Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Robert Englund on May 11, 2017, 09:30:27 PM

Title: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Robert Englund on May 11, 2017, 09:30:27 PM
These are probably a couple of questions that even a noob such as I should already know the answer to, but here goes anyway.

First, why is the B chord major? I know that e is the relative minor of G, and B is V chord of e. But how often is that necessary? I've a clutch of tunes that need a b, and have yet to come across a tune that requires a B. What was Hohner's rationale here?

Second, is it better to tape off the third on the B chord or to have the third flattened to sound as b? I quite like having the thirds on the other chords. Would removing the third on the B chord alone sound odd?
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Stiamh on May 11, 2017, 09:43:55 PM
B chords are handy in Em tunes (assuming that you won't be attempting E major on a D/G) and whether you need major or minor really depends on the type of tune. Most of the Em tunes I play are actually E dorian, and you wouldn't want a B major for those. For certain tunes that are more firmly in E minor, however, a B major chord will sound good.

For greatest flexibility I would blank off my third. I play C#/D and use my B neutral chords a LOT. For tunes in Bm, for tunes in Em, and for tunes in D major. If I really want to make a B chord major I can always sneak in a D# on the right hand.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 11, 2017, 10:27:49 PM
These are probably a couple of questions that even a noob such as I should already know the answer to, but here goes anyway.

First, why is the B chord major? I know that e is the relative minor of G, and B is V chord of e. But how often is that necessary? I've a clutch of tunes that need a b, and have yet to come across a tune that requires a B. What was Hohner's rationale here?

Second, is it better to tape off the third on the B chord or to have the third flattened to sound as b? I quite like having the thirds on the other chords. Would removing the third on the B chord alone sound odd?

Most people I know frig a Bm by playing a B bass with a D chord and Am by putting an A bass with a C chord. This gives you the minor 7ths, which is close enough for most purposes.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 12, 2017, 12:04:05 AM
This is a perennial question, surfacing from time to time on this forum.
As Stiamh has mentioned, a B major chord is useful when playing tunes in E minor. Most melodeons have the B chord as major, although a few are customised so the B chord is B minor.

The choices are:

1. Have the B chord as B major (the default position)
2. Customise the B chord to B minor
3. Tape off the thirds in a B major chord to make it B 'neutral', or use a stop to remove the thirds if fitted (not on a Pokerwork)

As others have mentioned, with option 1 you can also play a Bm7 chord as a reasonable compromise for B minor. It's a push B bass with a push D chord. It actually sounds quite nice and slightly jazzy. It doesn't work nearly so well with the thirds taped or stopped off.

So if you have option 1, you always have the choice of B major or Bm7 as and when you need them.
With option 2, you can only have Bm; you can't fudge it to make B major -  which is why I would always choose option 1 over option 2.



Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: vof on May 12, 2017, 12:41:15 AM
As others have mentioned, with option 1 you can also play a Bm7 chord as a reasonable compromise for B minor. It's a push B bass with a push D chord. It actually sounds quite nice and slightly jazzy. It doesn't work nearly so well with the thirds taped or stopped off.

Steve - presumably, you mean it does not work so well if the third in the D chord is taped off? Taping off the third in the B chord does not affect the B bass/D chord combination does it?

The minor chords I found I wanted most on my D/G Pokerwork other than Em of course were Am and Bm so I taped off the thirds in the A & B major chords. I was sufficiently pleased with the result that, after a few years, I got microbot to fit a thirds stop to the LH end. Of course, other fettlers are available ;)
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 12, 2017, 06:35:05 AM
As others have mentioned, with option 1 you can also play a Bm7 chord as a reasonable compromise for B minor. It's a push B bass with a push D chord. It actually sounds quite nice and slightly jazzy. It doesn't work nearly so well with the thirds taped or stopped off.

Steve - presumably, you mean it does not work so well if the third in the D chord is taped off? Taping off the third in the B chord does not affect the B bass/D chord combination does it?

Yes - you are correct. I should have been clearer in my reply, sorry.
To clarify - a Bm7 chord doesn't work so well if the push D chord has its third removed either by a stop or by taping off. It needs that F# to sound convincing.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 12, 2017, 07:53:21 AM
It took me a while to discover the B chord in my playing, using the B bass note/chord against a push G note in the melody more in my playing, it took a while for me to get it going, dunno why!
Rather than taping off the third I prefer using the work around of B bass/D chord for a Bm7, as it also gives me an opportunity to use the 'full' B chord should I need it. I am delving into some odd tunes currently and quite a few use a D# accidental in the melody. It sounds good against a full B chord so that gets used in that situation.
Sometimes I find a B bass and full B chord or a B bass and D chord don't sound right for some reason, so I just use a B bass only.

Therefore my choice is to keep the third in the B chord and use the D chord to make a Bm7 so I have both options available......but you may differ in your choice!
Q
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 12, 2017, 02:40:29 PM
A few other thoughts:
If you tape over a reed it is an easily reversible modification. Won't do any harm whatsoever and you can do it yourself.

I have had my A and B chords middle notes taped over for a few years, giving an A5 and a B5 ("power") chord on their respective buttons. I use the m7 and power chord options, more or less equally. I like the different tonal "colour" they give.

I have never missed the B major. Not once. I have, however missed the A major. (I have started playing more tunes on the D row) and I am thinking of taking the tape off the A chord. I am, also, wondering about flattening the D# in the B chord. I am in two minds about that, though. Not quite as easy to reverse.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Theo on May 12, 2017, 02:45:27 PM

I have never missed the B major. Not once. I have, however missed the A major.

I would miss the B major chord.  Not in many tunes, but where it is needed it really adds something.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 12, 2017, 03:04:17 PM
The "music theory" thing is that in "harmonic minor" the last note of the EM scale is D# rather than D, and that melodeons evolved in Vienna and France, where harmonic minor is prevalent. The Emharm dominant or V chord becomes B7 = BD#F#A#, cut back to simple B major as our chords only have 3 reeds.

Here in "English folk" modal minors dominate and the B chord is minor (technically minor7 as above).

Solutions as above. Another would be to learn some central European or Jewish tunes where both the B maj, and push Eb=D# accidental will be "just right"   ;)
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: squeezecat on May 12, 2017, 03:18:54 PM
Interesting thread! The Bmaj has never felt out of place to me. I seem to manage to work it in to almost any Em tune I play, but (as someone that doesn't play in D much) this thread 100% sums up my thoughts about the Amaj chord. I only use it very briefly in two or three G/Em tunes but it really adds something to both, and I couldn't even bear to tape it up even to let me play in A minor.

edited: words are hard
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 12, 2017, 03:23:41 PM
The 7 note, and indeed the 6 of the minor scale in European music is pretty flexible. Basically you are giving it "swing". Stéphane Grapelli did this sort of thing all the time  ;)
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: squeezecat on May 12, 2017, 03:31:11 PM
Minor Swing indeed. That's this afternoon's listening sorted, thanks  :D
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Robert Englund on May 12, 2017, 06:56:26 PM
Thanks to all who contributed.

I knew about the cross-chord B bass + D chord thing. The thing is, when playing in D, the vi chord is b, i.e., Bmin. And sometimes that seventh just doesn't sit right. That where I'm currently running into the desire for a b chord, as the vi chord in D.

I'm thinking that maybe taping off the third on the B chord to make it neutral is the way to go for now. As has been pointed out, it's always reversible should the need arise.

Thanks again. Your contributions are very much appreciated.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 12, 2017, 08:57:21 PM
I think I know what you mean..... Before indulging in minor surgery, have you tried just using a B bass in those tunes where the chord seems to grate....
Just a thought!
Q
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Andy Next Tune on May 12, 2017, 10:11:16 PM
Don't forget there is the 'Microbot option' - Mr Rowbotham of this parish is a master at adding a thirds bass stop to Pokerworks and other old Hohners.

Definitely more expensive than applying tape, but gives you complete flexibility.

And if you get him to tune it at the same time, you will get a lovely sounding box.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Daddy Long Les on May 12, 2017, 10:34:18 PM
I got Martyn White to remove the third on only the B major on my Lily. In this way all my other chords are intact and the B major/minor problem doesn't arise. Of course I still miss that full 1st,3rd and 5th on the B major and B minor but it's a workable compromise.  I have some tunes that need a B major and on those I use another box.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: playandteach on May 12, 2017, 11:06:38 PM
Steve F, I actually find the 3rdless G chord I use to create the  Em7 on my GC instrument (in other words the same as the Bm7 on a DG) is full and rich (perhaps it varies according to voicing of the chords - where the basses lie in relation to the 5ths etc).
I can also use a low accidental on the right hand to supply the major 3rd for the chord (B major in DG speak) for when I really need it. Theo knows my layout - and I don't know how common this is.
So, in short, I'd use the Bm7 option as the go-to minor chord. Failing that I'd consider taping over the 3rd of that chord only (i.e. not the other chords) and looking at low note accidentals (perhaps you only have them an octave higher...).
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 12, 2017, 11:49:03 PM
Steve F, I actually find the 3rdless G chord I use to create the  Em7 on my GC instrument (in other words the same as the Bm7 on a DG) is full and rich (perhaps it varies according to voicing of the chords - where the basses lie in relation to the 5ths etc).

Yes, you could be right about the voicing of your push G thirdless chord. Also, perhaps the thirdless Em7 sounds better on a lower-pitched box (i.e. G/C) anyway. But on a D/G a thirdless Bm7 to me just doesn't seem to have that 'squashiness', for want of a better word.
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 13, 2017, 09:25:20 AM
I have a thirds stop on my main DG simply because it came with one. I rarely use it though do appreciate the option as it gives a different thin sound which is another option should I want it.
My main Morris musician plays with his stop out all the time. That's his preference.

As ever with melodeons, you have options as discussed - a whole chord or a chord with a removed third by tape or stop. There is no right or wrong, the answer lies in your perception and preference of the sound they produce and what tunes you want to play.
Q
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Mike Carney on May 13, 2017, 12:06:27 PM
If you can run to it, having a thirds stop fitted is a good investment. I find that I generally take them out on French and Irish material, e.g. Fanny Power,  because of the freedom it gives to get round the bass and chord notes as single buttons.
Having the option means I can use the Bmajor in tunes like The Bedbreaker. Most often I keep the thirds in because of the wider range of chords (bass and chord button together) available. I then use the Bm7 with B bass and D push chord, or as some have mentioned, just use the bass B and no chord.
M  :||:
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 13, 2017, 09:47:50 PM
Steve F, I actually find the 3rdless G chord I use to create the  Em7 on my GC instrument (in other words the same as the Bm7 on a DG) is full and rich (perhaps it varies according to voicing of the chords - where the basses lie in relation to the 5ths etc).

Yes, you could be right about the voicing of your push G thirdless chord. Also, perhaps the thirdless Em7 sounds better on a lower-pitched box (i.e. G/C) anyway. But on a D/G a thirdless Bm7 to me just doesn't seem to have that 'squashiness', for want of a better word.

Maybe putting the F# back in by playing the thirdless B and the thirdless D together would restore the squash factor?
Title: Re: That B chord on a Pokerwork D/G
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 14, 2017, 03:55:33 PM
If buying a new box I always simply get 1+5 chords. It is actually more flexible when you cross-bass as the 3rd is often a "sour" note.   eg B on G bass = G B - F# and sounds as a cool G maj7. With the D# 3rd it … ain't so nice 😳

Many more clashes like that should you get 12 or 18 bass. Basically your 1+5s => 3+7th and you get a nice extended chords. The 3rd can become a #5: that's deeply uncool, outside jazz "altered dominants"😖

No 3rds is also lighter. If I actually "want" a D in my Gmaj7 chord I can just dab it in on right end with a spare finger. Nothing lost. Several gains?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal