Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Barry M on September 27, 2017, 01:21:15 PM
-
Hi all
May be a silly question
While playing I'm losing track of when how many A's or B's I have played
Would appreciate any thoughts or tips
Thank you
Barry
-
usually by concentrating hard ;D but when i notice it being a persistent problem such as in some tunes where the A is not hugely different from the B I'll use my foot position as a marker.
I find it much more of a problem when running a slow session as my mind will sometimes wander off.
And of course you get those wonderful moments when you are absolutely sure that you should be playing, say, a B part but someone else starts an A and all of a sudden the doubts are there and, and, and... ;D
-
I don't always.........
-
I try to count and more importantly listen to who I'm playing with to see if they started playing something different yet.
-
I don't always.........
;D
-
Hi all
May be a silly question
While playing I'm losing track of when how many A's or B's I have played
Would appreciate any thoughts or tips
Thank you
Barry
Badly sometimes although control is getting better with time - and apparently without thinking about it.
There's more than one good friend of mine used to be me hissing 'is that three?' at them in sessions :)
-
Mostly becomes second nature nowadays I only get lost if the tune is one where the B uses the A as its second half so AABA.
Or alternatively use the cricket umpire's 6 balls an over system and keep 4 pebbles in your pocket and swap one to the other pocket every time you play a part ;)
-
Thank you for those replies
So it's not just me that gets lost!
You have made me feel a lot happier
Cheers
Barry
-
I am constantly surprised by how difficult it can sometimes be to count up to 2.
-
I always assume that I've gone wrong when I hear someone playing something different.
The danger tunes for me are the ones I'm gaining familiarity with, you think it 's in the bag you relax and all of a
sudden your on the wrong part.
-
I am constantly surprised by how difficult it can sometimes be to count up to 2.
Especially three times in a row
-
If you are playing for dancing, then you should be watching the dancers. Knowing the dance and knowing which part of the music fits which bit of the dance should be enough to tell you where you are in the sequence of As and Bs (and sometimes Cs and Ds).
Of course, if you are in a session with no dancers, the expressions on the faces of your fellow musicians should give you a clue that you've gone wrong. Then it's a case of rapidly adjusting your playing to match everyone else! ;)
-
Even if you're playing for dancing, often the dancers and caller will expect a lead from the music, it's still up to us to be solid 'structurally'. We all know the feeling when the caller turns to the band leader with a worried look, because he/she realises the dancers have gone wrong, and the caller doesn't know why, or what to do about it, but they're calling for help. Easy to say here that past experience counts for a lot, but there's still times when the unexpected happens, for a caller. I feel the most important thing is that there are reliable channels of communications between caller and bandleader, and then bandleader and other band members. A good caller knows not to panic, but to give new instructions in time for the band to respond smoothly.
Personally I don't seem to have too much problem with counting the A's and the B's, but I do play with others who do. If there's trust between band members, it's quite possible for the lead to indicate to the others what's next in the tune's structure, but I also think that this may be a nervous 'conscious vs subconscious' issue again - we musicians must teach our conscious to trust our subconscious when performing. The musician leader should perhaps be quietly setting the structure out, to support other members in the band - this happens a lot in bands, I notice.
-
[quote author=Steve_freereeder link=topic=21172.msg254520#msg254520 date=1506524078
Of course, if you are in a session with no dancers, the expressions on the faces of your fellow musicians should give you a clue that you've gone wrong.
[/quote]
Maybe in your sessions! ::) If I may paraphrase, Cyprus is another country - they do things differently there........
Graham
-
When you're playing second box and following the lead musician, and they suddenly drop the tune, and you suddenly realise that you were on autopilot and can't remember if you just played the first or second B...
-
If you are playing for dancing, then you should be watching the dancers. Knowing the dance and knowing which part of the music fits which bit of the dance should be enough to tell you where you are in the sequence of As and Bs (and sometimes Cs and Ds).
That's part of it, but there's more to it than that:
Plan A: If playing for dancing, use the alternative approach of training the band to follow you and not worry about what the dancers think (if it's morris, they can barely hear the music above the clatter of bells anyway. If you randomise the order in practice, once in a while, they'll soon get used to it (:).
Plan B: When playing for dance, most of our dances (and why should any other side be different?) are made up of figures and sticking. When the sticks go up at the end of a figure, play the sticking music. Otherwise play the other.
Plan C: There are a few exceptions in which there are idiosyncratic A/B sequences (Twiglet and Ring O' Bells come to mind, from our repertoire). In these cases revert to plan A.
Plan D: If playing in a session where you are leading the tune, carry on with confidence, smile serenely and claim, afterwards that you tried it that way on purpose, to make the tune more interesting. Whatever you do, never, ever, stop and apologise with an embarrassed smile. You're in charge. If it's your set, you decide tempo, order of parts and tune sequence.Watch out for harmonies and counter melodies, though. If the people you are playing with aren't willing to give you the space to do this then don't play with them. They're prats. Note: You'll be fine in any sessions down our way. They are full of nice people.
Plan E: If playing in a session where you are not leading the tune. Just stop playing the wrong part and start playing the right one. Odds are no one noticed and you can be certain no one cares. Unless you discover that the A and the the B mix together rather well (again, Twiglet comes to mind), in which case carry on and say you did it on purpose, for the effect. The downside of this is that you'll have to be prepared to do this every time. It may well become a feature.
Seriously, don't fret about it. As your brain gets more involved with the sound you are making and less consciously aware of the mechanics of doing it, it becomes much less of an issue. However, even some very experienced musicians get it wrong, now and then (especially after having drink partaken). When this happens, the above Plans A to E genuinely work. [edited to say I wasn't meaning to include myself in this category.]
-
Wot Greg said :D
-
Wot Greg said :D
Like it!
-
Does no one play five or six part tunes? That can get really interesting in a session.
A competent musician should be able to glide seamlessly from one disaster to the next without missing a beat >:E
-
...A competent musician should be able to glide seamlessly from one disaster to the next without missing a beat >:E
Absolutely. Smiling serenely as you go. If you can't manage that a smug smirk will do :D
If someone tries to put you right, all you have to do is play more firmly and a bit louder, while avoiding eye contact.
-
Interesting. I have never played for dancing, and with my crap timekeeping I don't suppose I ever will.I play mostly as accompaniment to singing, but when I play just a tune, I am always at a loss when playing it with someone else, as to how many times through one should play.
When I play solo, I play AA.BB.AA.BB.A.B.
I expect I'm wrong, but I'm used to that ;)
Sir John
-
Interesting. I have never played for dancing, and with my crap timekeeping I don't suppose I ever will.I play mostly as accompaniment to singing, but when I play just a tune, I am always at a loss when playing it with someone else, as to how many times through one should play.
When I play solo, I play AA.BB.AA.BB.A.B.
I expect I'm wrong, but I'm used to that ;)
Sir John
If in doubt in a session play 2A + 2B three times through. It's a guide, not a rule.
-
If in doubt in a session play 2A + 2B three times through. It's a guide, not a rule.
Two As, Two Bs, three times. It is the law. Well mostly. Over time I have found that I can pretty much know when I've done three times through although *top tip* if in doubt shout 'one more' that way no one knows whether you've lost count our just fancy another time through :|||:
-
If in doubt in a session play 2A + 2B three times through. It's a guide, not a rule.
Two As, Two Bs, three times. It is the law. Well mostly....
I agree it's the generally session etiquette, especially if you pair it with a second tune - so Tune 1 x3 then Tune 2 x3.
However, I do get a bit frustrated at a session when trying to pick up an unfamiliar tune; I find I have just about got it by the third time through, but then bang! we're into something different.
Quite often I will play a single tune at a session, and go through it perhaps 5 or 6 times. It is generally more satisfying - gives more opportunities for variations and harmonies, and gives people a better chance to learn the tune if they are unfamiliar with it. (Unless they belong to that incredibly rude group of people who, when faced with a session tune which they don't know, start talking loudly with their neighbour, or worse, try to carry on a conversation with someone across the other side of the room. Grrr! >:( ).
One of the lovely things about the Whitby fringe Euro-sessions is that the 'three times through' rule does not seem to apply. We might play a single tune many times, discovering how delightfully hypnotic it can become (and definitely not boring). If there are some dancers on the floor too, that encourages multiple repetitions of a single tune.
As John Kirkpatrick wrote (many years ago now) - 'if a tune's worth playing, it's worth playing 100 times'.
-
If in doubt in a session play 2A + 2B three times through. It's a guide, not a rule.
Two As, Two Bs, three times. It is the law. Well mostly....
I agree it's the generally session etiquette, especially if you pair it with a second tune - so Tune 1 x3 then Tune 2 x3.
However, I do get a bit frustrated at a session when trying to pick up an unfamiliar tune; I find I have just about got it by the third time through, but then bang! we're into something different. :(
Indeed. My post may have been just the tiniest bit tongue in cheek. Also as the organiser of a steady speed session we may play tunes 4, 5 or 6 times through to help learners. Anarchy I tell you ;)
-
... Anarchy I tell you ;)
Hooray! Count me in! (:)
-
And conversely if I'm playing Lester's Big Set (6 tunes) or Lester's Big Emin Set (7 tunes) I mostly play twice through each tune.
-
However, I do get a bit frustrated at a session when trying to pick up an unfamiliar tune; I find I have just about got it by the third time through, but then bang! we're into something different.
If I play a tune that seems to be fairly unknown in the session, but others seem to be starting to pick it up, I'll go beyond three ("One more!" as Helena says) for that very reason. In a regular session when introducing a tune that I'm not expecting others to know, that'll be pretty much automatic.
There's a fine dividing line between that and finding you are playing a solo which nobody's joining in with, in which case it might be better to finish earlier rather than later.
-
On the question of keeping a tally of how many times one has played each part, I work on the principle, that if I've almost got the tune right, it must be time to stop.
Sir John
-
I usually , but not always,manage to cope with the correct number of A parts and B parts etc but occasionally have a mental block as to how to get into the next tune in the set.
On one occasion playing for a mile long morris procession I got stuck in one tune and just could not get out of it . I kept muttering to the piano box player next to me ''change'' and it was some time before he eventually realised my dilemma and made the well rehearsed change!
This hasn't happened very often but when it does 'stuck means stuck'!
george
-
You might have enjoyed watching us today at Looe. Three sides were dancing in turn. I was the only musician with our side so I was grateful for the support I got from the other two sides. An interesting time was had with a more or less random selection of As and Bs in Beardown Man (done to Beardance) and then a similar experience was had on another sides dance to Theme Vanitaisse (aka Twiglet). The nice thing about both of these was that the mixed A and B parts went together beautifully.
-
Just back from a band booking and had a bit of a moment, the caller was calling then Ides of August and we were playing Oats, Peas, Beans. Now the band played a different (wrong) C music before I joined and we have never got round to sorting it so first time through I played the proper C and the rest of the band played their version so it all sounded a bit odd and the tune seemed to get across the dance. Next time through I played the band's version along with everyone else but it was all still was odd, then I realised the caller had missed a bit of the dance and required AABBC to fit what he was calling. Strange thing is the dancers seemed oblivious to all these shenanigans (:)
-
... the band played a different (wrong) C music before I joined and we have never got round to sorting it...
I work on the supposition that there is no wrong, just a living tradition. 8)
-
... the band played a different (wrong) C music before I joined and we have never got round to sorting it...
I work on the supposition that there is no wrong, just a living tradition. 8)
Feel free but everyone in the whole wide world plays it one way and the Hayloft Ceilidh Band plays it another way
-
. Strange thing is the dancers seemed oblivious to all these shenanigans (:)
Indeed! I have come to the conclusion that for most barn dances, ceilidhs or whatevers particularly for weddings, church hall do's, school pta's etc in essence all they need is something rhtythmic that they can do a sort of jaunty walk to for most dances with the exeption of very dance specific tunes eg Swedish masquerade
george
-
You might have enjoyed watching us today at Looe. Three sides were dancing in turn. I was the only musician with our side so I was grateful for the support I got from the other two sides. An interesting time was had with a more or less random selection of As and Bs in Beardown Man (done to Beardance) and then a similar experience was had on another sides dance to Theme Vanitaisse (aka Twiglet). The nice thing about both of these was that the mixed A and B parts went together beautifully.
I thought we were wonderful ;D and of course the audience were as enthralled with our multi part harmonies as the dancers were mystified :||:
-
I'm fairly innumerate and have always had trouble with A's and B's. I tried bell ringing many years ago, it was a disaster. If you lose count it can become dangerous and you could also break something. :(
-
. Strange thing is the dancers seemed oblivious to all these shenanigans (:)
Indeed! I have come to the conclusion that for most barn dances, ceilidhs or whatevers particularly for weddings, church hall do's, school pta's etc in essence all they need is something rhythmic that they can do a sort of jaunty walk to for most dances
You can get away with it, but if a tune has a clear structure it does help the dancers and they will enjoy it more when they subconsciously learn to associate a particular part of the tune with each part of the dance. This is also a convincing argument for John Kirkpatrick's "one tune per dance" rule.
-
Having danced on several occasions to Johns one tune per dance I must admit I am less than keen on the notion!
george
-
... but if a tune has a clear structure it does help the dancers and they will enjoy it more when they subconsciously learn to associate a particular part of the tune with each part of the dance. This is also a convincing argument for John Kirkpatrick's "one tune per dance" rule.
Totally agree!
-
... but if a tune has a clear structure it does help the dancers and they will enjoy it more when they subconsciously learn to associate a particular part of the tune with each part of the dance. This is also a convincing argument for John Kirkpatrick's "one tune per dance" rule.
Totally agree!
And of course it avoids the chance of forgetting how the next tune goes, (or starting something completely unknown to other band members !) Could be age related in my case I suppose.
Having participated in the Shropshire Bedlams and Martha Rhodens slightly
notorious sponsored Sir Roger de Coverley dance, many years ago, at least there's one tune I will never forget...three times through ? More likely a hundred or so...and I don't recall we ever played the parts in the wrong order ::)
J