Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Lester on November 10, 2007, 04:31:40 PM
-
I am the proud owner of Streb #21. For the uninitiated a Streb is a reedless midi melodeon. It has 128 different voices and amps and speakers for both the treble and bass.
First place to look for info is www.streb.co.uk
Steve Rouse, who appears here now and again, produces the Streb as a sideline when not teaching physics.
So what does a Streb let you do (please note this is what mine (Streb eMelodeon.2 2.5 row 12 bass) does, if you want anything else just ask Steve):
Keys:
It will play as a diatonic in E/A, A/D, D/G, G/C, C/F, F/Bb and Bb/Eb
Or in Irish in B/C and C#/D
But if you want really strange it is possible to tune it up or down a semitone so Db/Gb to D#/G# and anywhere in-between. I find it useful playing against my chums harmonium which is pitched a bit below concert.
Keyboard layouts:
- 3rd button start
- 3rd button start with accidentals
- 4th button start with low notes
- 4th button start with accidentals
- two minor key layouts courtesy of Sqeezy
Half Row Layouts:
- Standard Saltarelle
- Standard (?) Castagnari
- Andy Cutting
- Irish
Bass Layouts:
- Standard
- Standard with Bmin
- Irish
- Low Octave
There is a switch to take out the thirds
Voices
Each end of the melodeon can be allocated one of 128 midi voices these are mostly from the standard set by mine also has the following melodeon/concertina samples:
- Hohner 1 row mid 8ve dry
- Hohner 1 row mid 8ve wet
- Hohner 1 row low 8ve, mid 8ve dry
- Hohner 1 row low 8ve, mid 8ve dry, high 8ve
- Hohner 1 row low 8ve, mid 8ve wet
- Hohner 1 row mid 8ve wet, high 8ve
- Hohner 1 row low 8ve, mid 8ve wet, high 8ve
- Lachenal Edeophone concertina
- Mory middle octave Dry
- Mory middle octave Swing
- Mory Bass (low reed) Full fundamental
- Mory Bass (no low reed) Full fundamental
- Hohner Club
- Club Bass Full fundamental sample
- Wiener
- Wiener Bass
- Pokerwork
- Pokerwork Bass
Other stuff:
You can set up the following to your hearts content:
- Bellows Sensitivity – Light, Medium, Heavy
- Bellows Response – Flat, Linear + 3 more melodeon like curves
- Treble Octave – 2 octaves above normal to 2 octaves below normal
- Treble Pan – moves sound from treble end speaker to bass end speaker
- Bass Octave – 2 octaves above normal to 2 octaves below normal
- Bass Pan – moves sound from bass end speaker to treble end speaker
- Balance – Balance between Treble and Bass volumes
- My favourite The Knob Function – Sets what the second control knob does – Fine Tune, Chorus or Reverb
- For the ones not selected for the Knob Function you can set the Fine Tune, Chorus or Reverb
I did a quick calculation and found taking all the variables into account there is something like 2,000,000,000 different settings so don’t try them all.
How to Play
The Streb comes with the ability to play one of eight user-settable patches these are selected by one of the rocker switches. So after hours of harmless fun you can set up your 8 favourite patches which contain treble and bass voices and all the other parameters above.
The other rocker switch has two functions, one end changes the key of the instrument the other the keyboard layout.
Other controls are the Volume, On/Off, the Knob as described above, the Thirds Switch.
There are also sockets for:
- Headphones – really useful if, like me, you spend a lot of time in hotels, loud as you like and no neighbour disturbance
- Midi Out - to control other sequencers/midi boxes
- Mono Out – to drive a separate amp
- Combined Stereo – to drive a separate amp with Treble on one channel and bass on the other
- Separate Stereo – on two sockets to drive a separate amp with Treble on one channel and bass on the other
- DC in for the supplied power brick.
Power
The Streb takes 6 x “C” cells which last a remarkably long time. I use rechargeables (NiMH)
Again I must reiterate that this is my Streb but if you have any sane or insane ideas Steve is open to suggestions. For instance I have my twelve bass set up as a mini Stradella accordion bass not very successful but easy for Steve to implement and would have cost me a fortune on a reeded melodeon. So as any key can be mapped to any note the world is your crustacean of choice.
If you want any more info add a reply and I will update the review.
Edited to add new para at the beginning and a picture
-
What does it weigh? I can't help but imagine that it has got to be pretty heavy.
Guy
-
They're remarkably light - no reeds, you see. I've never weighed mine (2.5 row, 12 bass), but I'd say it's about the same as a Hohner Pokerwork.
Cheers,
Clive
-
What does it weigh? I can't help but imagine that it has got to be pretty heavy.
Guy
Quick visit to bathroom for scales - 3.5Kg. About 1.5Kg lighter than a Salterelle Connemarra 3 an equivalent 2.5 row 12 bass. Plus the weight distribution is different as most of the weight (batteries and electronics) is in the treble end so the bass end is relatively light.
-
how about putting a few hi-res pics up on ther site, or even a youtube video of just what it can do.. now that would Really make us all jealous ! - and probably give Mr. Streb more work than he could ever cope with ..
-
Hi Lester,
i wait for my streb melodeon. It should be arrived next Year Juni 08 :-) . Thank you for your interessting posting. :-)
Jürgen
-
I am also a proud player of the same model of Streb as Lester. All of the specifications of my box are the same and it's an absolutely brilliant invention.
While the sounds of sampled melodeons stored on the Streb are very good, I'm afraid you'd never mistake them for the real thing. I have been experimenting with the instrument as something I can use on stage in Bellowhead because a) it would mean I would never have to change the instrument I was playing, b) When flying to gigs abroad - the excess baggage on 4 boxes can be really expensive and c) it would allow me to play samples of other instruments e.g. Piano (which is very convincing indeed) ... so I needed to get the instrument to sound like a real melodeon.
Using a Mac laptop, good software and a soundcard attached to the midi out of the Streb, I think I've just about cracked it! Here's how it works:
Midi out
The midi out port on the Streb can be attached to the mac through a USB midi interface (it is best to have this as a separate USB device to the soundcard as the USB connection needs to be optimised to avoid stuttering in the sound). I have since improved on this with a fantastic device mad by M-Audio called the "Mid-Air", this transmits the midi signal from a little box which I have velcroed on the Streb to the computer making you completely wire and tangle free if you use the Streb on battery power.
Sampler - Sequencer
I think that this could be made to work with any such piece of software (and many are available). I use one called Kontakt 2 made by a company called Native Instruments. It's basically a powerful piece of software that turns your computer in to a proper midi playback device. You can load any high-quality sample bank available on the market and get the Streb to play them. Unfortunately the world has not yet found the need for a wide range of commercially available different melodeon sounds! So I recorded my own sample banks and put them together using Kontakt 2. So far I have made very convincing banks for: Hohner Corona III, Hohner 1 row-4stop, Saltarelle Connemara II and Jeffries Anglo concertina - I have had less good results with Oakwood model 7 and Castagnari Tommy. The program is able to link the volume controller (the one which makes the bellows change the dynamics) to the volume of the instruments and interpolates so there is no "step" that you can hear as the bellows pressure is slowly increased or decreased.
Output - Soundcard
I have a cheap sound card which again plugs in to a USB socket on the mac laptop called a Tascam US122 - this takes the sound and gives an option of jack out (Left and Right or Stereo), or a headphones socket. I can then send a left and right hand signal to the sound-desk for live performance through a DI box which gives the soundman the same thing as if you had 2 mics on an acoustic box. Of course for practice you could just plug some desk speakers into the laptop headphone socket or even listen on the laptop's rubbish speakers which is a bit odd!
This method gives a sound which (in a big band at least) sounds indistinguishable from a real acoustic melodeon. Yes - it takes a bit of a slog to set up and the extra equipment costs loads. But it achieves the ultimate goal of a melodeon for stage use that can change key/sound at will.
So why am I not currently using it on all gigs?
Well - I did take it to 3 festivals abroad in 2006. The first was a disaster - not because of the Streb but because of the dodgy Danish outside power supply to the Mac - the sound stuttered and stalled in places and occasionally just played one note really loud and got stuck on it! So I made some tweaks to the system and played the entire gig at Rudolstadt festival in Germany using just the Streb - it was perfect. I have a recording and to me it just sounds like me playing the melodeon in the band. I tried it again with Eliza Carthy and the Ratcatchers in Madrid and it was less successful - although the system worked - we had a dreadful monitor engineer who basically turned melodeon signal off in my monitor speakers - so I couldn't hear a note which hinders playing somewhat - unfortunately the speakers in the Streb are not loud enough to hear properly over the noise of a gig like an acoustic melodeon is when that sort of thing goes wrong.
Also - although the design is brilliant - playing it hard for over an hour is definitely less comfortable than most posh boxes, the dimensions, weight distribution and hard corner on the left hand are very similar to that of an old Hohner Club model III (the wooden ones) - I certainly get a bad line on my wrist and feel slighly awkward playing it ... however that may be something the same as getting an new box of any type and I should just get used to it. Above all though - I am not quite confident in the system of external devices I am using at the moment to play it on stage. I will keep trying though.
In addition to this way of playing it, the midi-out function is also brilliant for creating midi tracks in sequencers like Logic or Pro-Tools which store the tune information in midi form. It's also great for entering tunes in to music notation software like Sibelius or Harmony Assistant - for someone like me who doesn't think in piano keyboard mode.
All in all a brilliant product - still in development to some degree in my opinion - but Steve is incredibly clever at troubleshooting problems I've flagged up before and is dedicated to making it the best it can be.
Cheers
Squeezy
-
I'm also the owner of a Streb, and again the same model. Steve was great and responsive in setting up the instrument for me, and delivered it-no mean feat as I live in rural Wales!
It's brilliant, and I play it a lot, but haven't used it on stage for the same reasons-the sound isn't like that of a real melodeon. It would be great to be able to take one instrument, rather than several (especially as I play guitar and mandola as well, and fitting these into my Smart car is getting more like a jigsaw puzzle daily).
I like the idea of the different sample banks that you've recorded, and of using these live. However, you've talked about using a Mac laptop, and I don't have one. I'm going to pass this on to our regular sound man, but any ideas about if this could be translated to using a standard laptop would be welcome....
Thanks...helpful stuff!
Guy
-
Thanks for all of the, very, informative comments.
I don't play much live mic'ed up melodeon, record perfectly satisfactorily with the various instrument mics, mixers and digital packages on my pc and don't really think I need one.
But hell do I want one.
The only way to put me off is to tell me how much one is- I can't find a price which usually means I can't afford something.
-
I like the idea of the different sample banks that you've recorded, and of using these live. However, you've talked about using a Mac laptop, and I don't have one. I'm going to pass this on to our regular sound man, but any ideas about if this could be translated to using a standard laptop would be welcome...
Well - you can use all the equipment and software on a PC laptop as long as it's got a high enough specification. Off the top of my head I can't remember the amount of RAM memory you need and all that - but I use a mac because they are good at not getting taken over by all the paraphernalia that comes with a PC - I wouldn't trust my normal PC not to lock up and die for live stuff because the anti-virus program wanted to connect to the internet at that moment in time or something similarly trivial.
By the way - if anyone has the stuff to do this with their Streb - I am happy to burn CDs with the samples and patches I have made and send them to see whether it works or can be improved upon.
Squeezy
-
it might do loads of things.just like a keyboard i have.even get a good trumpet sound from that....but a streb AINT a melodeon.......and it has no place in accoustic music.................it's quite one thing to amplify an accoustic instrument.but.'midi'...........you could get exactly the same effects...from a midified !..just about anything............sorry mate but a melodeon it aint.
-
it might do loads of things.just like a keyboard i have.even get a good trumpet sound from that....but a streb AINT a melodeon.......and it has no place in accoustic music.................it's quite one thing to amplify an accoustic instrument.but.'midi'...........you could get exactly the same effects...from a midified !..just about anything............sorry mate but a melodeon it aint.
Calm down, you are entitled to your opinion but no need to rant!
-
The only way to put me off is to tell me how much one is- I can't find a price which usually means I can't afford something.
When I asked this question in July the prices varied from about £1k to about £1600 depending on the model. The waiting list was about 18 months so plenty of time to save up.
I was quite impressed by Revles's rant. There weren't enough capital letters for a real flame though. This is obviously a board for polite melodeon players only! Even when ranting!
-
This is obviously a board for polite melodeon players only! Even when ranting!
How could it be anything but polite. If I upset people here then I've nobody else to talk to. :'(
-
it might do loads of things.just like a keyboard i have.even get a good trumpet sound from that....but a streb AINT a melodeon.......and it has no place in accoustic music.................it's quite one thing to amplify an accoustic instrument.but.'midi'...........you could get exactly the same effects...from a midified !..just about anything............sorry mate but a melodeon it aint.
Whilst I am not over keen on electonic midi sounds I would still class the streb (which I dont own but would quite like to own) as an electronic melodeon for the simple reason that it has the same shape, size, keyboard layout, bellows etc and therefore requires the same playing technique.
My reasons for quite fancying one are probably the same as everybody elses in that whilst I much prefer an acoustic instrument the DG particularly has limitations in being able to play in various keys requested by singers and in the 'flat' keys to go with pipes or brass instruments. It must also be very useful to be able to nudge the tuning up or down in an infinately variable way as guitarists can do with crapo to fit in with the unknown kes of some singers.
I think on balaance I see the acoustic box & the streb as being complimentary - pity it hasnt got a true melodeon sound, but then I have never come accross a keyboard that gives a true accordion sound even when it has a button specially for that purpose.
george
-
I agree with Revies. Unless it has brass reeds and preferably, stiff leather bellows, it isn't a melodeon. Furthermore everything post-Flutina is suspect but then, I'm in my dotage. ;D
modified to correct glaring spelling error.
-
If the melodeon is defined as a free reed instrument then it isn't a melodeon ::)
EDIT: I wonder if it would be too difficult to add small midi switches to the keyboard of a normal reed melodeon. There is also room for a couple of PCBs.
EDIT2: ...and a pressure switch connected to the midi volume...
-
EDIT: I wonder if it would be too difficult to add small midi switches to the keyboard of a normal reed melodeon. There is also room for a couple of PCBs.
Yes! (http://www.accordionmagic.com/MIDI.html)
And here is an example of why I'm not a fan of midi instruments (http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/accordion/) ???
-
[
[ /]And here is an example of why I'm not a fan of midi instruments[/url] ???
it is rather like a strap on organ, if one is allowed to use that expression!
george
-
EDIT: I wonder if it would be too difficult to add small midi switches to the keyboard of a normal reed melodeon. There is also room for a couple of PCBs.
Yes! (http://www.accordionmagic.com/MIDI.html)
And here is an example of why I'm not a fan of midi instruments (http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/accordion/) ???
Oh come on Theo, you are a good enough craftsman and electronics engineer, plus it also offers the same advantage of the player piano, you'll be able to see and hear how the originator played the piece. It inspired many to take up the piano, might work for these funny squeezebox things.
BTW Risto, Will be shouting for Marcus and throwing rocks at Citroens in my homeland this weekend. ;D
-
I have been in correspondence with Peter "Stormy" Hyde (of this forum) who seems to have a number of projects in preparation at the moment including a box with both conventional reeds and a midi option.
-
Oh come on Theo, you are a good enough craftsman and electronics engineer, plus it also offers the same advantage of the player piano, you'll be able to see and hear how the originator played the piece. It inspired many to take up the piano, might work for these funny squeezebox things.
But did you listen to the sound sample on the second link?
Craftsman maybe, but electronics engineer me? Not a chance, anything DC and I'm ok but truly I am almost completely ignorant of electronics, either anlaogue or digital.
I'm a great believer in using the best available technology for whatever purpose. For the kinds of music I'm interested in that is usually a variety of acoustic instruments. For me one of the great strengths of the two row melodeon/diatonic accordion is that it is limited. It forces me to be more creative to overcome those limitations, and it sometimes forces me to stop playing and listen, which is good for keeping my ego under control.
-
Well.I (please note the use of capitals here !) have to say I have enjoyed the response to my post...but I was not ranting when I wrote it...I was actually having a chuckle to myself...............my first post..'returned and retuned'.....following a bout of long term illness............now fully recovered..............got only ONE response......got the impression the site was not particularly friendly or welcoming.........so decided to be a bit provocative.much better response...............it may be worth noting that ,as far as I can see, there is no 'new members' slot on the site...............have I missed it or are we not expecting any new members..........
Whilst I still consider the 'streb' to be not a true meodeon........it is an incredible bit of work and for those who enjoy I say best of luck and enjoy......Les.
-
... which is good for keeping my ego under control.
The Streb has a volume control to perform that function! :D
To Revles: I don't recall anybody, least of all me, suggesting that the eMelodeon was a true melodeon, God forbid. It is an electronic instrument needing a melodeon method of playing with sounds approximating to those of a melodeon. The same functional description could be applied to an electronic piano or electric guitar.
Thanks for all the positive reviews, I am pleased that the instrument has found a niche. I am still making them as fast as I can, honest, but the day job really gets in the way. Any teachers out there who find that the job sucks the life out of you these days?
Steve
-
....Any teachers out there who find that the job sucks the life out of you these days?
Steve
You may have heard of the shooting incident in one of our schools with eight shot dead including the principal. The intimidated teachers are now writing in the newspaper bulletin boards complaing about the same thing as you. Not having means to maintain dicipline because the students are so well protected now forces teachers to find other jobs.
----------
Yes!
Well, yes it could be for someone who has no related education or other suitable experience. Midi electronics are pretty much available for anyone these days. Certainly there would be things to sort out, like the bellows action for instance.
----------
BTW Risto, Will be shouting for Marcus and throwing rocks at Citroens in my homeland this weekend. ;D
Actually I do believe in miracles, but not this time (saves my raspy vocal cords). ;)
EDIT: Unless you can do something Bill?
-
Any teachers out there who find that the job sucks the life out of you these days?
Not any more ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
-
Theo,
Anyone who can cope with left hand throttles and Indian electrics, which in truth are digital. id est on or off, unlike those of us who had to deal with Lucas 'Prince of Darkness' equipment which had three states, on, off and maybe, would have absolutely no problems with MIDI switching. If you could also design a system of button lowering, we could all apparently play The Flight of the Bumble Bee. Now stay out of this Squeezy, we know you can. ;)
As you appear to enjoy the simple life, how's the fiddle going?
If only the Tudors hadn't usurped the Plantagenets, we would have had two King Theos already. We are lucky on Melnet as we have King Theo the First and are thankful for him. ;D
-
The same functional description could be applied to an electronic piano or electric guitar.
Not sure I can agree there- the electric guitar is a genuine guitar, it has strings which are plucked/strummed whose vibration is picked up by electromagnetic coils (as opposed to through the bridge on an acoustic) and then sent on to an amplifier and speaker. There are midi guitars in existence, which have a similar response to some of those above.
-
Hey,
How much do the Strebs cost? Anyone know?
Tom
-
How much do the Strebs cost? Anyone know?
Contact the man himself here:
http://www.streb.co.uk/contact.htm
-
Any teachers out there who find that the job sucks the life out of you these days?
A very accurate description - some days it feels like the Dementors have arrived on mass! There are two things that help:
1. I head for the top of the nearest cliff, step off and fly... ...attached to a paraglider of course.
2. I play a melodeon...
... and herein is my problem: I love the sound, I love the tunes - my family do not! Next to flying, this is the best way I've found to unwind me and get some 'soul' back. However, the degree of unwind is inversely proportional in the rest of the family who are truly wound up by it (no one else suffers this I'm sure).
So acute is the problem that my wife, in an effort to stave off divorce and family disintegration, has offered to buy me any melodeon that has a 'silent mode'. Enter the Streb...
So, add to its silent properties all the configurable options and the instrument must surely be a versatile, fun and very interesting addition to what is available to box nuts. I'm sure it isn't going to replace my acoustic instruments but I'm also sure it is going to help me practice more (I need it), experiment with different layouts and play more tunes. If it does this, it will be worth every penny.
My family can't wait for me to get my hands on it. My wife suggests that Steve should have an "express waiting list" on compassionate grounds. I'm just looking forward to a world in which my playing isn't the start of World War 3!
Keep up the good work Steve. Oh, and you are ready for the New National Curriculum, Specialised Diplomas etc. etc. etc. aren't you.
Rgds
Paul
-
Any teachers out there who find that the job sucks the life out of you these days?
A very accurate description - some days it feels like the Dementors have arrived on mass! There are two things that help:
1. I head for the top of the nearest cliff, step off and fly... ...attached to a paraglider of course.
2. I play a melodeon...
Another option is to take the melodeon into school and practice in your classroom at lunchtime.
I used to do this. Kids were completely fascinated by the instrumenet, and ended with a school ceilidh band. It was the best thing I did for the kids and myself. I was tolerated politely by the music department who were very much of the view that music=classical.
A colleague of mine who was a senior teacher played northumbrian smallpipes in his office at lunchtime. Nobody bothered him while he was playing.
-
Another option is to take the melodeon into school and practice in your classroom at lunchtime.
Quite so... if we have a charity event on I usually busk the dinner queue. I take a Pokerwork with me and hand it over to anyone who wants a go. Had my arm twisted to play the Student / Staff talent show last year - turned up with a set of Morris bells, played some fast and furious stuff whilst the kids spontaneously danced in the aisles. Got third place too!
Now, the Northumbrian Pipes... that is an idea!
Paul
-
So acute is the problem that my wife, in an effort to stave off divorce and family disintegration, has offered to buy me any melodeon that has a 'silent mode'. Enter the Streb...
Hi Paul, I know the problem with the family. My wife sometimes revolts against my "daily practice" (daily if it possible).
I live in an apartment an I can play until 21 pm with my Castagnari Box. She can not do really anything with Irish Music but she accept it and my part in a Irish Music Band. That`s the "chief reason" for me to order the Streb. To practice silence late at night :-) . The Rest fine options of the emelodeon are fantastic too. The waiting list is a long long time if there a tense situation but the Streb should be arrived in Juni 08. ;D I´m looking forward at this moment.
Sorry for my bad english and all the best from germany
Jürgen
-
But as a ballpark figure £1,000 to £1,500 minimum depending on your options (how many bass buttons, wood sused etc)
-
I have a (sensible)question....the batteries..do you have to keep buying new ones or can you plug it into the mains and recharge like a mobile phone?
-
I have a (sensible)question....the batteries..do you have to keep buying new ones or can you plug it into the mains and recharge like a mobile phone?
The Streb doesn't include an internal charger (it does include a mains adapter, so you can play it plugged in), or at least it didn't when I bought mine. However, I do use rechargeables, charging them using a separate battery charger. (I use Ansmann Max, which hold their charge for longer than most rechargeables, and I use AA rechargables in C battery holders, because it's what I had already; C rechargeables would obviously hold a much greater charge than AAs (over twice as much) -- but both the batteries and chargers are much more expensive. C batteries are also much heavier than AAs, so the melodeon would be heavier. I buy quite a lot of rechargeable batteries and chargers and use a company called Tantronics, www.tantronics.co.uk, who have a good range and are very helpful. I keep a charged spare set as well; so the total is 12 batteries. Even at AA that is not an inconsiderable expense (obviously not as much as a melodeon!).
-
How long do the batteries last before needing a recharge, say for example if you were at a festival doing lots of playing in sessions? I've heard they don't last very long.
-
How long do the batteries last before needing a recharge, say for example if you were at a festival doing lots of playing in sessions? I've heard they don't last very long.
I really can't imagine taking it to a festival or a session other than as a novelty to be honest. The battery life depends on whether you're internally amplifying or not and how much. A couple of hours maybe?
For festivals you can of course take bags of charged batteries with you (I already do this for my Edirol R-09!)
-
Another option is to take the melodeon into school and practice in your classroom at lunchtime.
Brilliant idea!! I have started doing this and even had a little 'busk' in the school yard. The kids loved it and it was great for my confidence. Unfortunately it is hard to busk with only two tunes so it was short lived glory, but I have great plans for the future!! (:)
-
I really can't imagine taking it to a festival or a session other than as a novelty to be honest.
Can I ask why not?
-
I really can't imagine taking it to a festival or a session other than as a novelty to be honest.
Can I ask why not?
Festivals: because (electrical) power and weight are at a premium for festivals; I'd rather have a small light melodeon that I can stick in a backpack or pick up as well as a backpack (hello, Liliput) and not worry about ensuring it's powered. The Streb isn't large or heavy, but it's larger than any of my other boxes.
Sessions: I'm going to be spending most of my time at a session knocking out tunes in D or G, or picking up tunes. I don't need the wilder features of the Streb at a session; I'm not going to be switching between different patches except for fun.
Compare a concert; if I were playing melodeon on several different songs/tunes, the Streb would allow me to set up a perfect patch for each piece and create multiple moods/keys.
-
I really can't imagine taking it to a festival or a session other than as a novelty to be honest.
Can I ask why not?
Festivals: because (electrical) power and weight are at a premium for festivals; I'd rather have a small light melodeon that I can stick in a backpack or pick up as well as a backpack (hello, Liliput) and not worry about ensuring it's powered. The Streb isn't large or heavy, but it's larger than any of my other boxes.
Sessions: I'm going to be spending most of my time at a session knocking out tunes in D or G, or picking up tunes. I don't need the wilder features of the Streb at a session; I'm not going to be switching between different patches except for fun.
Compare a concert; if I were playing melodeon on several different songs/tunes, the Streb would allow me to set up a perfect patch for each piece and create multiple moods/keys.
Ah thanks. So in other words, it's mostly because you wouldn't need the additional options the Steb offers and a smaller lighter box is more convenient...
Many thanks for the reply.
Many thanks for the reply.
-
Nothing to do, of course, with the (average) traditional folk musician's loathing of everything electric?
This of course ranges from Public Address Systems to electric instruments - and all stations in between!
-
Nothing to do, of course, with the (average) traditional folk musician's loathing of everything electric?
I really don't think I can be accused of this, given this blog posting from 2007:
Ah. A long weekend at Chippenham folk festival. Just us, a tent, and the great outdoors. Getting back to nature and enjoying English traditional music, song and dance.
I'm nearly ready to go. I just have to finish charging my camera, my husband's camera, my daughter's camera, my stereo camera, my Nintendo, my daughter's Nintendo, my son's Nintendo, my work BlackBerry, my home BlackBerry, my husband's phone, my iPod, my husband's iPod, my daughter's iPod, and all the batteries for my Edirol R-09 data recorder.
-
I never presumed you were Alison (audiences are a bigger problem than palyers) - but there is a STRONG resistance to technology (frequently referred to as electrickery) among a large chunk of the folk music world. I get it in many more ways than one: I am comfortable working with decent PA (both sides of the desk), I play electric guitar as well as acoustic and - real horror at this - I use a guitar synth as well as electric guitar to boot.
There was a time when free reed was modern technology, and not "proper" - I just wish they would remember it sometime.
-
There was a time when free reed was modern technology, and not "proper" - I just wish they would remember it sometime.
And the early music people have never forgotten this!
-
Apart from of course Blowzabella, who used melodeon to great effect from the outset.
-
I have a (sensible)question....the batteries..do you have to keep buying new ones or can you plug it into the mains and recharge like a mobile phone?
. I buy quite a lot of rechargeable batteries and chargers and use a company called Tantronics, www.tantronics.co.uk, who have a good range and are very helpful. I keep a charged spare set as well; so the total is 12 batteries. Even at AA that is not an inconsiderable expense (obviously not as much as a melodeon!).
Just wondering why do you need to buy a lot of rechargeable batteries doesn't this defeat the object of rechargeable or do they deteriorate?
-
I have a (sensible)question....the batteries..do you have to keep buying new ones or can you plug it into the mains and recharge like a mobile phone?
. I buy quite a lot of rechargeable batteries and chargers and use a company called Tantronics, www.tantronics.co.uk, who have a good range and are very helpful. I keep a charged spare set as well; so the total is 12 batteries. Even at AA that is not an inconsiderable expense (obviously not as much as a melodeon!).
Just wondering why do you need to buy a lot of rechargeable batteries doesn't this defeat the object of rechargeable or do they deteriorate?
They do to some extent, especially when you use them in cheap chargers, and they occasionally get lost. But we have 4 Wii remotes, and a Wii Fit board, and various wireless keyboards and mice and so on, and no end of a lot of hideous beeping toys, and the Edirol and the Streb and some portable speakers.
Having said that, we haven't gone through so many since I bought a much more expensive charger; it happily charges one at a time rather than in pairs, it's very smart about not over-charging, and it's fast. Worst charger ever was a cheap one from IKEA that ate a dozen batteries before we worked out what was going wrong.