Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Melissa Sinclair on February 07, 2017, 05:30:36 AM
-
So, now that I'm actually starting out and have two melodeons in two different keys and in two different layouts, I wonder, "why would you ever get different boxes in different keys and layouts?"
I was curious and looked around at different GC boxes (as I really do prefer that sound the best). There are 2 rows, 2.5 rows, 3 rows, 8 basses, 12 basses, 18 basses. Some have accidentals on the side, some on the top. Since playing this instrument involves a lot of muscle memory, how can you all switch between instruments so easily? or do you not? Like when you go from one to another, do you just always get the same keyboard layout to avoid all the relearning? Seriously! Is any other instrument like that? Is the relearning hard?
I ask because it was suggest to me and I followed that advice to start out with lighter, simple two row, 8 basses instrument - makes sense. I already realize how much shorter practice sessions would be if I had a huge, heavy instrument. But if I love this, I will eventually want to get a bigger instrument. I thought I might "learn one" on the smaller box and then once I "had it" move it over to the bigger box. But is that even possible? Huh...
Well, I "kind of" had to learn 3 different fingerings for different horns (F horn/Single horn, F/Bb horn with trigger/double horn, and then the mellophone (marching horn) which has fingering and plays like a trumpet). And it always took me a bit of time to switch between them. I couldn't do it instantly even with a young mind of 20 and that was less of a a switch than these keyboard layouts.
Or are they essentially the same and it's easy to switch?
-
Hiya,
I've come to melodeon later in life and this question pops up in my head sometimes. I was tempted with a 2.5 row/12 bass as I thought it might be more versatile but I've decided to stick to a 2 row 8 bass for several reasons.
I don't want to confuse myself in trying to learn different systems. I want to get to grips with the box I've got. That's a personal thing. I realise many out there do use different boxes, 2/2.5 and 3 rows, and can change between them. The people I've met who can do this often have been playing longer, have many years playing under their belt and perhaps that comes into play.
Rather than muddy the waters by learning different things at my learning point on my learning journey I've decided to focus on the straight 2row/8bass.
Possibly more to the point - the music I want to play, mainly English traditional music, doesn't really need anything more than the 2 row 8 bass.
One friend on this forum and excellent player demonstrated to me they keys he could play on his Castagnari Mory, a 2.5 row 12 bass box that has a sound to die for, but is a big beast.
I was blown away at the versatility but got my brain utterly confused. I realised for the type of music I play I simply don't need all that versatility. I don't want to play such a large repertoire that he has, often French as well as English. Maybe in umpteen years time when I'm more proficient, I might review this and enlarge my repertoire but not now.
When you were wondering what to buy a few weeks back, the question often bounced back to you is ' what do you want to play?' That then tends to push you in a direction for which one to go for.
Mostly my English repertoire is DG based and hence my weapon of choice! I'm learning to use the chin end accidentals with ease, and discovering that if I don't have a note ( often a low Fnat ) then I have to cheat - another learning thing!
Theo has often said to me and others that everything is a compromise and it took a while for this to sink in.
OK I can't play in all those other keys but in practice I don't need to.
Hope this has some logic to it..........
cheers
Q
-
A one row instrument is very limited in the keys it can play in, but with in its own limitations it is a wonderful thing. Adding a second row increases its scope. All the other systems are attempts to extend the capabilities. How far you want to go in adding more is a matter of personal choice. But for everything you add you also loose something of the lightness and agility of the simpler systems.
-
I was curious and looked around at different GC boxes (as I really do prefer that sound the best). There are 2 rows, 2.5 rows, 3 rows, 8 basses, 12 basses, 18 basses. Some have accidentals on the side, some on the top. Since playing this instrument involves a lot of muscle memory, how can you all switch between instruments so easily? or do you not? Like when you go from one to another, do you just always get the same keyboard layout to avoid all the relearning?
>
>
Or are they essentially the same and it's easy to switch?
Yes, on the two main rows they are basically the same, and it is easy to switch. The main variation you will find will be in the layout of the half row or third row. There is not really a standard layout for these, although most manufacturers will have their own particular layout which they tend to stick to. Having said that, there is not an awful lot of difference and you will soon get used to where to find the accidentals and reversals on any particular make of box.
I expect someone will come along soon and tell you about the Heim layout or other layouts for the third row, which have generally been developed for maximising playing of modern French music. Some of the different layouts are shown on the 'Keyboard layouts (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard.html)' section of this forum, which I expect you have already discovered. Quite a few are for D/G melodeons so you will need to make the appropriate transposition for a G/C.
Personally, I find that I have no need of a full third row. If I need accidentals in more than one octave, I play my 2.5 row Mory, but otherwise the standard two row is good enough for me, either with a pair of accidentals at the chin end, or as a short two-button half row, like this (http://www.castagnari.com//index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=66).
-
All of the above posts stick to the various layouts for 4th apart boxes but of course there is also the semitone box that I think should also be considered if wanting to move beyond a one or 2 row 4th aprt box.
I started 60 years ago on a double ray BC but playing mostly English and Scottish tunes rather than irish trad I found the lack of bass less than desirable!
A few years later I got hold of a 3 voice trichord with stradella '
I then followed what to me was the 'natural' path to larger 48 and 96 bass 3 row boxes which are very versatile and still part of the 'melodeon family'
for about 20 years I played mostly with myself so to speak! but then 'found' folk festivals and pub sessions as well as 'english' ceilids. I soon realised that almost everything was in D& G anad that most people were playing 2 row DG pokerworks which I had never come across. So to 'fit in' I bought one and used it extensively for sessions etc as it was light to carry and its case did not occupy a seat!
my playing then developed in 2 directions i.e. BC(C#) and DG and when I started playing for English(ish) ceilidhs my weapon of choice was and still is a simple 2 row DG mml. simply because it weighs next to nothing , produces the same volume as a larger box and can be played for long periods without becoming knackered ( me not the box)
I could never see the point in buggering up the 'purity' of the one row or the simple DG with a row of odds and sods that may or may not produce other than home keys when the BC or BCC# with stradella does it so easily.
I still enjoy playing both systems and have absolutely no difficulty in switching from one to t'other
george
-
Difference between two row and Club is one sound only. And additional 4 sounds - you can don't use them.
So not really big difference. After some time you can decide which system looks better for you. It's possible to change one to another easy - to change one sound only. My 2 row boxes are "clubbed". Lot of players are de-clubbing. It's your choice.
-
You ask "why would you ever get different boxes in different keys and layouts?".
In my case the reason for having different layouts is simply that is how the instruments came to me. I have a number of melodeons, some have accidentals and some don't, some have half-rows but both the number of buttons and the layouts are different. I don't have any real trouble switching between them. The biggest difficulty was with the club system, where the variant button is on one the main rows, but I managed with it for some time and only had it de-clubbed after a lot of thought. Usually the variants are accidental notes or reversals which you don't need to use very often.
It can become difficult where a tune makes heavy use of the non-standard buttons and in some cases I stick to playing them on one instrument, as far as possible. For most tunes it just means making a conscious effort to switch - you're still using muscle memory, just a different version of the tune.
If you struggle to switch between different layouts it should be straightforward for a fettler to tune your instruments to the same layout.
-
I have 3 melodeons in different keys (and makes, and ages)- all 8 basses, one is only 2 row, one is 2 row plus 2, the last is 2 row plus 5. I have had them all set out the same (reversals of some notes) on the 2 rows - which means that I would struggle to pick up a normal box and play without some rethinking. I really need only one of the plus buttons - the G#. All the others I can live without. I'm still thinking of a way to rig a link to the end accidental button on the 2 row only box to give me back that facility.
I would like extra bass buttons - but not really for extra chords, just for bass runs.
I like the light weight and size. If I want to play different music I'll play the piano.
-
I thought I might "learn one" on the smaller box and then once I "had it" move it over to the bigger box. But is that even possible? Huh...
I'm assuming you're talking about just 'quint' boxes?
If so, I'd say yes, many of the skills are certainly transferable, and your reasoning is good. However, some of the skills you acquire with the smaller box may need to be 'unlearnt' for the bigger box, IMO, where note reversals are involved. It seems to me that reversals on the third row are just as useful in extending the abilities of the box as are the accidentals, and therefore developing playing runs that use them as part of you playing is an important skill to learn. I don't see the two-row as a 'workhorse' as many players do, and in fact I don't play one any more. I know that few agree with me here, but I wish I had started from scratch with a big box. You sound as if you have a good grasp of music already, and I would have thought that you are likely to be in a position where you quite quickly get frustrated with the significant limitations of two-row boxes. I hope this doesn't put you off the instrument, because larger boxes, for the usual 'home' keys at least, can remove many of the limitations of the smaller ones.
-
Theo and I have discussed this previously, and his comment above resonated with me though took a while to sink in!
Being only a little chap, I have tried a 2.5 row Mory, it's a big beastie and weight also starts to play a part. The bigger boxes start to get heavy with all the extra reeds in them.
I've also told a slight fib, I do have a 2.4 row melodeon with 8 basses.
It is an old Hohner Erika in BbEb, made in the '30's.
I have had the keyboard set up to exactly mimic my DG melodeons so that my fingering is directly transferrable and won't confuse my small brain.
i.e. I press the buttons in the same order and the tune comes out in another key.
I have no idea what the half row is, I've not visited it yet. I chose the unusual key after listening to a concert where one of the younger chaps here played a BbEb and the sound was just wonderful. It's my 'playing for myself' box and being lower keys sounds less squeaky than the DG.
cheers
Q
-
I'm only a few years into my melodeon journey and my views my well change but I often think that on this forum we pay more attention to the boxes than we do to the music that we play on them ( - Ill get my coat :-X )
I'm probably not a very good musician (certainly not as good as I'd like) but for, i'm guessing. 90% of the music that i play I need only 2 keys D & G.
Often at a session I'll take 2 boxes,a D & a G both 1 rows with only 2bass spoons because i like the sound they make. If theres a tune that doesnt fit my boxes/playing ability i'll sit it out and listen. You dont have to play every tune ;)
I have a pokerwork that I play for morris. I do play that across the rows a bit. There are tunes that I only play on that because they wouldnt work on the one rows. And sometimes I'll play '1 row' tunes on the D/G along the row. Its ok but I dont get the 1 row sound that i like so much.
So for me its a compromise between the sound and the music I want to play. I like to play for our morris side :M, ideally I'd like to do it on 1 rows but the tunes they want to dance to really fit better on a 2 row. I like to play with others in sessions where i have more control over what i play so i go with my 4 stoppers because I LOVE that sound ;D
The house is burning down and you can only save one box?! It would be one of the 4stoppers, probably in G (:)
-
From the last few posts, it would seem that Melissa and I aren't the only ones to prefer a lower, even possibly a growly sound from the melodeon.
Whilst not wanting to hi-jack her thread, but the point is very pertinent to me at this precise moment; how about a D/G which is an octave lower? Could it still be played alongside those squeaky ones without causing a riot?
-
I thought I might "learn one" on the smaller box and then once I "had it" move it over to the bigger box. But is that even possible? Huh...
you are likely to be in a position where you quite quickly get frustrated with the significant limitations of two-row boxes.
I really couldn't let this statement go without saying that it is those significant limitations that make the two row box so very appealing, so intriguing, so wonderful for me and I cannot foresee the day when I would want more than two rows. I have been learning for five years and I haven't even scratched the surface of possibilities yet. If I wanted to add to what I already have at my fingertips, it would be extra basses, that's all and even then I am not too bothered.
You have two boxes Melissa and you can get an enormous amount of fine music out of them. My advice is to concentrate on the music, not the box....it is up to you to find it inside those boxes and bring it out.
Enjoy the music and love it!
-
Arty has a good point that took me a while to see, and what Theo has hinted to as well.
There are limitations to a 2 row 8 bass box, so that makes it all the more stunning listening to what some people can do within these limitations! Some people are quite breathtaking in what they get out of a very limited instrument.
Embrace the limitations and work out how to cheat ways around them as opposed to an alternative plan of getting a bigger box that gets round these limitations by sheer number of buttons.
Key choice comes down to you. I like playing and listening to the throaty roar of a BbEb for a change when in the comfort of my home. The key doesn't matter too much if playing on your own ( hence my BbEb, I like the sound ) but in the sessions I go to it is DG land, you need a DG to play along with everyone else.
Q
-
Since playing this instrument involves a lot of muscle memory, how can you all switch between instruments so easily?
The simple answer is that the core keyboard layout for most melodeons is the same. Accidentals on the end or on a half-row, for example: completely different places, but used so rarely that it doesn't make any difference most of the time. If there's just one note in a tune that's an accidental, you soon remember where it is.
Fourth button start vs 3rd button start: again, once your hand is in the right place, all the buttons are in the same relative positions.
There's another reason why it isn't much of a problem: players who have very different boxes typically play a separate repertoire of tunes on each box. A major reason for buying box B is to play tunes that were impossible on Box A.
When you get to fourth-apart versus semitone-apart systems it's another matter altogether: then you are learning to play two quite different instruments.
-
I think that the best now is to learn as possible with both boxes and then decide about the big one. Some time ago my favorite was 3 row - because more sounds and two 2 row like A/D and D/G in one box A/D/G.
Now i prefer 2 row 2 voice boxes, because less weight and more sensitivity. And it's enough for all music i play - i never have used accidentals on club boxes, and in some boxes accidentals on top of rows are replaced with next sounds of the key. So if you will find that you need lot of additional sounds that are not on your box, it will be sign that you need instrument with more sounds.
I don't know how much layouts will fit in your mind. In the beginning my idea was to keep all instruments as they are and to learn all possible layouts. But it was too much for me, or may be i am too old for my ~50. Only bandoneon has different layouts for every key (it's multi-key instrument). Concertina (the big one) is a little different layouts. Boxes peterburgska (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYuNlimxLrk) are similar to 3 row diatonic but with another bass system. Difference between two row and club system was too small in the beginning, but three different bass systems of three 2 row 12 bass accordions it was too much for me. I "clubbed" all boxes for the beginning. All 12 bass boxes will be remaded to one system because this is too much systems for me. And i have got beautiful wooden box in C/C#. I am thinking about to sell it there or to remade to may be G/C or B/E because not possible to learn perfect :(
Key of box depend on what you going to do. If you like to play together with other musicians you must look what keys are used around you. If you mostly play alone - it must be what you like more. If you are playing together with other instruments, you must ask musicians about the key.
I left some of my boxes in original key about a=435 Hz special to play alone or in folk group together with strings. C/F boxes are the highest ones to me, and D/G are too high. They (D/G) are very useful for violin too, but now i think better for me is lower G/C and A/D than A/D/G.
Very popular in Lithuania 3 row box peterburgska (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYuNlimxLrk) usualy is G/C/F or F/Bb/Eb. First one are called "very thin" by musicians. F/Bb/Eb - may be the best choice for man's singing. I own both of them but i am looking for very rare Eb/Ab/Db because wonderful low tone. It will be very difficult to play violin or other instruments together, but it will be box for the soul.
-
Since playing this instrument involves a lot of muscle memory, how can you all switch between instruments so easily?
again, once your hand is in the right place, all the buttons are in the same relative positions.
When you get to fourth-apart versus semitone-apart systems it's another matter altogether: then you are learning to play two quite different instruments.
I agree that playing a 4th aprt box in its home keys on the row is quite different to playing a semitone box - but playing a 4th apart box in non home keys requiring accidentals and normal semitone playing is not that different! eg playing in A on a DG instrument means starting on a different button than the 'normal ' start button ie 3rd or 4th from chin and finding a G# from somewhere - chin end or 3rd row and of course the push pull pattern is different from the home keys.
on eg a BC playing in G on the C row requires much the same process i.e. start on a different button aand follow a different push pull sequence and find a C# from somewhere..... but on a semitone box the required accidental is not in some odd place like chin end or row of odds and sods but is immediately to hand ( or finger) on the outside rwo. Same goes for D = C row + 2 easy nips onto the B row for C# and F#. A same but with an extra departure for the handily placed G#
other than playing just the home keys on a DG, Cf or whatever the two systems are much closer than seems to be commonly thought.
george
-
it is those significant limitations that make the two row box so very appealing, so intriguing,
Arty, your comment is one that many on this forum would agree with, I think. I'm sorry, but I have simply never understood its logic - how can it be possibly be true that a limitation, per se, can ever be a benefit?
-
it is those significant limitations that make the two row box so very appealing, so intriguing,
Arty, your comment is one that many on this forum would agree with, I think. I'm sorry, but I have simply never understood its logic - how can it be possibly be true that a limitation, per se, can ever be a benefit?
I'd like to answer this, if I may.
The layout of two-row, 4th-apart tuned instruments does two things at once: (a) it makes them relatively easy to learn, especially relatively simple diatonic tunes, and (b) imposes certain limitations when it comes to playing outside the main 'comfortable' home keys (major and minor). On a one-row instrument the limitations of (b) are even more marked.
(a) and (b) together give the melodeon the highly satisfying 'band-in-a-box' character when played in its comfy keys, all set in an instrument which is relatively light and very compact in size. I think this is unrivalled by any other similar instrument with the arguable exception of the anglo concertina (and possibly duet system concertinas).
The 'limitations' of the instrument mean that the player is channelled along certain styles of playing, particularly 'traditional' dance music, to which it can bring an extraordinary rhythmic drive. It is much harder to achieve such character in a fully chromatic, 'same note in both directions' instrument such as a piano accordion or CBA. Yes, it can be done, but the melodeon is just so outstandingly good at it.
For me, those are the benefits of the melodeon.
But if you want to play fully chromatic music on a free-reed instrument, then the piano accordion or CBA are probably the best choices. But the trade-off is weight, complexity and cost, and the greater difficulty in achieving rhythmic drive.
-
Oh Lord, won't you buy me a Streb mel-o-de-on?
My friends all have multi-boxes, I must make amends.
(apologies to Janis)
-
Steve, I agree with pretty much everything you say, but surely the advantages of the instrument, that you describe so well and with which I entirely agree, are not related to the question of whether to have a third row, which is not immediately going to impact on the lightness and dynamics of the instrument. But Arty, like many I suspect, seems to be going further - the concept seems to me to be that a limitation, per se, can be a benefit. That's the bit I have never understood.
-
The benefit is that the simplicity which make the melodeon very bad at playing chromatic music make it very good at playing diatonic music. As additional rows and basses are added to make it better for chromatic music this starts to interfere with its ability to play diatonic music.
All instruments are limited in their different ways. This only matters if you try to use them in ways for which they are not suited.
-
Wow! Seems I've hit a nerve/interesting topic!
I won't respond to everything, but I've read it all. So yesterday, I took advice (never say I don't do that!) and noodled around, choosing Twinkle Little Star. Not looking at a video of how I should play it, etc, but just sat down with the box and first plunked out in C the right hand melody. That was super easy as it's just the few notes right in the same line. It's one of the first songs you learn on almost all instruments. I remember it from my very brief stint at piano when I was 6 (and my child's later on). I remember it for the horn... and my son on the trumpet (later tuba), etc.
I picked some chords that seemed to sound Ok, trying to move around the left hand a little. I was still lousy at it, but then tried to do some embellishing. All notes still available on the same row of the box.But to limit the back/forth of the bellows (is that note reversal?), I tried to use the other row to keep the bellows moving in the same direction for longer - making it easier and faster to play those notes and not be super choppy. I want to learn to play cross rows as it adds more versatility and I notice the play I like better are people who have mastered bellow action by doing cross row, so I should practice it.
I like all the music if done well, French probably the best, but the #1 thing that seems to stick out with me is I'm awed and find the most appealing are all the people who have mastered the ability to make the sound smooth and not choppy... unless the tune specifically needs to be choppy (that's a different style of play).
It's not about the melodeon being limited. I know that. It's not about making the instrument into something it's not. It's about the boxes that just have more options - even with turning voices off and on and from what I can see with my limited knowledge so far, is that more of those bells and whistles are on bigger boxes.
And it's knowing my own limitations. I am 47 years old. My capacity for learning new is not what it was at 10 or 20. (though I'm not feeling terribly slow in life at acquiring new either.) So, if say, my dream box is a larger Castagnari or a Saltarelle or some other brand in GC, then I don't want to have to do a lot of relearning if/when I ever switch to a bigger box. I'm glad I'm playing the smaller boxes now as I feel in my muscle in my upper forearm, around my elbow, and the side of my palm some muscle fatigue as I build stamina. The lighter weight and simplicity of the smaller box make it easier to grasp what to do and allows me to practice for longer. All good... but the "worrier" in me wonders, "how much will it suck if I have to relearn the tunes I acquire if/when I switch boxes?"
I'm glad to hear that the changes are less than it seems... as right now, the keyboard layout stuff is only just beginning to make sense to me! I compared side by side three boxes keyboard layout yesterday for a GC instrument just to try to understand more. I used mine, an older, pre-pokerwork Hohner, A Castagnari Handry... and some other I cannot recall with 2.5 rows and 12 bases of some other brand/make. I circled the "have in common" keys, and yes, they do seem to be in a row/similar configuration, but not as much so in the basses (sort of the same, sort of not) and, of course, accidentals placed differently.
I have absolutely no idea how often and when accidentals will be used as I'm just learning, but that would be like changing the keyboard on my laptop... which sometimes happens as my husband is from Croatia and he sometimes turns on the Croat keyboard. He seems to be able to switch back and forth easily enough, but probably because he "knows" that keyboard too from his youth... where for me, I'm like how do you make the Å¡,Ä‘,ž,Ä.ć letters again? ;D And where did the brackets, colons and semicolons go now that they are letters? Yes, I can learn them, but it's an added layer to learning while I already feel I have a lot of learning to do.
So, I thought I would ask... especially when I snoop around here about talk about different layouts and read about how some people just couldn't get on with the new layout and give up on that box and try something new/different. Even the whole discussion (here and other places) on the CBA B system and C system and how people find one harder or one easier (Yes, I looked into those too before deciding to settle on a melodeon).
I think, for me too, noodling around will have limitations with just pulling things from my head because I didn't grow up with hearing and knowing songs that are common to the melodeon. I grew up in the middle of the USA, mostly 2nd-3rd generation German ancestry mixed in with everything else (and my family background is mostly German) and all that folk music is gone. The music I know are radio tunes - as folksy as it gets are those that were on the radio in my parents/grandparents youth and nursery rhymes. It will probably be easier for me to ingest and learn melodeon tunes and then play around with them after learning them because those are more likely to be accidental free. I think? Still don't know.
-
As additional rows and basses are added to make it better for chromatic music this starts to interfere with its ability to play diatonic music.
Correct. I had a Hohner Gaelic IV B/C/C# once, and playing it in C was really hard!
-
C is easier using 3 rows rather than tugging and shoving on the row
george
-
the concept seems to me to be that a limitation, per se, can be a benefit. That's the bit I have never understood.
What you do to make the music interesting while staying within the limitations is what makes for a specific idiom or style. It's what makes modal music of any genre what it is: you are only using a small selection of the notes available to you, which means you have to really understand their combinatorial possibilities. An extreme example is the music of the Highland pipes, where you start out with only nine notes to work with and then build enormous pieces in scales that leave some of them out. China has spent 4000 years doing that.
Violinists and keyboard players often use range and chromaticism as substitutes for creativity.
-
What you do to make the music interesting while staying within the limitations is what makes for a specific idiom or style
Yes, but, other things being equal, you can do exactly the same thing without those limitations. If you want. It's a choice, not a blockage. OK, many people then choose to go outside the boundaries, because they realise the added opportunities. It's wrong to criticise anyone for doing so, isn't it?
-
Melissa, I hope you will post some recordings on here in due course, because it seems to me you are completely on the right track. You clearly have the ability to recognise the (unique) dynamic possibilities of our instrument. It is my experience over 40 years of playing the box that it's quite possible to preserve the things that (you, clearly) like, and also overcome the limitations of the more simple instruments, and I reckon this search has maybe been a key feature of this forum. The button accordion has huge possibilities in terms of variable note dynamics and accompaniment, which few other instruments can get close to. We can all learn from your clear intention to get down to brass tacks.
-
Melissa: 47 is NOT old when learning a melodeon (at least). A lot of people seem to have started at 60 or more, myself included, and most are perfectly competent players (or in my case, happily incompetent due to lack of practice time available). Learn and enjoy is the motto, especially enjoy! :|||:
And go with what Chris Brimley says ...
-
Melissa, I hope you will post some recordings on here in due course, because it seems to me you are completely on the right track. You clearly have the ability to recognise the (unique) dynamic possibilities of our instrument. It is my experience over 40 years of playing the box that it's quite possible to preserve the things that (you, clearly) like, and also overcome the limitations of the more simple instruments, and I reckon this search has maybe been a key feature of this forum. The button accordion has huge possibilities in terms of variable note dynamics and accompaniment, which few other instruments can get close to. We can all learn from your clear intention to get down to brass tacks.
Oh thank you... I am recording my feeble attempts, today is day 4 on my blog. I'm showing warts and all because learning is a LONG, SLOW process. You can find it by clicking on the globe under my avatar (that's where everyone's blog can be found if they have one).
Today I am working on adding embellishments to Twinkle Twinkle (oh so exciting), but I'm going to help myself by writing it down too as my brain seems to find the "holding the music in my head" quite difficult... Well, I can hold the music in my head, just not in my fingers! :P
I am not working today, taking a comp day after working 50 plus hours last week. :o
-
Melissa: 47 is NOT old when learning a melodeon (at least). A lot of people seem to have started at 60 or more, myself included, and most are perfectly competent players (or in my case, happily incompetent due to lack of practice time available). Learn and enjoy is the motto, especially enjoy! :|||:
And go with what Chris Brimley says ...
Well, if I felt I was too old to learn new tricks, I wouldn't start. I'm just saying I don't pick things up like I used to. I have an 11 year old and 20 year old. I see what "quick" looks like. And it takes away the number of years I can work on it to get better.
ETA: I'm also living with my mother in law (81) and her deteriorating brains also influences me. She was a neurologist and psychiatrist - and was very respected in her profession. I have known her since before she was 60 and her brain was already diminishing - not for her expertise, but for anything else "new"... like how to use new cameras, computers, new to her kitchen appliances, etc. At 81, she wants to help, but can't remember how to start the dishwasher despite her living with us for 7 years and being taught no less than a dozen times. So, yes, that looms in my head a bit as basically I see what happens to some people as they age.
-
nope it isn't old.... a mere spring chicken ;D
....and yes, Chris is right, you're well on track!
Q
-
Melissa, just spotted your blog. Do you mind if I suggest something?
Holding the melodeon - at the moment you are not worrying about this because you aren't yet trying to cope with fast dynamics and button changes, but it's probably a good idea to develop a good posture early. A lot of box players recognise that the floor end of the box naturally wobbles when you change bellows direction, and so we try to restrain it. Others have different techniques, but I wedge it against my right thigh, with the upper end then naturally falling to my left, which helps me a lot.
-
Melissa, just spotted your blog. Do you mind if I suggest something?
Holding the melodeon - at the moment you are not worrying about this because you aren't yet trying to cope with fast dynamics and button changes, but it's probably a good idea to develop a good posture early. A lot of box players recognise that the floor end of the box naturally wobbles when you change bellows direction, and so we try to restrain it. Others have different techniques, but I wedge it against my right thigh, with the upper end then naturally falling to my left, which helps me a lot.
Don't mind help/advice at all. Just so it's done nicely and not meanly! (:)
-
I too have had a quick look - you're going great for a few days!
....and clearly enjoying it that's the best bit!
I also see you've linked Jimbo with his 3 tunes on a melodeon, I'm only just getting the first two now!!
My other real inspiration was here....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7RyY7WDmkog
Derek and Jimbo ripping up a couple of good tunes with such verve and full on enjoyment, just imspirational.
I'm listening to it as I type, still love it!
Keep at it and keep laughing!
Q
-
What you do to make the music interesting while staying within the limitations is what makes for a specific idiom or style
Yes, but, other things being equal, you can do exactly the same thing without those limitations.
I can think of several well known and distinctive one-row melodeon styles that simply would not sound right played on a instrument "without those limitations".
You could play the notes on a fully chromatic three-row, but it wouldn't sound Cajun or Quebecois, for example. And those differences, to me, are very much what makes those kinds of music interesting.
-
I think Melissa is just comparing 2-row and 2+ row layouts, isn't she?
-
I think Melissa is just comparing 2-row and 2+ row layouts, isn't she?
Maybe? Who knows! It's only day 3,
-
OK, well I agree with Anahata's point that one-rows can make very different sounds. The very light LH, small bellows, and multi-voice reeds typically give the opportunity for a driving, dynamic and full sound to be created.
The problem with one-rows is that having only two LH chords and usually only the diatonic RH notes available does make the melody and accompaniment possibilities quite limited.
-
I thought I might "learn one" on the smaller box and then once I "had it" move it over to the bigger box. But is that even possible? Huh...
you are likely to be in a position where you quite quickly get frustrated with the significant limitations of two-row boxes.
I really couldn't let this statement go without saying that it is those significant limitations that make the two row box so very appealing, so intriguing, so wonderful for me and I cannot foresee the day when I would want more than two rows. I have been learning for five years and I haven't even scratched the surface of possibilities yet. If I wanted to add to what I already have at my fingertips, it would be extra basses, that's all and even then I am not too bothered.
You have two boxes Melissa and you can get an enormous amount of fine music out of them. My advice is to concentrate on the music, not the box....it is up to you to find it inside those boxes and bring it out.
Enjoy the music and love it!
When I used the words "significant limitations", I was actually quoting you Chris. I don't have much experience with the melodeon as I have only been teaching myself for the last four and a half years. Personally, I don't see any limitations at all, I only see opportunities and that is why I am just as excited by the instrument as I was on day one.
I remember reading something written by Gianni Ventola Danese, (Diatonic Accordion Academy), where he said that the two row, eight bass was the only true diatonic. Now, I can't argue with that because I don't have the knowledge but I do hear the difference when a 2 row is played compared to a 3 row. Quite a lot of the 'punch', the natural rhythm of reversing the bellows is lost by the opportunities the 3 rows offer. In fact, I would go as far as to suggest that a 3 row box seems to me to be a kind of half way house....I mean, why not go for a 4 row, as played by Marc Perrone? Wouldn't that offer even less limitations? Then, of course, why not go the whole way and have a CBA?
Personally, in my blissful state of ignorance (!), I actually think of them as almost different instruments that offer different things and one would choose according to the kind of music that one wants to play.
The 2 row box that I play, is perfectly suited to the type of music that I love to play and therefore, I do not feel limited by it at all. I don't know what box you play Chris but I would guess that you have done the same as me and chosen the box that best suits the kind of music that you want to play, in the way that you want to play it. Which, of course, means that neither of us feel limited by our instruments. And that is how it should be, isn't it? It doesn't mean that one is better than the other, it doesn't mean that one is inadequate.
The hard thing for a complete beginner to know, like Melissa, is 'what type of music do you want to play'? But she will know, in a year or two's time, and she will or won't change her instrument accordingly.
She may throw both her melodeons in the bin and buy herself a 120 bass piano accordion....and none of us will ever speak to her again !!! >:E
-
Really, I was just trying to offer objective advice to Melissa - I noticed she had already picked up the point about enhanced dynamic control of the bigger boxes, and I'm convinced that effect results from having more opportunities for selecting combinations of melody, accompaniment and bellows direction. It's more about explaining what is possible with different designs than attempting to give advice on which to select. But I just started with the 'limitation = benefit' concept, which I'm afraid I'll probably never get my head round.
-
ah Chris has replied whilst I type:
there's been a lot of threads about smaller boxes giving more punch, apparently a smaller surface area for a given force means the reeds get a greater air pressure through the bellows. I feel it when changing from my full sized Hascy to the smaller Tommy. The Tommy feels more dynamic and lively and I feel I can master it because of it's smaller size.
I think arty has touched on something else and that is your choice of music you want to play can easily change as you bounce happily down the road of learning. Therefore whatever we say about musical choice and direction now could be totally different for melodeon youngsters such as Melissa, arty and myself who haven't had a long time to sort through all the possibilities and settle on a musical path. Who knows where we'll end up, just hope we all enjoy the journey
Q
-
I agree with your comments, TB.
-
ah good, thanks Chris. An accord.
I feel I've possibly taken far too much of Melissa's time tonight, so I wish you all a good evening. Having badly twanged my wrist over the weekend I'm off to sit in front the fire rather than play, I don't want to do further tendon damage!
Night all
Q
-
A bonus of a semitone system such as B/C or C#/D is that you can make believe that what you have is the other. For example, if you have a C#/D you can explore how the other half (of the Irish-music world) lives by learning to play tunes in E major, F# minor, B major and so on by using "B/C fingering" for D, Em, and A...
With a quint box such as a D/G I suppose you wouldn't get quite the same new horizons by pretending it's a G/C. (:)
Not much use me trying to imagine my box as a D/G either. I could pretend it's a one-row but can't think of a good reason to do so!
-
The problem with one-rows is that having only two LH chords and usually only the diatonic RH notes available does make the melody and accompaniment possibilities quite limited.
Maybe so, but to bring the argument full-circle, I personally rejoice in those 'limitations' and use my one-row four-stop instruments to play the sort of music they are really good for and which I love - stonking English (and especially East Anglian) dance music - polkas, jigs, hornpipes, schottisches, waltzes (don't ever forget the waltzes!). If I want to play dreamy French minor key mazurkas, I'll pick up my 2.5 row.
I'm sure you know all this really, Chris! ;)
-
Yep!
:)
-
I just started with the 'limitation = benefit' concept, which I'm afraid I'll probably never get my head round.
Perhaps this should be phrased the other way around. Those aspects (or benefits) of the one or two row melodeon which make them particularly good for playing diatonic music bring with them certain limitations, including lack of chromaticism and fewer chord choices. However if you only want to play diatonic music (which encompasses most folk music from the British Isles) then these limitations aren't really a problem for you, and they are even an essential characteristic of some traditional styles. Larger boxes may overcome these limitations, but there are trade-offs and they have limitations of their own.
Even Andy Cutting, one of the best-known exponents of the 'big box', also plays a one-row.
-
thanks Howard, totally agree.
Q
-
A bonus of a semitone system such as B/C or C#/D is that you can make believe that what you have is the other. For example, if you have a C#/D you can explore how the other half (of the Irish-music world) lives by learning to play tunes in E major, F# minor, B major and so on by using "B/C fingering" for D, Em, and A...
Yep, same here, but when in B/C mode on my C#/D, the novelty of a nice finger friendly horn pipe in G (A in reality,) wears off after a while and reinforces my decision to chase the C#/D system!
But...it is useful to be able to lift the G tunes second time around. :||:
-
So do I, TB and HJ - I won't repeat my original point.
I wonder if it might be more helpful to Melissa if we all turn to discussing the relative pros and cons of 2 and 2+ row quints, because I'm conscious that we haven't really been a lot of help, and I think she posed some very sensible questions.
If I were starting to learn the instrument today, but knew a bit about music already from a chromatic melody instrument, I wish I'd been advised (from what I know now) that if I wanted to play a range of different sorts of music, I should start with a 2+ row box, with more than 8 basses. If I then chose to play a more limited instrument for particular styles, I would already have developed skills which made that relatively easy. I knew when I started that I wanted to play the set of a local social dance band (most of which tunes were in the home keys), but quickly realised it just wasn't possible on a pokerwork, for several reasons. OK, that was just my interest, and others have other interests, but for me at that time, there just weren't any less limited instruments around. The situation today is very different, there are lots of instrument opportunities for those that can afford them.
-
Fair point Chris. However Melissa has already made her choice and already has an instrument (or is it two?). Her original question was about different keyboard layouts, which I think has been answered. She already knows and appears to accept that the instrument is limited in what it can do.
I think her best move is now to learn to play what she's got. Once she's got to grips with that she'll be able to decide for herself whether it meets her musical needs, and if it doesn't she'll have a better understanding of what will, whether that's a different melodeon with more choices or a fully chromatic accordion.
-
A bonus of a semitone system such as B/C or C#/D is that you can make believe that what you have is the other. For example, if you have a C#/D you can explore how the other half (of the Irish-music world) lives by learning to play tunes in E major, F# minor, B major and so on by using "B/C fingering" for D, Em, and A...
Yep, same here, but when in B/C mode on my C#/D, the novelty of a nice finger friendly horn pipe in G (A in reality,) wears off after a while and reinforces my decision to chase the C#/D system!
But...it is useful to be able to lift the G tunes second time around. :||:
Actually I find that many tunes in G, especially ones that go right down to low G (including several hornpipes such as Cooley's and Brendan McGlinchey's), lie much better under the fingers on B/C.
-
So do I, TB and HJ - I won't repeat my original point.
I wonder if it might be more helpful to Melissa if we all turn to discussing the relative pros and cons of 2 and 2+ row quints, because I'm conscious that we haven't really been a lot of help, and I think she posed some very sensible questions.
If I were starting to learn the instrument today, but knew a bit about music already from a chromatic melody instrument, I wish I'd been advised (from what I know now) that if I wanted to play a range of different sorts of music, I should start with a 2+ row box, with more than 8 basses. If I then chose to play a more limited instrument for particular styles, I would already have developed skills which made that relatively easy. I knew when I started that I wanted to play the set of a local social dance band (most of which tunes were in the home keys), but quickly realised it just wasn't possible on a pokerwork, for several reasons. OK, that was just my interest, and others have other interests, but for me at that time, there just weren't any less limited instruments around. The situation today is very different, there are lots of instrument opportunities for those that can afford them.
Actually, this is great, thank you! When I came, without the assistance with this board, I just knew the sound of the instrument I liked- what tones, etc. Then, through this site, I realized I like mostly French/continental music (but not exclusively!). So, I was advised to go with a GC, I did. I picked up a CF too because it's a common pairing too.
Now that I keep listening and paying attention and learning more, I'm realizing I probably only need a GC and maybe a BbEb? (is that right?).
It was also recommended to me to start with a smaller box because it's lighter, less to "confuse me" and is good for learning. So, an older GC Melodeon is what I got. It works well too because I also got Used) a French Diatonic method Book - Milleret and Pignol and it's exactly as the book is, so again, it's all helpful.
BUT... I think what it means (for me) is that once I have a hang of it after a bit - 1 year? 2 years? (never?) I'll probably want a 2.5 row to expand to cover more music with more accidentals/helpers.
Maybe I should have started with that (but liliput is that, yes? But wrong keys for French). Still so much to learn!
-
Can you be more specific, Melissa, when you say you like French/Continental music? That's still a very wide field, and it perhaps means different things to different musicians. These are perhaps the next questions I'd ask:
Do you mainly like traditional and/or folk music? Or jazz maybe?
Do you want to play LH accompaniment, or just melody?
Do you want to accompany singers, who may demand particular keys?
When talking about French folk music, are you interested in say Breton traditional melodies, or the much more complex music from the contemporary scene?
How wide are your interests, in terms of 'the continent'? - Scandinavian, East European, Spanish, etc?
It's just that there's a huge number of different music genres around, and they tend to have their own preferred styles, which probably have a big influence on the best instrument to use. Personally I'd suggest that two or three two-row 8-bass boxes in appropriate keys might suit many of the more traditional genres, but they would struggle with more complex contemporary music.
-
Better yet, you can just post some videos that you have been enjoying.
What helped me in deciding was looking at the musicians I wanted to play like (Andy Cutting and other 2.5 and 3 row players) and the keys I wanted to play in (D, G, A, C, F, E). Once I knew that I started looking at the specific boxes that those folk played (usually by asking the knowledgeable folks here).
For example, if you said "I want to play and sound like Stephane Delicq and play in the keys he played in" people would tell you to get a G/C two row, because that's what he played (also, check him out if you haven't already, I think you'll like him).
You've already given your personal musical preferences and tastes in another thread, but I've found that on melnet thing can get sidetracked very easily, so being as specific and redundant as you need to be will get you the answers you are looking for. Give lots of examples of what you like to hear, and don't get too bogged down in the technical side of things unless that stuff really interests you.
A lot of people play two rows happily for a lifetime, others get more complex boxes. I'd say play your G/C until you start to realize what it's limitations are and specifically know what you wish it could do that it can't. Entering into the world of 2.5 and 3 row boxes gets a lot more technical and you can spend insane amounts of time trying to figure out how to organize the notes on your half or third row, not to mention getting more basses and needing to decided what they should be.
Most of all, have fun!
Baron
-
It's late in the conversation, but I'll join in. But instead of "Why would I change systems?" I'll go with "Why DID I?"
That's somewhat misleading because I don't feel like I've changed system so much as chosen different accoutrements for each box, and in each case I had a reason. I never feel as if I've had to unlearn something.
1) 2.5 row Saltarelle G/C/#, aside from being a gift (that sort of settles the decision) was THE key for the music of my dreams. French Bal Folk. When I visited Alsace, I was in a dance with ten other accordion players, and they were all GC. Still, at its heart, this is a 2 row 8 base quint box with extras.
2) 3 row Dino Bafetti F/Bb/Eb, I got this one when I was playing with a singer and her key was "Eb" -- so I looked for an Eb box and someone here said, "Hey, why don't you just get that three row at the Button Box?" And I did. I would say that this three row has changed my playing more than any other. It hasn't moved me away from the heart of 2 row 8 bass, but it has made me MUCH more aware of cross rowing possibilities, and really helped me get concrete in my mind those instances when I want to cross row or go up and down the row. Taking on this challenge has hugely improved my playing all around. I don't play with that singer anymore, but I've never regretted betting this box.
3) 2 row A/D Erica, I wanted a box that played in D; I wanted access to the classic Erica sound (a la Jean Blanchard's classic Accordeon Diatonique record), and I really did want a straight 2 row 8 bass box. Then it Helena offered this Erica up for sale and Lester vouched for its soundness. This has met all of my needs and is usually the first choice when I want to comb through a book looking for tunes.
4) 1 row (+2), Ab, I've been wanting to try a one row for a long time, and I've been wanting one of these organettos for a while. Their sound is very very charming. It being in Ab is a curiosity. My bandmates are a clarinetist and string player who do all the keys. And if I'm just playing by myself, it doesn't matter.Aside from the problems mentioned in another thread, I have absolutely loved playing this piece. One thing, it is a bourree MACHINE. Bourrees sound SO GOOD on it.
So that's me. In each case I had some tangible reasons to justify my choice, but also in each case the decision was made because the box showed up in my sphere of availability. I am a believer in propinquity.
-
BUT... I think what it means (for me) is that once I have a hang of it after a bit - 1 year? 2 years? (never?) I'll probably want a 2.5 row to expand to cover more music with more accidentals/helpers.
I wouldn't worry about it at all right now. I think you will be surprised at how many tunes can be played on a 2 row 8 bass. It is quite possible to go for years using a basic 2 row melodeon. At some point you may want to explore the possibilities offered by more complex boxes, but at that point you will understand much more about the diatonic accordion & will know what to go for.
-
Airtime's right. For the moment just enjoy the learning thing. Don't worry about the future, just get on with your learning. Whatever happens in the future your learning will be money in the bank, give you a good understanding of the basics and the options that unfold from it.
Cheers
Q
-
Airtime's right. For the moment just enjoy the learning thing. Don't worry about the future, just get on with your learning. Whatever happens in the future your learning will be money in the bank, give you a good understanding of the basics and the options that unfold from it.
Cheers
Q
You are right. I just did a personality testing thing the other day for work.. I learned that I am a "think ahead-er" I plan 27 steps ahead when most people plan like, 5.. I think of all the pit-falls, the what ifs to avoid mistakes, regrets, disasters, etc. My "type" are excellent problem solvers, but... what it also means is that we are anxious about unknowns too. And that goes with learning this... "did I choose the right thing?" "Am I going to regret it?" "Should I jump on a sale of what I might think I want 6 months down the road?" "A year down the road?", etc.
-
"Should I jump on a sale of what I might think I want 6 months down the road?" "A year down the road?", etc.
My opinion for this dilemma is: NO. You never know what you're going to like in the future.
-
"Should I jump on a sale of what I might think I want 6 months down the road?" "A year down the road?", etc.
My opinion for this dilemma is: NO. You never know what you're going to like in the future.
Morethan that... I don't even know if I'll continue to like this at ALL!!!
And now when it's 7:15 and have more than a 5-10 minute break ALL day, I'm about to do some homeschooling with my son and THEN I can practice a bit. Most days it can only fit in around 8 or 9 pm.
-
I have another question about different layouts... I was thinking on this while following another discussion.
Let's say an instrument comes up for a great price and a person is tempted to buy it. (not me - not now... this truly is conjecture) But they've been playing on a standard layout and this temptation is a different layout. Couldn't you pay someone to change the layout for you? (Or do it yourself if you know how?) I was just reading someone say on a thread, "Loved it, but didn't love the layout". Would that ever be a reason to not get one if that is fixable? Or is it not?
I never would have thought it was something you could change easily until I saw all these threads floating around about changing this and that. It opens the door to more possibilities then too, doesn't it?
-
I have another question about different layouts... I was thinking on this while following another discussion.
Let's say an instrument comes up for a great price and a person is tempted to buy it. (not me - not now... this truly is conjecture) But they've been playing on a standard layout and this temptation is a different layout. Couldn't you pay someone to change the layout for you? (Or do it yourself if you know how?) I was just reading someone say on a thread, "Loved it, but didn't love the layout". Would that ever be a reason to not get one if that is fixable? Or is it not?
I never would have thought it was something you could change easily until I saw all these threads floating around about changing this and that. It opens the door to more possibilities then too, doesn't it?
The safe answer is, it depends. A Dutch reversal for instance is a relatively simple thing to have added or removed. A Club layout is a little harder but still commonly done. People don't tend to change an irish system box to fourth apart though. It generally depends on how the reeds can be rearranged. The main thing is to remember to factor the alteration into the 'great price', or it may not be such a bargain after all.
-
Think of it like buying a car. Doing a complete change e.g. CF to DG or CC# to DG is the equivalent of putting a new engine in a car. It can be done but its expensive. If something comes up at a great price that is not your usual system then it's much better to see it as an opportunity to learn a new system.
-
If something comes up at a great price that is not your usual system then it's much better to see it as an opportunity to learn a new system.
And the thing is, learning new systems is FUN. If you're playing melodeon, you've already given up on utility as a goal.
-
"If you're playing melodeon, you've already given up on utility as a goal."
Or normality, and MAD looms!
-
"great price" = "free lunch" i.e. no such thing. You WILL pay.
-
But does it feel like starting over? Or is it you curse at pressing the wrong button for awhile and then just used it, and then you go to an older box you have and curse again at having to switch back and forth?
I do have a bit experience with that with switching from marching horn and double horn, and even from single horn to double horn (as I owned a single horn for awhile)... and that was my experience... all the other skills were there, just the fingering had to be adjusted to which (as a teen/early 20s) was easy enough within a few hours.
but some of it I don't quite understand... like I don't want get how/why layouts are so different. Is there any other instrument like that?
-
There are some differences between orchestral instruments - on flute you can have an open G# or a closed one, (in other words on some systems it will play G# by default if you don't hold down the key), German clarinets are quite different, Viennese oboes are too. Other oboes have different octave key configurations.
And of course there are open tunings on guitars etc. which might be a closer parallel. DADGAD is a common tuning.
-
It's a great question Melissa.... If only I knew the answer!
The different keys available reflect where the melodeon originated.
Our DGs were brought into England after a collecting trip by a tune collector in the north of the country in the mid 1950's. He found most tunes were in D or G so brought in the first batch of DGs.
As I understand it, the BbEb's and CF's are used in Germany reflecting their brass bands, and GC in France because I think the tunes tend to be in that key.
The variations beyond that possibly might be because there is great variation in design.
There's a 1 row, and more commonly the standard 2 row 8 bass.
The half row or helper row can be anything from 2 to 5 or more buttons, and eventually increasing up to a full 3rd row. Each maker has their own tweak on the makeup of the notes of the row from just accidentals to accidentals and reversals to a full row in another key.
The basses can be 8, 12, 14, 18 and even 9 !
With such a huge variation in builds the makeup of the keyboard and basses reflect this variation.
Well, that's my tuppence.....
Q
-
There are some differences between orchestral instruments - on flute you can have an open G# or a closed one, (in other words on some systems it will play G# by default if you don't hold down the key), German clarinets are quite different, Viennese oboes are too. Other oboes have different octave key configurations.
And of course there are open tunings on guitars etc. which might be a closer parallel. DADGAD is a common tuning.
You learn something new every day!
-
...but some of it I don't quite understand... like I don't want get how/why layouts are so different. Is there any other instrument like that?
Carrying the other instruments analogy a bit further:
The fourth-apart tuned instruments, D/G, C/F, A/D, etc., are a bit like members of the saxophone family in that you can use the same fingering on each to play the instrument, whether it be soprano, alto, tenor, baritone, etc. All that happens is that the sound comes out in different pitches for the equivalent same fingerings.
But the semitone-tuned instruments are a bit different: similar, but different in that playing across the rows doesn't work in the same way as on a fourth-apart box, and vice versa. An analogy might be comparing the difference between a mandolin (four pairs of strings tuned a fifth apart) and a guitar (six strings tuned a fourth apart except for between the 4th G string and the 5th B string, which are a third apart). So although they are both fretted string instruments, the fingering techniques and shapes needed are totally different.
-
the simplest analogy for the semitone boxes are that ,eg, on a BC the C row is akin to the white notes on a piano and the B row to the black notes - a sort of push/pull piano.
However the same 'transferability' applies to semitone boxes as it does to 4th apart boxes in that eg tunes played on a BC will come out in different keys on a CC# or C#D with exactly the same fingering.
But to complicate matters all 12 keys are possible on any semitone box but some with considerable difficulty- hence the combination of BC and CC# to provide the BCC# box which gets round those difficulties and provides 12 keys without any real problems.
george
-
...but on a semitone box the required accidental is not in some odd place like chin end or row of odds and sods but is immediately to hand ( or finger) on the outside rwo. Same goes for D = C row + 2 easy nips onto the B row for C# and F#. A same but with an extra departure for the handily placed G#
george
What a good argument for playing semitone-apart boxes - whereas the argument for DG seems to be that if you learnt them not realising the advantages of semitone-apart systems, because they were supplied to the English folk revival by someone who didn't know much about box playing and didn't bother to find out where trial and error had led Irish players over the years, and because everyone else seemed to play/supply them - then it's simpler to carry on in spite of their obvious limitations...
Probably best to duck and run for cover now?
-
the reason I play both systems is that I started on a BC because DG's were more or less unheard of. ( I think John Kirkpatrick started the same way) I then added the C# row by buying a trichord and it was not until many years later when I started to attend folk festivals and sessions that realising that every other bugger was playing DG and more importantly virtually every tune was in D or G that I bought a SG pokerwork to sort of 'fit in' with everybody else and also because by then I didn't have a BC. only a 96 bass BCC# which was too cumbersome to cart about for sessions /festivals and its case took up an extra chair with ensuing dirty looks!
I still use a dg for sessions/festivals but very much enjoy the versatility of the big 3 row and have recently purchased a 'doer upper' BC with the all important 12 stradella bass which is where I started and which will make a good box for when I am old and knackered!
george
-
Yes, a BC or Csharp/D with the mini-stradella bass seems a pretty good solution for English players who like lot of bass. I also suspect that if you want to play in the full range of major and minor scales and modes that feature in Irish music you would be unable to do so on a DG, though some of you may be able to contradict me on this possibly? (The tunes that lend themselves to DG are not always the most interesting tunes, I think). I'm not too sure myself, coming from the Irish tradition, whether bass is that important. Would you want a bass rhythm on a fiddle? or on a tin whistle? I don't think so. Until recently we've had to buy whatever the Italians or the Germans wanted to make for us..
I started on BC because I bought a Double Ray for a fiver in a Dublin pawn shop in 1966. A stroke of luck looking back on it
-
Richard - I reason I came over from English concertina was because I wanted an accompaniment available from the bass end of a DG. The tunes I play would just be thin without.
The other reason is simply most of the English tunes I play are in D or G. If I had a more chromatic system such as you describe, or even a 2.5 row/12 bass then a lot of it would not be used so all I've done is given myself a weight penalty over a straight 2 row 8 bass DG.
Horses for courses and all that!
Q
-
Thrupenny Bit - How does a BC with 21/23 buttons and 8 basses have more weight than a DG with similar buttons.? And why would the notes not be used? You would be able to play in all sorts of modes and keys and play really interesting tunes with no extra weight. no extra buttons. I use all the buttons on my box, pretty much, I think. Many of the tunes I play are in D or G too, but my accidentals are all in sequence like black notes on a piano, not at one end or on an accidentals row.
-
Richard - no, they must be similar weight.
I was thinking of your reference to a stradella, which I'd have thought weighed more. For English music we don't need to be capable of playing in lots of keys so anything giving more options isn't really necessary unless your music takes you elsewhere. I was trying to say was that to play in many more keys needs more than a 2 row 8 bass and if you don't need more keys then that adds more weight for no given advantage.
Q
-
the 12 stradella bass on a double ray makes absolutely no noticeable difference to its weight compared with the 8 melodeon bass setup.
I have thought about fitting a 12 stradella double ray bass end to a DG Erica as it would be a straight fit. Just haven't come across a cheap unwanted bass end!
the 12 stradella would work well ( could be thirdless) on a DG giving bass note and major chord FCGDAE same in both bellwos direction so no need to cross row just to get slightly better bass. The stradella fingering is also same in every key just start in the right place . so for example in key of G you use CGD bass which in diagonal rows are
in that order. for D its GDA again in the same pecking order of diagonal rows. same for key A = dae bass.
Larger stradella works just the same but with more vertical rows of between 3 and 6 the latter being counter bss, bass, major, minor , 7th and dim chords all in the diagonal row of the bass note and stacked in diagonal rows to provide same fingering/
george
-
ah well George, fair enough, I bow to your knowledge here.
Q
-
Yes, a BC or Csharp/D with the mini-stradella bass seems a pretty good solution for English players who like lot of bass. I also suspect that if you want to play in the full range of major and minor scales and modes that feature in Irish music you would be unable to do so on a DG, though some of you may be able to contradict me on this possibly? (The tunes that lend themselves to DG are not always the most interesting tunes, I think). I'm not too sure myself, coming from the Irish tradition, whether bass is that important. Would you want a bass rhythm on a fiddle? or on a tin whistle? I don't think so. Until recently we've had to buy whatever the Italians or the Germans wanted to make for us..
What I love about the fourth-apart tuned instruments, D/G, C/F, G/C, etc., is that the RH side is ideally suited to playing both melody and harmony. I like to play both so the fact that the RH side of D/G and similar systems can play major and minor chords both on the rows and crossing the rows, easily, almost without thinking about it, is a huge plus for me. So, on a D/G box, it is straightforward to play triads of G major, D major, Em, Am, Bm, A major, F#m, in various inversions.
Playing the RH side of the melodeon is, to me at any rate, much more than just playing 'the tune'; I can play the tune with lots of extra notes thrown in when I need to. And that's before I start using the LH side. It truly is a 'band in a box'. I don't think that can be said in quite the same way for a B/C box. Sure - you can do RH chords in C major, Dm, B major and C# minor (not exactly startlingly useful in general), plus a cross-row Em. But where are your useful RH chords for, say G major, D major and Am? You can't do it, because the relevant notes are not all in the same bellows direction.
If you want only to play fluid melody-only driven tunes, then I can accept that a semitone-tuned box is good, but for me, I want something with a bit more overall beef on both sides, and without the added weight of a stradella bass. Apart from Ireland and Scotland where the semitone systems are generally favoured, I think it is significant that in most other countries/cultures the fourth-apart box is preferred.
I guess it is now my turn to duck and run for cover. ;)
-
Biggest problem with the 12 stradella bass is the lack of a B bass and chord. For me B bass is indispensable on a DG box, as is F. Both are found on most melodeons with 12 basses. I agree that Stradella is more logical, but it does give you fewer bass notes and chords than a traditional 12 bass melodeon.â˜ï¸
-
as someone has already said 'horses for courses' and that's why I like and play both systems
george ;)
-
« Insert the name of the system you play » is the worst possible system - except for all the others!
-
« Insert the name of the system you play » is the worst possible system - except for all the others!
Love it! ;D
-
I enjoy listening to most, if not all types of melodeon but was reminded of the following comments: "After initially giving an enormous boost to Irish instrumental music, the B/C accordion has long since passed its heyday ...Stork or butter tests have revealed that it is now virtually impossible even for experts to tell the difference between top players. standardisation has led to decadence". Not the words of a D/G playing Morris Man but from the sleeve notes of "Johnny O'Leary - Music for the Set". Johnny O'Leary himself wrote "I spent some time going up to Padraig (O'Keefe) too. Padraig was never gone too much on that crossing of the keys".
As I say I enjoy all styles of melodeon, even the Twinnies! (What's not to like about girls on roller skates playing melodeon!) So I would take issue with the view that "Tunes that lend themselves to DG are not always the most interesting tunes". By extension this must include other fourth apart boxes, so are there are no interesting tunes from the English, French, Italian etc traditions?
Like Steve I feel that the ability of these instruments to provide their own accompaniment is a great strength. Antoine Bouscatell the famous French piper certainly thought so "The dayes of my bagpipes are numbered! This character with his accordion carries with him our ruin!... The accordion is a miracle that falls from the sky. It is a revolution on the way. Did you hear? It is complete, it is hot, it is alive. And it is a whole orchestra, this instrument of the devil". To be fair he also said that the accordion was only fit for bears to dance to!
For anyone not familiar with the Twinnies
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpmDAu_47OE
-
I only said 'not always'. I never suggested or even implied that there are no interesting tunes in those repertoires; what I at least meant to convey was that the most interesting tunes in ITM do not always lnd themselves to DG boxes. That's all.
-
So it would be just as true to say "The tunes that lend themselves to BC are not always the most interesting tunes, I think". I agree that the DG does not seem to be the ideal instrument for ITM(although some players like Dave Mallinson do pretty well) ........ the one row 4 stop is ;D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6HOhqKrmfvY
For me the variety (anarchy?) of systems is one of the great things about the melodeon, I may even invest in a CC# >:E