Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Ollie on July 31, 2009, 03:17:47 PM

Title: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ollie on July 31, 2009, 03:17:47 PM
I started playing about a year and a half ago on a Pokerwork, but I'm thinking that soon I'm going to need to move onto a better box. My ideal melodeon is probably something like a Castagnari Mory; something that can do more than my current box can both in terms of notes played and sounds produced. Trouble is I'm skint and probably don't have enough money to move onto something like that just yet, but I still feel like I need to move on. Really, I'm looking at going half way to a Mory and getting something with some more voices, but sticking to a 2 row. A stop taking out the thirds in the left hand would be extremely useful as well. Any recommendations?

Ollie
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: jb on July 31, 2009, 03:21:03 PM
take a look at this recent thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2028.0.html)
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ollie on July 31, 2009, 03:23:21 PM
Ah, thanks for that. Not sure how I missed that!  (:)
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: george garside on July 31, 2009, 05:22:25 PM
most of us played pokerworks quite happily  untill all the costallotis came on the scene!  Several professionals would have nothing other than a well set up pokerwork  & the prices of most of the more expensive boxes is well past the ridiculous - perhaps its our collective fault for buying them but I cannot see how it can possibly be more costly to manufacture a 2 row 8 bass box than  a 120 bass piano accordion with many times the number of  reeds & loads more mechanism.  Perhapps one of Theo's restored/ refurbished non chinese pokerwords would be just as good & far cheaper.

george
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: joe on July 31, 2009, 05:33:16 PM
I ended up getting a Castagnari Dony in D/G (did I mention that anywhere else?!!!!)

I was thinking of a C/F but at the end of the day the D/G will be more session friendly. I dont see it as a replacement to the pokerwork though, which definitely my choice for playing morris. (mind you my Pokerwork is German, and the sound has matured over the years, like a good cheese)

The new box (like most italians (boxes that is)) has a great dry sound, is a lot more reactive and plays nicer in many ways. But it did cost a fortune. I had to buy one after playing a Castagnari the other week, and noticing that things were so much easier to play on it. I got the extra .5 row for that bit of experimentation, but it does mean the box is quite heavy.

Too many decisions for you!!!!!
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Mike Higgins on July 31, 2009, 11:04:19 PM
We old chaps like pokerworks, if I could play a pokerwork as well as JK I would be a very happy bunny.

I hope no one takes offence at the following comment but, may I say that the sound JK gets out of a pokerwork suggests that the problem is not in the melodeon.

Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Waltham on July 31, 2009, 11:10:56 PM
If you've been playing  D/G pokerwork then consider as your next box a G/C pokerwork.  It'll open a whole new world of melodeon playing to you.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ollie on July 31, 2009, 11:13:06 PM
If you've been playing  D/G pokerwork then consider as your next box a G/C pokerwork.  It'll open a whole new world of melodeon playing to you.

May I ask how?

I hope no one takes offence at the following comment but, may I say that the sound JK gets out of a pokerwork suggests that the problem is not in the melodeon.
When I said sounds produced, I meant that I'd quite like a box with at least 3 voices and a stop; even JK can't manage that on a pokerwork. Also, I'm not a huge fan of swung or wet tuned boxes, I much prefer the Italian dry sound.

I dont see it as a replacement to the pokerwork though, which definitely my choice for playing morris. (mind you my Pokerwork is German, and the sound has matured over the years, like a good cheese)


Yeah, I agree, Italian boxes don't really work for playing Morris. I'd definately keep my Pokerwork for that.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 01, 2009, 07:53:29 AM
G/C is essentially what the instrument was originally designed for. AFAIK someone modified to D/G to suit English music (also C/F for Germans etc)  The C scale lies well on the keyboard and has real guts when you dip to a G against it's V (G or G7) chord. Just sounds a nice tone - pokerwork or otherwise.

But the big step comes when you play in its main keys: C or Am. Its higher octave is also a fifth lower in pitch, so no longer sounds tinny and thin. Most D/G players (including yours truly) rarely venture to the upper octave - those buttons are more or less wasted.

On a C/G its a pleasure. You'll find yourself building the melody there, and dropping in bass runs with index finger. It is a whole different way of playing.  D3R

Addendum re below: Fred Paris is utter master of the 'play it with fingers 3/4/5 and put in a counterpoint with index finger' and it's worth listening for that in his music. But not possible on a D/G, as we play down at the bottom where there aren't those lower notes.

As for Norbert and Stéph - I've attended several of their 'stages* d'accordeon' and will be at another this month. I'd found it a bit of  struggle playing in their keys on even a D/G 3-row - the main issues being lack of pull Ab in A harmonic minor, and no pull G-bass = a rather weedy Gm. My 2 row C/G has these, but 30% fewer notes so also a restriction.

But this is another step beyond.  I feel the issue in this thread is whether to change voice or experiment with extra buttons. Chris

*stage = course. Well recommended, they challenge everything you take for granted in UK. But a bloody long pedal down to val d'Isere!
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: melodeon on August 01, 2009, 07:54:18 AM
I have owned a few Pokerworks and Ericas...  Coronas  and  Club boxes

I have also owned 1  row  2 row  3 row  and 2 1/2 Castagnaris  including the Mory.

One very talented player on You tube  plays a few tunes on his 3 row  Handry Castagnari and a few on his  Hascy 2 row....
he mentions he much prefers the 2 row

I agree.. I much prefer the 2 row.

In 2 row Castagnaris I have owned 2 Lillys a Tommy and a Hascy.  The Hascy is an outstanding accordeon.. a classic.
Adult sized .. full volume  full tone.... incredible box.

I would strongly recommend rather than opting for more alternatives with added buttons...

Get a Hascy and get a third stop for the bass

The new Hascy's have grille mounted switches  rather than top mounted.   3 reeds with the stop to pull out the low reed.

Frederick Paris plays  Hascys and I have recordings of him using a G/C  and a C/F  remarkable stuff.

I would recommend  getting  G/C  for all the continental music and for all the literature available including the Milleret/Pignol tutorials.

I would suggest that you could play hundreds if not thousands of tunes with a 2 row  and be 90% of the way to what a 2  1/2 row could do.

You might also consider the SANDER  which would be a less fancy version of the Hascy with durall reeds.  They sound great and play well.
And lower price.  But still a Castagnari and miles apart from the Hohner in playability, tone.. and tone modulation... timbre... etc

were I to buy another Castagnari.. it would be a Hascy   either in A/D or Bb/Eb

I found that I used my Mory in the 2 row mode the majority of the time.... and did not care for the extra weight and bulk.  And they do not breathe like a HAscy.

Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: george garside on August 01, 2009, 09:26:34 AM
We old chaps like pokerworks, if I could play a pokerwork as well as JK I would be a very happy bunny.

I hope no one takes offence at the following comment but, may I say that the sound JK gets out of a pokerwork suggests that the problem is not in the melodeon.



Tony Hall  gets more out of  2  voice pokerwork  than most people can gt out of a 3 voice box. Both Tony Hall & John Kirkpatrick will be at Whitby folk week.

george
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Sandy on August 01, 2009, 10:48:11 AM
Fred Paris is utter master of the 'play it with fingers 3/4/5 and put in a counterpoint with index finger' and it's worth listening for that in his music. But not possible on a D/G, as we play down at the bottom where there aren't those lower notes.


Don't want to be picky but it is possible on the D/G saltarelle nuage and possibly other three stop boxes. John Spiers uses this technique in 'red kites'. I couldn't cope with out the 'low sound' reed combination for a few of my e minor arrangements.

Sorry this isn't really on thread but G/C boxes sound interesting.

I also find it strange that some people only like one particular sound. My salterelle can sound particularly sweet but I also love the hohner sound for certain things.....still saving for one of Theo's refurbed Ericas!

cheers

Sandy
 (:)

Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Falseknight on August 01, 2009, 11:02:26 AM
I started playing quint on a G/C Erika.  When I added a three row Corona, I was really quite disappointed with how limited the G Row was.

Incidentally I've always considered the outer row to be the main row of a two row instrument - don't know if that is correct or not.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: IanD on August 01, 2009, 02:03:25 PM
We old chaps like pokerworks, if I could play a pokerwork as well as JK I would be a very happy bunny.

I hope no one takes offence at the following comment but, may I say that the sound JK gets out of a pokerwork suggests that the problem is not in the melodeon.



Tony Hall  gets more out of  2  voice pokerwork  than most people can gt out of a 3 voice box. Both Tony Hall & John Kirkpatrick will be at Whitby folk week.

george

TH gets more out of a 2 voice pokerwork than most people can get out of *any* melodeon irrespective of number of rows, reeds or buttons... ;-)

Ian
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Mike Higgins on August 01, 2009, 02:07:59 PM
When I started playing a melodeon I didn't know that there were other makes, models or types than a D/G pokerwork. In fact I didn't care either.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 01, 2009, 02:22:38 PM
Quote
When I started playing a melodeon I didn't know that there were other makes, models or types than a D/G pokerwork. In fact I didn't care either.

I would kind of echo Mike's sentiment - except I wasn't playing a melodeon - as far as I knew then it was an accordion. The names and makes actually mattered diddly-squat, all I knew was that I wanted to be able to play it and have fun. Not much has changed for me.
AL
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: george garside on August 01, 2009, 02:34:36 PM
We old chaps like pokerworks, if I could play a pokerwork as well as JK I would be a very happy bunny.

I hope no one takes offence at the following comment but, may I say that the sound JK gets out of a pokerwork suggests that the problem is not in the melodeon.



 ]

TH gets more out of a 2 voice pokerwork than most people can get out of *any* melodeon irrespective of number of rows, reeds or buttons... ;-)

Ian

indeed! ;)

george
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 01, 2009, 03:46:54 PM
John is superb, Tony Hall amazing! Such prestidigitation. Shame I cannot make Whitby this year.

Once watched Quebecois legend Philippe Bruno play a one row in five keys (most of which "aren't there")  ???
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Mike Higgins on August 01, 2009, 05:58:16 PM
Quote
Such prestidigitation

I have a sneaky feeling that this comes of sticking to one instrument for n+ years and becoming utterly familiar with everything that it can do.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: waltzman on August 01, 2009, 06:02:29 PM
Quote
Such prestidigitation

I have a sneaky feeling that this comes of sticking to one instrument for n+ years and becoming utterly familiar with everything that it can do.

The cure for MAD?
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Nick Hudis on August 01, 2009, 07:08:59 PM
Choice of instrument might depend on what music you want to play and who's playing inspires youto want to emulate.

If you are into to the english session scene, or morris or whatever a D/G Poker makes sense.  Maybe one day you'll sound as good as JK or TH.  Mind you a lot of Tony's recordings are on a C/F and G/C boxes. 

Once I really got into box playing, I found myself playing mainly French, Slavic and Scandi stuff and really inspired by the likes of Stephane Delicq and other great French players.  A G/C with Italian reeds has been a perfect choice for me.  You can play in a suprising number of keys on a G/C+ 3 row including all the D/G keys, but it doesn't sound remotely like someone playing the "English style" on a Pokerwork. 

I once heard a clip of a (very good) italian player playing an Irish jig on  a nice Costalotti.  Nice and slick, but if I hadn't read the caption, I's have assumed I was listening to a Tarantella!
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Mike Higgins on August 01, 2009, 07:24:42 PM
Quote
I once heard a clip of a (very good) italian player playing an Irish jig on  a nice Costalotti.  Nice and slick, but if I hadn't read the caption, I's have assumed I was listening to a Tarantella!


I'm not surprised at this comment as I know that if one comes from a particular, strong, musical culture it is almost impossible to entirely shake this off thus playing everything with a hint of that culture remaining underneath. In much the same way 'classically' trained musicians have the same underlying technique, witness Stephane Grappelli playing jazz with Yehudi Menuhin.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 01, 2009, 07:45:57 PM
I have a sneaky feeling that this comes of sticking to one instrument for n+ years ..

Can't argue against that.  I've had a few in my time and am 'where I want to be' at the moment. The core of my melodeons is still an honest D/G and 'un clavier simple en sol/do' for the other one.

But there's more to playing our instrument than extra buttons or scales.  Timing, rhythm and swing are so important as well as the ability to pass from chords to 'run' to tune effortlessly. And that mysterious ability of good players to make the ear hear notes - they haven't actually played.  Tony Hall has achieved this.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Prestidigitator on August 02, 2009, 02:20:43 PM
I have a sneaky feeling that this comes of sticking to one instrument for n+ years ..

And that mysterious ability of good players to make the ear hear notes - they haven't actually played.  Tony Hall has achieved this.

I couldn't agree more. I've been listening to Tony Hall play live in East Anglia (and other places) for around 40 years. I've been pushing melodeon buttons for about the same time, and whilst I greatly admire the playing of younger musicians (John Spiers and what I've heard of Sandy Shallis spring to mind), my own aspiration has been to play with the wit, fluency and mysterious magical ability that Tony has. Fat chance of that, but nothing like setting the stakes high!
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Sebastian on August 03, 2009, 12:03:04 PM
I hope no one takes offence at the following comment but, may I say that the sound JK gets out of a pokerwork suggests that the problem is not in the melodeon.
Yes, exactly.
Incidentally I've always considered the outer row to be the main row of a two row instrument - don't know if that is correct or not.
Don't know about "correct or not", but many of the things I play modulate into the quint and back (but never into the quart), so for me the inner row is automatically the main row (if I play in major keys).
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: ganderbox on August 04, 2009, 01:23:21 PM
I started playing about a year and a half ago on a Pokerwork, but I'm thinking that soon I'm going to need to move onto a better box. My ideal melodeon is probably something like a Castagnari Mory; something that can do more than my current box can both in terms of notes played and sounds produced. Trouble is I'm skint and probably don't have enough money to move onto something like that just yet, but I still feel like I need to move on. Really, I'm looking at going half way to a Mory and getting something with some more voices, but sticking to a 2 row. A stop taking out the thirds in the left hand would be extremely useful as well. Any recommendations?

Ollie

I would suggesting thinking why you feel you need to "move on", and what you want your next box to do that your pokerwork doesn't. Do you want to play in more keys (if so, which and why?), play on both ends of the keyboard, have low notes as well as accidentals, have accidentals on an extra row rather than at the end of the box etc etc, or do you just want a box that's maybe more comfortable to play?

Next thing is go out and find some boxes try, and see what you like. If you are used to a pokerwork, something like a Mory will feel like a big heavy lump, and probably totally alien in your hands. Find what sort of boxes, big or small, feel right for you.

I've just got back from Sidmouth, and played lots of different boxes on the stands that I haven't played before(including an 18 bass Handry which DEFINITELY wasn't me!).  If I'd been looking to buy a 2 row 3 voice D/G, I would have been tempted by the Beltuna Sara 3 on the Hobgoblin stand, and also the Saltarelle Berry which the Music Room had. I've heard great things about Hascys. but unfortunately there were none to try.

 

 
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Owen Woods on August 10, 2009, 07:16:31 PM
I've just got back from Sidmouth, and played lots of different boxes on the stands that I haven't played before(including an 18 bass Handry which DEFINITELY wasn't me!).  If I'd been looking to buy a 2 row 3 voice D/G, I would have been tempted by the Beltuna Sara 3 on the Hobgoblin stand, and also the Saltarelle Berry which the Music Room had. I've heard great things about Hascys. but unfortunately there were none to try.

Aye, I played the Handry as well, didn't much like it. The one I was taken with was the cannibalisation of a Pigini CBA into a C#DG, with the stradella transposed into D home rather than C and with the counters a semitone below. It was around 1400, which compared to some of the prices that they were charging for DGs is very good. Of course it had a stepped keyboard and an inadequate air button.

Now is not a good time to buy a brand new box though. The prices for Italien boxes are through the roof, the pound being as weak as it is. May be a good idea to scour the second hand markets, although getting a Mory for an affordable price would be tricky.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Bob Ellis on August 10, 2009, 11:44:02 PM
Progressing from a Pokerwork can be a tricky business. There are plenty of traps for the unwary....and I have fallen into quite a few of them, bruising my wallet and my ego in equal measure in the process. When I made the transition from my first box (a D/G Erica), I decided on a Mory because I like the sound Andy Cutting gets out of his and because I thought I would grow into it, eventually producing stunning sounds by using the slides and buttons to change the tone. Not surprisingly, it didn't work out like that: the box was too big and heavy for me; I couldn't achieve the fast light bellows action I wanted; and it did serious damage to my back when I played standing up for long periods playing for our Morris side. After a couple of years struggling, I down-sized to a Dony, with which I had the same problems only to a lesser extent. I also found that the half-row wasn't giving me enough of the accidentals I wanted.

After two ill-thought-out and failed attempts to move up to a box that would suit me better than the Erica and give me more of what I wanted, I decided to do the job properly. I sat down and worked out carefully what I needed and spent several months trying different boxes until eventually I devised a right-hand layout that suits my needs, abilities and limitations and had a small three-row box made to accommodate this system. Problem solved: the standard of my playing and the enjoyment I get from it have both improved significantly because I am now playing a box that suits me.

The moral of this story is threefold: be clear about what you want out of a new box, don't rush the decision, and try as many boxes as possible until you find the perfect partner for you.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Andy Next Tune on August 11, 2009, 09:59:44 PM
As this thread has shown, there are lots of places to progress to from the Pokerwork.

And it 100% depends upon the type of music you wish to play, where you want to play it and what new stuff you want from the next box.

My personal progression has kept me in D/G land. When I returned to box playing after 15 years in the wilderness (not for this thread), I purchased a Dino Bafetti Binci from the Music Room as my focus is morris and english tunes, often playing outdoors - the Binci has a great bass and a really strong sound.
However that was followed by a Hohner Liliput (Ebay, plus Theo makeover)  a really compact 2.5 row box with that distinctive Hohner sound and great for sessions.

But the Pokerwork is still in use (its had its 25 year overhaul & retune), particularly as a 'poor weather' morris box.

Oh, and a couple of 4 stop one-rows happened to arrive as well.

As Bob said, you really need to think not just what but why. And definitely investigate second-hand boxes, they are great value and can often be resold for their purchase price if you find you've made a mistake.

Andy
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Steve C. on August 12, 2009, 01:56:49 AM
Another thought.

Often, I project "if only I had an 18 bass Handry, then I could play just like Riccardo Tesi".  Or a nice cherry Benny and play like Florence Pinvidic. Or other similar follies.

I have taken this to be called "You Tube Disease".  And a major cause of MAD.

What I have found, is that I do have a DG Pokerwork and I still cannot play like Tony Hall.

So, if you want another instrument, to get another type sound, look, set of keys, etc. go ahead.  I have done it, as have most members of the group.

But one is not "progressing from a Pokerwork".  Can't be done.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: waltzman on August 12, 2009, 12:05:01 PM


So, if you want another instrument, to get another type sound, look, set of keys, etc. go ahead.  I have done it, as have most members of the group.

But one is not "progressing from a Pokerwork".  Can't be done.

Well said.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2009, 12:20:06 PM
Another thought.

Often, I project "if only I had an 18 bass Handry, then I could play just like Riccardo Tesi".  Or a nice cherry Benny and play like Florence Pinvidic. Or other similar follies.

I have taken this to be called "You Tube Disease".  And a major cause of MAD.

What I have found, is that I do have a DG Pokerwork and I still cannot play like Tony Hall.

So, if you want another instrument, to get another type sound, look, set of keys, etc. go ahead.  I have done it, as have most members of the group.

But one is not "progressing from a Pokerwork".  Can't be done.

Very true. Although Tesi has a 16 bass box ;)
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2009, 12:36:48 PM
Oh yes, I've played a pokerwork and couldn't stand it. But the point that was beiung made was that you don't need millions of bass and an extra row in order to play well, indeed many players are fantastic on a "mere" two rows.

Tesi played a GCC# box I think, which I hadn't come accross before.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: ganderbox on August 12, 2009, 01:01:34 PM
I sometimes think of the hundreds, nay thousands, of pounds I have spent on melodeons, and then think of people who can play much better music than me on just a penny whistle!
 
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ellie on August 12, 2009, 01:42:45 PM
But where's the fun in that? Some of us don't have the patience to make beautiful music out of a penny whistle  ::) (we just make terrible music out of melodeons instead  ;D)
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Owen Woods on August 12, 2009, 01:50:43 PM
I sometimes think of the hundreds, nay thousands, of pounds I have spent on melodeons, and then think of people who can play much better music than me on just a penny whistle!
 

My girlfriend plays penny whistle, I have to restrain myself every time she starts talking about spending 80 or 90 pounds on a really nice one... qs I know full well that a really nice melodeon would cost 50 times that...
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 27, 2009, 08:12:07 AM
Think I've posted this here already. But last time I was in Galway the lady in the corner who'd played whistle (very well) all night - turned out to be one Sharon Shanon.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ollie on August 27, 2009, 01:25:27 PM
As mentioned elsewhere, I managed to pick up a 1930s Club III for £50 the other week, so I think eventually this will replace the pokerwork, once I get it converted to a D/G (and possibly dry tuned; not sure about that yet).
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Sebastian on August 31, 2009, 07:40:31 AM
I get it converted to a D/G
Sinful thinking ...  >:E
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 31, 2009, 08:42:05 AM
....once I get it converted to a D/G (and possibly dry tuned; not sure about that yet).
Arghhh! Don't do it! I assume it was originally in C/F? That tuning is becoming more and more popular these days. Get it overhauled and the tuning fettled, but much better to leave it in its original key, IMO.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 31, 2009, 09:28:06 AM
Quote
get it converted to a D/G
WOAH! I agree with Steve - leave well alone if you can.
AL
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: C age ing on August 31, 2009, 10:00:32 AM
Go for it Ollie. This is not meant to cause mirth or anger. Okay, it isI've got an Erika in D/G with flattened third and sevenths on the half row. It's my blues box.
It was supplied by Theo, so Stevie F and H. Al are criticising the guy who pays for this site. :( :(
To show the strength their convictions are Steve and Al willing to bear the full cost of converting my box back to the original tuning?  ;D ;D
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 31, 2009, 10:04:35 AM
Quote
To show the strength their convictions are Steve and Al willing to bear the full cost of converting my box back to the original tuning? 
Why? Would you rather it was back in its original tuning?
 ;D
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ollie on September 02, 2009, 12:11:28 AM
Quote
get it converted to a D/G
WOAH! I agree with Steve - leave well alone if you can.
AL

Hmm, the third person who's said that to me as well. It really needs a re-tune and a service, but am now thinking twice about getting it converted to a D/G. Tis tempting though... :-\
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Alison Scott on September 02, 2009, 08:39:44 AM
Hmm, the third person who's said that to me as well. It really needs a re-tune and a service, but am now thinking twice about getting it converted to a D/G. Tis tempting though... :-\

I've had a lot of earache about getting the Liliput converted (from Eb/Bb). I am sure it was a fine antique in its original key, but this way I actually play it. The household has a bucket of Liliputs though since hubby discovered how cheap they are on German eBay.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 02, 2009, 01:09:22 PM
Hmm, the third person who's said that to me as well. It really needs a re-tune and a service, but am now thinking twice about getting it converted to a D/G. Tis tempting though... :-\

I've had a lot of earache about getting the Liliput converted (from Eb/Bb). I am sure it was a fine antique in its original key, but this way I actually play it.
But, but .... Alison - isn't this t' tail waggin' t' dog?  ;)
What we need to be doing is breaking out of this prison of only playing in D and G. Let's play in the gloriously sonorous keys of C, F and Bb too.
If it's OK for Brass Monkey ...... etc.
Retuning C/F and similar instruments to D/G only perpetuates and reinforces the prison bars.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: OwenG on September 02, 2009, 01:21:06 PM
Too true!!

Also, with Club boxes the keys of D and G are still available and are perfectly playable, but have a completely different feel. Somehow more slinky  8)
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 02, 2009, 01:26:13 PM
Agree with Steve, but the standard UK session keys are the D/G based ones, with only A and Bm really awkward on the D/G box. I've just re-arranged my 'down and out' blues into Bb as it suits my voice. But it's a song and I don't need to concern overmuch about other people.  

So I'll be keeping the Oakwood for standard festival sessions.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: rees on September 02, 2009, 02:54:04 PM
Three of us had a Bb/Eb session at ECMW this year - it's a start.  :||: :|||: :||:
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: melodeon on September 02, 2009, 03:18:04 PM
Just found a mint Pokerwork ion F/Bb    custom made for a player in the states a number of years back

Thought I might pick it up.. not sure what a value should be on a near mint box.. plastic fingerboard though

Perhaps  F/Bb  is halfway to playing with you big boys.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: HallelujahAl on September 02, 2009, 03:38:13 PM
Quote
Three of us had a Bb/Eb session at ECMW this year - it's a start.
Well, I too am hoping to get an F/Bb/Eb box soon - so be keen to join in again next year ;)
Mind you - I only want it so I can jam with my brass band!
AL
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Falseknight on September 02, 2009, 03:39:46 PM
Too true!!

Also, with Club boxes the keys of D and G are still available and are perfectly playable, but have a completely different feel. Somehow more slinky  8)

In the right hand, but not really in the left.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: melodeon on September 02, 2009, 03:41:06 PM
http://sketchup.google.com/3dwarehouse/details?mid=1bc80fdb9d7b31bd89c091eff00709a5
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Alison Scott on September 02, 2009, 03:49:35 PM
But, but .... Alison - isn't this t' tail waggin' t' dog?  ;)
What we need to be doing is breaking out of this prison of only playing in D and G. Let's play in the gloriously sonorous keys of C, F and Bb too.
If it's OK for Brass Monkey ...... etc.
Retuning C/F and similar instruments to D/G only perpetuates and reinforces the prison bars.

I wanted a Liliput specifically to cart around festivals, light enough to carry around all day so that I'd have a melodeon on me in case a session started up. Most session tunes are in D/G (and Em) so for this purpose I needed a D/G; I can pick up the easier tunes in those keys now within the three-times-through that we mostly get, but not tunes in other keys. And there are sufficiently many Liliputs on German eBay that I am not seriously concerned that the stock of C/F and  Bb/Eb boxes will disappear.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: OwenG on September 02, 2009, 03:59:19 PM
Quote
In the right hand, but not really in the left.

 ???

With a bit of fudging, and on older Club boxes where you can tape up the thirds, you've got the three-chord trick for both D and G (as well as C, F and Bb).
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 02, 2009, 04:08:56 PM
What we need to be doing is breaking out of this prison of only playing in D and G. Let's play in the gloriously sonorous keys of C, F and Bb too.

To my ear the beauty of those last 2 keys lies in their relative simple minors = Dm and Gm respectively.  There's a load of French tunes coming out at present that alternate G major with G minor, joining the (frankly not too well related) keys over a D7 chord. The bagpipers love it too.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: C age ing on September 02, 2009, 05:41:48 PM


But, but .... Alison - isn't this t' tail waggin' t' dog?  ;)
What we need to be doing is breaking out of this prison of only playing in D and G. Let's play in the gloriously sonorous keys of C, F and Bb too.
If it's OK for Brass Monkey ...... etc.
Retuning C/F and similar instruments to D/G only perpetuates and reinforces the prison bars.
Steve,
You are a talented clarinetist and own at least one pair of black sticks. That raises two questions
1) Why not just own one liquorice stick, the longer one, and learn to really play altissimo?  ;)
2) If you are already playing one chromatic instrument, why are you so against those who want to keep playing their quint two rowers in the keys they prefer? If you really want to play a chromatic melodeon, George Garside is the boss.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: ganderbox on September 02, 2009, 06:17:26 PM
What we need to be doing is breaking out of this prison of only playing in D and G. Let's play in the gloriously sonorous keys of C, F and Bb too.

To my ear the beauty of those last 2 keys lies in their relative simple minors = Dm and Gm respectively.  There's a load of French tunes coming out at present that alternate G major with G minor, joining the (frankly not too well related) keys over a D7 chord. The bagpipers love it too.

I really like those sorts of tunes, and bagpipes and hurdy-gurdies like them because they can move seamlessly from major to minor, as the drones will fit either.
A C/F plays easily in Gm and Dm , but then to play those tunes you would have to play in G or D major as well, which isn't so straightforward on the C/F. On the other hand, you can get by in G and Gm on a D/G 2.5 row, and D/Dm works reasonably well too (but sometimes better on a G/C).
That's why I resisted the temptation to buy a nice C/F recently! :(
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 02, 2009, 06:50:37 PM
Steve,
You are a talented clarinetist and own at least one pair of black sticks. That raises two questions
1) Why not just own one liquorice stick, the longer one, and learn to really play altissimo?  ;)
2) If you are already playing one chromatic instrument, why are you so against those who want to keep playing their quint two rowers in the keys they prefer? If you really want to play a chromatic melodeon, George Garside is the boss.
Hello Bill,
Ultimately of course people have the free choice to tune their boxes to whatever they like. All I'm really trying to do is to get the message across that there are other options for the melodeon in the UK other than playing in D and G, and old boxes say in C/F , F/Bb, etc., can really sound so nice in those keys that it's a shame to change them. There are plenty of D/G boxes around for those that want them.

Just over a year ago, I bought a 2nd-hand Marc Savoy cajun box in C. It was tuned beautifully in Cajun just temperament with flattened thirds and sevenths, and some of the RH chords sounded gorgeous. However, as a result of the Cajun tuning it didn't sound so good on the East Anglian tunes, which is what I mostly wanted to play. I had two options: get it retuned to 'equalish temperament' or sell it on to someone who really wanted a Cajun box for Cajun music. It seemed somehow sacreligious to change such an already beautifully tuned box, so I chose the second option. My C box is now the good old Max tuned in equal temperament, which is cheerful and happy for East Anglian tunes. So everyone is happy. 

I have no desire to play a chromatic melodeon, thanks.

I'm lazy on the clarinet. I would much rather play in the flat keys on the instrument rather than the sharp keys. So I'm always looking for opportunities to play on the A clarinet, which has the automatic effect of removing 3 sharps from the concert key signature. 
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: theSmoiler on September 02, 2009, 09:50:50 PM
Three of us had a Bb/Eb session at ECMW this year - it's a start.  :||: :|||: :||:

We could make that four (at least) at Stowmarket this weekend - with Matt Quinn also bringing his Eb/Bb...   :||: :||: :||: :|||:
Now there's a thought...Sessions being taken over by Eb/Bb players...I love the sound of such boxes!

Diane
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Falseknight on September 02, 2009, 10:38:32 PM
After I posted, I guessed taping the thirds would be an answer.  Mine is a coupled IIIM so I don't think this is an easy option.  Mind you, I could always use the basses without the bass chords  (:)

I'm going to struggle with Emin and B min though I think.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: rees on September 03, 2009, 12:05:06 AM
Three of us had a Bb/Eb session at ECMW this year - it's a start.  :||: :|||: :||:

We could make that four (at least) at Stowmarket this weekend - with Matt Quinn also bringing his Eb/Bb...   :||: :||: :||: :|||:
Now there's a thought...Sessions being taken over by Eb/Bb players...I love the sound of such boxes!

Diane

Game on.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: C age ing on September 03, 2009, 08:20:01 AM
Just over a year ago, I bought a 2nd-hand Marc Savoy cajun box in C. It was tuned beautifully in Cajun just temperament with flattened thirds and sevenths, and some of the RH chords sounded gorgeous. However, as a result of the Cajun tuning it didn't sound so good on the East Anglian tunes, which is what I mostly wanted to play. I had two options: get it retuned to 'equalish temperament' or sell it on to someone who really wanted a Cajun box for Cajun music. It seemed somehow sacreligious to change such an already beautifully tuned box, so I chose the second option. My C box is now the good old Max tuned in equal temperament, which is cheerful and happy for East Anglian tunes. So everyone is happy. 

I have no desire to play a chromatic melodeon, thanks.

I'm lazy on the clarinet. I would much rather play in the flat keys on the instrument rather than the sharp keys. So I'm always looking for opportunities to play on the A clarinet, which has the automatic effect of removing 3 sharps from the concert key signature. 
Steve,
That makes sense to even an old Alzie like me.
Strange our aversions, no objection to sharps or flats until they reach five and then reach for the Electronic Wind Instrument and use its transposing facilities. Do the same on keyboard yet despite all this electronic trickery, still pick up the Erika, in DG sorry, and enjoy a blast on a simple box.
Surely the answer is a National Streb Service and then we can all be happy.  :D
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: melodeon on September 03, 2009, 10:17:38 PM
According to common wisdom...Savoy does not tune to the standard "cajun/just" tuning.. his is a bit modified

of course your Savoy may have been retuned.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 03, 2009, 10:49:19 PM
That makes sense to even an old Alzie like me.Strange our aversions, no objection to sharps or flats until they reach five and then reach for the Electronic Wind Instrument and use its transposing facilities. Do the same on keyboard yet despite all this electronic trickery, still pick up the Erika, in DG sorry, and enjoy a blast on a simple box. ..

I like the flat keys too (and flattening notes).  2007 was my year of the jazz courses. It was me, a pianist and about 8 saxophones in an old schoolhouse in the upper Clyde valley. I was having to playon the C#/D/G Oakwood in 2-3 flats (relative to C) all the time - sometimes 4. Anything in F was sheer pleasure.  ;)

  Then came the modal jazz weekend. Eb :Ph ... [diddle diddle] ... D  .. 8) 

Such pleasure to see all those horn players suffering  - trying to play in  five #s  >:E
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: C age ing on September 04, 2009, 07:44:10 AM
That makes sense to even an old Alzie like me.Strange our aversions, no objection to sharps or flats until they reach five and then reach for the Electronic Wind Instrument and use its transposing facilities. Do the same on keyboard yet despite all this electronic trickery, still pick up the Erika, in DG sorry, and enjoy a blast on a simple box. ..

I like the flat keys too (and flattening notes).  2007 was my year of the jazz courses. It was me, a pianist and about 8 saxophones in an old schoolhouse in the upper Clyde valley. I was having to playon the C#/D/G Oakwood in 2-3 flats (relative to C) all the time - sometimes 4. Anything in F was sheer pleasure.  ;)
  Then came the modal jazz weekend. Eb :Ph ... [diddle diddle] ... D  .. 8) 
Such pleasure to see all those horn players suffering  - trying to play in  five #s  >:E
Chris,
Even have problems in C.

The answer to all key problems is to call it Free Jazz.

What might prove helpful is at the next DG session, when they come in, give them a sequential number. After the first tune, announce that for the next melody, odd numbers play the G row and evens the D row. And then alternate. Yet another reason to buy a Streb.
Old out of tune Bill.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Ollie on September 17, 2009, 10:30:50 PM
What are Castagnari Sanders like? Someone I know may possibly be selling their Sander so I looked it up on the Castag website: what are the differences between that and a Tommy (other than size)? Are they good boxes? Seems to be just what I was after.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Theo on September 17, 2009, 10:47:20 PM
What are Castagnari Sanders like? Someone I know may possibly be selling their Sander so I looked it up on the Castag website: what are the differences between that and a Tommy (other than size)? Are they good boxes? Seems to be just what I was after.

Sander was the 'entry level' 3 voice Castagnari,  it had less fancy woodwork and machine made reeds.  Still a nice box.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: george garside on September 17, 2009, 11:15:28 PM
Three of us had a Bb/Eb session at ECMW this year - it's a start.  :||: :|||: :||:

 Now there's a thought...Sessions being taken over by Eb/Bb players...I love the sound of such boxes!

Diane

 why stick at Eb/Bb - Ab   sounds nice as well

george
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: melodeon on September 18, 2009, 03:05:26 AM
It was my understanding that the Sander has dural reeds and only the Studio has machine reeds
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Theo on September 18, 2009, 08:46:28 AM
It was my understanding that the Sander has dural reeds and only the Studio has machine reeds

You could be right Jeff,   my source for this statement was a 'Music Room' catalogue from 2004.
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: melodeon on September 19, 2009, 01:17:25 AM
It was about that time they made the change.

OT   I played a Studio with binci reeds... freakin  brilliant
Title: Re: Progressing from a Pokerwork
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 20, 2009, 07:37:44 PM
What are Castagnari Sanders like? Someone I know may possibly be selling their Sander so I looked it up on the Castag website: what are the differences between that and a Tommy (other than size)? Are they good boxes? Seems to be just what I was after.

Sander was the 'entry level' 3 voice Castagnari,  it had less fancy woodwork and machine made reeds.  Still a nice box.
I use a Sander as my 'outdoor' box. It is very similar to the much sought-after Hascy: as Theo says, it has just a little less ornate woodwork on the grille and less fancy inlay on the ends. Mine has tipo a mano reeds fitted as a customised item, rather than the usual super dural reeds, which I guess makes it even more like a Hascy. However, I have played a Sander with super dural reeds, and to be honest, there was hardly any difference between it and mine with the TAM reeds.

The Sander also has the full three reeds on the basses, compared with the Tommy's two, so you get a much richer bass sound.

Overall a very nice box. Definitely recommended.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal