Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Jonathan Arnett on May 09, 2017, 08:56:35 PM

Title: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on May 09, 2017, 08:56:35 PM
Sorry if this has been covered a thousand times but the link for advice in tune of the month is dead. And the one free app I've tried only works at very low quality sound. Then the video stutters to a halt. I'm running windows 7 using a cheap plugin external mic which works ok and a webcam. After ten weeks ish I can now actually play a couple of tunes and would like the laugh of hearing how awful they sound once recorded and played back. After which I may have a bonfire with the box.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Lester on May 09, 2017, 09:18:20 PM
I'm a fan of VLC and it's free

https://www.cnet.com/uk/how-to/how-to-record-your-webcam-with-vlc/
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on May 09, 2017, 09:46:22 PM
I use a Zoom H4n, with additional twin mikes.


Sir John
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Graham Spencer on May 10, 2017, 10:43:59 AM
Windows MovieMaker should do a reasonable job with a webcam and is already installed in Windows 7.......
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: squeezecat on May 10, 2017, 11:16:19 AM
Audacity for audio, mobile phone for video, synced using Windows Movie Maker  :|glug
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 10, 2017, 01:05:13 PM
You might find recording yourself audio only to be less daunting, I've pretty much moved from You Tube to Soundcloud, recording with Audacity which is excellent and free and a Zoom H2n microphone.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: nigelr on May 10, 2017, 01:40:37 PM
You might find recording yourself audio only to be less daunting, I've pretty much moved from You Tube to Soundcloud, recording with Audacity which is excellent and free and a Zoom H2n microphone.
I'm seriously considering taking this route as I find videoing pretty stressful and the sound quality is never as good as I would like (as well as the added joy of seeing my gurning face!) (:)
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 10, 2017, 05:26:09 PM
Yes, I too find it easier to use Soundcloud and a good recorder.
It is a shame though as I do learn a lot from observing people play, but really do find sound recording easier.
Q
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on May 10, 2017, 09:14:11 PM
Thanks I'l have a play. Afraid movie maker was removed from windows 7 so is not an option unless I pay for it. I  too learn from watching others play so would like to have a go at filming myself. Often try Lesters tunes first as theres so many and it helps a lot to get me going. Since I'm still pretty green I doubt anyone would learn anything watching me though. Except how not to do it!
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: playandteach on May 10, 2017, 11:35:44 PM
I think people like the warts and all approach to youtube. With soundcloud there's always the question of how much editing has gone on. It makes us feel better to see other players in the raw.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Mike Carney on May 11, 2017, 09:26:40 AM
I think people like the warts and all approach to youtube. With soundcloud there's always the question of how much editing has gone on. It makes us feel better to see other players in the raw.
I have heard this before a few times and still find it puzzling. As someone who has moved from video to soundcloud I can confirm all my recordings are single takes, with no cutting and pasting. I don't actually see how with a melodeon you can really do that anyway, I think it would be audible. All I do when "editing" is normalise and compress to reset and fractionally improve the quality of the sound, which can also be done with the sound on a video recording. They won't always be the first take...sometimes what you get is a weary Take 62! Oh, and all played without notation, having learned the piece.
M
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Lester on May 11, 2017, 09:33:35 AM
I think people like the warts and all approach to youtube. With soundcloud there's always the question of how much editing has gone on. It makes us feel better to see other players in the raw.
I have heard this before a few times and still find it puzzling. As someone who has moved from video to soundcloud I can confirm all my recordings are single takes, with no cutting and pasting. I don't actually see how with a melodeon you can really do that anyway, I think it would be audible. All I do when "editing" is normalise and compress to reset and fractionally improve the quality of the sound, which can also be done with the sound on a video recording. They won't always be the first take...sometimes what you get is a weary Take 62! Oh, and all played without notation, having learned the piece.
M

It is perfectly possible to make undetectable edits in Soundcloud and even on YouTube. I have edited the sound on a number of my videos when, after 20 takes I cannot get the tune three times through to my satisfaction, I just detach the audio, edit it in Audacity (usually cut'n'paste of a good bit over the bad bit), and then add it back to the video. Helps if your speed is reasonably constant through the piece.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Mike Carney on May 11, 2017, 09:40:15 AM
I think people like the warts and all approach to youtube. With soundcloud there's always the question of how much editing has gone on. It makes us feel better to see other players in the raw.
I have heard this before a few times and still find it puzzling. As someone who has moved from video to soundcloud I can confirm all my recordings are single takes, with no cutting and pasting. I don't actually see how with a melodeon you can really do that anyway, I think it would be audible. All I do when "editing" is normalise and compress to reset and fractionally improve the quality of the sound, which can also be done with the sound on a video recording. They won't always be the first take...sometimes what you get is a weary Take 62! Oh, and all played without notation, having learned the piece.
M

It is perfectly possible to make undetectable edits in Soundcloud and even on YouTube. I have edited the sound on a number of my videos when, after 20 takes I cannot get the tune three times through to my satisfaction, I just detach the audio, edit it in Audacity (usually cut'n'paste of a good bit over the bad bit), and then add it back to the video. Helps if your speed is reasonably constant through the piece.
Well, there you go. That's what you do.
M  (:)
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 11, 2017, 09:50:02 AM
This has thrown up some interesting bits for me.
I have a Sony recorder, and whenever I plug it in, it goes straight to the Sony 'Sonority' programme which I find clunky.
I'd never thought of opening the sound file in Audacity - duh! Thanks for that tip.
Like Mike, I too only record if I've learnt the piece, though the pressure of recording means it often becomes unlearnt!
I find when only sound recording and using Soundcloud I'm less prone to mistakes. Please note 'less prone' to mistakes as opposed to 'don't make' mistakes  ::)
Q
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Anahata on May 11, 2017, 10:42:10 AM
I record my sound with Ardour (http://ardour.org) which make copy/paste editing incredibly easy (much easier even than Audacity). And you usually can't hear the join. It's a bit overkill for a simple stereo recording, but I have it there anyway because I record multi track stuff anyway.

I then combine the sound with the video using KDEnlive, and if I've edited the sound, that may mean I'll have to edit the video track  to match. It's amazing what you can get away with on a video cut, if the sound is smooth under it.

Cheating? I don't know. Who types text on a computer keyboard without ever correcting errors?
I make lots of mistakes in live performances too, but that's not a problem because they can't be played back repeatedly like a YouTube video can. And it should be obvious enough that I don't fix every fluffed note...

For me, editing is preferable to doing 29 takes (which also isn't an option with live performance!)
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 11, 2017, 10:59:12 AM
The other difference between a live performance and a recorded piece is posterity.
In a live performance, it's there, it's gone and people move on to the next tune or song and any 'typo's' that happen during that particular piece is forgotten or at least not dwelt on as you listen to the next tune.
Anything recorded and left for posterity using YouTube or Soundcloud is a permanent reminder of that particular typo or error. As often others use the recording to learn from, errors become very obvious and a constant reminder.
Plus personal pride is a huge driver to want to make sure things are correct.
Q
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Helena Handcart on May 11, 2017, 12:12:10 PM
I think people like the warts and all approach to youtube. With soundcloud there's always the question of how much editing has gone on. It makes us feel better to see other players in the raw.

Really? I don't feel that way, although I agree that sometimes it is preferable to be able to see what a player is doing which is possible on YT but not Soundcloud.  Given that the video and audio tracks are separate things it is possible to 'correct' the sound track to a video before uploading it to You Tube so there is no guarantee that what you are seeing is 'in the raw'... and if 'in the raw' involves me pulling silly faces then I'll stick to Soundcloud :)

Not sure where I stand on the rights and wrongs of editing recordings. Professional musicians do this all the time. For me Soundcloud is primarily a tool for recording my progress with morris tunes and sharing these with team officers so there would be no point in recording other than warts-and-all performances, and it shows, but I am happy with that.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Anahata on May 11, 2017, 01:26:29 PM
The other difference between a live performance and a recorded piece is posterity.
Yes. In case it wasn't clear, that's (part of) what I meant by "played back repeatedly".

Quote
Plus personal pride is a huge driver to want to make sure things are correct.
Guilty as charged, m'lud.  :|glug
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 11, 2017, 02:03:44 PM
Anahata: re-reading - yes it was clear. Apologies  :-[
Pride - I think we're all guilty but I think it is a positive thing as it encourages us to try harder to get things right and not settle for a half done job!
Q
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself
Post by: Mike Carney on May 11, 2017, 05:16:30 PM
Maybe after these points have been made we should ask people posting on the forum to state in the little blurb for each published recording whether it is pasted or unpasted (effectively edited/unedited by cutting and pasting.)
M

Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Graham Spencer on May 11, 2017, 07:39:47 PM
Afraid movie maker was removed from windows 7 so is not an option unless I pay for it.

When? It was there when I was using Windows 7 and Windows 8 (on W10 now). In any case, there's a free download at http://www.windows-movie-maker.org/ (http://www.windows-movie-maker.org/)    Please understand I carry no torch for Microsoft - first up against the wall when the revolution comes, if you ask me - but if there's a program that works for what you need and costs nothing it seems daft not to use it.

Graham
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Jonathan Arnett on May 12, 2017, 04:17:41 PM
Maybe only on better versions of 7 than mine! Anyway grabbed the free download. Thanks. Useful for editing video also.

I'm really shocked that some of my melodeon heroes actually edit there takes! Lol. Actually that makes me feel a whole  lot better. Though I bet you don't need to edit as much as me. And if you didn't I wonder if I could tell the difference! Probably will be awhile before I can produce something that isn't too shocking to put my name to. May invest in a metronome as I tend to speed up as I go along at the moment. Thanks for all the help everybody.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: Tyker on May 12, 2017, 06:36:20 PM
Microsoft have removed the download from their site, so you can't get it there. Existing copies are fine.
Title: Re: Which app' to record yourself?
Post by: playandteach on May 12, 2017, 08:20:36 PM
I think people like the warts and all approach to youtube. With soundcloud there's always the question of how much editing has gone on. It makes us feel better to see other players in the raw.
Not sure where I stand on the rights and wrongs of editing recordings. Professional musicians do this all the time. For me Soundcloud is primarily a tool for recording my progress with morris tunes and sharing these with team officers so there would be no point in recording other than warts-and-all performances, and it shows, but I am happy with that.
Should have said it makes ME feel better to see players in the raw. No hint of criticism about those who use Soundcloud intended - I've done several myself - but in my case it's because I know I need to edit the playing. I've played on quite a few CDs as a clarinet player, over 1200 in fact, with some great players, and although I only every bought one or two of them I do now look out for cheap copies in charity shops (thought twice about posting this as I am here as a melodeon learner, not an ex clarinettist). Those recordings did of course benefit from having recording engineers who did nothing else all day long. So I've nothing against editing per se. I do want to learn as I watch - subtleties of technique etc. I also get involved in the piece so much more if I can see it happening. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal