Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Bryson on July 17, 2009, 09:59:25 PM
-
I have the feeling that, after 2 years playing the Salterelle Connemara II D/G, there is not enough air getting out of the air hole, even on full depression of the air button. I originally thought it may be the stiffness of the bellows that was causing the "resistance". The bellows are, indeed, still fairly stiff but when I want to quickly suck in some air it won't.... by which I mean it feels as if the air's not getting in quickly enough? OK maybe I had forgotten that the bellows should be more extended to take on a particular phrase nevertheless has any other Salterelle Connemara II owner had thoughts... whatever on the air question.
Maybe I'm barking up the wrong tree but I ain't got no other tree..
cheers
Bryson
-
Easy enough to enlarge the air hole and fit a bigger pallet. I've done it to my Castagnari Sander and plenty of Gabbanellis which suffer from minute apertures.
It's made a huge difference to the Sander, loads of air on tap.
It may be something to do with the organetto tradition in Italy, where they play long runs in alternate bellows directions. Piano accordions also have small air valves.
I like the Hohner Club version which opens up a huge flap running almost the entire width of the box.
-
I have the feeling that, after 2 years playing the Salterelle Connemara II D/G, there is not enough air getting out of the air hole, even on full depression of the air button.
Bryson
When I had my Connemara II one of the first things Rod Stradling - who I think used to import them - said to me was to make the air hole bigger, so likely a common complaint.
Diane
-
Nothing's worse than an inadequate air button! Makes your phrasing become desperate, especially if you tend to breath in sympathy with your box...you may wind up holding your breath and passing out! x :-X x...
I concur with Rees, make a bigger opening and fit a larger pad.
-
As a comparison for you, the most effective air valve I ever had was on a Paolo Soprani Elite II. It had a 28mm diameter hole, giving an area of 616mm². The air valve hole on my 3-row Paolo Soprani measures 454mm², and is also very effective. What size is yours? ;)
-
the size of ones airhole is indeed of vital importance & without a doubt biggest is best! Out of all theboxes Ive had a go at the hohner is by far the best enabling instant collapsing of the bellows if needed. Its much better than on my 3 row paulo soprani . As to smaller boxes the bog standard hohner pokerwork/erica is fine & I quite like the sliding air button round which the thumb can be hooked. Most 2 row boxes seem to be fine & too smaller airhole can sometimes be confused with over stiff bellows . Playing technique also comes into it as some players need sudden copious supplies of air because they go in for playing as many notes in a single direction as possible whereas otheres use as many ins & outs as possible and some are much more turgid on teh bass than others. So its not just a question of size after all!
george
-
I just checked the size. The hole is in fact a slot with straight sides about 7mm across and rounded ends. The length is about 35mm. So about 245 mm2. In comparison to the figures above it seems rather small... lucky me :)
I don't want to fiddle about too much as I'm off to seven days of music and dance in Franken next week. I'll probably send it to Len Killick, from whom I bought the melodeon and who recently was very patient about my ideas for retuning the Salty Beast.
Thanks for all the advice.. and once again I discover that size really does matter..
cheers
Bryson
-
the size of ones airhole is indeed of vital importance & without a doubt biggest is best!
yup - agree there, after reading this thread I decided to do some woodwork and this afternoon I've just enlarged the air hole on the little D/G Primo by 3 times its previous size, and it has made such a difference. Took me a couple of hours all in all, which includes making a new pallet and spring lever and felt/leather pad. But plays much better already, bellows seem softer without losing any compression and it sucks in so much air now, so that the air button only needs to be lightly touched whilst playing. Before it was a slow process to refill it with air.
AL
-
...the bog standard hohner pokerwork/erica is fine & I quite like the sliding air button round which the thumb can be hooked.
george
The air button on my erica is the one thing I don't like . I have short thumbs ! I much prefer the push in air button.