Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: fc diato on May 10, 2017, 12:35:53 PM

Title: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: fc diato on May 10, 2017, 12:35:53 PM
Last summer I bought a one-row that I only started playing this winter. Turned out to have a few problems.  I was able to fix the leaky pallets. Recently, I finally looked inside and saw the reeds did not just have the usual tuner’s scratches, but deep pits (like someone had dug out gouges with a dremel.)  Am I correct to think that this is not really OK? (The photos flatten things out. Those pits are pretty deep.)

Oh, I do really like the box. I’m not planning to go complain. Just want to know. And wondering whether this would make further tuning difficult? And whether this means that a wise purchaser best needs to peek inside.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Cooper on May 10, 2017, 01:58:54 PM
i am no expert at all, but it looks a bit like it's tuned with a "dremel". The way Pariselle taught me in his workshop,...whether it's done correctly i cannot say ofcourse :-). And i suppose it is possible to go to deep ;-)
W
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on May 10, 2017, 02:02:38 PM
They do appear to have been tuned with a power tool.  Not something I'm in favour of, but I don't think there is any damage done.  If the reeds sound ok and none are any worse than the photos then I don't think you need to worry.  Power tool tuning can be a problem if done carelessly, but unless there are bits missing from the reed tips, or if the grinder has slipped off the side of the reed tonge then all should be well.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: fc diato on May 10, 2017, 02:12:01 PM
Quote
but unless there are bits missing from the reed tips, or if the grinder has slipped off the side of the reed tonge then all should be well.

I did photograph the worst. There is one where there was slippage off the side (in photo labeled 1 - but that comes second). But that's it. No bits missing off tips, so I'm reassured.
Thanks, Theo!
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: diatonix on May 10, 2017, 02:23:56 PM
Damaged or not damaged: these reeds were not tuned by a professional. You simply don't do this to Binci reeds! Whoever through a certain lack of skills resorts to a Dremel instead of proper tuning tools is bound to make other mistakes as well. As a tuner you are not only supposed to not ruin the reeds but also to optimize their potential and achieve good results.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on May 10, 2017, 02:27:29 PM
Agreed!

Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Cooper on May 10, 2017, 02:37:10 PM
Damaged or not damaged: these reeds were not tuned by a professional. You simply don't do this to Binci reeds! Whoever through a certain lack of skills resorts to a Dremel instead of proper tuning tools is bound to make other mistakes as well. As a tuner you are not only supposed to not ruin the reeds but also to optimize their potential and achieve good results.

I would love to hear more of this. I am sure you are correct. But how do you "optimize their potential and achieve good results"? I mean, what would or could the result be if it is done with a powertool? (apart from overshooting etc.). What is the undesired effect when tuning with a powertool? Less long lifespan? altered responsiveness, and if so, how? What is "their optimized potential" and how is it compromised?

I am asking a) to gain more general knowledge, but also b) if i notice it on my Pariselle that is tuned in this way.

W
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on May 10, 2017, 02:49:04 PM
My take on this is that power tools are simply unnecessary.  A good set of sharp files and scratchers are very efficient tuning tools. Either of these hand tools is faster to use, can reach into smalller spaces, doesn't leave abrasive grit etc etc.  Power tools are noisy and take time to speed up and slow down. We all make mistakes and a slip with a file or scratcher can only cause very limited damage, a slip with a power tool has more potential for damage.

Others may differ of course.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: diatonix on May 10, 2017, 03:09:24 PM
I quite agree. Through time and experience skilled tuners develop a certain amount of what in German is known as Fingerspitzengefühl -
 which is not compatible with having to handle a heavy, unpredictable and irritatingly noisy Dremel.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Cooper on May 10, 2017, 03:40:28 PM
ok, so you are saying it is more about the ease to use it, then the effect it has on the reeds, correct? (still apart from the damage done by overshooting). Because i am more interested in the effect it as on the reeds.

I am sure you are correct, if you do this a lot and get a feel for it (fingerspitzengefuhl). I did it only once, and in all likelyhood, IF i go tune something again, it will also be my own box, and in that way i will never get that "gefuhl" for it. But if you are like me then perhaps a dremel is the way to go, as i was much more capable of determining how much pressure i needed to get the result i wanted. I actually felt it was easier to not damage the reed then with scratchers etc, as i was constantly afraid i would push too hard and break something, whereas with that dremel i could with much smaller force aim a lot better at what i wanted.

Again, i am sure you are right that when you are experienced you shouldnt use a powertool. But if you are less experienced, like me, perhaps it is a good option. (as long as you dont overshoot, slip) Agreed?
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on May 10, 2017, 03:47:31 PM
I think you are better to use tools where at least you have the possibility of developing the skill and the feel for the task.  One obstacle is getting your hands on good quality files and scratchers.  Buying a dremel is easy in comparison.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: diatonix on May 10, 2017, 03:55:16 PM

 But if you are less experienced, like me, perhaps it is a good option.  Agreed?

No, I don't agree. A Dremel in the hand of an unexperienced person is likely to cause even more destruction than if I or Theo were (by whatever powers) forced to use it.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Cooper on May 10, 2017, 06:25:05 PM
thx for your replies!
W
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: fc diato on May 10, 2017, 06:38:06 PM
Enlightening, thanks.

I still love the box - just can't help be a just a tad irritated at the Very Reputable Shop (VRS) that sold it to me. I thought the premium price paid for getting something at a VRS would be a fettled box (sans leaky pallets) and full disclosure.
No buyer's remorse, but if there is a next time with them, I'll certainly want to see the innards!
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Peter Courtney on June 18, 2017, 02:41:40 AM
There are many sites on the nett showing tuning being done with Dremel tools, one in particular is the  Dirk computer tuning programme, scroll though there and you will see a reed bing flattened. I use a long diamond tip file about 2/3 mil in diameter on my dremel. Inside reeds just lift the valve a little on in you go . Takes a little practice to stay in the middle of the reed but it works fine. On outside reeds i hold the machine at a 90 degree angle to the reed in a horizontal position and just move it up and down the base of the reed. (You can if you are really fussy polish up the marks with fine sandpaper but the tuning will need to be checked afterwards) I use  The machine on the slowest setting.
 I still use a file to sharpen reeds.
Don't try this though on brass reeds

Cheers
Peter
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: diatonix on June 18, 2017, 09:00:08 AM
I hate to repeat myself, but professional tuners with respect for themselves do NOT use electrically powered abrasive tools. I've seen many of these ridiculous "tutorials" on youtube: 9 out of 10 show pure acts of vandalism. As long as they mess with their own instruments I don't really care, but it makes me angry when they start acting as if they were skilled technicians by propagating their more than dubious "method"  and taking money from trusting victims.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on June 18, 2017, 09:18:29 AM
It's just human nature I think.  Advice based on experience in this field is freely available.  Unfortunately it's often the case that the freely given advice based on experience is not so easy to accept.  It may be an example of the "Don't press the big red button syndrome",  where the thing you are told never to do is the most interesting thing to try.  Just want to see what happens if I press this!

Next month I will be working on one of Emmanuel Pariselle's courses.  I will have 4 or 5 days to tune 12 new melodeons. That is a little over 1500 new reed tongues. I can do that comfortably with two sizes of file and two scratchers. 

I hope that puts my advice in context.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 18, 2017, 09:42:36 AM
For further context, how far is it (typically) necessary to tune new reeds? Or, to put it another way, how close to final pitch are they from new?
Obviously it will be different for each row, but just for ballpark.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Lester on June 18, 2017, 09:47:17 AM
For further context, how far is it (typically) necessary to tune new reeds? Or, to put it another way, how close to final pitch are they from new?
Obviously it will be different for each row, but just for ballpark.

If you are lucky they are tuned mostly to pitch in the open air, unfortunately when you mount them they will need tuning a bit. Then the M+ reed will need tuning up to the required amount of 'wetness'
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Anahata on June 18, 2017, 09:49:16 AM
I think the state of tuning in a new box varies a lot from one manufacturer to another.

For those that care about getting it just right, there's also the complication that reeds seem to go though a settling in process in the first few months of playing, so there's a good case for "running in" a brand new box for a while and than getting it fine-tuned - it's much more likely to stay in tune after that.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on June 18, 2017, 09:52:39 AM
For further context, how far is it (typically) necessary to tune new reeds? Or, to put it another way, how close to final pitch are they from new?
Obviously it will be different for each row, but just for ballpark.


It varies between makers too,  and the design of the reed blocks and the way the reeds are fitted and valved also makes a difference.  On the last course I worked on they ranged roughly between +/- 10 cents.  It's not unusual to find errors where a small number of reeds are off by a semitone, usually all the reeds in a set the same.  For example last time there were some chord reeds that were C# when they should have been C, or maybe it was the other way round.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: Theo on June 18, 2017, 09:54:35 AM
I think the state of tuning in a new box varies a lot from one manufacturer to another.

For those that care about getting it just right, there's also the complication that reeds seem to go though a settling in process in the first few months of playing, so there's a good case for "running in" a brand new box for a while and than getting it fine-tuned - it's much more likely to stay in tune after that.

Yes, and sometimes a third tuning is needed too.   This depends on how the instrument is played, as well as on the make and quality of the reeds.
Title: Re: Have these reeds been abused ?
Post by: folkloristmark on June 22, 2017, 12:51:27 PM
I have practiced this dark art and confirm it is easy to ruin reeds.But good fun and you do get better as time goes on, it is lazy and makes the old pitch hohner reed mods quicker. It easier to find the dremel than the misplaced file under the car.Its Ok say with a few reeds in an old hohner, if they dont work, then they are easily replaced but if I have a box to retune as most ebay hohners do then it is off to the tuner for me as it cheaper than a half dozen new reeds.The latinos seem to like this tool, in practiced hands it must be perfectly acceptable?.I would not let one near a better box unless I dont see it.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal