Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Jonathan Arnett on January 26, 2017, 09:55:57 PM

Title: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 26, 2017, 09:55:57 PM
Hello, Having had to sell my Piano I'm looking to try the melodeon. Having read quite a bit on here. It seems the Hohner d/g Pokerwork is favored. However if I can't track one down within my budget. I notice that on Amazon Scarlatti d/g boxes are around £280 which is just about within budget. And they don't sound too bad. But how durable are they? They do look a bit plastic y.  I will try to find a Hohner or similar but in the end I need to get my hands on something to play on for now. Of course I would love to spend 500+ on a wooden one but I just don't have the money right now. And even if I did I don't yet know if I'm going to be able to play the thing anyway! I reached grade 5 with the Piano when I was 16. That was quite a long time ago. Sadly after moving away to college and then working all over the place I could only play my Piano rarely. Well it's now gone to a new home. I love folk music and though I did consider an accordian I just like the sound of the melodeon better. Or maybe I like the sound of good melodeons better! 
Another question. How much does it cost to tune a melodeon? Say I find a C/G Hohner in good order but need a D/G as theres so much more study material out there. Or I find a wet tuned box and want to dry it off a bit.... Not sure what the right terminology for that is.
Great mine of information on here and thanks for reading this far. Sorry if this has all been asked before but I came up blank when I searched.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Anahata on January 26, 2017, 11:20:42 PM
A cheap box may sound OK. What makes it cheap is how easy (or not) it is to play. When you start a note, if it takes a comparatively long time for the sound to start, it feels like hard work to play and it won't go fast, or some notes will hardly respond at all if you try to play it quietly.  And yes, reliability may be a problem too.

As for tuning - that won't convert a G/C to a D/G! Even a shift of just a tone (C/F to D/G is often done) is best done by moving the reeds around for best fit, tuning the ones that are a semitone out and replacing the few that can't be used from the old set. You'd have to ask a fettler for a price and let them see the box - some are much harder work than others and an old box may need new valves or other work done on it.

Changing the amount of tremolo is easier, but again you're better off asking for a quote.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: playandteach on January 26, 2017, 11:23:58 PM
I would have thought that if you find a good quality GC box in good order, that you should be able to trade it for a DG or at least sell it for enough money to get a similar quality DG. Though you might find a CF cheaper for the same quality, price as the key you want.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Theo on January 26, 2017, 11:39:22 PM
I would have thought that if you find a good quality GC box in good order, that you should be able to trade it for a DG or at least sell it for enough money to get a similar quality DG. Though you might find a CF cheaper for the same quality, price as the key you want.

That makes more sense, though you have to rely on your own judgement of the worth of a (say)GC box.

It really only makes sense to buy a box in the pitch that you want (eg DG).   Would you buy a car that had the wrong engine in it and then trade it or have the engine changed?   Its more or less equivalent.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 27, 2017, 12:07:00 AM
I had a Scarlatti as my first box. The only thing i found wrong with it was that, from new, it was very stiff to play and it took some work on the inside to get it working alright. I don't know whether this stiffness is general, but I tried one at my local melodeon outlet (NOT Acorn Instruments!) and this had the same stiffness. Apart from this, which can often disappear with playing, it was a good starter melodeon. I would recommend however that you check the Buy and Sell market here and look for a second-hand D/G, possibly a Pokerwork or a Sandpiper (mine's a cracker!) Good Luck!

Chris B.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: TomB on January 27, 2017, 01:42:19 AM

This is for sale on Ebay at the moment, perfectly good starter box.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Very-Nice-Delicia-Popular-Melodeon-in-key-of-D-G-/192083066835?hash=item2cb90affd3:g:ExMAAOSwZQRYc4DR
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: george garside on January 27, 2017, 09:16:32 AM
chinese boxes depreciate  initially very rapidly  so a 2nd hand one can be ok to start on and can probably be sold on for much the same as you paid .  Don't buy a new one because you will stand the initial high depreciation.

Other than that a second hand pokerwork is worth looking for and  small faults such as  a  reed not sounding right  are easily put right at reasonable cost  . A second hand pokerwork from one of the fettlers/dealers that post on here can be a very good buy and can last a lifetime. There are a number of 'professional' players who use nothing else!

george
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 27, 2017, 09:43:16 AM

This is for sale on Ebay at the moment, perfectly good starter box.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Very-Nice-Delicia-Popular-Melodeon-in-key-of-D-G-/192083066835?hash=item2cb90affd3:g:ExMAAOSwZQRYc4DR

Hmmm... I started out with the wooden 'deluxe' version.  It was hideous.  After three months I bought a Pokerwork... such a difference. The Pokerwork still gets played and is currently on loan doing missionary work with a wannabe player.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 27, 2017, 01:23:02 PM
Thanks for the detailed advice. You learn something every day. Will avoid cheap then as I can't at this stage try one one out. And certainly don't want anything difficult to play. So will consider the Delicia though it looks a bit like a childs toy. And see if I can find a Pokerwork then!
There are two B/C Pokerworks on ebay. Even a secondhand one at Hobgoblin. The B/C boxes seem less popular so don't quite walk of the shelves as fast giving me a better chance to get a good one. But I havn't seen much study material available for them. There are no local teachers here even I could afford that. So will be learning from books and the internet. Do like the lower tone of the B/C but having something easier to learn on is probably more important at this stage. There is a Hohner Morgane on ebay thats not too far from me and it sounds great to my ear. But it weighs 10kg's. Seems like a lot compared to the Pokerworks 3. Have experssed an interest in a Chinese D/G Pokerwork on here though not at the asking price. Are they ok to learn on or am I better buying an older genuine German one?? Probably for similar money. Havn't seen a sandpiper for sale at all. Crying shame about the Music room. If only I'd known I would have got one even before I sold the Piano but thats life. It's there fault I'm here really. They persuaded me it was possible.... 
Really appreciate all the help.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Theo on January 27, 2017, 01:35:06 PM
BC is a very versatile system because it is chromatic.  It is usually used for playing Irish or Scottish music and most teachers and teaching material you find will be Irish style.  It's much less popular for Scottish these days, but still a very good system. 
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Nigel on January 27, 2017, 01:45:50 PM

This is for sale on Ebay at the moment, perfectly good starter box.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Very-Nice-Delicia-Popular-Melodeon-in-key-of-D-G-/192083066835?hash=item2cb90affd3:g:ExMAAOSwZQRYc4DR

Hmmm... I started out with the wooden 'deluxe' version.  It was hideous.  After three months I bought a Pokerwork... such a difference. The Pokerwork still gets played and is currently on loan doing missionary work with a wannabe player.

Dave Gray started on the basic Delicia (as advertised on ebay) and is proud to say so.
You're a much better player than me Helena but my wooden delux version is great. I think that Lester stated elsewhere that the set up of the box is important and I may have been lucky.  Initially I hired a Pokerwork, then bought an old Gremlin which I resold quickly on expert advice (from Theo) and then bought the Delicia. For a beginner, I think that it's second best to a Pokerwork but not by that much. I now have an Italian box but whilst obviously inferior, the Delicia works and sounds fine when occasionally played. I really should sell it but I'm MAD.     
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 27, 2017, 01:52:42 PM
Further to Theo's comments, the BC boxes 'function' in a different way.
i.e. the 4th apart boxes such as DG, GC, AD or BbEb are similar in the way they play.
If you played a tune on a DG then went to any of these others, pressed the keys on the keyboard in the same order, the tune comes out the same but the different key of the new box. That would not happen if you went from a BC box to one of these.

When people start off trying to get their first melodeon, the often asked question is ' what music do you want to play?'
As said, Scottish or Irish favour the BC's whereas English music players generally go for DG. That tends to be the prominent weapon of choice on here. Others favouring French or continental music will possibly gravitate to a GC.
As a gross generalisation if you listen to any of the genre's of music then for instance the Irish tend to fly around the keyboard so tend to want something chromatic and often the basses are played spasmodically or poked in where they can.
Something like the English style relies heavily on basses to provide a rhythmic backdrop to the melody in their home keys of D and G. It's horses for courses.
Any ideas as to what style you like to listen to and eventually play?

cheers
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: gettabettabox on January 27, 2017, 02:30:21 PM
Hohner Morgan's don't weigh anywhere near 10kg?
(Unless someone has put a lead brick inside.)
A little bit heavier than a pokerwork I'd say, towards 4kg.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 27, 2017, 02:41:29 PM
Hohner Morgan's don't weigh anywhere near 10kg?
(Unless someone has put a lead brick inside.)
A little bit heavier than a pokerwork I'd say, towards 4kg.

I've never played a Morgane, but judging by the photos I've seen I'd guess it would be around the same weight as my Saltarelle - about 3.8Kg.

Graham
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: David A on January 27, 2017, 02:42:44 PM
I started with a secondhand Scarlatti Nero that I "borrowed" for £50 from Hobgoblin for the week of Sidmouth Folk Festival in 2015 so that I could go along to Ed Rennie's workshops. At the end of the week I decided to keep it as I'd really enjoyed playing it and Ed's workshops were excellent so paid Hobgoblin the balance. However I did find pulling the bellows hard work and now that I've decided I intend to continue playing I've splashed out on a Serenellini Lady to replace the Nero. The Lady sounds much nicer and is much easier to play.
For lessons I go to as many workshops as I can at the various folk festivals I go to. In addition to Ed's, I've been to ones run by Bob Ellis (Sidmouth 2016) and Mel Biggs (Shrewsbury 2015 & 2016). All were great fun and very helpful. Mel does lessons by Skype that several people have told me are good. And I've bought a few lessons from Les Titford from his website (http://www.daddylongles.com/). These are also good. But the best thing I've found is to get together regularly with some other players (not necessarily just box players) as playing with others, even at low level of competence, is much more rewarding that practising alone.
Everyone tells me it's virtually impossible to find the box you want straight away, so I recommend getting one (perhaps hiring it if you're near a Hobgoblin shop) and getting started. Once you're playing a bit you'll start to work out what's really important for what you want to play.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: george garside on January 27, 2017, 03:42:56 PM
Jonathan - if we had a clue as to where you live there may be a forum member near to you who could give you some help/advice or whatever.

I can't understand the need for secrecy as to ones abode and putting country, county, and town can't do anybody any harm but may result in some positive connections being made!

george
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: 911377brian on January 27, 2017, 04:08:40 PM
We're whizzing off piste here George but I've never understood the need for secrecy when it comes to addresses either. I don't expect a post code but a county would be helpful.....
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 27, 2017, 04:29:13 PM
Thanks again for all the help. It's no secret where I live. I just havn't filled in my profile yet.... If I wanted to be incognito would have used Sqeezer or something as a username. Sorry only just joined.  Halifax.
ok. So the B/C  is probably more Piano like. Do you get the same note on the push and pull? Or is it just that the keys go up in semitones rather than tones? And carry on going up rather than changing direction half way like the D/G I've watched a few of Daddy long les blogs on utube so sort of understand how the D/G works. Well as far as you can without actually having one to mess with.  Think it will take some getting used to after a Piano.
I wasn't aware that Hobgoblin hired instruments. There Leeds shop isn't a million miles from me so may be worth a visit. Though Friday afternoon is the only real time I have for that sort of thing and driving to Leeds on a Friday isn't my idea of fun.
Style of music. I listen to English, Scottish and Irish. So not much help there.... Sorry. Used to play Classical and ragtime on the Piano. Though have long listened to folk.
Would be great to play with others but having small children makes that a bit difficult. Chances of a workshop or festival pretty slim at least until they get a bit bigger. Though skype is a real possibility.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Huw Adamson on January 27, 2017, 04:52:21 PM
There are no differences between a B/C and D/G except for the fact the keys D and G are a fourth apart, and the keys of B and C are a semitone apart. Both still play different notes in each direction, and the scale changes halfway up (don't worry about this though, it takes very little getting used to and helps with chords.)
Because the keys of B and C are a semitone apart, you can play in more keys in total, having more 'accidentals', however the advantage of a fourth apart box is that you tend to be able to do a lot more with the bass and chords.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 27, 2017, 05:03:10 PM
Jonathan, if you go to the Home page of the forum, on the left hand side is a section called Articles.
There you can click on the link and view typical keyboard layouts for most of the common keys. Both BC and D G layouts are there.
With your experience of piano it might give you a good insight into how they vary from key to key and also how BC and DG compare.
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 27, 2017, 05:45:33 PM
Arhhh. That makes sense at last. On the face of it the B/C is more versatile. But as you say there advantages to both layouts. Have an offer in on a D/G Hohner Polkerwork so wait and see if it's accepted. If not there are 2 B/C Hohner Polkerworks I could have a crack at.  Let fate decide.
The seller of the Morgane said it was 10kg. It is a bit too expensive really though it's a great sounding and looking box. Noticed a Sherwood Shire on Amazon at 450 though I know nothing about them and can't find anything on utube either. Bit expensive also really. Didn't get so much for the Piano. There so heavy and difficult to move it's not easy finding anyone committed enough to come and take it away.
Thanks for all the help.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 27, 2017, 06:07:33 PM
Glad you see what's going on through the keyboard layouts.
The reason the DGs are the preferred box for English music is a historical thing. One of our tune collectors collected a lot of tunes in those keys in the mid 50's and asked Hohner to produce a batch in these keys therefore the box is designed to play the tunes in the keys commonly used for English music.
The BC is more versatile ( chromatic ) if that's what you need!
For the majority of tunes in the common English repertoire you don't need this, hence the two keys. Also most DGs have some accidentals at the chin end to help out if you need them.
More food for thought!
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 27, 2017, 06:08:15 PM
There are no differences between a B/C and D/G except for the fact the keys D and G are a fourth apart, and the keys of B and C are a semitone apart.

That's pretty much a fundamental difference..........
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Winston Smith on January 27, 2017, 06:09:40 PM
I know I'm a skinflint, but when I see someone looking for a "budget" box, I still think in terms of £15 to £18! Mind you, I now realise that Hohner's and the like don't usually come for those sort of prices, and you do tend to get what you pay for.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 27, 2017, 06:12:45 PM
The seller of the Morgane said it was 10kg.

I'm guessing that will be the shipping weight (s)he'll be charging for, not the weight of the instrument.

Graham
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 27, 2017, 06:20:40 PM
Yes, that makes sense. When I posted my Scarlatti, including the case and packing, it was getting on that way. By the way, the bellows stiffness is curable, without too much effort.

Chris B.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: vof on January 27, 2017, 08:05:34 PM
There are no differences between a B/C and D/G except for the fact the keys D and G are a fourth apart, and the keys of B and C are a semitone apart.

That's pretty much a fundamental difference..........

That's what I thought too when I read it except with added exclamations and adjectives!  >:E
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Grape Ape on January 27, 2017, 08:55:07 PM
THE MORGANE IS NOT 10kg!
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Lyra on January 27, 2017, 09:31:09 PM
They might be referring to volumetric weight which is a construct used in some shipping agencies? It's something that needs taking your socks off to calculate, imho, but there you go.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: george garside on January 28, 2017, 09:25:21 AM
In England the choice of DG or BC  depends on what you want to play and who you want to play it with!   DG is best for most 'english'  pub sessions as most of the stuff played will be in D or G!  If however you only intend to play with yourself ( so to speak)  then a BC  does offer fairly easy playing in FCGDAE   but mostly without usable bass. The fairly rare Hohner double ray with 12 stradella bass improves things considerably as you have bass for CGDA and enough to get by on for F & E. I have one of those and its a very useful/versatile lightweight 2 row box, but then I would not consider the 8 (melodeon ) bass double ray( which is popular for Irish music ) because I rarely play Irish trad music.

george
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 28, 2017, 09:29:13 AM
It always comes back to 'what do you want to play?......'
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 28, 2017, 12:05:18 PM
Probably English. Most likely will be playing by myself at least for some time. Will just about manage 15 minutes a day. Maybe a bit more Fridays though more than that may lead the neighbours to rebel anyway. At least until I can get a tune out of it! I'm no Tim Eday. Biting my fingernails a bit now as waiting for a response to the offer I put in on a D/G Hohner Pokerwork. There is a C/F Pokerwork on ebay very cheap and it looks in fine fettle. That may be the fall back. If it stays cheap enough it may be worth converting depending on the condition. Ebay a bit of a gamble. Though of course I could always have two. No no I didn't say that. It's a tough choice really. Love the Morgane on ebay but it's a lot of money if I can't get my head around it. But then I don't want something thats going to offend my ears. Are there any fettlers in West Yorkshire? To get whatever I get checked over and maybe tuned/adjusted a bit? Was planning on using the guy at the music room though he must live somewhere around here.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: george garside on January 28, 2017, 12:15:19 PM
the music room used Paul Flannery Music for repair and tuning work. He is in Cleckheaton and has a website

george
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: David A on January 28, 2017, 01:38:43 PM
I think Ollie King (here on melnet and also at www.olliekingmusic.com) works part time at Hobgoblin in Leeds. It might be worth having a chat with him about an hire-purchase arrangement for a box. I found making a proposal (eg 4 quarterly instalments) better than asking what they could offer. Cheers, David
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Huw Adamson on January 28, 2017, 02:06:16 PM
The main things you have to check on ebay are the tuning and the bellows. I'd never buy a box off ebay if there wasn't a clear picture of the bellows spread open.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 28, 2017, 02:22:59 PM
Ollie has now moved to London and I do remember him saying he'd given up his job which presumably was Hobgoblin in Leeds.
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 28, 2017, 02:24:26 PM
Just thought as I pressed 'send'
A lot of fettlers use couriers to get boxes too and from them, which saves a very long trip in the car.
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 28, 2017, 02:41:38 PM
the music room used Paul Flannery Music for repair and tuning work. He is in Cleckheaton and has a website

george

Came up blank on Google.  Not listed on here either. Though Jolly rodger accordians claim to have been trained by him. Only reference to him I can find. Would rather go direct than through a shop if possible. Thanks.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Caroline on January 28, 2017, 03:42:11 PM
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Hohner-2-row-Pokerwork-Melodeon-/292007935057?hash=item43fd077c51%3Ag%3AgY0AAOSw9GhYhfQx
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Bill Young on January 28, 2017, 03:49:51 PM
the music room used Paul Flannery Music for repair and tuning work. He is in Cleckheaton and has a website

george

Came up blank on Google.  Not listed on here either. Though Jolly rodger accordians claim to have been trained by him. Only reference to him I can find. Would rather go direct than through a shop if possible. Thanks.

https://www.facebook.com/PaulFlannerymusic/
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 28, 2017, 04:24:07 PM
Jolly Roger is on here as RogerT.
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on January 28, 2017, 05:22:11 PM
Re Paul Flannery - this may help: https://all-opening-hours.co.uk/07011103/Paul_Flannery_Music

It also has a map for his business.

Chris B.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Lyra on January 29, 2017, 12:01:26 AM
Love the Morgane on ebay but it's a lot of money if I can't get my head around it.
Well, yes and no - a decent box can generally be sold on without major loss if it decides not to choose you :)
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on January 29, 2017, 02:33:49 PM
Thanks for the links to Paul. I'm going to need him. Think I have a box as my offer accepted. It's a D/G Pokerwork of 30 years vintage. And not too expensive compared to the Chinese ones. Maybe I will aspire to a Sherwood Shire. But first I need to actually learn to play at least to an elementary level. Thanks for all the help. Sure I will be back for more. What an amazing friendly bunch you are. Usually on forums there are people who just want to show you how little you know or how superior they are to you. It's refreshing to receive so much help. Especially I listen to some of you on u-tube. And will probably never be able to play as well as that. Maybe Melodeon players are just good people! Now I need to go and arrange to collect my new instrument. Thanks again for all the reply's.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 29, 2017, 02:51:12 PM
Well done Jonathan in acquiring the box. A Pokerwork will keep you going for ever.
Once you have it sorted, don't forget to keep popping back and asking advice, don't get stuck!
Cheers
Q
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Graham Spencer on January 29, 2017, 03:38:11 PM
Maybe Melodeon players are just good people!

Sounds about right to me........
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on February 17, 2017, 05:07:19 PM
Finally got it. Great sound with strong bass. Sounds in tune to me.  Bit battered but it is 30 years old. Came with new expensive padded straps and the book by Dave Mallinson so that softened the blow a little. It is quite easy to play needing very little air to play a sound. I Love the sound of it. Not sure the neighbors will! Think I may need to drive out to a deserted moor and annoy some sheep. By the time i got back only had 15 minutes to play with it. Think I will live with it as is for now as I may want to change a key somewhere later so will hold off getting it looked at for now. All I have to do now is learn to play the thing. Got to go and feed the kids now so it won't be today. Thanks for all the advice. The Hohner is a lovely sounding box.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Sage Herb on February 17, 2017, 06:16:44 PM
Re Paul Flannery - this may help: https://all-opening-hours.co.uk/07011103/Paul_Flannery_Music

It also has a map for his business.

Chris B.

Jonathan, if you can't contact Paul F via website, PM me and I'll give you his mobile number. BTW good luck with the box - Hohners are wonderful.
Cheers
Steve

Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Christopher K. on February 21, 2017, 04:49:56 AM
Quote
Bit battered but it is 30 years old

And the best ones usually are.An excellent choice. 8)

Congratulations on your first box, and welcome to the melodeon.  :||: :||: :||:
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Garry Probert on February 21, 2017, 11:34:24 AM
Quote
Bit battered but it is 30 years old

And the best ones usually are.An excellent choice. 8)

Congratulations on your first box, and welcome to the melodeon.
excellent purchase I was lucky as my friends a player so tried a few far east ? starter boxes

My vintage hohner's are so superior in build quality and I played a modern chinese version and even with my limited knowledge the build quality and sound are inferior ,darrens advice was buy a vintage hohner as they were expensive when new and quality built instruments ,and he thinks are still very undervalued compared to modern budget instruments

A bit battered is character for me probably because i,m also a bit battered lol     
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on February 23, 2017, 07:19:49 PM
 It's what you guys recommended I get. But on hearing it I could understand why. Really don't get why the guy sold it as he was still playing. It has a truly awesome sound. I have heard a few on utube but not like this one. Only issue i have is it's really loud. Not too bad when playing only the treble. But now I'm getting the bass going with the simple tunes. Theres just no way to keep it quiet. So it's either clear out the shed. Which needs doing anyway. Or take to driving off to remote places and get arrested for disturbing the peace.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 24, 2017, 07:39:55 AM
It's what you guys recommended I get. But on hearing it I could understand why. Really don't get why the guy sold it as he was still playing. It has a truly awesome sound. I have heard a few on utube but not like this one. Only issue i have is it's really loud. Not too bad when playing only the treble. But now I'm getting the bass going with the simple tunes. Theres just no way to keep it quiet. So it's either clear out the shed. Which needs doing anyway. Or take to driving off to remote places and get arrested for disturbing the peace.

It should be perfectly possible for a Pokerwork to be played relatively softly. Try it and see - the reeds should respond with relatively little bellows pressure. You shouldn't need to force the instrument to play. However, a lot depends on how the reeds have been set up (or not). If the reeds have a 'breathy' sound and are slow to respond except at higher bellows pressures (= a loud sound), it is likely that some adjustment of the reed tip gap is needed and maybe some valves replacing too.

Some players (particularly morris musicians) who need extra volume may have had the reed gap set deliberately on the high side, which could mean the instrument is more difficult to play quietly.

A good instrument repairer and tuner can check what is needed and do the work to set up the instrument for you. 
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: george garside on February 24, 2017, 08:56:41 AM
many boxes will play a lot quieter if you squeeze less hard!  so doing does not seem to come naturally and actually takes considerable practice

george >:E ;)
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on February 25, 2017, 10:53:10 PM
That's interesting. I can play the treble soft. But the Bass no way. When played together it's really loud or no sound comes out at all. Think I probably need to get it set up properly. It also seems to need more pressure on the pull than the push. Or maybe thats just me. There are grommets under the bass buttons so it has had some work in the past. A bit busy rebuilding the kitchen at the moment but I will get around to it. Also I don't want to be without it for a week. It's sort of addictive. 15 minutes stress relief at least twice a day! (Today more like an hour and 15m. )
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: TomBom on February 25, 2017, 11:23:31 PM
That's interesting. I can play the treble soft. But the Bass no way.
You can try to play the basses really really staccato. Very short, just tipping the buttons.
It's not easy, though, to play one side staccato and the other not.
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on February 26, 2017, 04:39:39 PM
Thanks. Will give it a try but probably my skill level isn't there yet. About 5 years off!
Title: Re: Budget boxes
Post by: Kimric Smythe on March 10, 2017, 07:38:49 AM
Hohner Morgan's don't weigh anywhere near 10kg?
(Unless someone has put a lead brick inside.)
A little bit heavier than a pokerwork I'd say, towards 4kg.
Does if you get the tungsten or depleted uranium reed plates. Sure its heavy but the sound is awesome!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal