Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: 911377brian on June 03, 2017, 12:28:13 PM
-
I've got a couple of the Child Prodigy type kids melodeons that have been Hohnerised by Mike Rowbotham and they play remarkably well. The bellows are always the weak link though and I've been in touch with Igor to see how practical it would be to have new bellows made. The smallest depth of bellows fold Igor can do is 25mm, the depth of fold on the Child Prodigy 16mm. Can anyone tell me if the difference in fold depth will have a detrimental effect? I've got round the problem of air loss up to now by glueing two sets of bellows together, however, Lester has recently retuned one for me from C to b flat with the original reeds and that plays OK with single bellows...
-
... The smallest depth of bellows fold Igor can do is 25mm, the depth of fold on the Child Prodigy 16mm. Can anyone tell me if the difference in fold depth will have a detrimental effect? ...
You would need to check that the deeper bellows folds do not contact or otherwise impact on the reed blocks. So long as there is (I'm guessing) about a centimetre minimum clearance between the interior of the bellows folds and the reed blocks you should be OK. If the bellows folds are too close to the reed blocks there is the risk of the reed tongues and/or valves contacting the folds during playing and also could have an impact on the tuning (it would flatten the pitch a bit).
Before you order new bellows it might be worth making up a 25 mm folded thin card mock-up of a section of bellows and looking to see if it would contact the reed blocks when held in place.
-
That is an excellent observation Steve and the possibility of the folds engaging the reeds hadn't occurred to me. Thanks
-
The quick answer is no.
You have less than 10mm clearance top and bottom on the bass block, which extends (albeit not far) into the bellows space, and next to nothing at the sides.
On the treble end you have less than 10mm on the sides, nearer 5mm, and 10mm or less on top which includes room for reed and valve travel.
Malcolm
-
Actually the basic cardboard of the bellows is not bad. The real bugbear is the white cloth stuff (NCB knows what it's called) that they used for gussets and for the corners, which makes the average colander or sieve appear airtight by comparison.
Unfortunately (on a sample of one) the glue used to fix this stuff is probably the strongest and most durable part of the entire box and I couldn't figure out how to shift it without wrecking the cardboard. But by the time that's a problem it's all getting a bit major anyway.
-
You just beat me to the draw Malcolm. Having pulled one of them apart it's very clear that there is no room for bigger folds. Silly thing is I hadn't given that aspect any thought.
-
Well, while I had the box apart, there was a reed that hadn't been working for ages (as I couldn't be bothered to open it just for that). Quick ping and it's happy again.
-
Just a thought, anyone know of another bellows maker who might do smaller folds....(better to die an optimist)
-
Actually the basic cardboard of the bellows is not bad. The real bugbear is the white cloth stuff (NCB knows what it's called) that they used for gussets and for the corners, which makes the average colander or sieve appear airtight by comparison.
Unfortunately (on a sample of one) the glue used to fix this stuff is probably the strongest and most durable part of the entire box and I couldn't figure out how to shift it without wrecking the cardboard. But by the time that's a problem it's all getting a bit major anyway.
Yes - the white cloth stuff is awful. I fixed one of these boxes for a friend a couple of years ago. The gussets were split and leaking badly so I patched them with some skived thin leather patches which I cut from thin leather supplied by Mark Adey (https://concertina-spares.com/product-category/replacement-concertina-bellows/repair-parts-concertina-bellows/leather-repair-concertina-parts/?v=3a52f3c22ed6) for mending concertina bellows. It bulked up the bellows a bit, but it stopped the leaks and was quite flexible.
-
It isn't any harder to make bellows with shallow folds, just different layout of the folds. I have also made replacement bellows for view cameras. Even tapered shapes are possible. While the camera bellows don't have to be airtight, they must be light tight. They also have no gussets.
-
Igor doesn't have folded card smaller than 25mm, PV, that's the problem, and having read plenty of posts on the subject here on Melnet the thought of attempting to make a set of bellows fills me with dismay, not to say terror :-\
-
Actually the basic cardboard of the bellows is not bad. The real bugbear is the white cloth stuff (NCB knows what it's called)
Jaconette !
-
Hi Nick! I just managed to avoid reactivating the old 'Chanson' thread with this post...I'm going to try and fit leather gussets from the inside of the bellows, leaving the jaconette in place and glueing the leather to it. Think it will work? (You can probably tell that I'm bored witless at the moment)
-
There is a material called "Goldbeaters' Skin", or something like that. Charlie used to sell it as Zephyr IIRC (may still do) which is astonishingly thin and strong.
Just a thought, it might do what you need without too much bulk.
If you decide to go with leather, Concertina Spares (https://concertina-spares.com) used to sell some very thin leather for repairs. Rather easier to handle.
-
Thanks Malcolm..I'll chase that up..
-
Hi Brian,
I don't understand when you say leave the jaconette in place and fit the leather gussets from the inside. Surely the leather should be on the outside. :o.
Don't be bored: there's plenty on here to amuse and educate.
-
Getting the jaconette off is a full bellows rebuild.
Putting the leather on the inside will work just just as well, but won't notice if you make a rough job of it.
Either way it will bulk up the bellows a bit.
Don't ask me how I know.
-
Don't you end up with jaconette on the pretty side then?
-
I've just won a kiddie box on eBay for a fiver, perfect test bed. PVA good as an adhesive Malcolm? Can't face leathering the outside Nick what with repapering the folds etc. I remember your problems with making bellows Nick, even with your bookbinding skills and machinery at your disposal. I think it shortened your life a bit... ;)
-
Too true Brian! PVA is good but make sure it's not woodworking stuff. It's very brittle.
Paste is ideal, but you need patience. Quite a long drying time but you get to able to move it about for sometime if needs be.
-
I would be tempted to use something like Bostik, a contact adhesive, but use it wet to allow positioning. I used pearl glue, but I think that would be difficult doing it from the inside.
-
Hmmm, pearl glue! Put some gelatine in it, keeps it flexible.
-
Did Theo once say that chamois leather was not suitable for gussets because it wasn't airtight or wasn't thin enough?
-
I did, and its probably too thick as well.
Pneumatic lamb is the leather you want, soft flexible and airtight. Available from organ builders suppliers like Russells (http://www.russels.com/pipeorgan.php). You will have to buy a whole skin, so you will have enough to offer a service to other toy melodeon owners. Charlie sells leather gusset diamonds which would also be ok.
-
Thanks Theo.
-
Something like this from Pittards would also be suitable https://www.pittards.com/shop/leather-skin-ivory-economy?___SID=U
-
Gets better all the time! Thanks Theo
-
£6 a skin! Bargain!
-
Quick update...replacing the gussets from the inside has proved impossible so I've stripped the tape and bellows paper off and am in the process of fitting gussets of pneumatic lamb skin over the existing Jaconite. Having fitted half a dozen I've started to worry as to whether I should have covered the edge of the bellows (that will eventually be covered by the metal corners) with the lamb skin.. The glue used in these bellows is totally unmovable by the way, an attempt to remove one of the original gussets for a pattern looked like destroying the bellows entirely so I gave up....
-
Either corners or leather. If you use leather, the corners will bulk up and metal corners won't fit.
-
Thanks Malcolm
-
Agree with Malcolm here Brian .
You've set yourself a really tedious task, like working in a car factory. Same thing..repeat.. same thing .. repeat and you're not even getting paid for it!
NOW PEDANT ALERT. It's Jaconette, not to be confused with Jacobite or gelignite.. that could get you into a lot of trouble. 🙉
-
£6 a skin! Bargain!
If you want longer strips etc it might have a few blemishes. Here is a bigger one....
https://www.pittards.com/shop/black-leather-skin-55mm
If you are day trippable to Yeovil Pittards is worth a visit, though it has to be said they don't seem as knowledgeable about the skins as I had hoped. You have to go and rummage...
-
Morning Nick, I can cope with boring, endless gussets (56) , stripping tape and bellows paper etc, what I wasn't up for was trying to make the actual bellow. Thing with the endless gussets was that I got better all the time. Sadly only the last few looked pretty good. Roger, I got all 56 gussets out of a £6 skin with enough over for another 20 or so. Now I'm looking for an alternative to metal corners to replace the tape originals, but I think that's a wish too far..... ::)
-
Morning Nick, I can cope with boring, endless gussets (56) , stripping tape and bellows paper etc, what I wasn't up for was trying to make the actual bellow. Thing with the endless gussets was that I got better all the time. Sadly only the last few looked pretty good. Roger, I got all 56 gussets out of a £6 skin with enough over for another 20 or so. Now I'm looking for an alternative to metal corners to replace the tape originals, but I think that's a wish too far..... ::)
Excellent! Did you need to skive the edge of the gussets or was the leather thin enough as it was?
-
No skiving required Roger, it's very thin indeed...
-
I've also been putzing around inside these toy melodeons; I bought an old beater 3v1r melodeon off of ebay and discovered it was in the key of G and decided to take its reeds and put them into the toy one, for a lark. They're not actually better reeds really, but they are more evenly responsive, so, not nearly as nice as a hohnerised one I'm sure but still an upgrade. I took the 'worse' set of 3 from my beater, and have converted one toy box to, for the time being anyway, a one voice with flat mounted reeds (and 3rd button start with a low E).
Obviously, the bellows are still leaky and awful though, and I remembered reading this thread. Considering how straight forward it seemed to do as a layperson, I'd offer an idea to consider: perhaps it would make more sense to simply design a replacement reed block that wouldn't foul against the edges of some nicer bellows with 25mm folds?
-
Good morning Gena, around a couple of years ago we had a thread running on Melnet headed ' Chanson' after the name of one of the kiddies toy melodeons. The thread ran for ages and wise old greybeards were driven to do ridiculous mods to these toys. Nick Collis Bird made replacement bellows and had to be locked in very quiet room for ages, Malcolm Bebb invented an alternative air button and I stripped the plastic and polished the carcass. All in all it left a few of us a little unwell. I've suffered a nasty relapse on the bellows front as you can see by reading back on this thread. Now you rock up with ideas on replacement reed blocks. Have you no plty? :'(
-
I've also been putzing around inside these toy melodeons;
Oh dear, Gena, so soon - and in one so young! But welcome to the Chanson club anyway ;D >:E
The treble reed block isn't very big and I think you'd end up with something very skinny - but I think your method of flat mounting is where I'd look first. (Good to see you Saturday BTW!)
Malcolm
-
Good morning Gena, around a couple of years ago we had a thread running on Melnet headed ' Chanson' after the name of one of the kiddies toy melodeons. The thread ran for ages and wise old greybeards were driven to do ridiculous mods to these toys. Nick Collis Bird made replacement bellows and had to be locked in very quiet room for ages, Malcolm Bebb invented an alternative air button and I stripped the plastic and polished the carcass. All in all it left a few of us a little unwell. I've suffered a nasty relapse on the bellows front as you can see by reading back on this thread. Now you rock up with ideas on replacement reed blocks. Have you no plty? :'(
Ah Brian , I designed the air button from model aircraft parts.
Now, I don't see any reason why a full set of cheap melodeon bellows couldn't be utilised using the two ends of the chanson. It would look pretty odd but there again aren't we all?
-
Oh of course you did Nick...it's all coming back to me now like one of those rum induced dreams. That Malcolm is getting far too much credit what with his Koch and all....
-
I did cut a lever from a bass set to make a Hohner style air button. Bit flimsy but works.
-
That sounds good Malcolm, could you post a photo?
-
That's got me thinking,Nick! I've repapered and gusseted the Chanson bellows and they have got very stiff indeed. Can't think what they'll be like when the corners and tape are fitted... I guess a couple of suitably engineered blanks on the Chanson ends to marry them to a set of cheepo bellows....it's my 80th birthday so I feel empowered to follow through with some daft ideas..and someone has just added a shot of Pussers rum to my coffee...
-
Many happy returns Brian, being a navy man a spot of grog works wonders.
-
Good morning Gena...
Have you no pity? :'(
I certainly don't! I've since found & read through that whole thread and am positively bursting with ideas. Was very impressed with Nick's bellows and Malcolm's air button mods, but I feel like a good amount of half measures could be achieved with a little bit of alternative thinking and eschewing years of accepted wisdom.
I am of course barking up trees best left unbarked, but there's really no helping me now!
-
There is a God! We've waited ages for a mildly mad lady to join the Cult of Chanson and our prayers have been answered... >:E
-
That sounds good Malcolm, could you post a photo?
Your wish, etc...
The mech was sawn from a spare set. The actuating wire from the button was bent and crimped on the lever using pliers, then fixed with epoxy and eventually cut to length. The button is just a bass button, a bit big but I had one spare...
Crude but it works.
The cutout in the back panel limits the travel.
PS those filaments of hot glue are really hard to see in the flesh!! ???
PPS the pallet is a sawn down bass pallet.
-
That's looks good Malcolm