Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on August 01, 2009, 02:24:15 PM
-
hi all! i have a cheap old Rossetti rambler 1row that I'm quite happy to tinker around with and its in desperate need of a re tune, how is it done
? is it something you can do with basic household tools or do i need something a bit more specialist? cheers!
tom
-
Hi Tom - tuning is not a sacred science - however mistakes can be costly and ruinous unless basic precautions are taken. You are wise having a go at a box you're not too bothered about. On the other hand deciding to re-tune your p.sop would be foolish until you'd learnt what you were doing - and even then some. Now I'm no expert either but I've been finding my way through this field slowly. Here's (http://elektor.htl-leonding.ac.at/~jp/en/h/tuning.htm) a good little article that may help you get going, and it certainly helped me. My previous experience has been tuning concertina's - which are a doddle compared to accordions - I've probably tuned about 50 + concertinas, so the basic principles of reed health and taking metal off the reed at the top or bottom to reach desired tuning was already there. The problem for me was much more along the lines of how to tune the reeds that were on the inside of the reedblock (the article shows how that's done - though it could be explained better) and what tools (http://elektor.htl-leonding.ac.at/~jp/de/h/bilder/StimmTools.jpeg) I'd need. Again the article was helpful - a little. I use Dirk's Accordion Tuner (http://www.dirksprojects.nl/index.php?Lan=english&Page=Tuner/accordion_tuner_22.php) you can download a free copy of the software and trial it (with some limitations) before you buy - its not cheap. Alternatively I also use a programme called Tune!It which I got off the web from somewhere. Its basically free for about a month - but again like Dirk's it enables one to tune in situ more than one reed at a time. Pretty important. I also have a standalone Korg electronic tuning meter to help.
Hope this helps - as I said I'm no expert and am currently finding my way through this area myself. But I wish you all the best with your experiments! Feel free to pm me if you want to know anymore about my own experiences in this field.
AL
-
I have a Casali BCC# 48 bass off ebay which is in need of a bit of tlc. I'm not sure whether to have a crack at it or give it to an expert. Can one REALLY cock it up? Or is just a bit likely that I'll cock it up.
-
Hi Mike - have a go and then I'll tell you the answer at the workshop in September;)
AL
-
Hi Mike - have a go and then I'll tell you the answer at the workshop in September;)
I'm not sure that this is encouragement or a thinly veiled warning.
-
I'm not sure that this is encouragement or a thinly veiled warning.
I'm all encouragement mate! ;)
Actually its not such a sacred science as some folk think - but if truth be told Mike I'd not be inclined to start out on a three row/48 bass beastie - there's one hell of a lot of reeds in that animal. I started on 2 voice 2 row 8 bass and that was a big enough job. Am now doing the Heligonka - which is easy because the reeds are were not waxed in but held in by pins (now very small screws as I've replaced all the pins to make getting the reeds in and out a lot easier). I've also got 4 concertinas on the go - 2 anglo and 2 english - and I know I'll have them finished before I've finished the gonka!
AL
-
I'd not be inclined to start out on a three row/48 bass beastie
Right oh! I'll have a chat with Rees then.
-
Right oh! I'll have a chat with Rees then.
Yeah good stuff!
AL
-
[quote . Can one REALLY cock it up?
[/quo
Yes! best get hold of some old reeds from ? a knackered piano accordion and experiment on those before you touch a half decent box. Theres a world of difference between replacing one reedplate & tuning it to match its neighbours compared with retuning a complete box.
george
-
Yes! best get hold of some old reeds from ? a knackered piano accordion and experiment on those before you touch a half decent box.
I have an unplayable B griff, I'll experiment with that I think.
-
Yes! best get hold of some old reeds from ? a knackered piano accordion and experiment on those before you touch a half decent box.
I have an unplayable B griff, I'll experiment with that I think.
Sounds a good one to learn on.
Ideally you should learn to tune the reeds while mounted on the reedblocks, its miles quicker than having to dismount them and then mount them again which you might have to do two or three times for each reed. There are a couple of simple tools you need to buy or make to do this. If you are at Whitby call in at my stall and I'll show you.
-
There are a couple of simple tools you need to buy or make to do this. If you are at Whitby call in at my stall and I'll show you.
What a generous offer Theo, thanks very much indeed. I can't get to Whitby this year due to work commitments, so I am a bit fed up at this golden opportunity missed.
Have you though of making a DVD of this sort of thing? I would buy one like a shot and I expect others in here would as well. Although, I expect the cost of making such a video would outway the income generated from it. :( :(
Thanks again for the kind offer, I don't suppose that you are at Shrewsbury?.
-
Theo
Any chance of some photos of the tools as I am also about to embark on a restoration having purchased an unloved club on eBay for 77 of your English pounds.
-
Well done Lester I too was watching that one - hope it comes good!
Agreed some tool pics would be useful?
AL
-
Theo
Any chance of some photos of the tools as I am also about to embark on a restoration having purchased an unloved club on eBay for 77 of your English pounds.
Lester -
You now officially have too many boxes! ;D
Drop me a PM about you know what! >:E
-
I found a set of detail sanding pens from Axminster Tools (http://www.axminster.co.uk/product.asp?pf_id=21968&name=detail+sander+pen&user_search=1&sfile=1&jump=0) invaluable for tuning reeds, much less aggressive than files.
(http://www.axminster.co.uk/images/products/DSK_l.jpg)
-
so you basicly get to the reeds and file off the thin strips of metal? i was going to use my other box as a tuner, playing the corresponding notes till they sound the same?
-
Theo
Any chance of some photos of the tools as I am also about to embark on a restoration having purchased an unloved club on eBay for 77 of your English pounds.
I'll take some photos, but you really need to see how to use some of them which may not be clear from a photo.
-
Basically the theory is that you take a small amount off the bottom end (the wider end) of the reed tonge to flatten the note or a small amount from the tip of the reed in order to sharpen it. It needs to be done very carefully however as it is very easy to damage the reed. I use cut up sections of empty lager cans as my reed tuning shims - placed under the reed while filing or scratching the reed tongue. Having done that you'll have put the red out of position so the reed height needs to be re-set. Re-setting the reed height will probably affect the tuning of the reed... do you see a vicious cycle happening here? Anyway - that's it simply put. As Theo says the trick is to do it while the reed is still on the reedblock - saves one hell of a lot of faffing around. A fairly rough and ready job can be done with all reeds out of the instrument and off the block - but they'll still need to be fine-tuned on the block and under pressure when in the case.
You'll need a tuning meter I think. The ear can play all sorts of tricks - especially when tuning more than one reed at the same time.
AL
-
Al - cut up lager cans!!!! Can't be yours ::)
Pete - those files are essential for all kinds of instrument repairs/set-ups, from making bagpipe reeds to touching up high frets on stringsthings. Recommend a set to all that dabble in muso-surgery. Tony.
-
Al - cut up lager cans!!!! Can't be yours
Wondered if someone would pick that up - yes, a friendly neighbour donated them -empty and rinsed out of course - no beer on my reeds no matter how free!
;)
AL
-
Here is a link to photos showing my tuning tools (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=95032&id=709188166&l=5be6150682).
-
I've always had more success with using the plate supporting and lifting method as opposed to the hook, but by far the easiest way (I think) is to take the reed plates off from the block and put them on 'upside down' so that all the pull reeds are now on top - you can just tune as if they were the push reeds which is nice and straight forward. Just reverse the plates to the original position when you are done with the pull tuning.
If its a major over hall of a box its usually worth re-waxing around the plates. The old wax becomes really brittle and its hard to stick the plates on in the reverse position. Just clean all the old wax off (dusty job!) and replace with a small amount of fresh wax around the plate which is usually enough to hold it steady.
You wont be able to tune to another box, its just not feasible on many levels.
-
so how do you get the reeds out? they are waxed in!
-
Thanks Theo for really good pics and description of the process.
To get reeds out the wax needs to be re-heated. A basic soldering iron will do the job. It is even possible to take out the odd single reed here and there using a soldering iron - touch tune it and replace valves etc and then pop it back in by re-heating the existing wax. However, for a job lot you're going to have to remove old wax and apply new wax. Theo can supply wax I think?
AL
-
I've always had more success with using the plate supporting and lifting method as opposed to the hook, but by far the easiest way (I think) is to take the reed plates off from the block and put them on 'upside down' so that all the pull reeds are now on top - you can just tune as if they were the push reeds which is nice and straight forward. Just reverse the plates to the original position when you are done with the pull tuning.
If you want to do the best possible job you need to learn both techniques. As I said earlier, you give yourself an awful lot of extra work doing it your way, and depending on how accurate you want the tuning to be you will notice the difference in pitch that happens when the reed is on the underside rather than the top. So you will likely need to swap each reedplate over several times before you get it right.
If its a major over hall of a box its usually worth re-waxing around the plates. The old wax becomes really brittle and its hard to stick the plates on in the reverse position. Just clean all the old wax off (dusty job!) and replace with a small amount of fresh wax around the plate which is usually enough to hold it steady.
Of course if the wax needs replacing you have to take the reeds and wax off anyway, but in the lifetime of a box it will need tuning several times before it needs new wax. And you still have the tuning issue outlined above. In addition if the reed is not fully waxed when you tune it then air will leak around the edges of the reed and that too will affect the pitch of the reed by a small amount.
You wont be able to tune to another box, its just not feasible on many levels.
Perhaps not to another box, but the traditional method, before electronic tuners, was to have a set of standard reeds built into a tuning bench, and to tune to them.
-
Thanks Theo for really good pics and description of the process.
To get reeds out the wax needs to be re-heated. A basic soldering iron will do the job. It is even possible to take out the odd single reed here and there using a soldering iron - touch tune it and replace valves etc and then pop it back in by re-heating the existing wax. However, for a job lot you're going to have to remove old wax and apply new wax. Theo can supply wax I think?
AL
I think its false economy to try to re-use the old wax, even for a single reed, unless its an emergency back-stage repair.
[/quote]
touch tune it and replace valves
[/quote]
Replace the valves if necessary before tuning. The presence of the valve also affects the pitch, so tuning should be done with valve in place.
-
I think its false economy to try to re-use the old wax, even for a single reed, unless its an emergency back-stage repair.
Replace the valves if necessary before tuning. The presence of the valve also affects the pitch, so tuning should be done with valve in place.
yes - thanks for making sense of my ramblings!
AL
-
Here is a link to photos showing my tuning tools (http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=95032&id=709188166&l=5be6150682).
Fascinating stuff Theo, I didn't get to see the hook affair in your workshop. Perhaps I'll give that a go as all I seem to do with the German type of lifter is get it jammed - must practice more on a few old reed plates.
Does the German lifter work on hefty bass reeds with a lump of brass sweated onto the end?
-
Does the German lifter work on hefty bass reeds with a lump of brass sweated onto the end?
Sometimes, but I usually resort to poking something up through the vent to lift the reed enough to slip the support plate in.