Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: malcolmbebb on March 30, 2017, 06:54:40 AM
-
Played a couple of Morris events lately where the background noise has prevented me hearing myself, although the dancers could hear me.
I was wondering about a simple belt clip self-contained in-ear monitor system suitable for Morris use, only really needs to be treble.
Anyone use or come across anything along these lines? Or silly idea?
-
This kind of kit (only one example of what's on the market) might work for you as the basis of personal foldback - https://www.thomann.de/gb/behringer_powerplay_p1.htm?ref=prod_rel_366390_1
Obviously it's not a complete system and needs to be considered alongside whatever amplification and/or box mic'ing you have.
Hope this helps as a starter.
Cheers
Steve
-
In my brief sortie into the world of sessions I started using a Honeytone guitar amp that clipped to my belt. It's battery driven with an ear piece and a clip that would normally fit on the neck of a guitar.It works in as much as you can hear yourself over the wall of sound that is mass melodeons and doesn't need any other power source...
-
How have morris musicians managed perfectly well for generations without any electronic earole devices!
On a practical level it helps for the musicians to be up wind of the dancers so the wind blows the sound of the music to the dancers but not the sound of the dancers to the musicians
George
-
In my brief sortie into the world of sessions I started using a Honeytone guitar amp that clipped to my belt. It's battery driven with an ear piece and a clip that would normally fit on the neck of a guitar.It works in as much as you can hear yourself over the wall of sound that is mass melodeons and doesn't need any other power source...
Don't forget that each of those "mass melodeons" is being played by a player who has just as much right to hear themselves as you do. So should they should all get amplifiers too? ::)
(I've heard of this happening with stringed instruments. A mandolin player got a small amp to hear himself; months later the room was full of guitar amplifiers...)
If I walked into a session that was that loud, I'd just walk out again rather than add more noise.
-
If you can't hear yourself, you must be playing the same notes as everybody else.
Sir John
-
(I've heard of this happening with stringed instruments. A mandolin player got a small amp to hear himself; months later the room was full of guitar amplifiers...)
One hopes for mutual respect and tolerance at a session, and if it's not in evidence I don't bother going again. But that tolerance should include understanding for players of acoustically quiet instruments, in my case moothies. I can make myself heard in a session of 6 or 7 musicians without many boxes, but otherwise will use a (very) small amplifier. No-one has ever objected, and I sometimes get asked to use it in sessions where people know me.
Cheers
Steve
-
Lol the main problem was in halls with less than ideal acoustics. Lots of people talking near the musicians. The box sound is lost in the room. And high enough profile to not want to make too many mistakes.
And for Anahata- I specifically stated in-ear. :||:
-
In my defence I was attending sessions for the first time and didn't know any of the tunes that were being played. I don't think any one was aware that I was using an amp and as the sound was being squirted into my ear and nobody else's I can't see the harm. Any way, it was meant as a short term solution until I got familiar with the tunes.. :-\
-
That Behringer device looks interesting, Steve. Am I right in assuming it's intended for mic level input (in which case no phantom power?), or line level output from a mixer? I couldn't find that on the description, but either way, Malcolm would need further kit, including presumably close mics, for outside Morris playing.
I agree with you on the separate matter of small personal amps for sessions. Achieving a balanced sound at a session is lovely for everyone present if it happens, but it doesn't always. Dare I say it, we melodeonists can be some of the worst culprits! I never take my loud box to sessions. Speaking up for quiet guitar players, a friend recently showed me just how successful a small battery-powered amp can be, and for guitar instrumentals, it transforms the experience for the player and the audience. It's the quality of the sound that matters rather than the volume - if you are having to thrash a guitar for it to be heard, the sound will be all buzzes and no subtlety, and you will lose your fingernails. Slight amplification will permit the player the full use of the instrument's dynamic range, with lovely soft basses, and many in the audience will not realise the amp's there at all. Indeed, other players there may suddenly realise what guitarists can achieve if only they can be heard!
-
Hi Chris
the full spec is here - https://images6.static-thomann.de/pics/atg/atgdata/document/specs/337109.pdf
It doesn't appear to have phantom and is pretty clearly designed for output from a mixer, presumably line level. Excellent reviews and does have a limiter.
I don't own one of these, just something I came across while deciding how to solve the problem of hearing myself on stage over Rod Stradling's (!) melodeon, twin fiddles and a piano. My current plan is to use the spare (post-fade) Aux output on the mixer to give me a personal monitor mix, so I haven't yet gone for in-ear. We'll see.
BTW There is a different Behringer device, the 'Micromon' which allows the muso to mix into headphones his/her own mic input with a monitor input. Only downside seems to be no limiter.
On amps in sessions, I just destroy (moothie) reed plates if I increase my own acoustic volume too much - it gets expensive!
cheers
Steve
-
I know this is really drifty, Steve, but I was interested in your 'hearing yourself' issue. I'm fortunate (or unfortunate) enough to be able to balance our band's FoH and foldback onstage, and I've always felt philosophically that it should take a very good reason for one player to receive a different mix from what's going out in front. (Having a loud acoustic source onstage such as acoustic drums, or maybe a brass instrument may be one such reason.) OK, it may help an individual player to hear their own sound more clearly, but in a band shouldn't we really want to produce the best overall sound? I'm concerned that maybe your problem is that you may not be being heard out the front either!
-
Two points, I suppose, Chris. In practice, I personally will be heard in the FOH since the sound desk for both Phoenix and the Black Box Band is usually (wo)manned by my nearest and dearest, Annie Dearman (unless of course it's a festival with own engineers). More generally, it's difficult to insist on the same monitor mix for the whole band, partly because different instruments have different acoustic levels (eg left ear on top of fiddle), partly because different band members have different levels of hearing acuity, and partly because different band members have different 'tastes' in foldback levels of themselves.
cheers
Steve
-
And for Anahata- I specifically stated in-ear. :||:
So you did - my apologies! :|bl
-
I was talking " in ear"too...can I have a smiley?
-
I was talking " in ear"too...can I have a smiley?
(:) ;) :D ;D :o ::) :|glug
-
I know this is really drifty, Steve, but I was interested in your 'hearing yourself' issue. I'm fortunate (or unfortunate) enough to be able to balance our band's FoH and foldback onstage, and I've always felt philosophically that it should take a very good reason for one player to receive a different mix from what's going out in front. (Having a loud acoustic source onstage such as acoustic drums, or maybe a brass instrument may be one such reason.) OK, it may help an individual player to hear their own sound more clearly, but in a band shouldn't we really want to produce the best overall sound? I'm concerned that maybe your problem is that you may not be being heard out the front either!
I suspect most melodeon players who are in bands will be sharing the space with other loud acoustic sources. So far as I am concerned, the purpose of foldback is to help me blend in with the rest of the band. FoH sound is the sound engineer's responsibility. I want to hear myself (because I play by ear and need to know what I am doing), and also the fiddle and concertina as they are doing other melody things which interplay together. A bit of piano helps, but I don't want very much. I don't need guitar, as he's playing it in my bloody ear, and need very little bass as I get enough of the FoH speakers. Other band members have their own preferences.
Different bands may work differently especially if most electric instruments are DId with no acoustic sound on stage, but that suits us.
I use a wireless in-ear system with bone conduction headphones, so I can hear the foldback without blocking out other sounds as well. It works well, but the bone conduction feels a bit odd!
-
Thanks Lester, my brief sense of outrage has subsided....
-
So far as I am concerned, the purpose of foldback is to help me blend in with the rest of the band.
Is that the same as what I'm saying about the 'default' for foldback settings? It seems to me that it is - the ideal is to be able to adjust one's playing so that it fits in at the right level with the others, and if you're achieving that, the result is going to be pretty much the same as what's coming out the front. I know that some players are more interested in making sure that what they are playing is right, rather than making sure the balance is right, and therefore perhaps they prefer to hear themselves more. However I prefer the idea of 'playing to the mix', as it were - probably much the same as what would happen in a good session with sensitive musicians.
-
2 nhs hearing aids can be useful as you can adjust the volume (that you hear) of treble and bass independently!
george
-
2 nhs hearing aids can be useful as you can adjust the volume (that you hear) of treble and bass independently!
george
Hi George. I need hearing aids for both ears but have found only private sector aids give me good enough quality sound when listening to or playing music. I have been trialling hearing aids for several months and currently find those from Unitron best. Clearly it all depends on each person's hearing loss, but I'd be interested to know which NHS aids you have. Cheers, David
-
no make or model written on them so presume they are just standard nhs issue. I find them excellent for listening to music and to effectively turn ones box up or down - and to turn down the bugger sat next to you ( on either side) that is playing too loudly!
george
-
I have never played at a session, and probably never will. But there may be hope that an in-ear solution will actually reduce the volume as players don't need to get themselves heard (also noticeable as an ensemble issue, as the first one in will often dictate the pitch and tempo as they strive to hear themselves - or, cynically, get themselves heard. I say this not in relation to folk music, but wider genres). There are many ways to balance people sans amplification - but it almost always leads to an increase in the volume of the important voice rather than a reduction in the less important ones. No blame, it's just difficult.
-
I have never played at a session, and probably never will.
Then it must have been your double at the Melodeons at Witney Friday night welcoming session in Henry Box School last November... ;)
-
For hearing aid users there is this solution that I made up for the Sainted Mrs Bailey when she played her hammer dulcimer.
She had difficulty hearing both her instrument and the rest of the session so I put a pickup on the dulcimer and used it to drive a small battery amp (https://www.thomann.de/gb/fender_mini_57_twin_amp.htm). This amp in turn drove a t-loop inductive earhook (http://www.connevans.co.uk/product/4371280/95MUGLS/CLHook7---Single-inductive-earhook--3-5mm-plug-for-audio) which hooked behind one aid which she switched to 't loop' setting. She then had one ear on the session and one with just her instrument. Worked really well she said.
-
Lester, have you ever considered making and selling such a bit of kit?
george
-
Lester, have you ever considered making and selling such a bit of kit?
george
It's easy enough to knock up yourself and the implementation is instrument dependant due to the suitabilty of input device (mic/pickup/etc)
-
I thought there must be a downside to having full automatic control on mine.
-
Have you tried wearing a broad-brimmed hat? Playing fiddle, this provides instant personal foldback - the sound is reflected right into your ears and the effect is miraculous. Obviously a melodeon doesn't project sound upwards the way a fiddle does, but you never know, it might help.
-
We have a flute player in my local session who also wears a wide brimmed hat.
I'd assumed initially it was a bit of a pose, but no, as Stiamh says, there's a logic to it.
Q
-
If you want to gat ahead, get a hat.. :|glug
-
I have never played at a session, and probably never will.
Then it must have been your double at the Melodeons at Witney Friday night welcoming session in Henry Box School last November... ;)
If you ask Vicky, she'll confirm I just sat there holding a box.
-
We have a flute player in my local session who also wears a wide brimmed hat.
I'd assumed initially it was a bit of a pose, but no, as Stiamh says, there's a logic to it.
Q
I know that man!
Cheers
Steve
-
How have morris musicians managed perfectly well for generations without any electronic earole devices!
On a practical level it helps for the musicians to be up wind of the dancers so the wind blows the sound of the music to the dancers but not the sound of the dancers to the musicians
George
One of the joys of modern life is that people talk over any performance these days. Outside is not a problem, but some halls seem to amplify the chat. Winchester Great Hall was like that for a dance we did. I guess they never planned it for Morris. I couldn't hear myself and had to stand very close to the other box player.
-
This kind of kit (only one example of what's on the market) might work for you as the basis of personal foldback - https://www.thomann.de/gb/behringer_powerplay_p1.htm?ref=prod_rel_366390_1
Obviously it's not a complete system and needs to be considered alongside whatever amplification and/or box mic'ing you have.
Hope this helps as a starter.
Cheers
Steve
Cheers Steve, wondering about that so I've ordered one. Just need a mic now...
-
Can I mention the system I made by matching two Mics to the ART preamp box which incorporates a jack output. If I am using mics and amplifying my melodeon I can let the output go happily to the desk but take my own mini jack output to in ear headphones, either one in or both, and it has a volume control. Highly recommended.
As far as hearing yourself in sessions I have never used in ear monitoring.. I think the only thing is to pick very carefully where you sit, taking account of other instruments and players. Also try not to go to one with a cahon player who wants to show you he is in a ceilidh band. And if it is a poor session try a different one. But keep trying.
M
-
no make or model written on them so presume they are just standard nhs issue. I find them excellent for listening to music and to effectively turn ones box up or down - and to turn down the bugger sat next to you ( on either side) that is playing too loudly!
george
Thanks. I too find my hearing aids useful for toning down loud players/talkers. Losing some of your hearing is one of the benefits of getting less young. ;)
-
Have you tried wearing a broad-brimmed hat? Playing fiddle, this provides instant personal foldback - the sound is reflected right into your ears and the effect is miraculous.
LOL yes - although for one side the hat is a bowler, maybe not so broad brimmed, t'other is a straw hat.
The first few times I played outside of practice halls were a dreadful shock - the box had suddenly gone so quiet, with no walls to reflect it back.
-
Would one of these work? I do not own one and have no idea if there is any hysteresis in them.
https://www.amazon.com/BuyDBest-TM-Personal-Sound-Amplifier/dp/B000QJ9M2M/ref=lp_7504307011_1_1_a_it?srs=7504307011&ie=UTF8&qid=1491317090&sr=8-1 (https://www.amazon.com/BuyDBest-TM-Personal-Sound-Amplifier/dp/B000QJ9M2M/ref=lp_7504307011_1_1_a_it?srs=7504307011&ie=UTF8&qid=1491317090&sr=8-1)
I tried a few apps on my smartphone using Bluetooth headphones but there was a noticeable delay in the smartphone picking it up and processing to the headphones (wired or Bluetooth) at nearly half a second.
-
That does appear delighfully simple, and may indeed be adequate for occasional use.
-
Read the reviews. It looks awful.
-
Yes, I did. This particular one can be placed on a slow boat from China for under four quid in the UK. The concept is delightfully simple, and Amazon UK does come up with one with better reviews.
However, I think both might struggle more than a tad in the target environment.
There is no very simple candidate, and since the requirement only happens once or twice a year it's probably not worth spending more time looking as my needs don't justify professional equipment.
There is a lad on my team, an electronics graduate, who designs op-amp circuits almost for fun while waiting for the kettle to boil and has a particular interest in audio. I may have a chat with him and make something as a project, maybe using a CC-75 or similar. We make belt clip gas detectors and I can easily get hold of a scrap one for the housing. Any colour, as long as it's yellow.
But thanks for the suggestions, it has been interesting.
-
Smartphone in your shirt pocket using the inbuilt mike and app of your choice (whichever you use for recording, I use the in-phone software) and an earpiece. Could also use the mike on an earpiece set with a bit of messing about.