behind the scenes" tour before it opened.  The baggage-handling area was a maze of conveyors which delivered the luggage down some high and very steep chutes, and it arrived at the bottom with a considerable impact. Having seen what happens to your luggage by design, before the handlers get stuck in, I would never put anything breakable in hold luggage.

I was once at the same airport waiting for my luggage when I noticed a battered cardboard box going round on the carousel.  Despite being labelled "Fragile" in large letters it was upside down and looked as if it had been given a good kicking. Just as it had disappeared out of sight I heard a voice behind me say, "Don't worry darling, it's marked 'Fragile'".
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Dazbo on March 21, 2017, 05:11:37 PM
A Mexican friend told me that melodeons should be stored on their legs (right end), never on their sides, that otherwise wax will creep, reeds will move.  Not noticed this in 30 years m'self. Is there any truth ….even 'alternative truth' in this?

Not heard this about melodeons in the years I've been playing but I have heard something similar about proper concertinas (ie not accordian reeds) where the concertina should be stored in the same orientation it is played in. 

Is this another Urban Myth Theo?
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Theo on March 21, 2017, 05:18:25 PM
Concertina valves do set into a curled position if stored on one end for long periods.  The equivalent for a melodeon would be laying it on its back.  I've seen no evidence of wax creep from incorrect storage position in the climate we have in the UK.   Mexico might be different.  Wherever you are its best just to play the thing and not get too preoccupied with minute details of storage.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Jules0654 on March 21, 2017, 08:05:31 PM
I gave in and have garage racking in the lounge to hold the 20+ melodeons.......trouble is so many are played and left on the floor and the racking is empty....!
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Clawhammer on March 22, 2017, 07:15:15 PM
As a single box kind of guy, I got a little "Fishman Loudbox Artist Slip Cover" to enable the thing to sit covered in the living room and taunt me whenever I'm watching the worthless box that makes sounds when turned on.  It's sits right there in front of me in my chair and continues to remind me that it does not care to be ignored.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: squeezy on March 24, 2017, 09:33:42 AM
Unfortunately if you play gigs abroad with more than one box needed then the NEVER EVER use the aircraft hold is an impossible rule to follow.  I have had one pokerwork almost completely smashed up by EasyJet but because it was the cheapest box I had with me it was also in the cheapest case.  I have never had a box damaged in a proper case made of resin bonded birch plywood with decent aluminium fittings.  I don't use bubble-wrap and foam inside the case but instead I remove the reedblocks, wrap them up and take separately in the suitcase, stuff the instrument full of my pants and socks for the trip and then wrap the melodeon in larger clothes like T-shirts and jumpers until it cannot move in the flight case.

I'm not saying it's impossible to have your instrument broken this way - but a regular melodeon case that comes with the instrument is certainly not good enough for the job.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Julian S on March 24, 2017, 12:07:47 PM
Unfortunately if you play gigs abroad with more than one box needed then the NEVER EVER use the aircraft hold is an impossible rule to follow.  I have had one pokerwork almost completely smashed up by EasyJet but because it was the cheapest box I had with me it was also in the cheapest case.  I have never had a box damaged in a proper case made of resin bonded birch plywood with decent aluminium fittings.  I don't use bubble-wrap and foam inside the case but instead I remove the reedblocks, wrap them up and take separately in the suitcase, stuff the instrument full of my pants and socks for the trip and then wrap the melodeon in larger clothes like T-shirts and jumpers until it cannot move in the flight case.

I'm not saying it's impossible to have your instrument broken this way - but a regular melodeon case that comes with the instrument is certainly not good enough for the job.

Excellent advice. Presumably the dirty clothes get squeezed inside the instrument on return ? >:E
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: squeezy on March 24, 2017, 02:21:29 PM
Well ... yes ... but you can put them in a plastic bag first if you're squeamish about it I suppose!
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: rebus on July 13, 2017, 12:32:26 PM
What about keeping the melodeon in the car (into a gigbag)? I have sometimes the need to keep mine in the car all day long, but I am worried about weather and humidity conditions (temperature may be almost 50°C in the summer or below zero in winter)
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on July 13, 2017, 01:34:29 PM
I prefer accessible storage

SJ

Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: 911377brian on July 13, 2017, 02:15:41 PM
There was a post a bit back on Eskimo melodeon bands and I wondered then how on earth they were stored and kept playable in formidably low temperatures. Perhaps we're worrying too much....
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: tirpous on July 13, 2017, 04:38:34 PM
Quote
What about keeping the melodeon in the car (into a gigbag)? I have sometimes the need to keep mine in the car all day long, but I am worried about weather and humidity conditions (temperature may be almost 50°C in the summer or below zero in winter)

I think it's generally considered not to be a good idea.
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: The Idle Rich on July 13, 2017, 05:18:09 PM
The late Jim Coogan once  told me that he was in Florida with his Paolo Soprani and had to leave it in the car parked behind some palm trees in the shade. When he returned the car was no longer in the shade and all the reeds had melted off the reed blocks!   :P
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Lester on July 13, 2017, 05:25:48 PM
As I have related previously, I left my Castagnari Lily in my boot all day when at work as we were going dancing in the evening to fleece entertain the Christmas crowds. It got very cold. We went into a pub for a pre-dance stiffener where it warmed up some, then back out into the cold. Cue big suck treble chord to attract the crowds attention, all the reeds parted company with the box, ended up with very expensive Castagnari Shaky Egg   :(

Be careful out there !
Title: Re: Storing the melodeons
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on July 17, 2017, 03:19:00 PM
Here's a thought. How about putting  the box into a suitable cool box. It should then be impervious to temperature.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal