Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andy Simpson on July 14, 2009, 08:34:51 PM

Title: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: Andy Simpson on July 14, 2009, 08:34:51 PM
I've never heard an explanation and I'm curious to know.

I can't quite fathom why they'd stop making melodeons with more than healthy demand for them in a flourishing market with rising retail prices.
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: rees on July 15, 2009, 10:34:59 AM
At Sidmouth last year, I proudly showed Martyn one of my Clipper melodeons.
"Let me know if you ever manage to make a living at it" said he.  :-[
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 15, 2009, 10:49:59 AM
At Sidmouth last year, I proudly showed Martyn one of my Clipper melodeons.
"Let me know if you ever manage to make a living at it" said he.  :-[
That's exactly it, isn't it.
To earn a living from melodeon making, you have to reach and exceed a certain critical mass in terms of number of instruments made, successful sales, quality of build, etc. This means having a dedicated workshop/factory employing several or several dozen people all of whom have their specific job(s) to do in contributing to the final instruments. The Castagnari family-run business is probably the best example of this. Anything smaller and it won't work in financial terms.

Building melodeons, and even more so, concertinas, is incredibly time and labour intensive. Individual makers, however good they are, cannot ever hope to earn a living from their instrument making - the prices they would need to charge for the instruments would be astronomical and completely unrealistic for a prospective purchaser.
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: TomB-R on July 15, 2009, 12:56:22 PM
At Sidmouth last year, I proudly showed Martyn one of my Clipper melodeons.
"Let me know if you ever manage to make a living at it" said he.  :-[
That's exactly it, isn't it.
To earn a living from melodeon making, you have to reach and exceed a certain critical mass in terms of number of instruments made, successful sales, quality of build, etc. This means having a dedicated workshop/factory employing several or several dozen people all of whom have their specific job(s) to do in contributing to the final instruments. The Castagnari family-run business is probably the best example of this. Anything smaller and it won't work in financial terms.

Building melodeons, and even more so, concertinas, is incredibly time and labour intensive. Individual makers, however good they are, cannot ever hope to earn a living from their instrument making - the prices they would need to charge for the instruments would be astronomical and completely unrealistic for a prospective purchaser.

I think you're a little pessimistic there Steve. For example Marcus Music in Gwent and Bob Tedrow in Alabama have both been there making hybrid concertinas for a long time, though both have other aspects to the business.  Whether you can actually make minimum wage at it......

Bob Tedrow reckons about 40 hours for a concertina (which seems optimistic) but adds an hour each for 60 traditional reeds on those models!

Ref Castagnari - A client of mine, a dealer in industrial machinery, took one of his customers, a printer from Glasgow, to see a binding machine in Italy a few years back. Chatting to the Italian factory owner they realised that wage costs in Italy were approx half what they were in Glasgow..... Of course that in itself doesn't mean much [Edit - from the employees' point of view] until you look at tax, cost of living etc etc.
Tom
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 15, 2009, 01:00:52 PM
Quote
At Sidmouth last year, I proudly showed Martyn one of my Clipper melodeons.
"Let me know if you ever manage to make a living at it" said he.
Darn...and I had such high hopes for my kitchen sink melodeon!
 :D
AL
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 15, 2009, 01:21:09 PM

To earn a living from melodeon making, you have to reach and exceed a certain critical mass in terms of number of instruments made, successful sales, quality of build, etc. This means having a dedicated workshop/factory employing several or several dozen people all of whom have their specific job(s) to do in contributing to the final instruments. The Castagnari family-run business is probably the best example of this. Anything smaller and it won't work in financial terms.

I don't doubt that it's labor-intensive, but I do doubt the assumption that small builders like Bertrand Gaillard and Sylvain Vézina are not "making a living" just because they aren't producing on a scale comparable to Castagnari.  Both builders offer (relatively) limited ranges of instruments and work in very small shops that don't have the extensive division of labor as seen in Castagnari's production.
-Andy
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: triskel on July 15, 2009, 01:39:38 PM
Building melodeons, and even more so, concertinas, is incredibly time and labour intensive. Individual makers, however good they are, cannot ever hope to earn a living from their instrument making - the prices they would need to charge for the instruments would be astronomical and completely unrealistic for a prospective purchaser.

I think you're a little pessimistic there Steve. For example Marcus Music in Gwent and Bob Tedrow in Alabama have both been there making hybrid concertinas for a long time, though both have other aspects to the business.  Whether you can actually make minimum wage at it......

Let's just say that one of the concertina makers (who I won't name) has told me that he can only do what he loves because his wife has such a good job...
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 15, 2009, 01:52:41 PM
I don't doubt that it's labor-intensive, but I do doubt the assumption that small builders like Bertrand Gaillard and Sylvain Vézina are not "making a living" just because they aren't producing on a scale comparable to Castagnari.....
Well - perhaps we'll agree to differ, but I will maintain that as single maker it is not possible to generate one's sole living requirements by making and selling melodeons. You'd have to have another source of income as well, otherwise you'd starve.

I think you're a little pessimistic there Steve. For example Marcus Music in Gwent and Bob Tedrow in Alabama have both been there making hybrid concertinas for a long time, though both have other aspects to the business. 
Exactly my point.
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: ganderbox on July 15, 2009, 02:00:07 PM
I would imagine that most small scale makers have other sources of income, and don't rely entirely on making melodeons to earn a living. If that were the case, they could afford to sell them with very low profit margins (if any), but they would need to have a love of making the instruments to want to do it.

I still wonder, though, with the current stupid prices for Castagnaris and Salterelles, if it wouldn't be worthwhile for somebody in Britain to start up. Then again, if the euro were to take a tumble against the pound, the situation would change very quickly.

(I wrote this before reading the last 2 posts, but I'll make the point again anyway).
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: TomB-R on July 15, 2009, 02:01:34 PM
The financial points are well recognised! Try googling "Luthier jokes"  ;D

Here are a few

Did you hear about the instrument maker that won millions of pounds on the British lottery? When asked what he planned to do with his new found wealth, he said, "I guess I'll just keep making instruments till it runs out".


Q. How do you get a instrument maker off your doorstep?
A. Pay him for the pizza.


Q. What do you call a instrument maker who breaks up with his girlfriend?
A. Homeless.
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 15, 2009, 04:52:31 PM
Quote
Q. What do you call a instrument maker who breaks up with his girlfriend?
A. Homeless.

********Thread drift alert as my mind wanders off in a bubble of memory:

Funny you should say that Tom because we had a little while ago a fiddle maker staying in one of our nearby hostels. He was a very talented guy - but sadly his life was controlled by d&d. He cleaned up and has moved on - I was thinking about him the other day and wondering if he'd gone back to fiddling with fiddles or gone off and done something totally different.
AL
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: James Fitton on July 15, 2009, 06:42:17 PM
Quote
but sadly his life was controlled by d&d.

D&D? Not dungeons and dragons, surely?
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 15, 2009, 07:16:27 PM
Quote
D&D? Not dungeons and dragons, surely?
Sadly not...although I have encountered that as well in my time!
 ;)
AL
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: pete /acorn on July 15, 2009, 09:32:43 PM
Hi,
Possibly the answer to this is in Italy originally small makers of components traded together and to make this cost effective they all congregated in one area,now mechanisation has become necessary with cnc and laser cutters making the intricate work quicker,have a look at the grill on Castagnari s,the edge of the pattern on the grill is burnt,its cut by computer controlled laser.
This manufacturing components is what I do,I make wooden  consumable components for other manufacturers,either items the do not have recourse or not cost effective so thy farm out this work.
Re Melodeon making as mentioned previously I'me working on range using Oakwood 2.5 row as a pattern,will keep posting when further on.

Pete
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: IanD on July 15, 2009, 11:17:21 PM
my impression was that in the end martyn simply preferred to devote his workshop time to the strings.

Martyn told me that it was a matter of economics -- do you pay somebody to make a melodeon that sells for X pounds and takes N hours to make, or a stringed instrument that sells for X/2 pounds and takes N/4 hours to make? (my guesses at the numbers) -- coupled with the fact that though Martyn was keen on melodeons his partner John wasn't, at least not to the extent of being willing to ignore the economics.

A great shame, the best boxes ever made for English dance and band music IMHO. Jerry Tozer's been trying to persuade Martyn to make a batch of Model 4 identical to mine for some time without success, even the prospect of £20,000 or more for batch-building non-customised identical boxes hasn't changed Martyn's mind :-(

Ian
Title: Re: Why on Earth did Oakwood stop making boxes?
Post by: Malcolm Austen on July 16, 2009, 03:51:18 PM
Was there not an interview published some time back with Oakwood (Martyn)?
I seem to remember information like the large number of saw cut setups that were required, references to training staff and starting out making their own buttons only to find you could just get them from Italy. I will have a look back through some old magazines.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal