Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on July 14, 2009, 01:00:47 PM
-
Ok - I'm significantly failing the grade on this simple little tune. I've cracked it in G - now am trying to play it properly in A - BIG PROBS. I seem to be playing it mainly on the pull. Apart from the obvious (like trying to find appropriate reversals) is there a trick?
AL
-
Interesting question,Al,I've just put the box on and played it thro' and find I'm halfway thro' the 3rd bar before I play a push in on the F# and E. One wee tip that might help is don't give the notes their full value, i.e. very staccatto and clipped with gaps in between. Gives lift to the music and saves wind !
Ian.
-
Yes, I've noticed that (short changing the note values is usually my first cheat!). Also I may be trying to play too loud - got this sound of a whole band in my head - so am just about to chock things down a bit to try and conserve air. Watching you pro's you never seem to get the bellows extensions that I'm getting. How is that?
Also I notice that I'm throwing in a G# in that third bar on the rundown: A - C#. Now I've just dug out my sheet music to check (I was trying to play from memory) and the version that I have is a transcript by Gerry Paci from Sha Shand 78 record. How do you play it? 'Cos if I don't need I ain't gonna play it!'
btw am I right in thinking that this was Sir Jimmy's sort of 'theme' or signature tune?
AL
-
as well as playing 'shot' notes & staccato bass the following may be worth a try-
bars1,2,5,6 use pusf B on outside row
bars3,6 use pushF#E
baar 9 use push E's & push C# inside row
etc etc
about 6 inches of bellows should more than cover it!
george
-
[
btw am I right in thinking that this was Sir Jimmy's sort of 'theme' or signature tune?
AL
[/quote]
As far aas I know his original theme tune was Bonny Dundee but later efectively the bluebell polka became synonemous with his name.
george
-
as well as playing 'shot' notes & staccato bass the following may be worth a try-
bars1,2,5,6 use pusf B on outside row
bars3,6 use pushF#E
baar 9 use push E's & push C# inside row
etc etc
about 6 inches of bellows should more than cover it!
george
Thanks for this George.
AL
-
"Kate Dalrymple" is the signature tune of the Scottish Country Dance music programme on Radio Scotland on a Saturday night. I heard it first about 1945 when I was a wee boy, and it's still used today. The programme is now called "Take The Floor", introduced by Robbie Shepherd. Every band appearing on the programme plays it. Jimmy Shand would have played it when he broadcast on the programme.
If you've any ambitions about having a band on "Take The Floor", you'd better learn to play it really well!
-
I think it was Ian Powrie [ a friend and fellow band leader of Sir Jimmy's ] who told me that when he'd asked Sir Jimmy if he was ever bothered with nerves when he was recording and was told that "As soon as the green light comes on, even Kate Dalrymple becomes difficult !"
I do remember doing an outside broadcast in a hall in Forfar for TTF in 1990 as a member of Rob Gordon's band and we played the 16 bars of Kate for the opening of the programme probably about 6 or 7 times simply for the reason that Rob [ and the rest of the band] weren't happy with the sound balance from the BBC's monitors. My son up in the balcony said to his mum " we're going to be here a long time if they can't even play that tune right !" He was only 7 at the time though.
Will Starr did an interesting version of Kate with variations etc. and Graeme Mackay of this forum does them as well but I don't think he's recorded them.
Ian.
-
I like it in G. I think it adds a bit more dynamics to the whole thing and it helps with the air. Also looks good playing the whole tune without moving fingers, confusing any audience members who are trying to work out what my fingers are doing! >:E
I haven't recorded it but it's on youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4bsqL7XOEE (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d4bsqL7XOEE)
Hopefully we'll be doing it on TTF soon as we passed our audition a couple of months ago and just in the rehearsal stages but have the program almost ready to record. I'll keep you posted when it gets broadcasted.
-
Also looks good playing the whole tune without moving fingers
Graeme
Is this really true, or am I being gullible again?
I saw this a day or two ago and thought that there was something wrong with my computer as I could see no finger movement.
-
I could have sworn that your box was playing itself for the first minute Graeme, lovely stuff.
-
Great stuff Graeme. I see you only put it on 3 days ago, must be premonitions going on here. The sound is great but as ukebert and grittite point out there is almost no movement for a lot of the clip, is that something to do with the you tube compression ?
Well done on the audition too, the more button boxes on TTF the better.
Ian.
-
Great stuff Graeme - I love the variations! When you slow the theme down at 2:15 I consider that to be about my pace!
AL
-
When you slow the theme down at 2:15 I consider that to be about my pace!
Boaster :P
-
Boaster
Race you at the workshop?
AL
-
I like it in G. I think it adds a bit more dynamics to the whole thing and it helps with the air.
Yep, I've tried it without moving any fingers and it definitely helps with conserving air - alas, it doesn't sound much like Kate Dalrymple when I play it???
AL
-
Race you at the workshop?
Youuuuuuuuuuur oooooooooooooooooooooooon
-
Hopefully we'll be doing it on TTF soon as we passed our audition a couple of months ago and just in the rehearsal stages but have the program almost ready to record. I'll keep you posted when it gets broadcasted.
This is really GOOD NEWS! Please do keep us posted about this - will it be one of their outdoor broadcasts or will it be in the studio?
AL
-
The videos not the best quality and does stick a wee bit but not enough to hide what I am doing. I really only use the four buttons playing it in G. I don't move my fingers at all. Just to press the buttons. Let the bellows do the work. I think it's something that Starr would have done, start by making it look really simple & then getting stuck into it.
I added the video about a month ago. 14th June. ;D
TFF will be in studio as it's our first broadcast. I'll be the first to let you all know when it's on.
Race you at the workshop?
Youuuuuuuuuuur oooooooooooooooooooooooon
Am I going to have to keep you two apart in the classroom? ;D
-
Am I going to have to keep you two apart in the classroom?
Nah - just in the bar!
AL :D
-
Did I forget to mention there is a bar in the same room? Not sure if it'll be open tho haha
-
Did I forget to mention there is a bar in the same room? Not sure if it'll be open tho haha
Bit of a tease, eh what?
-
Graeme
Your left hand appears to be fairly active in the second time through. I've tried to work out what you are doing but can only manage the good old melodeon oom pah. Any hints of what those busy fingers are up to?
Mike
-
Well the stradella bass system can be as musical as the treble end. It's not just to keep time. use the counter basses for bass runs as a pianist would vamping. I think the easiest way to practice this is by playing scales using the two bass rows.
-
the stradella bass system can be as musical as the treble end
Bang on, in fact I manage a rather nice thirds apart run in one particular tune. Somewhere in the piano stool there is a book of simple hymns, single line treble clef and single line bass clef. I might have a crack at those to get a bit more fluency.
Al is probably a whizz at these already. ;D ;D ;D
-
Al is probably a whizz at these already.
Don't you believe it! Nowt wrong with a bit of oom pah pah in my book ;)
AL