Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on February 23, 2017, 02:03:27 AM
-
I have a one-row, 4 stop box in D. The first button is an "A" note on the draw, which is redundant as there is already the same note on the 2nd button push. As I play mostly Irish music, a "B" note on the draw would be much more useful. I know a lot of Quebec-made boxes already come with this layout, but for some reason most other one-rows don't (I'm not sure why - on an instrument that already has a limited number of notes, why a redundant note?).
Anyhow, I know this is a modification that is not uncommonly done, but I'm wondering how big of a job it is for an accordion technician to do. Would they be able to use the existing reeds? There would be four reeds to change (LMMH).
-
Not a difficult job. Take out 4 reed plates, the existing reeds can be tuned up. There is a small chance that the high reed might need to be replaced but not usually necessary
-
I have a one-row, 4 stop box in D. The first button is an "A" note on the draw, which is redundant as there is already the same note on the 2nd button push. As I play mostly Irish music, a "B" note on the draw would be much more useful. I know a lot of Quebec-made boxes already come with this layout, but for some reason most other one-rows don't (I'm not sure why - on an instrument that already has a limited number of notes, why a redundant note?).
On a one-row four-stop box with only two basses and chords I prefer the duplication of having the low A on both push and pull. It allows me to have the low A with the pull LH bass/chord of A. There are lots of tunes/instances where this really fits nicely with the harmonic structure of the tune - e.g. where a tune in D modulates into the key of A, as quite often happens at the end of a phrase.
If the low A is only available on the push, the only bass/chord you can have is D which is inappropriate/discordant in the example cited above.
If I need a B on the RH, I play it an octave higher, which, given the rich growliness of a one-row four-stop box, doesn't usually sound out of place.
-
An older thread : http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12729.msg156306.html#msg156306 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,12729.msg156306.html#msg156306)
-
Very useful to have this A lifted to B in my world on a single row in D. Chordal accompaniment is less of a 'driver' with the Irish stuff and it's a note that is very much used if you are shifting G tunes down to D.
It is possible to employ the higher B, but this is an octave higher, can be a distraction and at the speed of some Irish tunes, presents an unnecessary finger challenge.
But it's not a modification i consider unless I'm keeping the box because others prefer the original layout.