Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: GbH on July 27, 2009, 06:29:21 PM

Title: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: GbH on July 27, 2009, 06:29:21 PM
The references to music examinations on one of the other threads and got me thinking.  When I was school age I had some formal lessons, with the inevitable exams, on other instruments.  Although, in hindsight, my experiences of this weren't entirely positive*, it did at least present me with a logical order to learn in.  Subsequently, when I tried to teach myself other instruments, I followed a similar sort of pattern, something that seemed to work out more-or-less OK.  Although I didn't do exams on self-taught instruments, that exam structure still gave me some sort of path to follow.

Then, however, I start playing melodeon.  Suddenly, with this box thing, it feels like the rules have changed and that lots of things learnt previously either don't apply or take a different form.   Playing what's written on paper is now of little importance.  Much of the time, sight reading doesn't seem to be a particularly worthwhile skill.  Learning scales seems useful, but only in a special melodeon sort of way.  Music theory is apparently not so important either, yet I find myself thinking more about that than I ever have on any other instrument.  Perhaps most of all, the hunt to find and play 'more difficult' music no longer seems to make so much sense - the melodeon just doesn't seem to work like that.

The thing I'm now wondering is, though, how it is that people go about continuing to learn and improve.  So far, being relatively new to it, it's often seemed quite obvious which things I need to work on, but even then I'm often not sure whether I'm doing things in a sensible order or whether I'm missing important stuff or learning bad habits.  With the melodeon, it's often not so obvious to me what the next thing to learn should be.  Maybe I think about this stuff too much and should let things just happen?  On the other hand, if I don't think about it, isn't it probable that I'll just remain where I am with it?  I know the aim is to have fun with it, but surely the more technique you have, the better equiped you are to pursue that.

Any thoughts?


Guy

*  Years of piano lessons taught me only how to pass exams, but left me barely being to play anything at all.  I guess I just didn't get what the lessons were really about.

Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: ganderbox on July 27, 2009, 10:27:00 PM
I've been thinking about this one while cooking the dinner and having a  beer, and this is what I thought..

When you are taught say, piano or violin, you are given tunes which will help you to learn the instrument. The tunes are therefore secondary to the instrument.
People who pick up a melodeon generally do it so that they can play tunes (morris, Irish, whatever), and so learning the tunes rather than the instrument is the main purpose.
The melodeon isn't a classical instrument. There's no single "approved" way of playing it. There are many different styles, and how you play it is entirely dictated by what you want to play on it. There is thus no defined path to learning it as an instrument.

As for how to progress....without a teacher, mentor, or more experienced players around you who are prepared to pass on useful tips, it's difficult. Sometimes you just reach a plateau, and need some outside input to get you up the next step, in which case you can either wait for it to come along or go out and look for it. There are tutor books and DVD's, workshops and courses, and obviously just going to sessions and getting out with other players will help.

The thing is probably to know what you want to play, and then go out and learn about the music and how people who play it already do it, and the rest should follow.

Over to someone else for their thoughts....I'm off to get another beer.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Lizzy on July 27, 2009, 10:57:19 PM
A huge jump forward for myself was to learn to play across the rows as well as up and down them. This opened up more  chord structure and a smoother way of playing when its suits.  I would really like to play more blues numbers but not sure how to go about it. I suppose that is when a good knowledge of scales comes in handy.
I have the same piano experience (:)
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: risto on July 28, 2009, 08:56:19 AM

The thing I'm now wondering is, though, how it is that people go about continuing to learn and improve.  ....
Guy


Dissatisfaction to how I'm currently doing things and how my playing sounds is one important driving force for me. Also listening (and watching) to other players gives me direction of what/how to do and  - as importantly - what not to do. One also needs a goal or goals. Why am I and practising and where do I want it to lead me (realistically!)? The answer to that may change on the way but it's important to keep the motivation up.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: HallelujahAl on July 28, 2009, 09:16:04 AM
I think the thing that's driving me onward at the moment is the listening that I'm doing. The more good players I listen to the more I want to be able to emulate what I'm hearing. Another motivator and I hope assist, is Graeme's button-box workshop in September - the motivator is the fact that I don't want to make a complete ass of myself when I get there, and I want to be able to draw as much benefit from it as possible.
AL
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 28, 2009, 09:20:00 AM
Well I like to set myself targets..One big target and lotsa little ones to achieve on the way. I also give myself a target tune to play...something difficult usually. Then I email or post here for help.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: joe on July 28, 2009, 12:27:26 PM
I'm in a bit of a rut, I have a great new and totally different sounding/feeling melodeon, but keep playing the same old tunes. I work by hearing something and thinking 'I would love to play that', so I think I need some new influences.... particularly with tunes that use the extra buttons I seem to have acquired....(any advice here?)

This is the other difficulty, using the 2.5 row I am trying to learn new ways of playing across the rows, how to incorporate the new basses etc, its so much to take in, and difficult when I only have the odd half hour to practise.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: george garside on July 28, 2009, 12:42:27 PM
work out & then practice scales in the keys you wish to play iin in such a way as to get the best available  bass harmony  taking into account the practicality of air supply and maintaining reasonable fingering .  It should then be relatively easy to play tunes in these scales as the treble & bass button & bellows direction will become programmed in - with any luck! ;)

george
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 28, 2009, 12:42:29 PM
Scales are boring, but need to be practiced if you are into impro.  I'm currently learning the 'other two' half diminished on my F#GC 'systematically'. Magically you can then use the same notes over eg the whole common Bm, A7, D progression (got this sussed for G).

It's also doing me much good transposing all my songs (usually same chords but different places) to the French box.

I think more generally.. You stop moving forward when you stop learning new stuff. So I'm actively seeking that out. Present challenge is to make 'Take 5' work. I've then got a week in the Alps with Stéphane and Norbert end of August. You never know what they'll come out with!  A weekend at the Upton Jazz festival .. simply moved me on back to Wirral  :-\

IMHO row crossing playing is the single best step a melodeonist makes in his career.

Followed by 'playing in chords'.  PS - followed by 'uncrossing' for phrasing - no argument there!
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Sandy on July 28, 2009, 01:38:55 PM
IMHO row crossing playing is the single best step a melodeonist makes in his career.

I spent the first three years playing tunes with a lot of row crossing. My biggest step in the last year has been to uncross them for certain accented dance tunes and focus on the beat or 'punchiness' of the box. So I suppose that means I am hopefully learning when it is appropriate to cross or not cross the rows.

Motivation is the key for me. If a tune grabs me then I can't wait to work on it. Not easy with young children in the summer holidays though!

cheers

Sandy
 (:)
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: waltzman on July 28, 2009, 02:40:20 PM
I think of the melodeon as primarily a dance music machine....a 4kg dance band.  So when I'm looking for music to learn on it I'm always thinking of dancing which means focusing on the rhythm primarily...so lots of crossing rows for waltzes and polskas (hambo) and not so much for jigs and reels.  It's the rhythmic capabilities of the melodeon that tickle me.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: GbH on July 28, 2009, 05:12:28 PM
Thanks for the thought provoking answers, all.  That certainly gives me a few things to think about and I should probably make a note to myself to revisit this thread in a few months time.

For me personally, motivation to play or learn new tunes has not been a problem.  However, motivation to break away from stuff I like doing and to work or core technical things doesn't always come so easy, which probably isn't surprising, given the impatience and frustrations that can go with this.  This is probably even more accute if I'm not 100% sure where a certain technique is going to lead me, or it simply doesn't have an immediate pay-off.  I think that trying to re-learn a simple tune in an awkward key is probably a good example of this - you suspect it's good for you in the long run, but the immediate result is that you just get to play the same tune that you already knew.

It's interesting to see row-crossing mentioned several times.  For me, row-crossing has never been an issue, as that's what I did from day one, not realising that people played in any other way.  I'm still not at all strong at playing along the rows, though, so I think that's something I need to try harder at.  It was interesting to read that Sandy had learnt this way around too.  Also, I guess that dance-orientated playing is an issue for me in general, as I don't have the background to really know what I'm doing with it.

I have tutorial DVDs and have certainly found them useful.  However, the danger I've found with these is that it's too tempting to put them on and then just watch them, when you really need to only watch a small bit and concentrate just on that.  It seems to take a lot of willpower to press the stop button and not to just watch "one more bit".

Finally the words "playing in chords' got me thinking more than anything.  I'm aware that I do this at least a bit, but can't help but feel that I'm really not giving it the thought that it no doubt deserves and that my knowledge of chord theory is somewhat lacking.


Cheers,

Guy




Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: george garside on July 28, 2009, 05:22:57 PM
[quote author=GbH link=topic=2089.
 and that my knowledge of chord theory is somewhat lacking.


Cheers,

Guy





[/quote


Wihilst some enjoy deep & meaningful theoretical debate about which chord goes where & with what many others including Tony Hall ,who in my opinion is at the top of the pile, just look at it as rooting around untill you find a combination of notes that you like the sound of & then remembering  where they are for future reference. As to what is the 'correct' chord for a particular situation its really down to if it sounds good it is good! - keep it simple

george

Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Theo on July 28, 2009, 07:04:46 PM
George,  I suspect that Chris's mention of "playing in chords"  was more to do with right hand chords.  I find its invaluable to know a good range of chords on the right, which can then be used as chords as an alternative to just playing a melody, it also helps to learn the chords as arpeggios, because thse crop up so frequently in so many tunes.  To my mind its more useful to practice arpeggios than scales.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Mike Higgins on July 28, 2009, 07:19:07 PM
Quote
mention of "playing in chords"  was more to do with right hand chords

I use them when I get tired. Also, if people get up to Mallard speed in the session a bit of chord vamping keeps you in the picture without demonstrating kack handedness on the right hand.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 28, 2009, 08:06:06 PM
George,  I suspect that Chris's mention of "playing in chords"  was more to do with right hand chords.  I find its invaluable to know a good range of chords on the right, which can then be used as chords as an alternative to just playing a melody, it also helps to learn the chords as arpeggios, because thse crop up so frequently in so many tunes.

Thank you. That's more or less what I meant. Every melody has chords underneath it. So if your brain doesn't yet hear these it's another good way to progress your music. I started on guitar and still occasionally visualise them that way.  As the melody has these bones within, if you right hand vamp or arpeggio them there is no tension and it allows embelishment without disturbing the Session.

Contrast an Impro Session - where the soloist purposefully moves off the chord notes - (Miles Davis "So what?" the classic example). But even that piece has chords (just 2  ;)). Irish music also differs. Its chord structure is less developed but the melody more so. If you play in chords you tend to go Am, G all afternoon  :-X. But if you depart from these you get funny looks.

Virtually all other mainstream music - 'feeling' it in right hand chords gives easy variation.

Quote
To my mind its more useful to practice arpeggios than scales.

We may differ now. To mine the chord (block or arpeggio doesn't matter) and scale are the same thing. Dm6 is Dorian, etc.

     PS: just thought of another exercise that helped me. Play in darkness - where you can't look
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: ganderbox on July 30, 2009, 11:29:06 PM
I'm in a bit of a rut, I have a great new and totally different sounding/feeling melodeon, but keep playing the same old tunes. I work by hearing something and thinking 'I would love to play that', so I think I need some new influences.... particularly with tunes that use the extra buttons I seem to have acquired....(any advice here?)

This is the other difficulty, using the 2.5 row I am trying to learn new ways of playing across the rows, how to incorporate the new basses etc, its so much to take in, and difficult when I only have the odd half hour to practise.


When I read this yesterday I thought you'd got a C/F Dony. I started to compose a reply but I got all the keys muddled and gave up. Just as well, as I now realise from your new thread about the half row that it's in fact a D/G. (:)

One thing you can do is practice using the D and E reversals, especially on tunes like waltzes and mazurkas. It really makes a difference, especially having the D on the pull.

You will be able to do a lot more with it if you take the thirds out of your basses. As has been said before on this forum, it's really annoying how few Castagnari's have bass stops as standard. It's quite easy to do, and I think the instructions are somewhere in a fairly recent thread. You can then use your F naturals and your F bass for playing in A minor, and use all those nice handy Bbs and Ebs for playing in G minor, and then you can seamlessly change from G major to G minor, as bagpipe players do. You will be able to play Horse's Braul with all the right notesl
D minor is there as well, but a bit more awkward, depending on the tune. F isn't too bad either.

It takes time to learn where everything is, but its fun finding out, and the possibilities are endless...well, almost!

Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: joe on July 30, 2009, 11:35:33 PM
I migt start with those D and E reversals! Afterall the box will be there for a lifetime of discovering new things. I think I expected to quickly pick up new keys, didnt, and promptly reverted to playing the easy stuff I know.

I am really enjoying playing in Bmin though, with those lovely low notes, and playing tunes in D that werent quite possible on the 2 row.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 31, 2009, 08:11:52 AM
"Horse's Branle" surely ??? but never mind. I once heard a tune called "Bar Room Branle" - and very nice too

We seem to have strayed into the 'modifications' thread somewhat. I'd say that creating a D note on pull (filed-down C on my C# row, personally) was one of the best things I ever did. It made me refinger a whole load of descending phrases in the upper half of the G scale,  and gave me complete G scale and nearly all a D scale on pull.

both score most in Em - massive in melodeon repertoire (and the whole of folk music). I've now got E dorian (with C#) and aolian (using C natural) notes right through and into the next octave, a fuller Em chord with a 7th, and even 'extensions' if the session starts to swing. So it's moved my music on considerably.

Present challenge in Em is to use C# on the way up, and C natural on the way down. This a common and traditional  style amongst fiddlers

That Dutch reversal? Well I tried it, struggled for 6 months before re-reversing. As I posted earlier the problem is unlearning the old stuff. If your beard isn't grey I'd recommend it strongly before those fingerings bed in. It's logical, simple and reversible - you even get a free E on the push! D3R
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: ganderbox on July 31, 2009, 01:33:03 PM

I am really enjoying playing in Bmin though, with those lovely low notes, and playing tunes in D that werent quite possible on the 2 row.

I forgot that you probably didn't have the low notes on your previous box.
That low B is lovely, and what is also handy is having the D on the pull on the first button of the G row, giving you the first 3 notes (D, F#, and A) of a D chord, which is also a sequence of notes which occurs in a number of tunes eg
Calligype (hope that's spelled right!) and Vona's Delight.

"Horse's Branle" surely ??? but never mind. I once heard a tune called "Bar Room Branle" - and very nice too


At least if you spell it as Braul it doesn't get pronounced "Brannel" and it's better than "Brawl"!
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: OwenG on July 31, 2009, 01:43:45 PM
Quote
I think I expected to quickly pick up new keys, didnt, and promptly reverted to playing the easy stuff I know.

A good way to start finding your way around this is to play the stuff that you know, but in different keys. So for a D/G 2.5 row, try playing tunes in C, E and A and related minors.

I've done this having slipped down a tone to a C/F 2.5 row, and tried to re-learn stuff in D, G etc. The different fingerings make tunes sound different, and it's also a good way to start thinking about the extra notes that you've got as not just accidentals, but as notes from different keys.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: GbH on July 31, 2009, 02:43:40 PM
     PS: just thought of another exercise that helped me. Play in darkness - where you can't look

Ah yes, I've had a go at this - it certainly proved an interesting exercise.  I think I must have played constantly for about half an hour, happy in my own little world, using one of those travel sleep mask things rather than finding a dark room.  I noticed two specific results:

1.  As I'd half expected, I found I didn't need to look, playing pretty much exactly as normal.  Well, mostly, anyway.  To my surprise, during one or two tunes, I suddenly had a urge to look down, which was a bit unexpected.  As it turned out, I didn't really need to see anything for those particular phrases, but must have got into a habit of looking anyway at some point.

2.  Secondly, and far more interesting, was that, in the darkness, I gradually begun to listen much more attentively than usual.  I've previously heard how one sense can become more sensitive if another is disabled and that seemed to be the case when doing this.  The real revelation, though, was the day afterwards, when playing as normal with sight, I noticed that things sounding noticably better than before, despite having put the previous days experiment out of my mind.  I really do think it made a difference.

So, yes, from my own experience, it can prove a worthwhile thing to try.

Guy
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: ganderbox on July 31, 2009, 03:44:00 PM

     PS: just thought of another exercise that helped me. Play in darkness - where you can't look

I believe that this is what Andy Cutting used to do to hone his skills when he was learning.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 31, 2009, 03:49:24 PM
     PS: just thought of another exercise that helped me. Play in darkness - where you can't look

So, yes, from my own experience, it can prove a worthwhile thing to try.
when I started learning concertina we had a powercut...and I learnt this by accident.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Falseknight on July 31, 2009, 06:41:48 PM
It's prbably not applicable to most here, but I've found that when I hit a plateau on an instrument, if I step backwards from it and concentrate on another instrument for a month or so, I find that when I return, the problems causing the plateau are surmountable.  I'm currently playing melodeon a lot to divert from a stilted mindset in my approach to guitar.  I actually NEED a stint where I have to play bass properly again.
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: mikesamwild on August 05, 2009, 12:39:40 PM
I think the thing that's driving me onward at the moment is the listening that I'm doing. The more good players I listen to the more I want to be able to emulate what I'm hearing. Another motivator and I hope assist, is Graeme's button-box workshop in September - the motivator is the fact that I don't want to make a complete ass of myself when I get there, and I want to be able to draw as much benefit from it as possible.
AL


I see Al that you have 999 posts You are a beast and a half!
Title: Re: How to progress and keep improving?
Post by: Lester on August 05, 2009, 01:01:07 PM
I see Al that you have 999 posts You are a beast and a half!

No that's just the Austrailian beast    >:E
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal