Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Jimbo on February 13, 2017, 05:57:57 PM
-
Anyone suggest a common glue (I'm in Canada) appropriate for attaching a leather valve to metal? I thought I saw Gorilla glue mentioned in a post, but can't find it now... Also, anyone ever try one of those hot glue gun thingees? Thanks in advance. Jimbo
-
Ordinary impact/contact adhesive like Bostik Contact Adhesive (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Bostik-BST80211-Contact-Adhesive-50ml/dp/B0001OZI4S/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1487009146&sr=8-2&keywords=bostik+adhesive) or the EvoStik equivalent (https://www.amazon.co.uk/Evo-Stik-Impact-Adhesive-347908-x/dp/B0001P03S8/ref=sr_1_1?s=diy&ie=UTF8&qid=1487009316&sr=1-1&keywords=evo+stik+impact+adhesive) is fine.
Put a thin smear of glue on the end of the valve (usually about 6 - 10 mm depending on the valve length) and immediately press gently into place. Don't put glue on both surfaces, just the valve. You have a short time to reposition the valve if necessary.
You can also buy the special valve glue (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Valves.html#21) from suppliers like Charlie Marshall (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html), but in my experience, contact adhesive works just fine.
Don't use hot melt glue, Superglue, PVA, gorilla glue or silicone sealant!
-
I agree with the suggestion of a contact adhesive, but if it is a solvent based one test on plastic valves first. Some solvents cause some plastic valves to distort.
-
While it's not a contact adhesive, Gorilla Super Glue (not the same as Gorilla glue) works fine for both plastic and leather valves. Can't remember if I got it from Canadian Tire or Rona, but it's easy enough to find...
-
Going with contact adhesive leaves the choice of solvent or water based.
As Theo says there is always the risk of solvent based adhesive damaging valves - but this is easy to test for.
Water based might appear a safer bet, but I am always concerned that this would set up corrosion - not so easy to do an instant test for.
Does anyone have experience that allays or confirms corrosion fears with water based contact adhesives?
-
I've never had any problem with the solvent-based contact adhesive brands Bostik, Evostik or Homebase 'own brand' affecting the plastic of the valve.
-
You've been lucky then Steve. Not common but it can happen so prudent to do a test.
-
I use a form of shellac designed as a sealant for gaskets in automotive application. I apply a thin U shaped line at the rivet end of the reed, using a toothpick. Thus no chance of too much adhesive in the undesired location. I apply the leather while the shellac is tacky. The shellac will disolve at anytime in the future with alcohol. No brutal removal methods needed at at later date. The worst glue and leather removal I have done was to remove leathers made from an old belt, applied with epoxy, which oozed onto the reeds. I wouldn't have bothered but the reeds were prewar Dix made.
-
Another reason I use shellac: alcohol is the only solvent needed to remove later, no corrorsion hazard to steel reeds and none to synthetic valves.
-
Interesting - I guess you mean a product like this one:
https://www.permatex.com/products/gasketing/gasket-sealants/permatex-indian-head-gasket-shellac-compound/ (https://www.permatex.com/products/gasketing/gasket-sealants/permatex-indian-head-gasket-shellac-compound/)
Do you know if it also works with plastic valves ??
-
I use either solvent free Bostik ( I think Rees recommended this) or Uhu (Paul Flannery recommended it).
-
Interesting - I guess you mean a product like this one:
https://www.permatex.com/products/gasketing/gasket-sealants/permatex-indian-head-gasket-shellac-compound/ (https://www.permatex.com/products/gasketing/gasket-sealants/permatex-indian-head-gasket-shellac-compound/)
Do you know if it also works with plastic valves ??
Yes, but I don't have long term experience with plastic valves, I mostly use leather.
-
Yes, but I don't have long term experience with plastic valves, I mostly use leather.
OK, I understand. Thanks Psuggmog.
-
It does not really work with plastic very well.
-
Hi solvent free Bostik this was recommended on the forum easy to use quick tack application
does not react with plastic valves "perfect"
-
Unfortunately, Bostik solvent free is not widely available (if at all) in Canada where OP lives. Searches on Google and eBay bring in mostly UK sources.
-
Hi guys
Unfortunately, Bostik solvent free is not widely available (if at all) in Canada where OP lives.
sorry always assume with globalisation you can get anything anywhere
-
Bostik is also not available in the US, that I know of. I've used Barge and Pliobond with good results with leather. But I've come to use, from advice received here, Bison glue because it's good for both leather and plastic.
-
Hi guys with the lack of availability of solvent free glue thought i would try hide glue i think its available just about everywhere............appears to stick really well easy to use cheap and seem to stick almost anything,and easy to remove
so might be another option
-
Hi guys with the lack of availability of solvent free glue thought i would try hide glue i think its available just about everywhere............appears to stick really well easy to use cheap and seem to stick almost anything,and easy to remove
so might be another option
I've never used hide glue for valves, but my instinctive feeling is that it would set too hard/brittle which might be a problem with vinyl valves. Contact adhesive retains a degree of plasticity which is helpful for slight repositioning adjustments and also for removal - any residue left on the reed plates mostly peels off easily; any stubborn bits can be removed with a cotton bud moistened with methylated spirit.
If you can't get solvent-free contact adhesive, I will (once again) mention the proper Hohner valve adhesive (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Reed_Valves.html#21).
It's easily available from Charlie Marshall (http://www.cgmmusical.co.uk/CGM_Musical_Services/Welcome.html) and he will ship worldwide.
-
Hi
I've never used hide glue for valves, but my instinctive feeling is that it would set too hard/brittle which might be a problem with vinyl valves.
give it a try ,i've used hide glue for over thirty years but never used it on plastic but seems to stick perfectly,i think because its quick tack and effectively dehydrates to stick it has many more uses than i thought
I have to hard felt some new cornet valves i,m going to try the bottom layer with hide as an alternative to pva ,its so cheap and easy to use and readily available, and also so easy to remove and " i like the smell" lol
-
I use Pliobond here in the US it is low VOC so not to bad on the fumes. Smells a bit like cat pee.
You just want to be careful and use a very thin layer as it will sometimes cause a single ply valve to warp.
In this case I apply the glue to the valve press it in place ,pull it off ,blow on it then stick it down.
http://www.hannarubbercompany.com/adhesives/pliobond/