Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Rog on April 12, 2017, 09:06:58 AM

Title: Stethoscopes
Post by: Rog on April 12, 2017, 09:06:58 AM
On another thread a stethoscope was suggested as a way to pinpoint air leaks. I see engineer's scopes are well cheap on eBay. Anyone know if these are better/worse than a medical scope....for the purpose intended. I'm not normally trying to work out if the tappets are rattling on my Hohner. (:)
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Broadland Boy on April 12, 2017, 02:08:06 PM
Engineers version tends to be the refined version of listening with a hammer shaft or screwdriver wedged twixt engine etc and ear, the end of the rod seems to terminate in some not terribly effective diaphragm in the little moulded lump where the ear-tubes are attached so other than direct mechanical vibration they are effectively deaf to airborn sound (well, those I have seen so far)

The medical stethoscopes are available fairly cheap, have a large or small diaphragm on either side of the head but are also fairly deaf.

The interposing of the diaphragm has two functions, one is to pick up and amplify 'mechanical' sound as opposed to airborn sound, this has a knock on benefit of preventing ear drums being damaged by excess noise and in our application, air flow leading to damage, which is why the next is not for those unable to take care !

My late organ pipe and organ making friend and his colleagues tended to use the earpiece parts of the Stethoscope but to join the air tubes with a Y piece (eliminating the diaphragm) and take a straight tube to a metal or glass tube drawn down to a fairly fine orifice, using this directly to locate, very precisely, the point of leakage.

Very sensitive and effective it has to be made and used very carefully, the seating force of the earplugs being far in excess of the eardrum failure pressure, there is no 'safety device' other than care, attention and rapid reactions.

A single bit of tube which just fits the ear was generally available as a quick & dirty when travelling but a finger in the spare ear is then needed to damp any ambient.

A hole or holes somewhere between probe an ear would releive pressure build up but may not spill enough in the event of higher pressures. 

I have converted both engineers and medical at need mainly for LPG gas burner checks for my little boilers, the engineers were always cheaper pre china on the interweb, most recent was modified by a Chinese medical scope from ebay for about a fiver delivered IIRC, it is much more comfortable to wear than than the engineers equivalent.

The amount of pressure which may be needed for eardrum damage is indicated here http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2007/ShemikaWhite.shtml  just multiply bellow width by depth to get the force needed as end pressure, press on some sensitive scales to register this and it will give an idea of how hard you can operate tuning table or instrument to approach a risk level if you seal the probe opening over the entire leak

Hope that helps and covers the risk factor adequately those who might follow Roger, Melodeon  Players / Fettlers eardrums may become naturally hardened against repeated pressure fluctuations (=diaphragm scope) but not direct pressure (airline / vacuum cleaner applied to lug/s scope.

It is of course far safer to use a solution of detergent or soap in water to locate leakage by bubble formation  >:E
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Rog on April 12, 2017, 04:09:59 PM
Wow. Thanks for that v interesting reply. I had not thought of the possible dangers. I had in mind using it like a sniffer, for instance to work out which pallet is leaking. But...perhaps I'll stick to using tape etc.
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: hickory-wind on April 12, 2017, 04:57:20 PM
The amount of pressure which may be needed for eardrum damage is indicated here http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2007/ShemikaWhite.shtml  just multiply bellow width by depth to get the force needed as end pressure, press on some sensitive scales to register this and it will give an idea of how hard you can operate tuning table or instrument to approach a risk level if you seal the probe opening over the entire leak

Hope that helps and covers the risk factor adequately those who might follow Roger, Melodeon  Players / Fettlers eardrums may become naturally hardened against repeated pressure fluctuations (=diaphragm scope) but not direct pressure (airline / vacuum cleaner applied to lug/s scope.


Per the above referenced papers eardrum rupture occurs around 84 to 100kPa. A two row button accordion operates around 0.5 kPa.
A small concertina might reach 1.25 kPa. There is absolutely no chance of rupturing an eardrum at those pressures. Most air release button pallets will open above 2 or 3 kPa (on the press, not the draw) so again, perfectly safe.

That being said, there is no advantage to completely seal the leak with the stethoscope tube anyway. It would make no noise then. I use a stethoscope for very small leaks. I bought a cheap ($6) medical unit and just removed the metal diaphragm end piece. It works fine with just the bare tube end. I hold it about 5mm above the suspected leak area. It will go from completely quiet to a loud sound like a microphone used outdoors on a windy day when you go by a leaking area.

Before I grab the stethoscope though I've found that just licking my lips and running the bellows gasket seam near them can find 80% of the leaks. I haven't tried the reduced diameter tube as mentioned above and that may merit further study.

Scott

BellingersButtonBoxes.com (http://BellingersButtonBoxes.com)
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Broadland Boy on April 13, 2017, 02:55:01 AM
Thanks for putting it in context Scott, was not in a position to pressure test a box, and as with all these ideas, someone might see and hijack it for some other higher pressure purpose.

Forgot to mention that with the air flow across rather than in line of the probe orifice tends to give best results Roger - suspect its the wave formation a la blowing over an open bottle.

Favourite probe for the 'one lug' jury rig version in Dereks workshop was usually an old disposable clear plastic BIC pen outer casing (they fit bunsen rubber tubing)
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Rog on April 13, 2017, 08:40:08 AM
Great (:) 'one lug jury rig'....I think I'm going to try something similar. I have a piece of model aircraft plastic fuel pipe ( good for rebushing some of the the cheaper concertina buttons). Might see if that works!
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: diatonix on April 13, 2017, 10:31:15 AM
9 out of 10 leaks are easily located by moistening one's lips or using the tip of one's tongue. It's effective and inexpensive.
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on April 13, 2017, 11:14:47 AM
Replacement tongues are VERY expensive.  >:E
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: robotmay on April 14, 2017, 02:22:46 PM
9 out of 10 leaks are easily located by moistening one's lips or using the tip of one's tongue. It's effective and inexpensive.

This is how I've been doing it. Helped me detect a few very tiny holes in my concertina's bellows that need attention, that otherwise would be pretty tricky to find.
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 14, 2017, 05:32:46 PM
I know exactly what diatonix means, it's a technique I use for finding small punctures in my bike innertube........
Q. 
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: robotmay on April 14, 2017, 06:38:16 PM
I know exactly what diatonix means, it's a technique I use for finding small punctures in my bike innertube........
Q.

Probably best not to try the alternative inner-tube hole-finding technique of submerging it in water on the melodeon, however >:E
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Nick Collis Bird on April 15, 2017, 07:21:24 AM
I know exactly what diatonix means, it's a technique I use for finding small punctures in my bike innertube........
Q.

Probably best not to try the alternative inner-tube hole-finding technique of submerging it in water on the melodeon, however >:E

Oh I don't know, but Tubby Reynolds tried it on mine...... yes it did leak.... pure H2o  :o
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Pete Dunk on April 15, 2017, 12:11:43 PM
For leaky bellows I normally put a bright lamp inside (LED torch works well) and look for tiny chinks of light, this works very well.
Title: Re: Stethoscopes
Post by: Psuggmog Volbenz on April 18, 2017, 04:59:33 AM
I have an old high quaility medical stethescope which has a double ended transmitter and double tubes which terminate at well formed eartubes, which are slightly angled to match the angle of the ear canal. There is a diverter valve in the transmitter which allows me to choose between the diaphram or an open port which is internally threaded to allow attachment of any termination configuration desired. I added additional hose to avoid having to bend over when using on an instrument on the workbench. The tubing is natural latex which is soft and flexible to aid easy manipulation. I usually use a solid metal rod with a hemispherical end to isolate noises when diagnosing mechanical machine problems.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal