Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 06:43:15 PM

Title: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 06:43:15 PM
Hi all,

We've often discussed the Irish-American accordions here, including those sold by Baldoni-Bartoli & Co, NY in the 1920s and 1930s. (Others were sold by Walters, Superior, Butti, etc and a search of this forum will bring up multiple discussion threads for each of those labels, in addition to general discussions). Some of them were made to very high standards of quality for professional use, and reflected innovations in materials and design as well as wonderful workmanship.

Some of the parts for these boxes were imported from Europe (and complete instruments in some cases), but some instruments seem to have been assembled, completed, or at least decorated in New York.  Almost every individual Irish-American Baldoni-Bartoli accordion that we've found from the early years (late 1920s to early 1930s)  has some unique features - no two are exactly alike.  In addition to the customized engraving, and the choices of voicing and button layout to suit each customer, the makers seem to have been experimenting with different types of action and other subtle design features. Few of them are marked with serial numbers or dates, and even when dates are present they may not always reflect the initial construction (they may be dates of a re-sale or repair). So those of us who are interested in their history are usually tentative in assigning dates to them. Oral history and photographs help. But mainly we rely on trends in a variety of constructional features, which enable us to roughly organize them into groups. This is a very approximate classification because it's probable that there was a lot of chronological overlap - at any one time there were probably a variety of different "types" of boxes for sale at the Baldoni-Bartoli shop, based on what was available to them and to cater to various tastes of the customers.

A newly discovered Baldoni brought to mind something that I've often noticed: the layout of the bass and chord reeds can be a great clue - a great "taxonomic character" - in classifying these instruments and moving toward an understanding of who made them, where, and when.

In this thread, over the next few posts, I'll compare the bass reed layout of the "Jack" Baldoni (which has some features intermediate between most of the metal-grille Baldonis and the celluloid-grille Baldonis) with some other instruments. The instruments themselves are currently in my collection except for the Cunningham and McNulty Baldonis. The photo of the McNulty Baldoni is from Ted McGraw*  The photo of the McAleer box is from Ray Dempsey. The photos of the Cunningham box (like the others) are by me.

First, here's the public face of the  "Jack" Baldoni, shown next to the F. Likely box which was probably made earlier.

PG

*http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Mas_Baldoni.html (http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Mas_Baldoni.html)
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 06:45:22 PM
Here are some bass layouts for other Baldonis.

First, the Likely Baldoni and the very similar (but unlabeled) McAleer box.

PG
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 06:49:37 PM
Now, Here are the bass reed layouts from two Baldonis that may possibly have been made a little later, the McNulty box and the Cunningham box.

Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 06:54:37 PM
Next, here are the bass reed layouts of the "Jack" Baldoni and the J.J. Dwyer Baldoni.

Both these instruments are unrestored at present.
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 07:03:22 PM
OK friends, see a match?

BTW, more photos of all these boxes (except the recently discovered "Jack" box) can be found on Ted McGraw's pages, as well as in other discussions here on melodeon.net:

http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Mas_Baldoni.html
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_-_White.html
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_-_Black.html


 ;)
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: hickory-wind on July 14, 2017, 07:36:46 PM
Here are pics of a one row Butti & Son in D -most likely made by Walters. It has two bass buttons. Its aluminum 'soundboard' is stamped 805 with matching 805 hand written on the interior. Probably later than what you are looking for Paul. What is your guess on its date?

Scott

BellingersButtonBoxes.com (http://BellingersButtonBoxes.com)
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 07:53:13 PM
Hi Scott,

Interesting, but as you know, that box is not a "1920s - early 1930s Baldoni" as specified in the topic subject and OP.

There are some general similarities to early Baldonis in the construction of the postwar Walters / Superior / Butti boxes - but those similarities don't help us classify and date the 1920s - early 1930s Baldonis.

I thought about starting a more general topic about bass reed layouts in the "Instrument Design, Construction, and Repair" subforum, but here was my thought:

My particular interest here is to identify particular Models (or clustered "types") of the early Baldonis, so it should go in the "Makes and Models" subforum.

Maybe we should start a general topic on bass reed layouts in that other subforum?

Re: your Butti (maybe made by Superior / Umbriaco?), We have few numbers correlated with confirmed dates. We do know that Walters No. 754 was sold in 1950. Your Butti is probably mid 1950s or late 1950s. Shake it!

Best,

PG
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 14, 2017, 08:05:52 PM
OK friends, see a match?
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: mory on July 15, 2017, 08:20:21 AM
Cunningham and Jack?
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 15, 2017, 08:50:07 AM
Hi mory,

We have a winner! As with the Likely / McAleer pair, the Cunningham and "Jack" boxes have that resemblance in bass reed layout.

The photo of the "Jack" box's bass reeds looks a little different because of its shallower folds of the bellows (which I think were replaced at some point).  The other 5 boxes have bellows with deep folds and most of those deep-fold bellows, or maybe all of them, are probably the originals.

In some other ways the Cunningham box is closer to the Likely & McAleer boxes. And in some ways the "Jack" box has features in common with the later celluloid-grille Baldonis.


PG


Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: mory on July 15, 2017, 10:32:06 AM
Do you think the keyboard is original on the Jack box Paul or just a transition box, with the cream colour it almost looks out of place, having seen the pics of the "usual" black box and black keyboard combination. AtB mory
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 15, 2017, 02:37:54 PM
Hi mory,

I think the "Jack's" keyboard is original (both the housing and the top keyboard plate). The keyboard plate is exactly fitted to the housing, and the housing is fitted just right to the body with the same bluish/grey/green celluloid running around it. All looks proper. On the other hand, this is an example of a box whose keyboard plate was probably replaced or reworked:

http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Mas_Baldoni.html

You're right that some later Irish-American boxes often have the keyboard plate color-matched to the rest of the box, but not always. You do see white keyboards in conjunction with grey, black, or colored celluloid even in the early years. For example this box that I've only seen from Ted's webpage:

http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_-_White_files/FinnertyBB1.jpg

But the treble buttons on "Jack" may not be original. Could be that those original treble buttons were the screw-center type, like the 2 bass buttons.  There's also some irregularity to the holes around the buttons suggesting re-working.

Many of the players (as today) did prefer the larger buttons with no screws, so that would have been a plausible modification.  Baldoni-Bartoli boxes that (I think) were made just after this, with celluloid grilles, were made from new with those larger flat buttons without screws through the top.

The grille ("gallery") of the Jack box is unusually nice for a metal-grille Baldoni  I'm sure it was made just for this instrument and is original. I don't think I've seen this pattern on a Baldoni before, but still it looked familiar to me - because its design elements are those seen in some PA grilles used by Paolo Soprani and others:

http://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/opMAAOSwjRpZSWoF/s-l1600.jpg

http://www.baldoni.com/P1010047.JPG



Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: triskel on July 22, 2017, 02:46:47 AM
The grille ("gallery") of the Jack box is unusually nice for a metal-grille Baldoni  I'm sure it was made just for this instrument and is original. I don't think I've seen this pattern on a Baldoni before, but still it looked familiar to me - because its design elements are those seen in some PA grilles used by Paolo Soprani and others:

http://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/opMAAOSwjRpZSWoF/s-l1600.jpg

http://www.baldoni.com/P1010047.JPG

It may be worth mentioning that I have an undated 1920's Baldoni, Bartoli illustrated catalogue that lists only Paolo Soprani accordions - so they evidently did a lot of business together...
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: triskel on August 21, 2017, 03:42:14 PM
Next, here are the bass reed layouts of the "Jack" Baldoni and the J.J. Dwyer Baldoni.

I got photos of my old Baldoni last night, showing that it has the bass reedblocks set up similarly to the J. J. Dwyer box - which it has other similarities to, and is probably contemporary with.
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on August 21, 2017, 05:24:01 PM
Next, here are the bass reed layouts of the "Jack" Baldoni and the J.J. Dwyer Baldoni.

I got photos of my old Baldoni last night, showing that it has the bass reedblocks set up similarly to the J. J. Dwyer box - which it has other similarities to, and is probably contemporary with.

Hi triskel,

I agree! Very similar except in color and a couple of decorative details. In my opinion, your (former) box should be classified with the J. J. Dwyer box and other similar ones (flags on the keyboard, celluloid grille where present, decorated celluloid rectangular plate on the top of the keyboard flanked by two additional separate pieces). Ted has classified your former one with the other "white" Baldonis, but those other early white / yellow pearl Baldonis have flags on the front of the casework and metal grilles, and usually screw-center buttons.

IMO the Radiotone Baldoni and the early black Carmody 1-row Baldoni (shown in the photo with Gene Kelly) are intermediate between the metal-grille Baldonis and the J. J. Dwyer box etc. The Radiotone for example has a single black celluloid plate on top of the keyboard.

The gorgeous Cleary Baldoni that just sold on ebay was also similar to yours and to the J. J. Dwyer box, except for the more complex keyboard profile. Thus it's closer to my black 13 key Baldoni and the white or yellow Jack Murphy box.

PG

Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: triskel on August 22, 2017, 12:31:35 AM
Ted has classified your former one with the other "white" Baldonis, but those other early white / yellow pearl Baldonis have flags on the front of the casework and metal grilles, and usually screw-center buttons.

Yes, on accordion-fashion grounds (the shape of the name-plate frame on the front of the treble casing and the "indicator") I reckoned mine was probably from the 1933-5 era.

Quote
The gorgeous Cleary Baldoni that just sold on ebay was also similar to yours and to the J. J. Dwyer box, except for the more complex keyboard profile. Thus it's closer to my black 13 key Baldoni and the white or yellow Jack Murphy box.

I had to go hunting for that auction (http://www.ebay.com/itm/Ornate-Vintage-Baldoni-Bartoli-Accordion-Irish-American-Flags-Jewels-Estate-Find-/362064800790?hash=item544cbe6c16%3Ag%3AjK8AAOSwr6RZidjf&nma=true&si=uXVGRlNvQbERdULf6QUbIXSETzE%253D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557) because (being limited to US sale only) it had never shown up in my searches. WOW, what a price it went for!  :o

And very similar to my old one, only in much better condition...
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: The Idle Rich on May 30, 2018, 04:23:29 PM
Bass reed layout on eight voice LLMMMMMM unrestored green and gold sparkle Baldoni Bartoli in D.

(http://i457.photobucket.com/albums/qq292/rchrss/DSCN5865_zpsynyb4wa6.jpg)

(http://i457.photobucket.com/albums/qq292/rchrss/DSCN5805_zpsee4slkdz.jpg)

(http://i457.photobucket.com/albums/qq292/rchrss/DSCN5682_zps8bgwg0fa.jpg)

(http://i457.photobucket.com/albums/qq292/rchrss/DSCN6755_zpsqf422nf8.jpg)

Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on May 30, 2018, 05:39:43 PM
Hi Rich,

Thanks for these great pics!

Because your Baldoni-Bartoli has the growl-box, this means that the air hole and the reeds for the basses and chords have to be laid out a bit differently than the others. However, there are some similarities of the bellows and the general reed-chamber construction between yours and the Cunningham box, etc.

I'll try to get up some interior pics of the bass side of the Globes (including the 6 voice Gold Medal Professional Deluxe) and the  O'Brady sonic blue (Walters?) boxes to compare with yours.

PG
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: triskel on May 30, 2018, 08:16:03 PM
Seeing this thread revived has reminded me that I'd meant to add the bass reed layout of the mini "Simon McArdle / M. J. Greaney" Walters to the gallery:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/059.jpg)
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: triskel on May 30, 2018, 08:22:18 PM
As well as Anders' black 1.3-row Baldoni, Bartoli (that was probably made by Iorio?):

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/045.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/046.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/044.jpg)

But that one is perhaps a bit later than you're wanting to consider here Paul?
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: tirpous on May 30, 2018, 08:53:21 PM
Funny how the Walters has the basses flat and the chords standing, while the Baldoni is (mostly) the other way.

Are these new reeds on the Baldoni ??
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on May 30, 2018, 08:57:11 PM
Hi triskel,

Thanks! Yes, I think Anders' black 13 key Baldoni-Bartoli is probably later than most of my original focus here but still very interesting. As we've discussed before, that one has a grille design that is related to (but transformed relative to) the Madden Walters box - so it's interesting to compare with the Madden box and also with a black 13-key Baldoni that is more similar to the JJ Dwyer box and your former blond one.

The Simon McArdle / Greaney Walters is interesting, in part because its trim and decoration are so similar to the Fitzgerald Walters (wish we had internal pics of that one), which in turn would be interesting to compare to Rich's 8 voice Baldoni.

In  sum, now we have a few "survey markers" here, different designs of the bass-side reeds that can serve as references when more info turns up. I'll get up pics of a few more for comparison when I can. 

PG

Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: 70stack@gmail.com on July 11, 2022, 02:33:16 PM
Afternoon! I'm a bit late to this thread but can anyone recommend tuning options for a 4 bass button baldoni in D/C#? I don't think I need thirds! The tuning i have is a mess!

Thanks
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: tirpous on July 11, 2022, 02:49:03 PM
Quote
Afternoon! I'm a bit late to this thread but can anyone recommend tuning options for a 4 bass button baldoni in D/C#? I don't think I need thirds! The tuning i have is a mess!

Not sure if you mean which basses/chords to have, or how to tune them.  Typically the 4 buttons are D/A (bass + chord) and D/G (bass + chord). 
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: 70stack@gmail.com on July 11, 2022, 03:06:25 PM
thanks! I've ended up with D/A and E/A but the chords have had some weird notes. I think it is a legacy of being changed to Csharp/D and back (and god knows what else)
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: 70stack@gmail.com on July 11, 2022, 03:08:09 PM
sorry, A/E, not E/A
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: pgroff on July 11, 2022, 06:03:07 PM
sorry, A/E, not E/A

That could be useful if you play a lot in the key of A major. With 4 basses you just have to choose which ones are more important.

A lot of the original 4 bass D/C# boxes had D/A and C#/G#, even if there were only a few buttons in the C# row (such as 10 + 3 on the melody side). Seems not a good use of those extra 2 basses to me.  I have a special box like that inherited from a friend and struggle with whether to leave it just as it was when he had it, or to reversibly swap out those C#/G# basses and chords.

As was mentioned earlier, D/A  D/G is common. I'd think D/A and G/G would be more useful.

D/A and A/E like you have would be good for playing in A. Maybe useful for a bit of accompaniment on E minor / E modal tunes if you take the third (G# note) out of the E triad.

I've also heard of D/A and F#/B

Some of the old time players on these boxes never played the left hand buttons, some played only the D/A bass and chords (sometimes sparsely, sometimes relentlessly), some just used the D/A bass button (not the chords) and others used mostly the D/A chord button and seldom if ever the bass button.

So it's really up to you; if you're sure the original layout has been modified then originality isn't an issue and you have the freedom to suit yourself!

PG

Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: 70stack@gmail.com on July 12, 2022, 08:16:34 PM
Thats great, really helpful.

Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: Lars on February 11, 2025, 07:35:15 AM
Here's the bass layout of the Jack Murphy, a late 20's Baldoni Bartoli - 6 voice treble.

The box: https://youtu.be/8vmzWQighrk
Title: Re: Bass reed layouts in the 1920s - early 1930s Baldoni Irish-American accordions
Post by: Lars on February 11, 2025, 08:44:53 AM
... and the (similar) bass setup of the P. J. Boyle (not mine) 8 voice Baldoni Bartoli. This one: https://youtu.be/NguuA6F7xfs?si=E1VsIZNOdPwZSV2r
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal