Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: melodeon on August 01, 2009, 03:55:49 PM
-
I recently received a German made bellows that was represented by the US seller as
" they are as good as an Italian bellows and in many ways better"
I had recently ordered and received a couple Italian bellows so when my Harmona bellows arrived I was able to make a direct comparison
Harmona Italian
$170 USD $155
Unlined Lined
Appeared to have thinner metal corners Thicker metal corners
Apperared to have thinner bellows tape Thicker bellows tape
Appeared to have thinner leather "diamonds" Thicker leather diamonds
18 Folds ( as ordered) 20 Folds
long sides bowed inward by 3mm Straight as an arrow
Different lengths along the diagonal (out of square) Dead square
Punky bellows cardboard Stiff bellows cardboard
Generally sloppy workmanship Exacting workmanship
Do not snap back to closed position when expanded Rapidly snap back to original position when expanded
Thick for only 18 folds When relaxed in the compressed state with 20 folds, , thinner than the Harmona with only 18 folds
The Italian bellows appear to be made to an excellent deign with excellent materials and careful workmanship
The Harmona bellows looked cheap and poorly made reminiscant of Chinese bellows as well as bulky and not as supple and "snappy"
I would conclude that the Harmona bellows are not a good value at $170 and I believe that considering all the above,
at $100 USD they would be serviceable for a Hohner Erica or Pokerwork but I would never use these on a handcrafted or
higher quality accordeon.
-
Kind of stumped by this one... :-\
All the post reunification Weltmeisters/Harmonas I've seen and owned (a 'GALOTTA' branded 'C' one row door stop for a year or two) the bellows were robust, well lined with fabric, ribbed taped and properly gusseted. No bowing either. Going back further... even the bellows on my new 1981 DDR Galotta 48 bass piano box was well made, and as tough as Red Army boots... Russian reeds too...
Regards your bellows origin... Two scenarios... The dealer ordered them to be made somewhere (location debatable) recently, to a rock bottom price... and he got what he paid for. Or, perchance, they are ancient DDR era bellows the dealer has unearthed from storage (and just wants to shift)?
I'm actually wondering, though... if these bellows are actually Chinese... being 'passed off' under the Harmona name? From your description, they certainly sound like Chinese... how big are they - Corona size? Did they come labeled up/badged up?
Something odd about all this, methinks...
Ed J
-
Yes there is more to the story and it's quite disappointing and disgusting.
The seller is hiding and refuses to talk about the issue.
There was also a minor amount of damage to the ends of the bellows... some of the cardborad was bent and wrinkled.. this could be covered by a frame
What I have told you about the bellows are the facts as I see them .. the actual comparison side by side
I showed the bellows both of them to some non concertina non accordeon
woodworkers and crafstman/artists and asked them to give me their comments
All without exception said the Harmona bellows were substandard when compared with the Italian
Interesting that the seller reacted so violiently when I sent him and e mail with my descriptiion and comment that they looked Chinese.. he went absolutley ballistic..
in subseqquient e mails I talked about responsibility when it was he who said:
"as good as and in some ways better than Itailian"....
they aren't and he has not and cannot back it up except to imply I am not qualifed to judge and he is an experienced tuner/builder and "accordion engineer"
Who incidentally was to be listed as a vendor instrument maker for St Chartier this year
I have no idea if he was there or what he was selling
Perhaps copies of my rerto fit keyboards for Pokerwork and Erica ( with out my permission) but I don't know that.
I made an offer to return them for half my money back.. he refused
He is standing by "this was a special order" so I am stuck and according to him he has no responsibiltiy
I have "known" this person via e mail and phone calls for 2 years and this is the first actual monetary transaction I have had with him
I have played and owned Welties and Gallotas.. and the bellows were better than these
This set of bellows fits an Erica/Pokerwork/HA114 etc but without the wood frame
-
Whi incidebntally was listed as a vendor instrument maker for St Chartier this year
I have no idea if he was there or what he was selling
On this list?
http://www.saintchartier.org/en/luthiers.php?PHPSESSID=d80fc62cae6f6229a2e6d0f872a804b2
I don't find any vendors from the U.S.
-Andy
-
n subseqquient e mails I talked about responsibility when it was he woh said
.... and he is an .... "accordion engineer"
Hey Jeff, I don't know the law in the US, but I'm pretty sure that over here you can only trade as an "engineer' if you have professional qualifications and are accredited by a professional body.
-
Alas no, though the Engineering Council would very much like that to be the case.
-
Why don't you try to contact Harmona directly. At least they should confirm if they actually made those particular bellows. When I complained directly to Hohner about my accordions they never were unfriendly in any way and were interested in what I had to say about their products. Won't cost you anything and then you at least know the facts. On the other hand, if you just want to warn us about this particular dealer then you should at least give us his name. Otherwise the blame is cast over Harmona who may not even be the quilty one.
-
Andy I don't see it either
and I must confess that information was given to me and I did not check it out
But it may have also been another festival and I simply did not hear correctly or is was BS
So we'll just strike that info.. as unfounded
I could not imagiine him being there as he essentially has nothing to sell except "Harmona" bellows : )
As to Accordion Engineer.... that would be the first time I have ever heard that term... ergo self proclaimed
In the states you can call yourself anything you want ie
Master Mechanic
ESQUIRE ( one of my favorites... arrogant, ignorant American lawyers.. have no clue as to what Esquire even means.. and it doesn't mean attorney and furthermore it is beyond gauche and tacky to call yourself "esquire")
As to contacting Harmona... I have no interest... however I might just order a bellows from them as I believe them to be much less expensive .. and I am not begrudging a reseller any profit but obscene profits off a substandard product and not taking any repsonibilty....
What I know is that whether from Harmona or Romania or China these are not bellows "that are as good as and in some ways better than Italian"
and anyone with average eyesight a pair of hands and a ruler can easily determine their quality as compared to an Italian bellows
BTW this "accordion engineer " also claims that he designed the Garvey AAA starter accordion and that he was ripped off of his original design .....minus a grille change
-
I think that there is some Belly Buick institution in the midwest (U.S.) that grants certificates for "accordion engineers" or something absurd like that.
It does sound like you have a good source of Italian bellows -- that price is cheaper than anything I've seen recently.
-Andy
-
This individual did not go through that Minnesota ( I believe) self certification program... Red Wing I believe was the name of that outfit...
My "reliable source" waffled and now tells me that the accordion engineer "might have attended" St Chartier.. that is different from my first conversation.
-
Read your mail in "Boxbuilders" list today ...
I just have forwarded this problem to Harmona-Weltmeister here in Germany in Klingenthal (http://www.akkordeon-klingenthal.de/) to their export department - let's wait what they will say.
I for one play a Harmona Cajun accordion since many years which has a fine quality. I'm very contented.
Therefore, I think it's a case of falsification and fraud, respectively - poor Chinese bellows sold as high German quality Harmona bellows.
Best regards.
'Tit J.
-
To clarify
I did NOT say that the bellows represented as Harmona bellows were made in China or Chinese
I said that they looked like they were made in China, or Chinese quality. ..particularly in a comparison with the Italian bellows
These bellows were NOT "as good as and in many ways better than Itailian bellows"
and the seller could not ,and did not ,and would not tell how they were as good as Italian bellows.. only implying I was not qualified to make that judgement and he was becasue he is
"an accordion engineer" whatever that is
I have owned Harmona made accordions and found them to be all right.
I am not in any way disparaging HARMONA accordions
My point is that the seller of these bellows said they were one quality level and I found them to be another. He said they were made by HARMONA.
See my original post and description
My post on the boxbuilders was only to suggest that Italian bellows would be a better choice over HARMONA bellows if in fact what I got were HARMONA bellows
Considering that boxbuilders is specific to making accordions, seemed an appropriate place to let builders know.
Also:
I am NOT saying the seller knowingly sold me Chinese made bellows... I do not know they are Chinese or HARMONA or Czech or Romanian..
that is not my assertion. My assertion is that the bellows I got are not " as good as and in many ways better than Italian bellows" it is that simple
And as a service to others who may be tempted to buy these bellows ( Harmona or whatever they are) .. I can only suggest that spend your money on Italian bellows, however the choice is yours.