Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Robert Sehy on July 01, 2017, 03:24:15 PM

Title: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 01, 2017, 03:24:15 PM
I just acquired a 1960s vintage Paolo Soprano 2 voice 21/8 button accordion in Bb/f tuning.  I actually bought it assuming it was a 3 voice, but was surprised to find it as a two voice. It has a stepped keyboard.  I bought it hoping to convert the keyboard to a flat, and then change to some semi-tone tuning.
I can't seem to find much on Paolo 2 voices...were they uncommon?  Otherwise, a beautiful box in surprisingly excellent condition for its age.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: pgroff on July 01, 2017, 03:49:51 PM
Hi Robert,

Congratulations! I think I saw that one on ebay for a while, & it looked like a really nice one.  They sound wonderful and are great to play when they're in good shape.

There were many types of 2 voice Paolo Sopranis made over the last century.

Here's a 2 voice F Bb Paolo that I once owned, similar to yours I think.  Does yours have the metal-edged button tops like this one?

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: triskel on July 01, 2017, 06:19:59 PM
I can't seem to find much on Paolo 2 voices...were they uncommon?

The answer to that would depend on where the box came from, and when it was made, because different countries/importers/markets, in different years, demanded different models - and those that Irish-style players consider "normal" weren't even catalogue options!

Paolo Soprani catalogues from the 1950s/'60s list only diatonic accordions with 21 buttons and stepped keyboards, and only the 2-voice version has no couplers, 3-voice ones were usually LMM, and the 4-voice one came with 12 basses...

Meanwhile I have two 2-voice ones myself, both with flat keyboards and made for the Irish-American market.

The 2-row one came from Boston and was made (in D/C#) about 1949-50. It has only 19 treble buttons and 4 basses:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/p10100062.jpg)

Whilst this 10-key, 4-bass, in D was made for Italian Accordion Mfg. Co. in Chicago, about 1953-4:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/007-6.jpg)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 02, 2017, 12:07:06 AM
Thanks for the info...Paul, it does indeed have the metal edge buttons like the one pictured. It seems to be identical.  It is not the one from eBay, this one actually came from Florida.  The original owner asked his sister to buy him an accordion when she was visiting in Italy (sometime in the 1960s), and she brought him this one on her return.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 02, 2017, 03:10:55 AM
It does look like a beauty, Robert. World class. As a diato player, I would cherish it as is -- F/Bb is a great key set, with the F row being so low --  but I understand you may have semi-tonic needs. No judgement. Congratulations on your acquisition.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 02, 2017, 02:53:13 PM
I play Irish B/C, but it might be interesting to try it as is. However, I know nothing about what music works for this key, can anyone suggest a book/tutor?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 02, 2017, 05:55:43 PM
I use my f/Bb/Eb box as a transposing box. Things that I play on the G/C, I transfer over to the flat box to place it into different keys. Aside from just the sonic difference, it's genuinely useful if you are playing with horns, or if you are playing with singers who ask for shifts in keys to suit their range.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: triskel on July 02, 2017, 07:22:38 PM
... I know nothing about what music works for this key, can anyone suggest a book/tutor?

Robert, I think you'll find there's a big difference in approach between these and the semitone-tuned boxes, and these are simpler in concept. So that whilst the general intention (in Irish and Scottish playing) with the semitone-apart boxes (B/C. C#/D, D/D#, D/C#, B/C/C# etc.) is to use them in whatever fingering they require to play together in the "concert pitch" fiddle keys, the fourth-apart system instruments are (as Gary said in his reply) basically transposing instruments, to play in different keys with the same fingering. So a book/tutor for one system can work equally well for any other, as long as you press the (relative) same buttons.

What's happened with them is that different countries/regions adopted different "national" key systems over the years, so that D/G is the accepted norm in England, G/C in France, C/F in Germany etc., and those are the keys you'll find instructional material for.

I hope this makes sense...  ???
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 03, 2017, 01:17:50 AM
Right, but who plays in Bb/F?  And does this key combination finger the same as A/D, C/F, etc.?  Would a tutor in those keys work for Bb/F? I was considering converting it, but may offer it up for sale if that proves unrealistic.  Im kinda of enamored with B/C!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 03, 2017, 02:33:35 AM
Exactly, Robert, the fingerings transfer. I am not trying to talk you out of B/C. There is a new vogue for "flat sessions" that feature Bb instruments. Typically, brass players show up. Also, Tex Mex players use F/Bb boxes pretty regularly.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: triskel on July 03, 2017, 03:14:06 AM
Right, but who plays in Bb/F?

Presumably the inside row is Bb and the outside one is F? In which case the box should be described as F/Bb (otherwise you've got something pretty weird there...  ???)

Not a whole heap of people, and nobody who plays Irish traditional music

Quote
And does this key combination finger the same as A/D, C/F, etc.?  Would a tutor in those keys work for Bb/F?

F/Bb fingers the same, in fact the whole thing would be a tone down from the G/C system that is the commonest in France, Holland, Scandinavia, and also Italy.

Quote
I was considering converting it, but may offer it up for sale if that proves unrealistic.

It can be done, but it's a big job. It's not just a matter of changing the reeds, but also converting to a flat keyboard - which is a big hassle!

I'm in a similar dilemma about what to do with a 21-key, 2-coupler, 3-voice, G/C "pepperpot grille" (like the black 10-key in my photo) Paolo Soprani at the moment. Though if I do convert it, it'd probably be to G/G#, which was a popular system in the 1940s/'50s. (Both Paddy O'Brien, from Nenagh, and Joe Burke started off on it!)

Quote
Im kinda of enamored with B/C!

I'd be more into C#/D and D/D# boxes myself, for the old "press and draw" style of Joe Cooley, Tony MacMahon, Jackie Daly & co.

Mind you, those have also been used as "transposing boxes" by some great players. Jimmy Shand sometimes played a C#/D Hohner Erica as a "bothy box", either in D on the inside row, or in A and E "across the rows" in B/C fingering, and the great Finbarr Dwyer loved to play a D/D# box in B/C fingering, so that he was in F instead of D: Finbarr Dwyer with Brian McGrath Geantraí na Nollag 2007 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDBYlGAD-l0)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Stiamh on July 03, 2017, 02:32:29 PM
You might consider converting it into A/A#, Robert. You could leave the inside row as it is (Bb = A#), which would leave you to find a set of A reeds for the outer row. 

Since you are a B/C player, this would give you a "C" box - one tone below your normal B/C. A nice low sound that would be enjoyable to play at home and handy if you ever come across "C sessions", as I do occasionally, usually arranged to accommodate players who have sets of pipes, and sometimes flutes, in C.

I have a 2-v Paolo Soprani that has been converted from F/Bb to A/A# in this way. Since my usual style is C#/D, it gives me a "Bb box".
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: mory on July 03, 2017, 03:05:13 PM
Then there's this perspective

"Since releasing my first solo album Tarantella in 1994 I have made many different recordings but began to feel the need to make another record of my accordion playing after starting to explore the interesting possibilities of an A and B flat tuned keyboard. I have not changed any of the keys of the tunes on this record but instead, have enjoyed using a range of new fingering patterns thrown up by thinking a tone higher than normal to produce the old notes.
I recorded the tunes with Junior Davey over two days at Doolittle recording studios Co Sligo in a playing marathon I am unlikely to repeat. As a result the playing is raw, spontaneous and full of life. I'm especially grateful to the contributions of Seamie O'Dowd and Dennis Cahill whose accompaniment and musicianship helped turn this feast of Irish accordion playing into a wonderful listening experience."

Luke Daniels referring to the Mighty Box double CD album played on a 2 voice AA# Briggs
All the Best mory
http://www.copperplatemailorder.com/shop/accordion/luke-daniels-the-mighty-box/
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 03, 2017, 03:57:24 PM
Wow. That is amazing.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Stiamh on July 03, 2017, 04:20:09 PM
Wow. That is amazing.

Yes it is, but perhaps not quite as amazing as it might sound to someone who's never experimented with a semitone box. He's playing everything a tone higher - which is exactly what, for example, a C#/D player has to do to play tunes in their proper keys on a B/C box. Takes a bit of adjustment but after a while, you're off. Though maybe not with the speed, fluidity and aplomb of Luke Daniels!*  (:)

I'd be interested to know how the keyboard is laid out - i.e. what button start. On a "normal" layout he'd be missing a few notes up at the top of the range.

* Note to self: try some D tunes in F# major on the C#/D this evening and report back - to self.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: mory on July 03, 2017, 05:54:51 PM
He's on Facebook Stiamh give him a message, sure he wouldn't mind, he's a lovely friendly bloke. AtB mory
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 03, 2017, 07:20:07 PM
Yes, I have considered having the box re-tuned A#/A, and being able to play in C. I also play the uilleann pipes, and do play flat sets in B and C, as well as the standard concert pitch D sets, so a box in C would suit the flat set well. The challenge of course is converting the fingerboard from stepped to flat.  I may attempt it myself, and have been researching the different methods used to do it.  I also have a 1930s Hohner pre-corse, which I am restoring, it is an A/D box, but may end up as C#/D.
All fun stuff.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: triskel on July 04, 2017, 12:41:14 AM
Yes, I have considered having the box re-tuned A#/A ...

Presumably you mean A/A#?

It may seem pedantic, but it's even more important to get it the right way around with semitone-tuned boxes because the earliest ones actually had the rows the other way round and, for example, C/B boxes were in use for at least three-quarters of a century before B/C even got invented... In fact I have an 1850's box by Anthony Faas of Philadelphia (that is the subject of the first US Accordion Patent) which switches the inside row between F and B, so it can be played in C/F, or C/B tuning. C/B used to be a regular system in France and Northern Italy, where it often got combined with the still-popular G/C tuning to create G/C/B boxes.

Whilst in Irish music you get C#/D, but the popular system with the old Irish-American players was D/C# - the opposite way around! (And I know several people who play both systems!)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 04, 2017, 01:02:50 AM
yep meant  A/A#!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Stiamh on July 04, 2017, 02:06:28 PM
Wow. That is amazing.
Yes it is, but perhaps not quite as amazing as it might sound to someone who's never experimented with a semitone box.

Having experimented briefly with the fingering involved, I will qualify my qualification. It _is_ pretty amazing.

Playing in D major on an A/A# box (E major for a B/C player or F# major for a C#/D player) is like stepping through the looking glass into a world where the rules are different and everything makes sense, but not by the rules of the world you know. The main thing I noticed is that while this fingering puts most notes on the pull it significantly removes the push F# roadblock / issue / feature that B/C players have to deal with when playing in D. Result: extreme fluidity and you can see why Luke D would find it refreshing, once he had got his head around it (which I am quite sure he did rather more quickly than I would).

It's rather like playing in A on the B/C (a few too many notes only available on the draw) but here the magic notes of A and D give some interesting choices. (And of course to play in G major on an A/A# box, you have to adopt A major (for B/C players) fingering.)

I tried some Dmix tunes and it was like exploring Finbarr Dwyer tunes in their original keys, i.e. seriously weird. The Colliers Reel - you can play one whole long phrase on the pull and then the next phrase (bar a quick reversal here and there) all on the push. The genius/lunacy of the semitone diatonic taken to the extreme.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Robert Sehy on July 04, 2017, 10:46:38 PM
Stiamh, did you convert the stepped keyboard to flat on that Paolo?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Stiamh on July 05, 2017, 01:40:27 PM
Stiamh, did you convert the stepped keyboard to flat on that Paolo?

Yes, it was converted, though not by me. I bought the box as a project from Paul Groff, who had had a replacement aluminium keyboard plate made but hadn't gone further than that. The levers on my box are wooden and my repair tech did his best with them. In the end he glued new buttons onto the lever ends. The conversion was not entirely successful in my view because I ended up with an action that is higher than I would have liked.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: pgroff on July 06, 2017, 12:20:25 AM
Hi Steve and all,

Sorry to hear that the converted Paolo still doesn't have the "set up" the way you would like it. I wish I had been able to finish that job myself but I had to sell it as a project, at the low ebb of my finances and time/space to work on instruments.

This example shows that there is a lot of custom work (and then sometimes, re-work) to convert a keyboard and then to perfect its set-up.

The best solution to the buttons on that (Steve's) conversion being too high, IMO, would be to change to buttons that are shorter in height, or to sand the existing buttons from the underside to a shorter dimension (thinner, top-to-bottom). I supplied those buttons, as well as the keyboard plate (all made to my specs by superb machinist Henry Szostek). So I could have asked for the buttons to be made shorter, but didn't want them too short -- then the buttons wouldn't be able to project high *enough* above the keyboard plate for some tastes (including mine, because I had hoped to keep that one).

The geometry of the action on an  "enclosed lever, flat keyboard" accordion," with levers under a flat keyboard plate to which are glued buttons that project through holes in the plate, puts a limit on how high you can raise the buttons. Obviously you don't want the levers themselves to hit the underside of that plate, in the region near the buttons where the keyboard isn't drilled for the button holes. Some players like the buttons to extend well above that keyboard plate (for example, in a recent discussion of Primatonas, Mike Hirst was asking how to raise the height of the buttons above the keyboard, and I'm finding the button height on my Amatona is also a little low for me).  So to accommodate that preference, the buttons have to be thick enough.

It is sometimes possible to lower the height of the buttons (without changing their dimensions directly) by adjusting the pallet levers (depending on the geometry of the rest of the box). But Steve's little Paolo has an action with an older design, so I think there may not be sufficient room in the keyboard housing under the wooden levers for those levers to travel substantially deeper. In that case, changing the heights of the individual buttons would be the best way to achieve his target set-up.

To repeat (and as I cautioned Robert via email), there's a lot of custom work needed to complete any of these stepped-to-flat conversions!

PG

edited to add:

Just for brainstorming. One other way to lower the effective button height on an instrument like this would be to shim under the keyboard plate, raising that plate relative to the plane of the button tops. In the case of Steve's instrument, the keyboard plate is part of a rather complex and partly-curved piece of aluminum so the entire piece might have to be modified slightly (or switched for another one) to try this solution - thus I'd recommend changing the button thickness instead.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani 2 Voice
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 06, 2017, 03:24:57 AM
This is a great thread. I am learning a huge amount. Carry on.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal