Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on July 27, 2009, 10:56:40 PM
-
How do you play a tune through (aabb) more than once? I could only play bear dance twice in succession before my left arm wanted to fall off and my right thumb was sore.
-
Practice practice practice.
Tenor saxophonoist John Coltrane had the opposite problem, his onetime employer Miles Davis complained about the length of his solos and Trane confessed "I don't know how to stop". Miles was unsympathetic: "Try taking the damn horn out of your mouth," he suggested.
-
I found it took quite a while to get my left hand stamina up - it still gets tired before the R hand, but then it's doing more :D When you practise at home, practise each tune at least three times through without a break, that way you get used to going back to the A the same as you would in a session as well as building stamina. Also, as you improve, you'll play faster, and can therefore get through it quicker! (not a recommended solution...)
-
I actually worked out with weights (I kid you not) the month before my Mori came from Italy.
But there are other ways. On a 2 row look for as many ways as possible to follow the melody using fingers (crossing the rows) as you can. That takes out a lot of bellows movement compared to labouring on one row. It's also frankly prettier (when solo) as you can play up to 6 notes against a single pull Em developing 'phrasing'.
When tired - drop into right hand chords .. halves left arm movement.
Otherwise I can only recommend more of those one-arm press ups ;) Power to your elbow.
-
Buy a one row four stop - by third time through the second tune of a set my left arm used to feel as if it had dropped off. After a number of weeks concerted playing it only feels as if it is about to drop off.
So 1R4S "as good as a gym membership"
-
It is also about being relaxed when you are playing. That too will come with practice. Don't use any more muscles than absolutely necessary, and mental tensions (such as being new to playing with others) can easily lead to tense muscles too. Being conscious of the tension can help to let it go.
-
It is also about being relaxed when you are playing. That too will come with practice. Don't use any more muscles than absolutely necessary, and mental tensions (such as being new to playing with others) can easily lead to tense muscles too. Being conscious of the tension can help to let it go.
I do have a bad habit of the more I panic the faster I get. Its like my brain goes 'if you speed up you might get to the end before you forget what you're doing'. lol!
-
I do have a bad habit of the more I panic the faster I get. Its like my brain goes 'if you speed up you might get to the end before you forget what you're doing'. lol!
I think everyone has experienced that!
-
The bellows on my new box were quite stiff and, with continuous effort, took a while to ease off.
Think some players play too hard rather than use a relaxed controlled technique which should develop as your playing improves. Don't know about really heavy boxes though.
Buy a one row four stop - by third time through the second tune of a set my left arm used to feel as if it had dropped off. After a number of weeks concerted playing it only feels as if it is about to drop off.
So 1R4S "as good as a gym membership"
Maybe walking around the house at the same time as playing is best for an all round workout. ;D
-
I do have a bad habit of the more I panic the faster I get. Its like my brain goes 'if you speed up you might get to the end before you forget what you're doing'. lol!
I think everyone has experienced that!
Is there a cure?
The bellows on my new box were quite stiff and, with continuous effort, took a while to ease off.
Think some players play too hard rather than use a relaxed controlled technique which should develop as your playing improves. Don't know about really heavy boxes though.
I've been practicing and hour each evening, and four at a weekend....I find when I'm trying to be considerate and play quietly I don't ache as much as when I'm playing loudly.
Does melodeon use different muscles to concertina?
-
I do have a bad habit of the more I panic the faster I get. Its like my brain goes 'if you speed up you might get to the end before you forget what you're doing'. lol!
I think everyone has experienced that!
Is there a cure?
Yep - get a metronome... or use one of the online ones - http://www.metronomeonline.com/
-
I've been practicing and hour each evening, and four at a weekend....I find when I'm trying to be considerate and play quietly I don't ache as much as when I'm playing loudly.
There's your answer!
Another benefit of generally playing a bit quieter is that you have some headroom left to use more volume on some phrases, notes, or even parts of notes. That can add a whole new dimension to your playing.
-
And Mr Garside of this parish will tell you that you should definitely be practising quietly (it's harder than playing loudly). And believe me, it works!
-
And Mr Garside of this parish will tell you that you should definitely be practising quietly (it's harder than playing loudly). And believe me, it works!
Well I've been practicing quietly for a long time...but when I went to a session the other week I realised maybe a little too quietly as I couldn't hear what I was playing and maybe I aught to up the volume a little.
When I say loud its to top volume its just drowning out the tv/hoovering/nextdoors DIY loud.
-
I suffer from the speeding up syndrome especially if I'm running out of air. I also try practicing with a metronome every now and again and find if very difficult. What helps me most is to play very slowly, any differences in speed are much more noticeable and when I play slowly I feel that I'm much more concentrated. My problem is that I tend to jump from tune to tune, having played something six or severn times I get bored and more to the next tune. Resulting in being able to play lots of tunes badly.
Louise
-
...but when I went to a session the other week I realised maybe a little too quietly as I couldn't hear what I was playing and maybe I aught to up the volume a little.
When I say loud its to top volume its just drowning out the tv/hoovering/nextdoors DIY loud.
[/quote]
not being able to hear yourself play is pretty normal in a reasonably large session - eventually you sort of get your ear tuned to your particular box but not always. The beauty of it is that everybody is in the same boat so they don't hear your mistakes either. As an example of this I was leading a session the size of a pubfull of players at a festival & we were playing a nice easy tune that most could join in with. I knew something was wrong with my playing but such was the cumulative session volume that. it took me about 6 bars worth of music before it dawned on me that I was playing the melody in D on the D row (where else!) and the bass for the key of G!) - nobody noticed or heard it! So - in a reasonably large session as long as you play quietly if not sure of a tune you are unlikely to do much damage! Just play the bits you can & with luck each time through the tune you get a few moe notes in.
As to weight/ physical effort required its not directly related to the weight of the box ( assuming you have the box properly attached to yourself with 2 nice wide padded straps) many other factors apply like the response of the reeds ( the better the reeds the more quietly you can play them) , The flexibility of the bellows, the strength of the springs controlling the pallets etc etc. Then there is your technique which for some people involves a great deal of dramatic pulling & pushing coupled to waving the bellows around in the wind - this is OK if you must but uses a hUge amount of unnecesary energy with absolutely no musical benefit! Keeping the bellows as near closed as possible most of the time ( there are times when only a good extension will do!) and using the wrist rather than arm movement greatly reduces energy consumption without effecting the volume to any great degree. The other cause of huge bellows movements is heavy ( & sometimes turgid) use of the bass - this is OK in small doses if you are doingit on purpose because it enhances the proceedings) but otherwise stick to lightly tapping the bass buttons &lifting fingres off between strikes to provide a good rhythm. Also , particularly in a long session consider playing treble only for some tunes - then the bellows need hardly moving atall!
All welcome at the middle earth sesion at whitby folk week - I will be doing 3 this year plus 4 beginnrs & 1 intermediate workshop
george
-
. Resulting in being able to play lots of tunes badly.
Louise
Don't worry about it Louise, I can do it with the greatest of ease! It does however come in quite handy for leading long sessions!
george
-
I suffer from the speeding up syndrome especially if I'm running out of air. I also try practicing with a metronome every now and again and find if very difficult. What helps me most is to play very slowly, any differences in speed are much more noticeable and when I play slowly I feel that I'm much more concentrated. My problem is that I tend to jump from tune to tune, having played something six or severn times I get bored and more to the next tune. Resulting in being able to play lots of tunes badly.
Louise
yep that's just like me..plus I have real problems using the airbutton and bass...I just can't co ordinate it...on the push i can hit it by accident but on the pull no chance whatsoever.
As to weight/ physical effort required its not directly related to the weight of the box ( assuming you have the box properly attached to yourself with 2 nice wide padded straps) many other factors apply like the response of the reeds ( the better the reeds the more quietly you can play them) , The flexibility of the bellows, the strength of the springs controlling the pallets etc etc. Then there is your technique which for some people involves a great deal of dramatic pulling & pushing coupled to waving the bellows around in the wind - this is OK if you must but uses a hUge amount of unnecesary energy with absolutely no musical benefit! Keeping the bellows as near closed as possible most of the time ( there are times when only a good extension will do!) and using the wrist rather than arm movement greatly reduces energy consumption without effecting the volume to any great degree. The other cause of huge bellows movements is heavy ( & sometimes turgid) use of the bass - this is OK in small doses if you are doingit on purpose because it enhances the proceedings) but otherwise stick to lightly tapping the bass buttons &lifting fingres off between strikes to provide a good rhythm. Also , particularly in a long session consider playing treble only for some tunes - then the bellows need hardly moving atall!
so looking at my youtube videos what do you think is my problem?
-
Sara - I will have a good look at them and come back to you
george
-
Sara - I will have a good look at them and come back to you
george
Thanks. :)
I think I may have to rest from any practicing tonight...
My arms feel like lead weights today and every time I go to type my shoulders ache.
-
From just looking at your picture I would say your thumb aches from a huge amount of bellows being pushed against it, you wear the melodeon quite high compared to myself. I know a lot of people do wear it high and I wonder how they rest their thumb. I prefer to wear it lower down and rest the corner against the inside of my right leg, takes away a lot of weight. I have seen others rest the melodeon on the outside of the left leg but that was too difficult for me with such short arms. (:)
It suits me but I'm pretty inexperienced on here compared to others.
-
How do you play a tune through (aabb) more than once? I could only play bear dance twice in succession before my left arm wanted to fall off and my right thumb was sore.
Hmmm.. try a lighter weight box?
-
I don't think the weight of the box is a problem. When you are first learning, the tension in itself is quite tiring. I think too that Bear Dance is in e minor which means a lot of accented notes on the pull, which is possibly new muscle training. Playing shouldn't hurt but I believe that when you push yourself into new limits then your arms, wrists, and backs of hands will ache a bit.
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
I know that this is going to sound daft to some - but like all muscular exercise its important to warm up at the beginning and warm down at the end. Stretches are quite useful too. I have an ongoing left shoulder injury and I hurt like crazy unless I don't gently do some stretching before setting down to play. I consider not doing it to be folly - like it or not you are participating in what, certainly for a beginner, is quite a strenuous activity in an unfamiliar muscle zone.
AL
-
Can you give an example of typical warm up exercises?
-
certainly for a beginner, is quite a strenuous activity
In fact some tunes on the BCC# are like chest expanders.
-
In fact some tunes on the BCC# are like chest expanders.
How true - and amazing when you see the greats getting such brilliant tunes and hardly moving the bellows at all!
AL
-
Sara - I will have a good look at them and come back to you
george
\i Sarah - haave had a look at your Utubes & notice that you are resting the bellows on your left knee which looks as if it is stopping yu playing with the bellows into a more 'closed' position. It will probably alsomean you are having to apply more pressure to overcome the friction between bellows and leg! This will also have a detrimental effct on bellow by wearing the bellows tape., the bellow should not be touching anypart of your person!
The box does look a little on the high side but I can't see your face or more importntly your chin relative to the top of the box on the utubes.sitting or standing in an upright position and looking straight ahead I recommend that the top of the box is about a stretched hands width below the chin. For most people this enables the elbows to be at a comfortable angle and the bellows clear of legs whilst seated. Posture is important and sitting upright rather than drooping forwards is helpful ( I cant see your posture on the utubes so this is just a general comment)
If you want to have the straps longer so the box will rest on left knee lengthen the right strap and shorten the left strap so the box moves more to the left putting the body of the box on the knee, not the bellows.
I think you are doing very well considering the short time you have been playing & the only other sugestion I can make is to tap more lightly on the bass i.e. make the bass notes much shorter as this reduces air consumption considerably & therefore bellows work. Many, myself included, also think a light rhythmic bass sounds better.
hope some of this is of help
george
I ]
-
Tom van Eyken runs participants at his workshops through general arm stretching/tensing stuff before anything else. Can't say it did much for me
-
In fact some tunes on the BCC# are like chest expanders.
How true - and amazing when you see the greats getting such brilliant tunes and hardly moving the bellows at all!
AL
This set me thinking as i normally just use as little bellows as possible depending of course on the tune. So as a quick daft exercise I taped a ruler onto the top of the box and found that scotland the brave (D) Rope waltz,(D), My love shes but a lassie yet (D) duke of perth (G) My HOme (A) Bonny Lass of Bon Accord (A) cock of the north (A or Bflat) 100 Pipers A or Bflat) all used a maximum of 6 - 7 inches of bellow measured with bellows staight out ( in practice it was a little bit more at the top and virtually nil at the bottom as I use the bellows mostly in a fan shape) Harvest Home (D) was mostly playable in 2 -3 inches. This on 3 voice 48 bass casali, Probably less opening required on 8o bass paolo as more air available per inch of movement due to larger bellwos.
For what its worth I tend to use the 'alternatives' to control bellows direction rather than going in for long runs in same direction as can be done for example in A. It is probably wise and probably instinctive once you get the hang of it to keep a weather eye on the bellows (eventually the elbow position probably 'senses' it ) and set a sort of loose target of say playing within a 9 or 10 inch opening (red light) with the 'yellow light' at say 6 or 7 inches. If you go through a yellow light stop & look at your keyboard chart to see if there is another way of doing it!
george
george
-
If you go through a yellow light stop & look at your keyboard chart to see if there is another way of doing it!
yep, and I'm slowly discovering that in fact if I do go through a set of traffic lights (frequently so in my case) I often need to go back quite a long way in order to work out a new route!
-
Tom van Eyken runs participants at his workshops through general arm stretching/tensing stuff before anything else. Can't say it did much for me
like what kind of stretching?
-
Tom van Eyken runs participants at his workshops through general arm stretching/tensing stuff before anything else. Can't say it did much for me
like what kind of stretching?
Its something you really need to learn by observing, trying to explain in words is probably not going to be successful. The stretches I use are mainly for the hands, arms, shoulders and neck, as these are the parts of the body that can suffer most from playing.
-
I would also recommend going for a five mile jog followed up by 10 lengths in the pool and finished off with 20 mins in the sauna before playing. Health warning - melodeons really shouldn't be played in either saunas or swimming pools as it's not good for them! Has anyone come up with an underwater melodeon yet btw?
;D
-
If you go through a yellow light stop & look at your keyboard chart to see if there is another way of doing it!
yep, and I'm slowly discovering that in fact if I do go through a set of traffic lights (frequently so in my case) I often need to go back quite a long way in order to work out a new route!
that sounds like significant progress Al! With the three row in a sense you need to know not only where you are going but also where youv'e been ( or where you are coming from) as where you've been (in a particular tune or bit thereof) should influence where you go next. Theres also an element of chess playing comes into it as it pays to think a few moves ahead!
The good thing is that , like chess, the more automatic such thought processes become & its all fascinating stuff!
george
-
Hmm...for some reason the more times i play a particular tune the worse it sounds and more mistakes i make. Its illogical captain. Why is this happening? Surely i should be getting better instead?
-
I found that with the flute, less so with melodeon. It's because although you're improving, your ear is also getting more tuned in and better at hearing mistakes. So it's a false impression. You need an impartial third party ;)
-
How do you play a tune through (aabb) more than once? I could only play bear dance twice in succession before my left arm wanted to fall off and my right thumb was sore.
After 2hrs solid laying for busking, my arms almost did fall off!
-
After 2hrs solid laying for busking, my arms almost did fall off!
??? ??? :o
I'll warn my hens about that!
-
Well something did fall off, the p for starters.....
-
Hmm...for some reason the more times i play a particular tune the worse it sounds and more mistakes i make. Its illogical captain. Why is this happening? Surely i should be getting better instead?
Play it more and probably slower. Instead of the aabb you say you're doing, try aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa........ until you are thoroughly fed up.
-
After 2hrs solid laying for busking, my arms almost did fall off!
??? ??? :o
I'll warn my hens about that!
lol! That made me spit my tea out with laughter. ;D
-
Even stranger, perhaps, is that certain tunes are more of a strain than others. OK, so that might be expected to some extent, but I guess I play certain tunes with more attack - Bear Dance being one of those, along with Balquidder Lasses. Now neither of these tunes is particularly fast or tricky, but when played for Morris, I find I have to play with as much emphasis on beat and phrasing as possible to contain the run-away tendencies of the rest of the band.
I agree it's not as serious as when playing the four-stop in a wide-open arena (sound evaporates into thin air...), for which I would recomend SAS training in resisting torture! Never admit to yourself that it hurts - like a ballerina, smiling through the pain. Even bigger problem in the practice season, when they finish the dance and then substitute new dancers to go again!
Unless you're having to maintain the drive, bounce and pace on your own, just back off a tad and maybe wriggle a bit to ease the muscles. With a big (>2) band, why not make out the strap has slipped and drop out for a measure?
It comes with practice!
Rob.
-
Lets put this into context Mum (calling) and the band who currently have no name (for some reason they didn't like my suggestion of busy lizzie and the plant pots?) have been asked to do another barn dance in september. I've been told I can play my melodeon for the short 2min 'rest' between two dances and my mum wants me to play bear dance. No one has said if this will be me on my own or if i'll have help from the others. So i'm really worried i won't be able to keep playing that long without causing myself damage because of how much I ached after my 'practice'.
I'm fretting that I'm not ready. :(
-
for some reason they didn't like my suggestion of busy lizzie and the plant pots
Well I think it's a brilliant name....wish we'd thought of it when we were looking for a name for our band.
I'm not sure the other guys would have been happy as the plant pots, though. Red Hot Pokers, maybe, but I believe that one's been done...... :(
No one has said if this will be me on my own or if i'll have help from the others.
Absolutely and definitely get the band to play with you, and have a practice first. You might find they've got a vacancy for a melodeon player!
-
Thats great ladyT, I remember when you said you couldnt play anything, things like this are great experience, totally different to sessions and will aid your playing in the future.
I still find playing for dancing quite difficult, especially as I dont get the practise very often. Playing in sessions (which I do most weeks at least once) is so easy in comparison, as there is less pressure to get it right, and if you go wrong its not like there are 6 blokes looking at you, a bit annoyed!
As to keeping a tune going, like people have said, practise it properly each time. Practice each tune AABBAABBAABB as you would play in a session, and you will find it a lot easier on the day, as you wont be doing it differently to how you practise it. Also, once you know a tune well enough, practise a beginning and an end, even playing the last couple of notes differently will give it an 'arranged' feel, and will sound great.
-
Agree. It's really tempting to just go through each tune once in a pactice. Real music isn't like that, and 3 times through seems the norm.
>:E Practicing in this way also makes you notice how flat that tune feel by it's second repeat, and encourages variation and impro. I don't personally think you should ever 'play it the same' twice let alone 3 times - but I know that some Irish Sessioners will disagree.
-
Thats great ladyT, I remember when you said you couldnt play anything, things like this are great experience, totally different to sessions and will aid your playing in the future.
got some info last night may or may not happen now as another band want to play too so may not be time.
I still find playing for dancing quite difficult, especially as I dont get the practise very often. Playing in sessions (which I do most weeks at least once) is so easy in comparison, as there is less pressure to get it right, and if you go wrong its not like there are 6 blokes looking at you, a bit annoyed!
just flutter your eyelashes ;)
Agree. It's really tempting to just go through each tune once in a pactice. Real music isn't like that, and 3 times through seems the norm.
>:E Practicing in this way also makes you notice how flat that tune feel by it's second repeat, and encourages variation and impro. I don't personally think you should ever 'play it the same' twice let alone 3 times - but I know that some Irish Sessioners will disagree.
Which I had the skills to add some variation that wasn't a 'mistake'. :P
After some experimenting I think I ache more when I stand up than sitting down.
-
I don't personally think you should ever 'play it the same' twice let alone 3 times - but I know that some Irish Sessioners will disagree.
It depends in what context. if I get a tune going and it sounds right, I will keep it going for a lot longer. Get the wole hypnotic vibe going!
-
Agree. It's really tempting to just go through each tune once in a pactice. Real music isn't like that, and 3 times through seems the norm.
>:E Practicing in this way also makes you notice how flat that tune feel by it's second repeat, and encourages variation and impro. I don't personally think you should ever 'play it the same' twice let alone 3 times - but I know that some Irish Sessioners will disagree.
In Grey Larsen's Flute and Whistle tutor he analyses Matt Molloy's playing and Matt Molloy never plays the tune the same way on each play through .
-
I'm starting that the weight even when sitting down is actually an issue. I tried a pokerwork the other day (comparison essay subject for another thread) but I found it so light compared to the sara and I didn't get that shoulder ache after playing bear dance I usually get.
Its so annoying I love my melodeon..but if its causing me pain I'm going to have to change. :(
-
if its causing me pain I'm going to have to change
Not necessarily. It's probably better to have a good look at how you are attached to the Melodeon. If your box is heavy and you are playing sitting down, try lengthening your straps (or playing with one strap) and resting the weight of the box on your knee.
I've got a box that weighs a tonne, but find that if I sit it on my knee like a ventriloquist's dummy, then it is perfectly stable and balanced and I can play for ages.
-
if its causing me pain I'm going to have to change
Not necessarily. It's probably better to have a good look at how you are attached to the Melodeon. If your box is heavy and you are playing sitting down, try lengthening your straps (or playing with one strap) and resting the weight of the box on your knee.
I've got a box that weighs a tonne, but find that if I sit it on my knee like a ventriloquist's dummy, then it is perfectly stable and balanced and I can play for ages.
As soon as I lengthen the straps..the box wobbles like mad and the straps fall off my shoulders. >:(
At Witney I will be taking a survey...on how to do my straps. I've loosened them a bit lately after Georges suggestion...but have yet to find the optimum arrangement.
-
Here's a variant on Owen's suggestion, which works for me when I'm playing seated.
Sit with your legs close-ish together and so that your right thigh is slightly higher than your left - maybe even cross your right leg over your left to achieve this. Then rest the bottom edge of the keyboard grill gainst the inside of your right thigh, with the weight of the box itself falling mainly on your left. In this position you can use your right thigh and your right thumb together to brace the box so that it is stable on push. All of this should make the left strap more or less redundant. So don't wear it, and tuck it out of the way. However you will need the right strap to make the box stable on pull. So, with the box in this position, and with your upper body in a comfortable posture, lengthen/tighten the right strap so that there is hardly any spare play in it.
Might not work for you. And/or it might take a little getting used to. But anyway I'm sure there will be plenty of alternative helpful suggestions both here and at Witney.
The problem with that one is I can never get my legs to cross over for long..for some reason crossing left over right is easy but right over left is hard. (my leg goes numb coz the blood circulation gets cut off) :o But I have just had in idea if I can get a doorstop of a book to rest my foot on that might work.
-
It is also about being relaxed when you are playing. That too will come with practice. Don't use any more muscles than absolutely necessary, and mental tensions (such as being new to playing with others) can easily lead to tense muscles too. Being conscious of the tension can help to let it go.
Glad you asked this question LDT because I have exactly the same problem. Last weekend I played with a buddy who is a terrific fiddle player - first time I have had the courage to play with anyone else and apart from stuffing up a lot, I got tired quickly. Mostly though I think I suffered from what Theo refers to here - the nerves of playing with others! I am taking lots of the advice here - playing tunes three times through, walking around the house while playing etc....basically keepin' squeezin' :|||: :|||: :|||:
-
in fact, pretty much as Bob Ellis seems to be doing.
Another couple of good examples here: http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=1531689&id=611503443&l=37f451dae7
-
The problem with that one is I can never get my legs to cross over for long..for some reason crossing left over right is easy but right over left is hard. (my leg goes numb coz the blood circulation gets cut off) :o But I have just had in idea if I can get a doorstop of a book to rest my foot on that might work.
Another possibility, if crossing your legs doesn't work for you, is to achieve the same effect by sitting with your right foot resting on your melodeon case, thus raising your right leg a few inches above your left and enabling you to rest your melodeon against the inside of your thigh.
-
in fact, pretty much as Bob Ellis seems to be doing.
Another couple of good examples here: http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=1531689&id=611503443&l=37f451dae7
There's a number of Melnetter's just waiting to be tagged in that Facebook album!!
Plus a wide variety of playing styles to try.
Andy
-
There's a number of Melnetter's just waiting to be tagged in that Facebook album!!
I'm in there even http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=1531662&id=611503443&l=37f451dae7
the moment I bought my new melodeon. ;D :|||:
-
I'm starting that the weight even when sitting down is actually an issue. I tried a pokerwork the other day (comparison essay subject for another thread) but I found it so light compared to the sara and I didn't get that shoulder ache after playing bear dance I usually get.
Its so annoying I love my melodeon..but if its causing me pain I'm going to have to change. :(
I wonder....... the actual difference in weight between your Beltuna and Pokerwork probably isn't that geat (although I'm saying that without seeing the specs). Perhaps the bellows on the Beltuna are still fairly stiff. The strain on the shoulders would then be from the "in-out" workout you're receiving rather than from any additional weight of the box itself. You haven't had the Beltuna all that long, so the bellows will probably loosen. Your muscles will also get used to the slightly more prolonged exercise!
-
I'm starting that the weight even when sitting down is actually an issue. I tried a pokerwork the other day (comparison essay subject for another thread) but I found it so light compared to the sara and I didn't get that shoulder ache after playing bear dance I usually get.
Its so annoying I love my melodeon..but if its causing me pain I'm going to have to change. :(
At M@W you should certainly find many different styles of holding the melodeon and how the straps are adjusted. It will be a good opportunity to experiment and also to let others watch how you hold the box. You might well find that you can tweak the strap lengths a little.
If you find that one particular tune (e.g. Bear Dance in Em with lots of pulls) causes you aches and pains, it may well be a sign that something's not adjusted quite right.
But it could also be that you are overpractising, playing too hard, getting tense, etc., on that one particular tune and you are developing a repetitive strain type of condition. I know that you practise for long chunks of time. Perhaps you need to go more gently with it and for shorter periods?
-
I wonder....... the actual difference in weight between your Beltuna and Pokerwork probably isn't that geat (although I'm saying that without seeing the specs). Perhaps the bellows on the Beltuna are still fairly stiff. The strain on the shoulders would then be from the "in-out" workout you're receiving rather than from any additional weight of the box itself. You haven't had the Beltuna all that long, so the bellows will probably loosen. Your muscles will also get used to the slightly more prolonged exercise!
Oh there was definately a difference when I lifted it up.
At M@W you should certainly find many different styles of holding the melodeon and how the straps are adjusted. It will be a good opportunity to experiment and also to let others watch how you hold the box. You might well find that you can tweak the strap lengths a little.
I hope so I've been experimenting with strap lengths and can't seem to find one that suits exactly.
But it could also be that you are overpractising, playing too hard, getting tense, etc., on that one particular tune and you are developing a repetitive strain type of condition.
Does more practice equal more improvment...or is there a saturation point where it doesn't make a difference?
I know that you practise for long chunks of time. Perhaps you need to go more gently with it and for shorter periods?
I have about an hour to fit my practice in when I get home. *sigh* if only I didn't have work.
Its a bit easier on weekends to spread it out.
My 'light' practice consists of 30mins melodeon -break-then 30mins concertina.
-
Going rather tediously back to the start of this thread, I have just experienced the worst attack of "unable to finish anything" itis. Every tune breaks down, even ones I know well. I am playing the wrong As and Bs even when there seems to be no musical connection. I also can't remember how to start any tune. I am only able to start a tune of which I have a recording. In every other way I feel fine, I have not taken strong drink. I am posting this to get it off my chest to an audience of people who have probably suffered in the same way at some time. I know that there is no cure for this malady as a professional musician of my acquaintance says that this also happens to him. I now feel loads better and will return to my instrument. Many apologies for wasting valuable forum space with these maunderings.
This is all on the dreaded Casali 80 bass BCC# by the way.
-
Last night I started a tune "Lady in a boat" in D, whereas I normally play it in G. I then was convinced that the next tune i play with it was "grandfather", however I had to give up after the (rather low) Lady in a boat as I couldn't make the change work. Later in the evening I realised that LIAB goes in G with Dingle's Regatta and Gfather goes with The Sloe (both in D). Oops.
-
Many apologies for wasting valuable forum space with these maunderings.
No apology needed Mike - that's what this forum is for...I think? Anyway - yes I know where you're at. In fact I'm not convinced I know how to finish anything at the moment - it feels like ages since I actually played anything all the way through - repeats an' all - without my mind and fingers wandering off into something else completely unconnected...in fact every time I pick up my instrument I seems to wander off into some strange little tune that my fingers keep playing - its a half of nothing kind of tune and vaguely familiar pile of nonsense and I really ought to stop it!
AL
-
I wonder....... the actual difference in weight between your Beltuna and Pokerwork probably isn't that geat (although I'm saying that without seeing the specs).
I just looked it up. A Sara 2 is rated at 3.5kg. My Pokerwork (an old one) weighs 3kg, but newer ones are rated at 2.6kg. That is an appreciable difference, and 3.5kg is probably at the top end of the weight range for 2 row, 2 voice boxes.
Hope that makes you feel better, LDT, even if it doesn't actually help your poor arm!
-
Going rather tediously back to the start of this thread, I have just experienced the worst attack of "unable to finish anything" itis. Every tune breaks down, even ones I know well. I am playing the wrong As and Bs even when there seems to be no musical connection. I also can't remember how to start any tune. I am only able to start a tune of which I have a recording. In every other way I feel fine, I have not taken strong drink. I am posting this to get it off my chest to an audience of people who have probably suffered in the same way at some time. I know that there is no cure for this malady as a professional musician of my acquaintance says that this also happens to him. I now feel loads better and will return to my instrument. Many apologies for wasting valuable forum space with these maunderings.
This is all on the dreaded Casali 80 bass BCC# by the way.
Ouch. Never had it quite that bad myself, but very close. It happens, unfortunately and that's precisely the right attitude to take :)
-
Going rather tediously back to the start of this thread, I have just experienced the worst attack of "unable to finish anything" itis. Every tune breaks down, even ones I know well. I am playing the wrong As and Bs even when there seems to be no musical connection. I also can't remember how to start any tune. I am only able to start a tune of which I have a recording. In every other way I feel fine, I have not taken strong drink. I am posting this to get it off my chest to an audience of people who have probably suffered in the same way at some time. I know that there is no cure for this malady as a professional musician of my acquaintance says that this also happens to him. I now feel loads better and will return to my instrument. Many apologies for wasting valuable forum space with these maunderings.
FWIW, when this happens to me, I find that it is often due to trying too hard: things are going wrong, so I try to play it again, concentrating harder on getting it right...only it gets worth instead of better. I think this is due to tension in arms/fingers/brain(?) caused by trying too hard. My solution is to get up, make a drink (non-alcoholic :o) and then try again, this time making a conscious effort to relax and telling myself that it doesn't matter if I go wrong. This often does the trick, but not always. If it doesn't, I put the box down and go and do something else. When I come back to it the following day, the jitters have usually gone. Cue for a new tune - Jittery Pokerwork anyone? ;D
-
I wonder....... the actual difference in weight between your Beltuna and Pokerwork probably isn't that geat (although I'm saying that without seeing the specs).
I just looked it up. A Sara 2 is rated at 3.5kg. My Pokerwork (an old one) weighs 3kg, but newer ones are rated at 2.6kg. That is an appreciable difference, and 3.5kg is probably at the top end of the weight range for 2 row, 2 voice boxes.
Hope that makes you feel better, LDT, even if it doesn't actually help your poor arm!
3.5kg....that's heavier than my handbag. :o
No wonder I ache...I suppose there is no way to make it lighter?
on a posative note...when I get fustrated its too heavy to throw through a window. :P
Going rather tediously back to the start of this thread, I have just experienced the worst attack of "unable to finish anything" itis. Every tune breaks down, even ones I know well. I am playing the wrong As and Bs even when there seems to be no musical connection. I also can't remember how to start any tune. I am only able to start a tune of which I have a recording.
I thought that only happened at certain times of the month. :-[
well that's my excuse.
-
I thought that only happened at certain times of the month. :-[
Yes, in my case, every time I go to a session. :'(
-
Trust me:
Compared to a 70s Telecaster, most Les Pauls, all Wal and Warwick basses... melodeons are really very light ;) OK. MAYBE not Coronas, Trichords and Shand Morenos - but the Hohner Club, Erika and Delicia I play (have played) are a breeze, seating or standing - oh, and I sing as well so i've got even more dynamic issues.
-
I thought that only happened at certain times of the month. :-[
Yes, in my case, every time I go to a session. :'(
Rubb?sh :P
-
I usually play a Tommy which is fine to play for a long period of time for me, but I've just played my Saltarelle for about an hour which is unusual and my arm and hand really ached at the end and I was very glad to put it down. I was suprised that the small difference in weight made such a difference. The Saltarelle is newer and stiffer and heavier and didn't I know it.
-
Trust me:
Compared to a 70s Telecaster, most Les Pauls, all Wal and Warwick basses... melodeons are really very light ;) OK. MAYBE not Coronas, Trichords and Shand Morenos - but the Hohner Club, Erika and Delicia I play (have played) are a breeze, seating or standing - oh, and I sing as well so i've got even more dynamic issues.
compared to a Shand Morino the trichord and Corona are extremely light! :D
george
-
I am now trying just one strap. I think i'm tensing up to try to stop left strap falling off so i got rid of it. So far left shoulder not as sore.
-
If left strap was falling off then you should tighten it, not take it off :P Then again, some people do react better to one strap playing. Personally I can't see how they manage it.
-
Well only when im sitting down.
-
Thats great ladyT, I remember when you said you couldnt play anything, things like this are great experience, totally different to sessions and will aid your playing in the future.
Its my pre-practice 'audition' this evening....for some reason I keep imagining it will be like 'britains got talent'.
I'm rather nervous...last night I just couldn't get the tune right no matter how hard I tried....yet I could play it perfectly before I knew I had to play today.
-
are you at a session tonight then?
-
are you at a session tonight then?
nope....although it may turn into one. There's a barn dance next week and the chap who organises the band/plays in it, is coming round to see what I can play. (a sort of practice before the practice with the whole band) Potentially I get a little spot in between dances to play a tune. Last time I was allowed to play the tamborine for some of the tunes ::)
-
I passed with flying colours...now just got to not bottleit on the day.
-
I passed with flying colours...now just got to not bottleit on the day.
Well done you!
-
Yea great news. well done under pressure (:)
-
I passed with flying colours...now just got to not bottleit on the day.
Yea great news. well done under pressure (:)
thanks both....I'll be playing Bear Dance.
Even got asked if I wanted to play a 2nd song...'Skye boat song' (comment-'that instrument sounds nice with the guitar')
-
Had the 'main' practice yesterday. Well it started off I was just going to play Bear Dance in the break....but they liked it so much I'm now playing it with the whole band for a dance!?!
I'm also joining in on skye boat song (practice was funny me and Anna - Fiddler- we were doing fine it was the two blokes with guitar and mandolin that kept going wrong.lol!)
And they all seemed keen to find ways I could contribute even if I wasn't playing the tune. Like on King of the Faries, it was suggested I drone Em to start them all off.
Now...just got to find someone to video my debut. lol!
-
Luv it!
(now I can say 'I knew ldt before she was famous ;) )
-
Luv it!
(now I can say 'I knew ldt before she was famous ;) )
don't think I'm going to get famous...more like infamous maybe ;)
-
Good on you LDT. I hope it's a heap of fun - and more exciting than being the tambourine player!!
-
and more exciting than being the tambourine player!!
What's wrong with being the tambourine player? I have a whole brigade of timbrelists (tambourine players) in my congregation - they really rock!
;D
-
We have what is politely known as a PTA ceilidh band - just for fun, local gigs. When we finally admitted that we could no longer justify meeting each week in the pub to find a name, we realised the only common thread was that everything was in Sharon's Handbag. The non-playing halves of couples became the callers and also join in, dancing like the Shadows with tambourines and collectively known as the Baguettes!
Rob.
-
Were still on a hunt for a name...none of my ideas have been picked yet. Oh yeah, how did it go tonight...well it went ok most of the notes in the right order but doubt anyone would have heard thanks to me getting the mic that was broke and no stand. Me and my cousin (impromtue soundman for the evenin) managed to tie the mic to my musicstand with a shoelace. Lol
-
and more exciting than being the tambourine player!!
What's wrong with being the tambourine player? I have a whole brigade of timbrelists (tambourine players) in my congregation - they really rock!
;D
Fair point - was it one of the musicians in the 'Buena Vista Social Club' who reckoned that playing the tambourine was an art form?
-
I remember a young lad who was a virtuoso triangle player for a ladies morris side in Uxbridge. Wonder what ever became of him, he was called Andrew Cutting (:)
-
Were still on a hunt for a name...none of my ideas have been picked yet. Oh yeah, how did it go tonight...well it went ok most of the notes in the right order but doubt anyone would have heard thanks to me getting the mic that was broke and no stand. Me and my cousin (impromtue soundman for the evenin) managed to tie the mic to my musicstand with a shoelace. Lol
my erm....microphone set up
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/08bd1209.jpg)
lol! good job I'm good at knots.
Pictures from the evening
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/10bd1209.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/07bd1209.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/LDTbd1209.jpg)
Didn't get a recording...the person I asked to record me was so buy laughing at her grandad dancing....she forgot to look over for my 'signal' to record. lol!
-
Congratulations LDT! It is great to see a pic of you up there with 'em playing your box, great stuff.
-
LDT,
congratulations on entering the wonderful world of the gigging musician, I wholeheartedly recommend you acquire a roll of gaffer tape. This will cure all manner of ills - dodgy mic stands, broken meloden bits, wayward leads, wobbly music stands. Etc. £4.95 per roll for the decent stuff, and it'll last ages. Walk into any hardware shop, look in the adhesives and tapes section, and ask for "Gaffer" tape, (or "Gaffa" dependant on your accent. The Americans call it duct tape, and it's not bad for that too). It's the most important tool in my gig bag, after my Leatherman, and it never leaves my gig bag......except when being used at gigs.
-
Q Why is Gaffa tape like 'The Force'?
A Because it has a light side, and a dark side, and it holds the universe together!
-
Congratulations LDT! It is great to see a pic of you up there with 'em playing your box, great stuff.
apparently I'm a 'bit of a diva'. lol
LDT,
congratulations on entering the wonderful world of the gigging musician, I wholeheartedly recommend you acquire a roll of gaffer tape. This will cure all manner of ills - dodgy mic stands, broken meloden bits, wayward leads, wobbly music stands. Etc. £4.95 per roll for the decent stuff, and it'll last ages. Walk into any hardware shop, look in the adhesives and tapes section, and ask for "Gaffer" tape, (or "Gaffa" dependant on your accent. The Americans call it duct tape, and it's not bad for that too). It's the most important tool in my gig bag, after my Leatherman, and it never leaves my gig bag......except when being used at gigs.
Gaffa tape (as a child I thought it was called Duck Tape)...thanks for the advice...anything else its handy to carry?
Q Why is Gaffa tape like 'The Force'?
A Because it has a light side, and a dark side, and it holds the universe together!
*groan* that was my msn messenger quote for ages. ;)
-
Gaffa tape (as a child I thought it was called Duck Tape)...thanks for the advice...anything else its handy to carry?
It is called duck tape (at least from one supplier)