Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Prestidigitator on August 04, 2009, 10:51:49 AM
-
Does anyone have any suggestions about avoiding "I want to play this" overload?
There's so much good stuff flooding in from all over the place that I think I need a 25 hour day solidly learning and playing just to keep up.
I'm inclined to blame it on Youtube and people like that Rees Wesson putting tunes such as "Zuppa Inglese" on it. When I heard it, I knew I just had to learn it. The only trouble is that a couple of other Andy Cutting pieces grabbed my attention at the same time. Much more of this and I'll be in the Zuppa big time!
-
There is no cure, the only consolation is that the more you learn the easier it gets, but then you start forgetting the ones you learned a while ago.
-
I'm forgetting more than I learn, the names at least. The tunes do just pop out unbidden. they say if you know the names of all the tunes you play you don't know enough!
-
The problem is, all the tunes I want to learn are difficult ones, and even when I've worked them out it takes forever to actually be able to play them through without totally falling apart. Even when I can do that, it takes a long time before I have the courage to play them outside the safety of my own home, and some of them never see the light of day at all.
It therefore seems that my "useable" repertoire grows at a pitifully slow rate, and when I go to sessions I end up churning out the same old stuff I was playing years ago.
-
I've read this thread with interest as lately I've been trying to play everything/anything I like the sound of on Youtube. To answer your question Prestidigitator I think the best thing to do is lay off Youtube for a month, don't learn any new tunes and just play through the ones you have learnt until you can play them like yourself. This is what I intend to do. I agree with Ganderbox, some of the tunes you spend time learning never become part of your repertiore as maybe they are a bit too tricky in the first place (or maybe just don't suit your natural style of playing). Although it is good to push yourself I think it's probably better to play tunes that you are comfortable with and that you can put a bit of yourself into. I'm not knocking Youtube, it is a fantastic resource but it can lead to all sorts of melodeon envy!
So I'll ban myself from learning new tunes for a month and let you know how it goes (or at least I will when I have finished learning this fantastic Mexican mazurka played by a Polish guy on an Australian box, living in Thailand !) ;)
-
The easiest answer would be to concentrate on the real ear catchers, the tunes that sticks to your brain, these tunes are often easy and fast to learn because you already got them in your system. The other thing you can do is simply to explore the musical traditions were ever you live at the moment. Bring some recording device to session, dance or whatever they do when playing music. Not always the easiest way to learn new tunes, but certainly the most inspiration and fun!
So simply: stay away from youtube for awhile, explore new tunes - ear catchers from the traditions that are alive around you, learn some new tunes and finally post these tunes on youtube - keep the circle unbroken ;)
-
Thanks for the sage words on this topic.
I think I'll follow the advice and stay away from Youtube (and Myspace too), at least for the while. I've got a motley list of tunes I'm keen on at the moment (a Breton gavotte, Sir Thomas Fairfax's March (a C17th jig), and some more contemporary pieces - including "Zuppa") which together make a varied and interesting set.
Best I buckle down and learn them properly, as they're stuffed with lovely but difficult twiddly bits.
However, I bet (myself) that I find my finger straying toward the Youtube Bookmark button at some point, especially if I just happen to notice an interesting link posted in the "Tunes" section of the Forum.
-
Interesting discussion. Traditional musicians often had a smallish local repertoire and played tunes through a lot longer (I wonder if the 78 record was seen as the YouTube of the day- ' Now boy keep off them newfangled shellacs and play what we've allus played round these parts! Nooe likes a smartarse'
Although I read that Irish musicians often used to go round to a music reader's for a play and get new tunes for The Book ie O'Neill's, and from 78s. These then got into the local tradition after the famine and emigration reduced the number of musicians around.
I wonder whether Scottish tunes got into Morris this way, or just from travelling musicians..
-
There's so much good stuff flooding in from all over the place that I think I need a 25 hour day solidly learning and playing just to keep up.
This is the problem...to much information. Not only are there new tunes all over the place, but we can look them all up on websites to get the dots or ABC and end up with bulging folders of music that we will never get round to learning. Then we can find out about how to play in different styles with Irish ornamentation or French cross-rowing and practice all that, then we need the right boxes to play them on, and so on.....it never ends.
-
Oh I have lots and lots I'd love to learn....but 99.9% I can't play. So I just get fustrated.
-
The problem with 'tune chasing' (which we all do) is that some never give themselves the chance to learn to play the box! Learning how to work the box like a well oiled machine i.e. developing the manual dexterity & skill required to get the best out of it irrespective of tune and also honing listening skills actually facilitates playing more tunes as you only have the new tune to worry about rather than the 'how do I do this with the box'
Perhaps a good compromise is to develop a relatively small number of 'sunday best' tunes & keep going back to improve them whilst still trying new stuff.
george
-
If you play for a morris side and go to local sessions, you build up a repertoire of tunes you have to learn for morris, and tunes you learn to keep your head above water at the sessions. Eventually you will build up a small collection of tunes you are confident enough in to lead at a session, and tunes you can play well enough to play on your own for morris. As well there will be a whole load of tunes that you can play along with at a session, possibly missing a few bits, provided someone else is leading it. When you hear a tune you really like, you learn it if you can.
-
There's a wonderful piece on Marc Savoy's site (Maker of "Acadian" Cajun boxes.)
The URL doesn't change but the site is
http://www.savoymusiccenter.com/
Follow the links to "Writings" and "Helpful Hints for Learning Songs and Playing Your Accordion"
(though everything he says is worth reading.)
In essence Marc is saying (IMHO) "the music has to be in you, instruments and technique are just a way of getting it out." When you can "sing" the tune (in your head if need be,) pick up the instrument and you can play it.
Or as Shetland fiddler Tom Anderson said "You should never learn a tune you don't know!"
(Sorry to be boring, I've quoted that here before.)
Tom (But not Anderson, he's deid, "mair's the pity!")
-
Thats silly. I have lots of songs that get stuck in my head couldnt play them if my life depended on it.
-
Hello. My two pennith would be to be (very) choosy about tunes to learn. When first starting out the wish to play everything is great but just too daunting. find a player you like and preferably know and start with their repertoire. I did this with Ian Dedic (of this board). I started off with only one or two tunes and after six months or so. Having learnt one or two tunes a week I had a very complete range of tunes for playing in sessions. Practice on just the tunes of the week focused my learning.
Andy
-
Thats silly. I have lots of songs that get stuck in my head couldnt play them if my life depended on it.
Well, that all depends doesn't it?
If it works for some people, (as it does) might there be an angle worthy of not immediate dismissal?
::) ::) ::) ;D
-
Hello. My two pennith would be to be (very) choosy about tunes to learn. When first starting out the wish to play everything is great but just too daunting. find a player you like and preferably know and start with their repertoire. I did this with Ian Dedic (of this board). I started off with only one or two tunes and after six months or so. Having learnt one or two tunes a week I had a very complete range of tunes for playing in sessions. Practice on just the tunes of the week focused my learning.
Andy
I think that's very sound advice, which I'll follow.
Theo's earlier comment about learning/forgetting is spot on. I see it as a conveyor belt, where some stuff drops off into the bin, some sticks and goes round and round, and someone up the other end is chucking new stuff on. Problems arise when the new stuff resembles the binned, or the gremlins get in the bin and put it back on the line.
I had my first beaten-up Hohner (an impulse buy at £1 17/6 from a secondhand dealer) many years ago. There weren't many players about then (or I couldn't find them), and "squeezebox" was a term of derision (up there with mother-in-law jokes) and very uncool. A lot of recorded material came from Shirley Collins,Bellamy/Young Tradition etc. and later folk-rock (Fairport and so on). Cyril Tawney arrived via Marianne Faithfull (Sally Free and Easy).
The downsides were the cost of vinyl and styluses (styli?) plus the sheer inconvenience of learning from LPs on a Dansette in student digs. Unlike today, finding fellow players who knew their stuff wasn't easy, so it was a rather solitary business learning. An awful lot of those tunes were also completely unsuited to the instrument.
As we say, these days it's a cornucopia of sources (or a trough, perhaps) and the danger of unproductive gorging is great; something I want to avoid. What does come out of this thread to me is the usual thing i.e. self-discipline and constant practice are somewhere near the top of the list.
Thanks, all
Peter
-
Thats silly. I have lots of songs that get stuck in my head couldnt play them if my life depended on it.
Well, that all depends doesn't it?
If it works for some people, (as it does) might there be an angle worthy of not immediate dismissal?
::) ::) ::) ;D
I know shouldn't have said silly (although if you have a instrument not capeable of playing all the notes in the tune in your head...technically you couldn't play it no matter how hard you tried)...but I'm plateauing...and its making me angry and fustrated and I'm lashing out. I hate being so musically stupid.
I'm going to go bash my head against a wall now...
-
actually i'm with ladydetemps on this. The idea, if accurately cited, that if you can (mentally) sing a tune then you can play it, clearly is silly. Yes, silly.
For a start, as she points out, your voice (and your head) can do things that your instrument almost certainly can't.
As it happens I think that singing a tune can be a valuable part of figuring out how best to play it, but certainly not sufficient.
[edit:] i suppose that a gifted player who had reached a level of being at one with his/her instrument might be able to play almost immediately anything that s/he could sing. But that kind of ability is rare in my experience, and in any case would make the idea more an aspiration than a general prescription or method.
-
Time for a parable...
The Young and the old Bull looked down the hill to the herd of cows below... let's run down and grab one says the young'un...
I'd rather walk down and get them all says the old'un....
..... :|||:
patience is a virtue, desired by many, possessed by few ;D
-
To suggest that you can play things your instrument physically can't because you can hear it in your head would clearly be silly! So with respect, it seems a bit silly to think that was what was being suggested!
My very brief summary doesn't do justice to, (and possibly distorts) what Marc Savoy is saying. I would recommend his articles highly.
I'm not suggesting that if you get a tune in your head you'll be able to pick up the box and play it perfectly first time, you may have to adjust the key after all, BUT if you have the tune in your head, you can find the right place to start and work it out, quickly or slowly, with the tune in your head acting like an invisible "phrase by phrase" workshop tutor.
YMMV but if you haven't got the tune in your head, how on earth are you going to learn to play it, unless you play constantly from music or tab?
It would seem to me that trying to sort out the mechanics of buttons and bellows and all is unlikely to succeed unless you've already "got" the music.
I'm sure many of us have had the experience of "learning" a tune phrase by phrase at a workshop, and at the end of the hour or whatever we're merrily playing it in the group. Can we play it a couple of hours later, or next day? In my experience, no, because I didn't "know" the tune, and had been taken straight to the mechanics of it by the phrase by phrase approach.
I'm not trying to be controversial, and I don't want to cause unnecessary thread drift, but there seem to me to be some interesting issues here relating to how we get to play all those lovely tunes that we hear.
Cheers all,
Tom ;D
(About to be away for a couple of days, but not sulking! ;D)
-
I'm sure many of us have had the experience of "learning" a tune phrase by phrase at a workshop, and at the end of the hour or whatever we're merrily playing it in the group.
nope. couldn't play it in the workshop or after.... that's how rubbish I am.
To suggest that you can play things your instrument physically can't because you can hear it in your head would clearly be silly! So with respect, it seems a bit silly to think that was what was being suggested!
you have to be very specific on forums about what exactly you are saying. ;)
My issue was: It sounded like you were saying anyone (which would then include me and I know I can't do it) rather than some people could perform such a miracle. And I wanted to point that out that's all. *shrug*
-
nope. couldn't play it in the workshop or after.... that's how rubbish I am.
LDT you most definitely are not rubbish I've looked at your vids, and they clearly show you are not. I don't think you really believe that either or you would have given up long ago.
Your natural frustration is a result of being at an early stage in the learning process, we've all been there and understand what its like. I'm there again because I decided to learn the fiddle - I've been playing 3 years and its taken me that long to be able to play in tune, but I'm not giving up either.
-
Time for a parable...
The Young and the old Bull looked down the hill to the herd of cows below... let's run down and grab one says the young'un...
I'd rather walk down and get them all says the old'un....
..... :|||:
patience is a virtue, desired by many, possessed by few ;D
I thought the old bull said:
"I will walk down and stay for hiefer and hiefer"
;D
-
I've been playing 3 years and its taken me that long to be able to play in tune, but I'm not giving up either.
11 years and I never bothered to learn playing in tune!
I agree with knowing how a tune goes in your head before you learn to play it will make the process a lot easier, and you know where you go wrong as soon as you make a mistake that way. Also if you 'hear' a tune differently to how it actually goes, you get a nice variation in how you play it. Proper folk process! The problem with this method is that I struggle with some tunes in retaining the thing in my head in the first place!
Theo's earlier comment about learning/forgetting is spot on. I see it as a conveyor belt, where some stuff drops off into the bin, some sticks and goes round and round, and someone up the other end is chucking new stuff on. Problems arise when the new stuff resembles the binned, or the gremlins get in the bin and put it back on the line.
Thanks, all
Peter
I find though that once you learn a tune, it will always be there somewhere, and when played in a session by someone else, you will be usually able to recall it fairly easily. Also with each tune you learn, phrases can be recycled when learning new tunes, and learning new tunes becomes noticeably easier. I would rather have learnt and lost than never have learnt at all......
-
nope. couldn't play it in the workshop or after.... that's how rubbish I am.
LDT you most definitely are not rubbish I've looked at your vids, and they clearly show you are not. I don't think you really believe that either or you would have given up long ago.
Your natural frustration is a result of being at an early stage in the learning process, we've all been there and understand what its like. I'm there again because I decided to learn the fiddle - I've been playing 3 years and its taken me that long to be able to play in tune, but I'm not giving up either.
That's very kind of you to say that. But it's very disheartening when I can't play anything that people I know would recognise that aren't nursary rhymes. And my Left hand wont do as its told at the same time as the right hand...and I can't seem to use the squeeky end of the melodeon without getting lost. And increasing practice isn't having any effect on my playing..it just stays the same...feels like I'm trying to climb up a vertical ice slope by taking a run up and have my fingertips glance the top before I go sliding back down again.
-
nope. couldn't play it in the workshop or after.... that's how rubbish I am.
LDT you most definitely are not rubbish I've looked at your vids, and they clearly show you are not. I don't think you really believe that either or you would have given up long ago.
Your natural frustration is a result of being at an early stage in the learning process, we've all been there and understand what its like. I'm there again because I decided to learn the fiddle - I've been playing 3 years and its taken me that long to be able to play in tune, but I'm not giving up either.
You're a fast learner, Theo! Last string/fretted instrument I tried was the octave mandola, and I couldn't even get the d...n thing tuned up after 3 years!
LDT, you seem to be getting a bit isolated and down on your own. Andy Cutting's modus operandi (as previously described) seems pretty good to me. Why not try it, if you can? It doesn't seem to have done him any harm.
-
.feels like I'm trying to climb up a vertical ice slope by taking a run up and have my fingertips glance the top before I go sliding back down again.
I have fairly recently taken up the BCC# on a whim, a friend had one she didn't play so I have borrowed it. I can play the old D/G pokerwork with some aplomb, depending on whether you are in the same room as me of course. The tuba? OK too.
The important thing is that I have been playing the D/G and the tuba for years and years and years, so they feel comfortable and natural.
The BCC# is new to me and I am absolutely in the same boat as you when it comes to this magnificent beast, left and right hands disagree, pushes and pulls suddenly go wrong, bellows run out of air, I could go on and on.
So, as everyone else has said, persist, laugh at misfortune. One day perhaps we will be at the same session playing Winster Gallop without a second thought.
-
That's very kind of you to say that. But it's very disheartening when I can't play anything that people I know would recognise that aren't nursary rhymes. And my Left hand wont do as its told at the same time as the right hand...and I can't seem to use the squeeky end of the melodeon without getting lost. And increasing practice isn't having any effect on my playing..it just stays the same...feels like I'm trying to climb up a vertical ice slope by taking a run up and have my fingertips glance the top before I go sliding back down again.
Sometimes it can help to take a break from playing for a few days. Not guaranteed, but its sometimes helped me.
And definitely concentrate on a very small number of tunes for quite a long time. Its worth it. I still remember the occasion when I first managed to play a tune in a dance band and ;Dpeople were actually dancing ;D. A magic moment. It was at a Folkworks Darlington weekend, and I'd been playing probably two years before I reached that stage. It takes time.
-
... it's very disheartening when I can't play anything that people I know would recognise that aren't nursary rhymes. And my Left hand wont do as its told at the same time as the right hand...and I can't seem to use the squeeky end of the melodeon without getting lost. And increasing practice isn't having any effect on my playing..it just stays the same...feels like I'm trying to climb up a vertical ice slope by taking a run up and have my fingertips glance the top before I go sliding back down again.
I learned this way of speed practising by a jazz musician needing to know lots of new music over night. I still use it from time to time if I hit the wall learning tunes. If you practice hard on a difficult tune with complicated passages, and your brain and fingers short circuit and you start playing in the blue. Then Instead of taking a break you take out one or two more tunes your practising on and start practicing the other tunes aswell, circulating inbetween them. Maybe concentrating on the difficult parts progressing to the easy parts, and the next day you practis them one by one, and often you more or less got them. I’ve learned lots of tunes this way, and forgotten half again!!!
But as “Willy Olsen” a good CBA player from Denmark ones told me (while I was practising my self to near dead), just because you've learnt a tune it doesn’t mean you can play it...
And I think Bill Farmer hit the head of the nail earlier in this thread:
If you play for a morris side and go to local sessions, you build up a repertoire of tunes you have to learn for morris, and tunes you learn to keep your head above water at the sessions. Eventually you will build up a small collection of tunes you are confident enough in to lead at a session, and tunes you can play well enough to play on your own for morris. As well there will be a whole load of tunes that you can play along with at a session, possibly missing a few bits, provided someone else is leading it. When you hear a tune you really like, you learn it if you can.
Yes ;D
-
So, as everyone else has said, persist, laugh at misfortune. One day perhaps we will be at the same session playing Winster Gallop without a second thought.
I wonder if I'll recognise you from your avatar? ;) :P
I too think you will get through your current doldrums, and that you should stick with it with confidence that this will happen. But it's possible (and I say this very very tentatively, and in the expectation that no-one else will agree) that you might benefit from just putting the box down for a week, and maybe even ignoring melnet for the duration too. Concentrate on something else. Read War and Peace. Clear your mind and come back to the box refreshed. Only a tentative suggestion.
Well I have been doing more..art lately....I find it calming.
And definitely concentrate on a very small number of tunes for quite a long time. Its worth it. I still remember the occasion when I first managed to play a tune in a dance band and ;Dpeople were actually dancing ;D. A magic moment. It was at a Folkworks Darlington weekend, and I'd been playing probably two years before I reached that stage. It takes time.
I think I lot of it is worrying about playing a tune at the barn dance (not with dancers dancing - I'm not trusted to do that) 2mins to fill seems a long time...I'm very close to backing out.
I've just been playing Bear Dance over and over and jusr seem to be getting worse.
-
Just a daft idea you may wish to pursue....
The Bear tune (or any other you have a reasonable grasp of) ...change the focus from 'learning for a performance' to a bit of self indulgence:
Close your eyes, play it, feel every note and nuance... you are playing it solely for you to listen to!
When you get lost in the tune with a warm fuzzy feeling then you've cracked it ;)
-
nope. couldn't play it in the workshop or after.... that's how rubbish I am.
LDT you most definitely are not rubbish I've looked at your vids, and they clearly show you are not. I don't think you really believe that either or you would have given up long ago.
Your natural frustration is a result of being at an early stage in the learning process, we've all been there and understand what its like. I'm there again because I decided to learn the fiddle - I've been playing 3 years and its taken me that long to be able to play in tune, but I'm not giving up either.
You're a fast learner, Theo! Last string/fretted instrument I tried was the octave mandola, and I couldn't even get the d...n thing tuned up after 3 years!
LDT, you seem to be getting a bit isolated and down on your own. Andy Cutting's modus operandi (as previously described) seems pretty good to me. Why not try it, if you can? It doesn't seem to have done him any harm.
I think playing with a morris side with a restricted repertoire is a great help and playing for dancers pushes you on, and you can hide in the crowd a bit. then go home and practice as Andy says.
Sorry a bit of repeating other people here!