Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Willh on August 11, 2017, 09:51:43 AM

Title: Basic repair costs
Post by: Willh on August 11, 2017, 09:51:43 AM
Hello to all,

I've got a couple of melody reeds that stick when I use one particular voice and the bass side doesn't fully kick in unless I lean on the bellows a bit. That is, if I play gently and quietly so as not to irritate my wife – and to be fair, who wants to hear anyone play a tricky four note passage about 300-400 times – the lowest of the reeds doesn't vibrate right away.

A friend who is an established player said the sticking reeds may free with more play, but one doesn't speak at all when using this particular voice, so I'm sure this one reed at least will need to be cleaned.

As for the bass side, my friend thinks the leathers may need to be replace on a couple of reeds, but is really an optional thing. That being said, I would like this box (Hohner Club IIIM) to be the best it can be.

Oh, and the bass side hand strap is too loose for me and I'd like to have this tightened.

Can someone in the know give me a general idea what the above work would cost? Basically, I'd like a couple of melody reeds cleaned, possibly replace the leather "wind savers" (at least that's the term for chromatic harmonicas) on the bass side and have the hand strap shortened.

Many thanks,

Will
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Theo on August 11, 2017, 10:08:33 AM
It's a reasonable question, but almost impossible to answer accurately without seeing the instrument. How many leathers need to be replaced?  If the leathers on the inside of the block need to be replaced then the reeds must come off and then be re-waxed.  The sticking reeds could be because of dirt, or loose wax, or valve problems.  Shortening the hand strap is something you can do yourself.   You need a screwdriver and something to make new holes in the strap. 

I'll mike a wild guess and say between £20 and £200.   In future you may find that you need to replace more valves and more wax. 
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Willh on August 11, 2017, 10:23:41 AM
It's a reasonable question, but almost impossible to answer accurately without seeing the instrument. How many leathers need to be replaced?  If the leathers on the inside of the block need to be replaced then the reeds must come off and then be re-waxed.  The sticking reeds could be because of dirt, or loose wax, or valve problems.  Shortening the hand strap is something you can do yourself.   You need a screwdriver and something to make new holes in the strap. 

I'll mike a wild guess and say between £20 and £200.   In future you may find that you need to replace more valves and more wax.

Thanks, Theo.

I'll book an appointment with my local repairman and asking him to give the box a once over and me a quote for the work involved.

Hopefully it'll be closer to £20 than £200. :)

All the best,

Will
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Winston Smith on August 11, 2017, 10:25:20 AM
Willh, not trying to be funny with you, or anything like that, and from my position of ignorance as well......... there's not really an answer to be had until one of our revered fettlers could have a look at your box. Only then would they be able to assess what it needs and then give an approximation of cost to make it "the best it can be".
Good luck with it.
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Willh on August 11, 2017, 10:32:11 AM
Willh, not trying to be funny with you, or anything like that, and from my position of ignorance as well......... there's not really an answer to be had until one of our revered fettlers could have a look at your box. Only then would they be able to assess what it needs and then give an approximation of cost to make it "the best it can be".
Good luck with it.

Thanks, Edward.

Point taken and I fully understand what you're saying. The same would apply if someone asked me similar questions about work on a double bass (my primary instrument), but ballparking (as Theo has done) helps. Not having had any accordion work done in the past, I just didn't want to turn up at my local repairman's workshop and have him say something like £200 or more and my jaw drop open and me look like a cheapskate / rube. :D

I'll take my box to my local pro and get his feedback.

Thanks for your time,

Will
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Rog on August 11, 2017, 11:46:28 AM
Completely agree with Theo. It may also be that if you want to play quietly and you are having to lean on the bellows to get it to speak, some of the reed setting might need checking and possibly altering to suit your ..er..salon style. Reed setting is the gap between the end of the reed and the slot. I am a noisy, loud player and tend to go at it like it's bullworker. But if, for instance, a child decides to play, they are often much more gentle and the box might need optimising for that style of play. Partularly noticed this one day when a child played beautifully on a PA and I was struck by how light was her touch.
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Willh on August 11, 2017, 12:16:50 PM
Completely agree with Theo. It may also be that if you want to play quietly and you are having to lean on the bellows to get it to speak, some of the reed setting might need checking and possibly altering to suit your ..er..salon style. Reed setting is the gap between the end of the reed and the slot. I am a noisy, loud player and tend to go at it like it's bullworker. But if, for instance, a child decides to play, they are often much more gentle and the box might need optimising for that style of play. Partularly noticed this one day when a child played beautifully on a PA and I was struck by how light was her touch.

Good points. I'll discuss this with my guy when I go to see him.

Will
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Grape Ape on August 11, 2017, 02:41:12 PM
I have also found that many problems can sort themselves by simply opening up the box and cleaning the inside of dust and debree.  I use an air hose with light pressure, blow out all the dust, and more than once this has sorted what I thought were more severe problems.  Also, replacing a few leathers is not a very hard job as long as the reeds do not need to be rewaxed. 
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 11, 2017, 04:41:48 PM
I'll book an appointment with my local repairman and asking him to give the box a once over and me a quote for the work involved.
Hopefully it'll be closer to £20 than £200. :)

If the repairman knows his stuff and deals with the wax, replacement valves, reed gap setting and tuning, etc. properly, you will probably (hopefully) be amazed at the difference this makes to the playability and response of the instrument. It really is worth spending the money to get the box properly fettled and set up. Almost certainly your Club IIIM will need this work doing. Don't skimp on it for the sake of spending a bit of money. Get the box playing properly now.
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Willh on August 12, 2017, 05:46:51 AM
I'll book an appointment with my local repairman and asking him to give the box a once over and me a quote for the work involved.
Hopefully it'll be closer to £20 than £200. :)

If the repairman knows his stuff and deals with the wax, replacement valves, reed gap setting and tuning, etc. properly, you will probably (hopefully) be amazed at the difference this makes to the playability and response of the instrument. It really is worth spending the money to get the box properly fettled and set up. Almost certainly your Club IIIM will need this work doing. Don't skimp on it for the sake of spending a bit of money. Get the box playing properly now.

Thanks, Steve. You've sold me. I like the way it plays now, but can hear where it can be improved.

I may never own another box, so you're right - it just makes sense to get this one playing the very best it can and enjoy playing it for as long as possible.

And is it too early to feel a twinge of MAD setting in? I've already caught myself thinking how useful it would be to have a club in D/G or even a B/C/C# with stradella bass! Oops!

Will
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Winston Smith on August 12, 2017, 07:20:32 AM
"I may never own another box"

You obviously don't know what we know!
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Willh on August 12, 2017, 11:22:36 AM
"I may never own another box"

You obviously don't know what we know!

I think this is what my wife fears. :D

Will
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 12, 2017, 11:39:27 AM
Quote from: Willh link=to pic=20972.msg251956#msg251956 date=1502513211

I may never own another box

 ::)  ::)  ;D
Title: Re: Basic repair costs
Post by: Grape Ape on August 12, 2017, 07:09:34 PM
"I may never own another box"

You obviously don't know what we know!

I think this is what my wife fears. :D

Will

She'll grow used to it, albeit begrudgingly...

Somewhere there is thread with sage (and some not so sage) advice on how to deal with one's partner in regards to Madness and its many manifestations.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal