Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on August 01, 2009, 05:19:17 PM

Title: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 01, 2009, 05:19:17 PM
Struggled a bit with this kit, but could see its capabilities. On a standard C#DG the C and F# notes are duplicated on pull (inner/outer rows). But you lack D, F natural and Ab on the pull.  

After much soul searching I got Paul Flannery to file my duplicated notes to F and D. This makes 'pull' fully chromatic apart from Ab, and suited my style.

Warning: doing this breaks box symmetry so it's defo 'oddball'. You now also have a pull G7 chord. A disadvantage comes playing outer rows in CC# style. While C is still there, you have to remember to cross in to get it.

The box's pull F push A chord pair is also non standard - put in by first owner EeeJay. They are excellent for playing in C on the pull, and A on the push.

Admin - you might like to add the gif to the 'oddball' keyboards as F'D'd about C#DG31 ? ;)

Layout plan attached ...

Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 01, 2009, 07:26:33 PM
Sounds fun - def oddball however.
AL
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Stiamh on August 02, 2009, 02:36:40 PM
Hey Chris,

Why not just get a BCC# and have done with it?  (:)

Only joking. When I got my first C#/D I quickly came to the conclusion that a D pull would be a great asset* and debated sacrificing my D# in favour of D natural. I'm glad I didn't though, my reasoning being that I didn't want to become dependent on a nonstandard layout and didn't want to be handicapped when playing a standard layout box.

But I suppose, being a D/G player, your messing with the outer row won't make things difficult for you when you pick up a standard D/G, and you probably come across other C#DG boxes even less frequently than I encounter C#/Ds.

* The only advantage I can see of playing D/D# layout in D rather than Eb (ducks while Tom prepares a fierce rebuttal).

Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: TomB-R on August 02, 2009, 04:08:08 PM
* The only advantage I can see of playing D/D# layout in D rather than Eb (ducks while Tom prepares a fierce rebuttal).


 ;D I've been meaning to put my mouth where my money is with a bit of comment on such matters! Must get round to it soon!  ::)
Tom
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 02, 2009, 04:37:36 PM
Starting again, if I didn't go 'Continental' I'd probably pick a BCC# or similar route.

But like many here I've been well pickled in DG technique and I'm an old dog. But that's also why I don't mind secrificing the C# and F# on my outer row. To my mind the entire set of nuttons there are 'extras' Chris
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Stiamh on August 03, 2009, 01:43:10 AM
Starting again, if I didn't go 'Continental' I'd probably pick a BCC# or similar route.

But like many here I've been well pickled in DG technique and I'm an old dog. But that's also why I don't mind secrificing the C# and F# on my outer row. To my mind the entire set of nuttons there are 'extras' Chris

Whereas if you were a C#D player you wouldn't sacrifice those particular notes, ever. They are called the magic notes for good reason!
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 03, 2009, 07:31:46 AM
Whereas if you were a C#D player you wouldn't sacrifice those particular notes, ever. They are called the magic notes for good reason!

I didn't know that, although I vaguely recall someone mentioning magic notes long ago. OK - that make me really weird! Looks like I'll be first against the wall come the revolution.

The Oakwood as it now stands also has some 'magic notes' the way I play. One is the old F/F# that has become F/F both ways. It is a real anchor in all the C related keys C,F,Am,Dm. (Recall that the box came with an unusual F-pull chord). As it happens C keys suit my singing voice. And somehow I also need that F whenever I fall in with Blues people (whatever key they seem to be in) ???

The other 'magic note' has been its Ab/Bb button - a whole load of scales/tunes seem to 'turn' there (F has same property).  Before anyone rejoins - yes I do realise any second-hand Hohner has a Ab/Bb.  But I'm playing here in a 'butchered' C#D mode, rather than dotting in 'accidentals'

Think we're back to 'old dog' here.  Basically my brain is now wired to a D/G model and I'm moving out from there. I got Gaillard to make my (F#)GC same fingering and have to say he looked a little pale (can you do that in a letter)?  

In my defence I'd say that the butchery makes the right hand scales work much better against its left hand chords (although I'd have killed for a G pull bass).  I'm a left hander and basically think of tunes as notes fitted against a LH riff. Whereas I understand yer true X/X# player doesn't get to use left-end buttons much if at all - is that fair?
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 03, 2009, 09:03:51 AM
Quote
Whereas I understand yer true X/X# player doesn't get to use left-end buttons much if at all - is that fair?

As a generalisation it works pretty well, but there'll be a host of people on this forum all making haste to point you in the direction of some person or other bashing away at the bass buttons on their semitone box, and saying how good it all is. I'm afraid I'm not convinced.
AL
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: george garside on August 03, 2009, 09:53:26 AM
Quote
Whereas I understand yer true X/X# player doesn't get to use left-end buttons much if at all - is that fair?

As a generalisation it works pretty well, but there'll be a host of people on this forum all making haste to point you in the direction of some person or other bashing away at the bass buttons on their semitone box, and saying how good it all is. I'm afraid I'm not convinced.
AL

for those requiring a more versatile 2 row semitone box  a BC hohner double ray de lux  with 48 bass stradella grafted on from a piano box as played by Bruce Lindsey on the dvd 'the button box in Scotland'  would be  both light & very versatile. Personally I can't see the point of having to 'drive' the treble end  to fit the bass where this is possible - having some form of 'same both way' bass leaves the plaayer free to get the best out of the treble and the bass. Presumably this is why some notable Irish players have  their own system of bass with the bulk of the notes same both ways but  still set out in 'melodeon' rather than 'stradella' format.

george
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Stiamh on August 03, 2009, 01:21:02 PM
but there'll be a host of people on this forum all making haste to point you in the direction of some person or other bashing away at the bass buttons on their semitone box, and saying how good it all is. I'm afraid I'm not convinced.

Al, you must be referring to one comment made by one person - me. Tell me, which of the people I pointed you to a while back have you actually listened to in order not to be convinced?
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 03, 2009, 04:11:33 PM
Steve, I received one or two comunications from some other folk, as well as a direct posting from you, all pointing me in the direction, of Jackie Daly, Billy McComiskey, Martin Quinn, Joe Derrane and of course the sublime Tony McMahon and incomparable Bobby Gardiner. I've googled, youtubed, and comhaltas'ed them all as far as I can remember and although they are all without doubt fantastic box players I still remain unconvinced about what's going on in the bass end. Some just provide the odd little punctuation mark every now and then - others (like Boby Gardiner) are much more subtle - and in other vids that I've seen they don't play any bass at all other than wagging the fingers of their left hand around as a way of keeping rhythm. Now I make no pretence of actually liking this kind of music anyway - fact is I don't - and undoubtedly I've not seen or heard much of them (just a few vids online). But given that there are perhaps a few exceptions to the rule I still think that it's not unfair to that say that generally the bass reeds and buttons in a two row semitone box are pretty much a waste of time - most people in my albeit limited experience simply don't use 'em. Maybe I'm missing something, perhaps my hearing is defective? Nothing would surprise me.
AL
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Theo on August 03, 2009, 04:37:37 PM
Al, the best example I can think of is Connor Keane, who I've heard playing a C#/D with 12 basses.   Great player of Irish stuff, and also of French trad where he makes great use of the left had end.  Unfortunately I don't know of any recordings.
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Stiamh on August 03, 2009, 04:41:10 PM
Fair enough, Al. But I don't think YouTube clips would give you much indication of what, say, Jackie Daly can do with the basses when he wants to. Spend some time watching him in concert and then tell me he "bashes away at the buttons."

Unlike you, I like the music and I like what these players do. I think the crucial point is that what they do is adequate and suitable for the music. And I'd much of what might be done with, say, a stradella-system bass end* would not be suitable and would not be appreciated by other musicians and punters. (Remember the YouTube clip of the young French lad playing Irish reels on his CBA?) No, you can't do as much with 8 or 12 basses on a semitone box, but you can do enough. So why lug around the extra weight, let alone pay for the extra hardware?

As for Irish players who don't use the left-hand at all, one reason is that they don't need to. In the circumstances that most of them play in, bass work is unnecessary and indeed often undesirable. So they simply don't need or want to work on the basses. Those that do will use them when they can, but not all the time.

A very different approach from that of a BCC# player, or that of an English or French player with a quint box. But it's a different musical tradition, a different aesthetic, and should be judged on its own terms.

Cheers!

* or even a D/G bass end
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 03, 2009, 04:55:23 PM
Quote
A very different approach from that of a BCC# player, or that of an English or French player with a quint box. But it's a different musical tradition, a different aesthetic, and should be judged on its own terms.

agreed - and therefore I will now shut-up!
AL ;D
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Theo on August 03, 2009, 05:27:18 PM

agreed - and therefore I will now shut-up!
AL ;D

Is that possible?   ;D
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 03, 2009, 05:31:47 PM
Quote
Is that possible?   

mmmmmmmmmmmmm...
Title: Re: Making a C# D G more chromatic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 03, 2009, 06:59:33 PM
.. Personally I can't see the point of having to 'drive' the treble end  to fit the bass where this is possible - having some form of 'same both way' bass leaves the plaayer free to get the best out of the treble and the bass.

You are so right. As mentioned elsewhere the Gauillard came with 18 button left hand with all bass notes, and several of the 12 chords in both directions. I cannot say how much that has freed up what one does at the other end!  Quite liberating, and unexpectedly so ...  and it's still a melodeon somehow.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal