Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Mike Mccarthy on June 11, 2017, 01:18:04 PM
-
by John Kirkpatrick. Sorry if this has been asked, I did a brief search, but my search skills are weak.
Seems this melodeon bug has bitten me good, so was thinking of getting some more teaching material. I am currently working my way through George Garsides book, and am happy with that, but am thinking about the next stage. I think I've boiled it down to either Ed Rennies book/DVD, or the J Kirkpatrick one. I'm a bit fan of JK's playing (naturally) and his on stage presenting style is really good, so I hope his teaching style is similar, but I just wanted to know before I decided one way or the other whether the JK DVD also comes with a printable PDF or similar? Something with the tunes on is basically what I want to know.
-
Mike, its a wee bit early to be thinking of further learning material ! Suggest you work through my book page by page rather than dipping in and when you get to the end start again at the beginning and work through again as a sort of consolidation period.
don't know much about JK's dvd but can certainly recommend Ed's book as a more long term project but only once you have got the basics well sorted!
george ;)
-
George, it sounds to me that Mike is 'working his way through' rather than dipping in and out. Also we know that he has some transferable skills, and we know how the bug bites at the early stage.
I wouldn't have thought it was too soon to have a range of inputs. Sometimes we can only find out for ourselves that the next development is a bit further away than we thought.
This is from a position of ignorance about all three methods as I don't know the books, but I would encourage the thirst. Although I invested in the Milleret Pignol methods I'm not using them fully yet as I have holes in my techniques. I am using some of the Milleret videos occasionally, though my 2+2 row is not ideally suited for them.
Maybe I should have started with your book.
Good luck, Mike.
-
thanks George, will have more of a look at the rennie material.
And thanks P&T, I am pretty methodical at most things, I think it's a hangover from my early working life when I trained as an engineer and then later as an accountant (I am not proud of the latter, but it paid well for very little real work). I tend to work at one thing till I get it right then move on to the next. Another hang over from this is I generally don't make rush decisions, but like to mull things over for a while, get as much info as I can. Hence asking now.
-
I learnt from the JK DVD about six years ago and I think it's superb. It's very methodical and takes you from scratch to a really advanced level going from a one row in D to a two row DG. As you would expect his personable style makes it very watchable. I didn't get any printed resources with my copy but he teaches each tune very clearly and I found it to be good exercise in learning tunes by ear.
Dave
-
I was going to say "Put it in the machine and press 'Play'" but that would be unhelpful and juvenile in the extreme... >:E
-
thanks dave T, I suspected he would have a great teaching style.
baz, I have a post graduate degree in being juvenile and and many years real life experience in being unhelpful in the extreme, so it would be churlish of me to deny others the opportunities life has given me.
-
You are a Civil Servant? >:E
-
Department of circumlocution!