Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: The Happy Wanderer on September 25, 2017, 11:45:28 AM

Title: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on September 25, 2017, 11:45:28 AM
Yesterday I was playing my Hohner Liliput at the store I work at and I felt the bellows get "crunchy". I thought it was nothing, but I asked the manager when I got concerned. He advised me to stop before I cause any potential damage, and man am I sure glad he told me that. I opened the Liliput up today and I found that one of the bass reeds got lodged in the bellows folds. I was able to get the bellows off, but the reed is seemingly permanently bent. I'm a bit strapped for cash at the moment so I doubt I could afford a probably very costly repair. However, the Liliput sounds pretty much fine, with the exception of the bass reeds being higher pitched, something I noticed several days prior to the "bending".

Is it possible to remove just one reed from the reed block? What's the best course of action here? Thanks!

I should add that the whole reed block is glued in. Do you think the reed is salvageable? If not, should I try sawing it off so I could continue playing it?

Also, I doubt I could put the bass side back on without the bent reed getting in the way. It's bent at about a 90 degree angle.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: frankpallister on September 25, 2017, 12:11:55 PM
you should take it to A and E pdq what is your location ? those melnetters  nearby will offer advice and help  i am sure
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on September 25, 2017, 12:20:34 PM
you should take it to A and E pdq what is your location ? those melnetters  nearby will offer advice and help  i am sure
I'm located in Connecticut in the United States. I know a guy near here who has an accordion museum. He taped my bellows on my other accordion for me. At the moment, I'm really looking for a temporary fix until I have more money for a permanent repair.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Theo on September 25, 2017, 12:44:47 PM
Dealing with that one reed should not be a big expense.   

The simplest temporary repair would be to cover the damaged reed with tape.  If the reed sticks out too far you should be able to push it down far enough for tape to keep it in place.

If you take the reed out you would then have to find a way to close the space so it is airtight.  Just placing tape over the damaged reed will be much easier.

On a slightly different topic I wonder how the reed came to be caught in the bellows?  You might want to have a look at your bellows technique.  Moving the bellows in and out without bending them much toward the front or the back will reduce the chance of this happening again.  That will also give you better bellows control in your playing
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 25, 2017, 12:54:28 PM
Never seen glued in reedblocks on a Liliput.
Also the bass reeds, i.e. the lowest set on the left hand side, are usually in the middle and well away from the bellows folds.

A photo might be helpful in perhaps assessing the situation.

I would expect that a reed bent 90degrees out of true would be pretty unsaveable, but shouldn't be expensive to replace. So snapping it off and covering the slot with a piece of sticky tape would be an acceptable temporary solution imho.

I would be more concerned about damage possibly caused to the bellows by the bent reed; now that could get expensive! Hopefully that has not occurred....
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on September 25, 2017, 01:04:03 PM
Thanks for the replies! Fortunately, I don't think the bellows have been damaged. I didn't know that reeds were a cheaper repair than bellows. That's a relief.  (:)
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Theo on September 25, 2017, 07:31:55 PM
I would expect that a reed bent 90degrees out of true would be pretty unsaveable, but shouldn't be expensive to replace. So snapping it off and covering the slot with a piece of sticky tape would be an acceptable temporary solution imho.


True, but I would try bending the reed tongue back first.  It might not break off.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on September 25, 2017, 10:37:34 PM
I just got back from college and I am attempting to fix this issue for now. I've tried bending it back and putting taillight tape over the reed, but it doesn't seem to hold. I tried bending it off, but it doesn't seem to want to budge. Is there a way to remove the nail holding the reed into the plate?

Now that I look at it, the reed blocks aren't glued I think. They seem to be held in with a little bit of twisted metal.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 25, 2017, 11:44:19 PM
Now that I look at it, the reed blocks aren't glued I think. They seem to be held in with a little bit of twisted metal.

That sounds like the usual fitting. The bottom part of it will be threaded, so give it a quarter turn anti clockwise; it might only be finger tight, or you may need a pair of pliers to turn it, but go carefully as you don't want to snap it....

Much easier to work on the reeds with the block removed.  :D
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on September 25, 2017, 11:48:29 PM
I managed to snap the bent reed near the middle and put taillight tape over the hole. It's not perfectly airtight though, and I'm not so sure how well the tape will hold. Better than nothing though. All I hope is that the tape doesn't come loose and rip all the valves off!  :o :P

I tried the bass button now. It sounds a bit more "buzzy" than before. I guess this is the tape vibrating, but I could be wrong.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 26, 2017, 12:05:37 AM
I managed to snap the bent reed near the middle and put taillight tape over the hole. It's not perfectly airtight though, and I'm not so sure how well the tape will hold. Better than nothing though. All I hope is that the tape doesn't come loose and rip all the valves off!  :o :P

I tried the bass button now. It sounds a bit more "buzzy" than before. I guess this is the tape vibrating, but I could be wrong.

Try pushing the remains of the reed further into the slot so that the tape only adheres to the plate and the reed is out of the way.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on September 26, 2017, 12:18:47 AM
I managed to snap the bent reed near the middle and put taillight tape over the hole. It's not perfectly airtight though, and I'm not so sure how well the tape will hold. Better than nothing though. All I hope is that the tape doesn't come loose and rip all the valves off!  :o :P

I tried the bass button now. It sounds a bit more "buzzy" than before. I guess this is the tape vibrating, but I could be wrong.

Try pushing the remains of the reed further into the slot so that the tape only adheres to the plate and the reed is out of the way.

What kind of tape do you recommend I use? Duct tape? Taillight tape? Scotch tape?

Thanks!  ;D
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 26, 2017, 01:24:46 AM
I managed to snap the bent reed near the middle and put taillight tape over the hole. It's not perfectly airtight though, and I'm not so sure how well the tape will hold. Better than nothing though. All I hope is that the tape doesn't come loose and rip all the valves off!  :o :P

I tried the bass button now. It sounds a bit more "buzzy" than before. I guess this is the tape vibrating, but I could be wrong.

Try pushing the remains of the reed further into the slot so that the tape only adheres to the plate and the reed is out of the way.

What kind of tape do you recommend I use? Duct tape? Taillight tape? Scotch tape?

Thanks!  ;D

Scotch 'Magic Tape' (https://www.scotchbrand.com/3M/en_US/scotch-brand/products/catalog/~/Scotch-Magic-Tape-Dispensered-Rolls?N=4335+3294529207+3294603601&rt=rud) is good for taping over reeds to silence them. A typical application would be to silence the thirds in a chord, but it will be good for what you want too. It doesn't leave a sticky mess when it is removed. Any sort of tape will most likely damage or remove the valves when removed, but it is no great problem or hardship to replace the valve with a new one.

I find it odd that you take a course of action - e.g. you go ahead and use your 'taillight tape' and then afterwards ask for advice on what sort of tape to use. You did that on your parallel thread about bellows tape. Why not ask for advice first and then act on what experienced people on here tell you.  ???
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 29, 2017, 12:11:03 AM
On a slightly different topic I wonder how the reed came to be caught in the bellows?  You might want to have a look at your bellows technique.  Moving the bellows in and out without bending them much toward the front or the back will reduce the chance of this happening again.  That will also give you better bellows control in your playing
This should give a clue:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfUFyi6X5UQ

THW: I would recommend that you try keeping the axis of the bellows far more in a straight line and not to use such an extreme arc when playing on the push direction. On a Liliput, there is very little internal clearance between the bass-end reed blocks and the bellows folds, so bending the bellows like this has almost certainly caused the reed tongue contact with the bellows folds and the subsequent breakage.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: The Happy Wanderer on October 08, 2017, 03:46:45 PM
On a slightly different topic I wonder how the reed came to be caught in the bellows?  You might want to have a look at your bellows technique.  Moving the bellows in and out without bending them much toward the front or the back will reduce the chance of this happening again.  That will also give you better bellows control in your playing
This should give a clue:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfUFyi6X5UQ

THW: I would recommend that you try keeping the axis of the bellows far more in a straight line and not to use such an extreme arc when playing on the push direction. On a Liliput, there is very little internal clearance between the bass-end reed blocks and the bellows folds, so bending the bellows like this has almost certainly caused the reed tongue contact with the bellows folds and the subsequent breakage.

Sorry for the late reply. Thanks for pointing that out. I'm used to playing bigger boxes, like my Accordiola, where the large curving is almost always needed due to the added weight. The Accordiola is about 13lbs I think, whereas the Liliput is only 4lbs or so.
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on October 16, 2017, 04:19:29 PM
Still too heavy for me to sneak it into my hand luggage without my wife seeing it, on our holiday flight ... (Bother!)
Title: Re: Bent Reed Stuck in Bellow
Post by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on October 16, 2017, 04:22:35 PM
Preciosa ?

SJ
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal