Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: mikesamwild on August 04, 2009, 01:25:39 PM

Title: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 04, 2009, 01:25:39 PM
Does diatonic  mean two notes push/pull on one button or something more to do with music theory .  I saw 'bisonoric' for push/pull = 2 notes.

Clarification welcomed.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 04, 2009, 01:37:18 PM
diatonic means that only the notes in a (normally major) scale are present, as on each row of a standard melodeon.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 04, 2009, 01:38:02 PM
Does diatonic  mean two notes push/pull on one button or something more to do with music theory .  I saw 'bisonoric' for push/pull = 2 notes.

Clarification welcomed.

Hi Mike
definately not - all diatonic means is a complete scale i.e. one with whatever 'black'notes are nedded already incorporated in it. The term diatonic really has nothing to do with boxes & is a ageneral musical term. HOWEVER  since the individual rows on any of the push pull boxes contains a diatonic scale   they have become known as diatonic boxes, even if they are chromatic i.e. have all the notes available to play any key.  Arguably the only true diatonic box is the one row  as it only possesses the notes required for one particular scale.  Again nothing really to do with the push/pull bit as thee is no technical reason why you couldnt have a diatonic piano keyboard i.e. one that had white notes only as required for a particlar scale. - but who would want such a thing.    All the two row  4th apart boxes have  'black' note or two available on the 'other' row  which means that  stictly speaking they are neither diatonic or chromatic. The semitone boxes have all the 'black notes' somewhere so are in fact chromatic.

this probably complicates rather then clarifies!

george ;)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 04, 2009, 03:40:11 PM
diatonic means that only the notes in a (normally major) scale are present, as on each row of a standard melodeon.
From the "Dolmetsch Online" music dictionary:
"from the Greek dia tonikos, literally 'at the intervals of a tone', notes that occur naturally in a standard major or minor scale, without being modified by accidentals other than the sharps or flats in the relevent key signature".

As George and JB say, in button accordion terms it refers to the individual rows. If you have a C/C# or B/C/C# then although each row is diatonic you actually have a chromatic instrument.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: triskel on August 04, 2009, 03:41:21 PM
Does diatonic  mean two notes push/pull on one button or something more to do with music theory . 

Like most other words 'diatonic' has more than one meaning, so it's both of those. Similar words are also used in other languages for the same thing, so the French would speak of the 'accordéon diatonique (http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accord%C3%A9on_diatonique)' (often abbreviated to just 'diato'), or the Germans of the 'Diatonisches Akkordeon (http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonisches_Akkordeon)' and likewise Italian or Spanish speakers would use 'diatonico'.

Quote
I saw 'bisonoric' for push/pull = 2 notes.

'Bisonoric' is quite a new term in English - deriving from the German academic term 'bisonor'.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 04, 2009, 03:49:22 PM
I always thought Diatonic was the Welsh doctor whom you went to see for a pick-me-up.
  ;D
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 04, 2009, 03:49:28 PM
"from the Greek dia tonikos, literally 'at the intervals of a tone'
Yes, the greek prefix "dia-" really means "through" (as in "diagonal" and "diameter").
I guess the fact that "di-" is a common prefix meaning "two" or "double" is the reason why "diatonic" sometimes gets confused as referring to the two-notes-per-button thing.

btw, "bisonoric"/"unisonoric" are ugly words in my opinion, but at least it is fairly obvious which is which, unlike with "double-action"/"single-action" each of which could easily mean the other, to my mind. Are there better words lurking around, or waiting to be invented?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: triskel on August 04, 2009, 04:45:17 PM
I guess the fact that "di-" is a common prefix meaning "two" or "double" is the reason why "diatonic" sometimes gets confused as referring to the two-notes-per-button thing.

Well it's not really a "confusion", in that it's been "standard usage" (in several languages, including those of the people who've made the accordions) for rather a long time.

Quote
btw, "bisonoric"/"unisonoric" are ugly words in my opinion, but at least it is fairly obvious which is which, unlike with "double-action"/"single-action" each of which could easily mean the other, to my mind. Are there better words lurking around, or waiting to be invented?

I agree about the ugliness of "bisonoric"/"unisonoric", they sound clumsy and unnatural to me in English, but our "double-action"/"single-action" is confusing, as you say. Why not just stick with "diatonic", seeing that it's internationally used/recognised anyway...  ???
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Bill Young on August 04, 2009, 05:20:53 PM
Here's how this word should be defined in English dictionaries:

diatonic¹ - relating to a scale used in Western music.
diatonic² - two-toned. Relating to accordions, producing two tones from one key (usual. a button)
cf. Ital diatonia - Passaggio del suono da un grado all'altro della scala senza alterazioni di note.

Once upon a time, an English-speaking person looked up "diatonic" in his dictionary and found only definition 1, which is all they normally have, and thought "Oh, diatonic accordions must be defined in terms of the scales they can play", and proceeded to invent the nonsensical explanation that has been repeated ad nauseam ever since. (I've even seen it translated back into French, complete with the bi-sonoric nonsense as well!). If only the original "definer" had had some knowledge of Italian, French or German and looked in some manufacturers' catalogues, he might have deduced that diatonic accordions are so-called because of how they're constructed. DG, CF, BCC#, C#D - they're all diatonic accordions because . . . they produce two tones per key.

Usually, the simplest explanation is correct. Could we put this hoary old chestnut to rest now? You know it makes sense.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 04, 2009, 05:53:15 PM
Quote
Usually, the simplest explanation is correct. Could we put this hoary old chestnut to rest now? You know it makes sense.

And all the people said...
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Selam on August 04, 2009, 06:17:39 PM
Quote
diatonic¹ - relating to a scale used in Western music.
diatonic² - two-toned. Relating to accordions, producing two tones from one key (usual. a button)
cf. Ital diatonia - Passaggio del suono da un grado all'altro della scala senza alterazioni di note.

And here was me thinking it was what I had with gin... ;)

Someone told me that I shouldn't call it a melodeon but in fact a diatonic, bisonoric button accordion. Rolls of the tongue, that...

euterpe
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: C age ing on August 04, 2009, 06:25:59 PM
Absolutely no objection to the use of diatonic providing you add something that indicates this is either the melodeon/accordion sense or musical theory sense.
Now back to sleep.
Old Bill.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 04, 2009, 07:21:31 PM
Once upon a time, an English-speaking person looked up "diatonic" in his dictionary and found only definition 1, which is all they normally have, and thought "Oh, diatonic accordions must be defined in terms of the scales they can play", and proceeded to invent the nonsensical explanation that has been repeated ad nauseam ever since.n is correct. Could we put this hoary old chestnut to rest now? You know it makes sense.
Alternatively:
an English speaking person came across a long established musical term and, not understanding what it actually meant, thought it would do to describe two notes on one button and misappropriated it.

Why are harps and tin whistles diatonic? How many notes do they produce per hole or string?

Usually, the simplest explanation is correct. Could we put this hoary old chestnut to rest now?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 04, 2009, 07:51:53 PM
Thanks for all this info I think I get it now.  That's a good point about whistles and Irish harps which are not  necessarily fully chromatic, wooden flutes too and pan pipes!

Ooh innit hard, language?!

George gets best marks for clarity in my book.  But as my old teacher said, 'Strive for simplicity but don't trust it'  someone else said 'You should be able to teach anything to anyone in an intellectually honest fashion and not patronise them'

None of my school 'music teachers' had this ability however!
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 04, 2009, 08:00:46 PM
diatonic means that only the notes in a (normally major) scale are present, as on each row of a standard melodeon.

In the notes by Neil Wayne to the CD set on Co. Clare Anglo concertina players he uses 'diatonic' to mean push/pull  ( like a melodeon)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Nick Hudis on August 04, 2009, 08:05:32 PM
And I always thought dire tonic refered to my playing.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 04, 2009, 10:11:43 PM
I'm with Bill Young on this - diatonic means each button can have different note on push and pull. eg in France they contrast <<diato>> against <<chromatique>>  The latter being a CBA or similar, with same note each way on the buttons. Piano accordions don't really get a look in there.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 04, 2009, 11:55:20 PM
I'm with Bill Young on this - diatonic means each button can have different note on push and pull. eg in France they contrast <<diato>> against <<chromatique>>  The latter being a CBA or similar, with same note each way on the buttons. Piano accordions don't really get a look in there.
Depends what you mean by "they".
As a general musical term it is defined in the same way as in English (http://www.cnpmusic.com/plus/lexiqueD.php).
And even in squeezebox circles there are evidently some die-hard pedants (http://pagesperso-orange.fr/diato-amateurs/lexique.htm), as also linked in my previous post.

(Here's a Google translation (http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fpagesperso-orange.fr%2Fdiato-amateurs%2Flexique.htm) of the latter.)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: risto on August 05, 2009, 12:47:21 AM
Once upon a time, an English-speaking person looked up "diatonic" in his dictionary and found only definition 1, which is all they normally have, and thought "Oh, diatonic accordions must be defined in terms of the scales they can play", and proceeded to invent the nonsensical explanation that has been repeated ad nauseam ever since.n is correct. Could we put this hoary old chestnut to rest now? You know it makes sense.
Alternatively:
an English speaking person came across a long established musical term and, not understanding what it actually meant, thought it would do to describe two notes on one button and misappropriated it.

Why are harps and tin whistles diatonic? How many notes do they produce per hole or string?

Usually, the simplest explanation is correct. Could we put this hoary old chestnut to rest now?


Definitively have to agree with Pushpull.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 05, 2009, 08:40:54 AM
Depends what you mean by "they".

Fascinating. "they" were Norbert Pignol, Stéph Milleret and other profs on their courses .. as they separated those with chromatique from those with diato's. So that's a current French usage - moi, je joue diato. But I'd picked up the word by decontextualisation rather then from my 3" thick Robert&Collins (which doesn't have it listed at all). I accept I'd got it wrong. Actually, thinking back to about 1994 I recall Steph giving a talk on la gamme (scale) diatonique.

Yes, aren't those french glossaries pedentic! But better not criticise personally ;) Goggle google ..

A nice and authoratative ;) sounding Wiki (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_and_chromatic) article basically maps the diatonic scale to the 7 modes of the major CDEFGABC (when in C) as you say. Which is what our melodeon row does.  Then it goes on mysteriously under "modern usage"

   All writers accept the major scale as diatonic. Most, but not all, accept
    the natural minor (and the descending melodic minor) as diatonic.


So that's ABCDEFGA and AG#F#EDCBA in there too ??? Manifestly inapplicable to melodeons. Worse: some modern writers term ascending melodic and harmonic minors as diatonic.  Appears we need a few more pedants?

Personally I now see "diatonic" as referring to the white notes on a piano, or equivalent in other keys, and hence the notes from holes in a mouth organ, hence a single row of our "diatonic" instrument.  (I've often described it as two/three mouth organs strapped together). Thanks for putting me right.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: cw67q on August 05, 2009, 10:27:54 AM
Yes, the greek prefix "dia-" really means "through" (as in "diagonal" and "diameter").

Suddenly I understand how "diarear"  got its name

- chris
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 05, 2009, 11:35:44 AM
I like the Do Re Mi etc approach, like a mouthorgan.  I have a diatonic set of pan pipes i got in Ecuador in a diatonic g Scale9no buttons)

i ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT THE 45,000 YEAR OLD 'NEANDERTHAL' FLUTE MADE FROM A VULTURES WING BONE PLAYS  A DIATONIC SCALE ( HAS ANYONE GOT ACCESS TO A RECORDING?)  CARVED ON STONE CYLINDER MAYBE?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 05, 2009, 11:48:55 AM
This is an interesting discussion - Language always moves on, and dictionaries reflect, they don't dictate.  Maybe there is no better forum than this one to decide what a word means?  

I like the view that so many people have adopted the word 'diatonic' to mean 'bi-sonoric', that that has become an additional meaning to the strict 'musical' definition, in the free reed world.

For that reason, I like the French slang, 'diato', because with this 'bisonoric' interpretation, it actually says something meaningful about what many box players are now doing, whereas 'melodeon' is a confused sort of word.

Erm, sorry to get back to the thread, because I enjoyed the spin-offs!
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 05, 2009, 12:03:44 PM
Small flute = whistle then!

re the use of diatonic I think some people may have confused di as = 2 and dia = through  ( I think - I have no Greek or Latin dictionary and my massive Dictionary is somewhere else) but diaspora = spread apart (or 'diarear'would come from through flow) and dichloride would mean 2 chloride atoms


I'm an old school ex teacher and as such a bit of an old  pedant, but we had standards to maintain in them days.


Now -- ditonic could mean two tone or sook blaw but would we have to play exclusively Ska music like The Specials
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 05, 2009, 12:09:06 PM
Whilst the term diatonic is perhaps  not  spot on for anything other than the one row & has no linguistic connections with  that horrible term biisonoric (I much prefer the  highly descriptive Scottish 'Sook an Blaw') I think its a loose term that is widely understood within the box world  and which differentiates the sook an blaw boxes from all others - so to use anything else would add to the confusion.

Probably there greater confusion  concerning the term melodeon  which seems to be a particularly English term for  a 4th apart box (even if it has only one row and no 'apart') or 2 or 3 rows. Most other nationalities call them accordions of some sortor other be it button accordion or accordion diatonique or whatever

george
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 05, 2009, 12:11:01 PM
jb.  Hmm. I'm not suggesting replacing the 'proper' definition, just adding an alternative meaning.  OK, they may sometimes conflict, but does that actually matter?  

The essential issue is that we need to find a useful word to distinguish those types of instruments that have different pushes and pulls from those that don't, because they have very different sounds, and are very different to play.  Perhaps the answer is to invent a new word, such as 'pushpull'?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 05, 2009, 12:15:13 PM
Whilst the term diatonic is perhaps  not  spot on for anything other than the one row & has no linguistic connections with  that horrible term biisonoric (I much prefer the  highly descriptive Scottish 'Sook an Blaw') I think its a loose term that is widely understood within the box world  and which differentiates the sook an blaw boxes from all others - so to use anything else would add to the confusion.

Probably there greater confusion  concerning the term melodeon  which seems to be a particularly English term for  a 4th apart box (even if it has only one row and no 'apart') or 2 or 3 rows. Most other nationalities call them accordions of some sortor other be it button accordion or accordion diatonique or whatever

george


Or the Irish Press and Draw but i like sook and Blaw George
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 05, 2009, 12:16:34 PM
jb.  Hmm. I'm not suggesting replacing the 'proper' definition, just adding an alternative meaning.  OK, they may sometimes conflict, but does that actually matter?  

The essential issue is that we need to find a useful word to distinguish those types of instruments that have different pushes and pulls from those that don't, because they have very different sounds, and are very different to play.  Perhaps the answer is to invent a new word, such as 'pushpull'?


Let's get Dr Doolittle to arbitrate or The Chuckle Brothers!
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 05, 2009, 03:06:18 PM
Yes, the greek prefix "dia-" really means "through" (as in "diagonal" and "diameter").

Loads of these in medic territory. Diabetes (the Greeks recognised 2 varieties). Diaphragm. Even diamorphine (Dr Shipman didn't let many die without it)!

Suddenly I understand how "diarear"  got its name- chris

Uggh, you really should see a doctor! The correct technical term is Otorrhoea, when yuk comes out of your ears.

 ... or into them - in some music circles I won't name
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 05, 2009, 03:09:59 PM
Yes, the ("modern") musical-theoretical usage certainly is complicated and ambiguous,
I don't actually think it is. I stick by the first definition I posted "notes that occur naturally in a standard major or minor scale, without being modified by accidentals other than the sharps or flats in the relevent key signature". I would say that includes modes too, but the harmonic and melodic minors are chromatic (because they are modified by additional accidentals).
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 05, 2009, 03:10:45 PM
Perhaps the answer is to invent a new word, such as 'pushpull'?
Sorry that's copyright.  ;)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 05, 2009, 03:31:07 PM
Yes, the ("modern") musical-theoretical usage certainly is complicated and ambiguous,
I don't actually think it is. I stick by the first definition I posted "notes that occur naturally in a standard major or minor scale, without being modified by accidentals other than the sharps or flats in the relevent key signature". I would say that includes modes too, but the harmonic and melodic minors are chromatic (because they are modified by additional accidentals).
I meant that the modern usage is complicated and ambiguous in that it varies (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic#Modern_meanings_of_.22diatonic_scale.22). As it happens I like your definition, but evidently there are rivals.
I also think it would be better if, even in boxland, "diatonic" was kept well away from the "pullpush" (rushes off to obtain copyright) meaning. But this seems to be a lost cause.

btw it seems to be ok to post again now. There was a quiet and expectant hush over the whole forum for a long while there. Bit like Waiting for Godot but without the dialogue.

Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 05, 2009, 03:56:27 PM
Well, having read jb's Wikipedia link, it seems that the term 'diatonic' must be just about as hopelessly confusing and pointless to music academics as it it seems to be to box freaks!

Pushpull, how much to buy your copyright?
 ;)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 05, 2009, 04:04:46 PM
Well, having read jb's Wikipedia link, it seems that the term 'diatonic' must be just about as hopelessly confusing and pointless to music academics as it it seems to be to box freaks!
Aye, perhaps it's easier to hear than to write about.
Quote
Pushpull, how much to buy your copyright?
 ;)
Hmm, I shall have to investigate.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 05, 2009, 04:10:00 PM
just to add to the confusion, here's an alternative wikipedia entry (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_scale) which seems rather more gung-ho unambiguous, and which I think corresponds with pushpull's definition.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 05, 2009, 04:23:43 PM
but has no real  relevence to  any box other than the 1 row sook an blaw ( or should I say diatonic) box.  As far as I can see we either stick with diatonic as a loose term or whats the alternative ? plain accordion, ? button accordion  --but then  others may think we play piano or  continental chromatics and that would never do!!!

george ;)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 05, 2009, 04:41:35 PM
but has no real  relevence to  any box other than the 1 row sook an blaw ( or should I say diatonic) box.
As far as I can see we either stick with diatonic as a loose term or whats the alternative ? plain accordion, ? button accordion  --but then  others may think we play piano or  continental chromatics and that would never do!!!

george ;)
Well I tell people I play melodeon (which creates just as many blank stares as if I said diatonic). As for you George, it's a BCA isn't it?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 05, 2009, 04:42:23 PM
just to add to the confusion, here's an alternative wikipedia entry (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_scale) which seems rather more gung-ho unambiguous, and which I think corresponds with pushpull's definition.
Ooh, I like that page (and I didn't write it)  ;D
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 05, 2009, 04:52:32 PM
[ ]
Well I tell people I play melodeon (which creates just as many blank stares as if I said diatonic). As for you George, it's a BCA isn't it?
[/quote]

also DG  and 1 row in A  ( and occasionally - usually for teaching purposes  piano box & continental chromatic)

george
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: risto on August 05, 2009, 05:12:41 PM
When someone calls his box 'diatonic' it really doesn't matter what his understanding of the word actually is, as there are no chromatic boxes with bisonoric behaviour or diatonic boxes with unisonoric behaviour (or at least I'm not aware of such)? A musician from outside Boxland will understand that he means an accordion with only the major scale notes. But as all diatonic boxes are such there will be no missunderstanding theory wise. The only information the outsider will be missing is that the box has two notes for each of its button, but does he really need to know that anyway;-). Right?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 05, 2009, 05:29:05 PM
  as there are no chromatic boxes with bisonoric behaviour or diatonic boxes with unisonoric behaviour (or at least I'm not aware of such)? 

if ,as I  presume, by 'bisonoric' ( what a horrible word - sounds more like a particularly disgusting medical term) you mean 2 notes per button - sook an blaw - or whatever then BC, CC# etc are chromatic in so far as they possess all black & white notes.  The BCC# is  chromatic in a more practical (easier to finger & bellow) way than the 2 row boxes but they are all chromatic.  Either a box is chromatic or it isn't , theres no such thing as being a bit chromatic!

george ;D
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: risto on August 05, 2009, 05:37:08 PM
 as there are no chromatic boxes with bisonoric behaviour or diatonic boxes with unisonoric behaviour (or at least I'm not aware of such)?  

if ,as I  presume, by 'bisonoric' ( what a horrible word - sounds more like a particularly disgusting medical term) you mean 2 notes per button - sook an blaw - or whatever then BC, CC# etc are chromatic in so far as they possess all black & white notes.  The BCC# is  chromatic in a more practical (easier to finger & bellow) way than the 2 row boxes but they are all chromatic.  Either a box is chromatic or it isn't , theres no such thing as being a bit chromatic!

george ;D

... which leads to the fact that you shouldn't use the term 'diatonic' for these particular boxes outside the Boxland unless you intentionally want to get misunderstood or into a situation where you have to explain the uncommon use of the word 'diatonic'.  ;)

PS. ... and while in the Boxland it's all the same...
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Stiamh on August 05, 2009, 06:12:57 PM
When someone asks me, what do you call that thing you're playing, I will try "squeezebox" for starters. If they're not satisfied with that, I volunteer "button accordion." I am loath to go any further because this would require mentioning not only the word "diatonic" - confusing, as you are all doing such a good job of pointing out in this thread - but "chromatic" (C#/D) as well - total confusion!
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Mike Higgins on August 05, 2009, 06:26:12 PM
Quote
When someone asks me, what do you call that thing you're playing,

I usually say that it is an accordion, where you have two notes on each button depending on which way the wind is blowing. This is usually enough to prevent further enquiries, thank goodness.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: risto on August 05, 2009, 06:32:33 PM
When someone asks me, what do you call that thing you're playing, I will try "squeezebox" for starters. If they're not satisfied with that, I volunteer "button accordion." I am loath to go any further because this would require mentioning not only the word "diatonic" - confusing, as you are all doing such a good job of pointing out in this thread - but "chromatic" (C#/D) as well - total confusion!

"A 2-row" has usually been enough for a 'hello and goodbye' type conversation. If someone is interested in details it's not a big thing to explain it's functionality thoroughly.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 05, 2009, 06:33:31 PM
Well, after all that I still think the basic difference between what I play and a PA is that mine sounds and plays completely different, because it's designed to go in and out to make different notes.  And when I'm next asked what it is that I play, I think I'll just offer my apologies and say that it's so complicated that nobody has yet decided what to call it!
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: risto on August 05, 2009, 06:37:33 PM
....  And when I'm next asked what it is that I play, I think I'll just offer my apologies and say that it's so complicated that nobody has yet decided what to call it!

I have to say that that was really funny!  ;D
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: risto on August 05, 2009, 07:11:47 PM
When someone calls his box 'diatonic' it really doesn't matter what his understanding of the word actually is, as there are no chromatic boxes with bisonoric behaviour or diatonic boxes with unisonoric behaviour (or at least I'm not aware of such)? ...

Totally for got the existence of the Russian diatonic accordions with unsonoric behaviour- These are  diatonic accordions but have same note with push and pull.

QUOTE:
Garmon
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 .... A garmon has two rows of buttons on the right side, which play the notes of a diatonic scale, ....

The garmons can be of two major classes: unisonoric, meaning that each button plays the same note or chord when the bellows is being expanded as it does when compressed, and bisonoric, in which the note depends on the direction of the bellowswork. Examples of unisoniric type are livenka (.... after Livny, Oryol Oblast)[1] and Khromka (Russian: ...for "chromatic"). Bisonoric garmons are, e.g., Tula accordion (Russian: ...after Tula) and talyanka (.., "Italian")

Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Pushpull on August 05, 2009, 07:39:53 PM
When someone calls his box 'diatonic' it really doesn't matter what his understanding of the word actually is, as there are no chromatic boxes with bisonoric behaviour or diatonic boxes with unisonoric behaviour (or at least I'm not aware of such)? ...

Totally for got the existence of the Russian diatonic accordions with unsonoric behaviour- These are  diatonic accordions but have same note with push and pull.

Which frankly consigns "diatonic = 2 notes per button" to the litter bin.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: waltzman on August 06, 2009, 01:42:51 AM

 The Pignol/Milleret system (G/Cm/C#m?) is more symmetric and provides complete chromaticity on pull over 3 octaves.

I'd like to see the layout of that one.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: triskel on August 06, 2009, 03:13:38 AM

 The Pignol/Milleret system (G/Cm/C#m?) is more symmetric and provides complete chromaticity on pull over 3 octaves.

I'd like to see the layout of that one.

This one maybe? http://duomilleretpignol.mustradem.com/medias/diato.pdf (http://duomilleretpignol.mustradem.com/medias/diato.pdf)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Stiamh on August 06, 2009, 04:03:59 AM
Looks like G/Am + accidentals to me. Harmonic minor scale of A to boot.  :-\ How many tunes in the French tradition use that scale I wonder. There must be a good reason for it... after all on a G/C + accidentals you could play in the A harmonic minor scale on your C row with a G# somewhere on your accidental row. Someone explain please...
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 06, 2009, 06:46:18 AM
Actually the Grenoble group(s) play loads of stuff in harmonic, and sometimes melodic minor. Cm Dm and Gm quite common, but they have a penchant for Em (equivalent to Bm on D/G). They'll often flatten the 2nd note (phrygian mode) for that 'Eastern' feel.

The layout:  OK - agree - the basis of the outer rows is a straight G scale - that's simple, diatonic - take it as a basis..

Middle row as you say is based on A aolian scale with a G#7th = harmonic minor. But look at the push-pull of it. The 2 consecutive notes on the pull are nearer your head on the middle row, where on a standard box the outer row 4 key block is the nearer. So the whole row has been moved a position cephalad bringing his 'C' back into its 'usual' relative position to G.

But Pignol frankly isn't much bothered about simple major diatonic scale. He might see this as merely a scale on the 3rd mode of A harmonic minor (= C 'harmonic major' = C major scale with a G#). The push pull run is 'out' if you view it in those terms - but when have we ever seen Norbert play up and down the rows?

Both he and Stéphe play and improvise almost completely on the pull. A 'given' is that all notes are available there, and I guess the inner/accidental row is optimised to achieve that - cannot see diatonic pattern in them myself in the terms of this thread.

I've made a 'finger run' diagram (attached) to show how this runs through a full chromatic 12 note scale on the pull. 'alors - vachement fluide'.  I'd guess the push inner row notes might be less important and ?optimised for useful 'to close the bellows' chords in his favourite keys. But as the air hole on the Gaillard is so massive - he'll not need those much.

Quite a few Grenoble protegé(e)s have bought this system and I've even seen it on an other manufacture box. It is frankly a pig for 'regular tunes' and in my mid 50's was a nono for layout on my own Gaillard box. I'd have had to relearn everything I'd done in 20 years! Is it diatonic?  Well the G row defo is, and the Am/C row is in 'modern' terms.

But if your joie de vivre comes from improvising it is quite amazing. I've seen them stand up and agree some riff picking chords in turn - eg F7#5#13, G7#5#13, Cm - set off chording - take turns making new music. Good stuff too on the whole.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 06, 2009, 07:40:29 AM
all this playing-mostly-on-the-pull stuff is very interesting. As was pointed out in another recent thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2005.0.html) this is also a characteristic of TexMex.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 06, 2009, 08:54:21 AM
Thank you, Risto, Pushpull and Steve Jones, your comments have sealed it, as far as I'm concerned!

I am confused no more.  I don't play a melodeon, nor a 'diato', nor a chromatic/diatonic, nor a diatonic with accidentals.  I also don't play a 2 1/2 row or a 2 3/4 row or a three-row.

On reflection, our discussions about button tunings seem a bit like saying to a guitarist who has retuned his instrument, 'That's not a guitar, it's a Hawaiian Slack Key'.  Or maybe, a 'DADGAD'.

I play a button accordion.  I suggest everybody else on this forum probably does too?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 06, 2009, 08:59:31 AM
Quote
I play a button accordion.  I suggest everybody else on this forum probably does too?


Sure do Chris...as did that well known Italian accordion player St. Francis of Assisi - a Castagnari Tommy I believe.
AL
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: triskel on August 06, 2009, 12:05:58 PM
I play a button accordion.  I suggest everybody else on this forum probably does too?

You wouldn't find any disagreement with that here in Ireland Chris, except when it's a "melojian" that's being played...  8)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 06, 2009, 01:16:42 PM
just to add to the confusion, here's an alternative wikipedia entry (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatonic_scale) which seems rather more gung-ho unambiguous, and which I think corresponds with pushpull's definition.


So we simple box players are suffering from heptatonia prima when we play our childlike nursery rhyme tunes for Morris etc  ( I was told that by a hotshot classical guitar player who was a smug plucker)
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 06, 2009, 01:20:42 PM
this has probably gone on too long already, but..
I don't think there's much dispute that "diatonic accordion" is a useful description. The issue is (or was, I thought) exactly what it is about them that is diatonic.


( Mike's comment: 'A one row would only play a diatonic scale in its home key anmd thats where the term came from not the two note on one button useage

All other push pull instruments are button accordions even when played across the rows like BC or C sharp/D' )
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: mikesamwild on August 06, 2009, 01:29:56 PM
all this playing-mostly-on-the-pull stuff is very interesting. As was pointed out in another recent thread (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2005.0.html) this is also a characteristic of TexMex.

And blues harmonica, cross harp means you suck to get different key than printed on the instrument eg A harmonica gives E .. C gives G  

P.S. Sorry about multiple resonses, I must learn how to handle quotes and replies.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: DRUMKILBO on August 06, 2009, 01:48:27 PM
I just usually call it a REAL accordion with buttons on both ends especially if there are piano accordionists present. I was playing at a trad music thing in Perth in June and I did point out to the audience that if George Scott Wood hadn't introduced the piano or Italian accordion into this country in 1927 [ I think it was ] and if it hadn't been taken up by George McKelvey [ of Jimmy Shand's band] and May Cameron in her father's band [ Jim Cameron ] in the 1930s and then taken up by the likes of Bobby McLeod [ who started on the melodeon ] then everyone in Scotland would still be playing real accordions.
Description of playing a scale, blaw sook blaw sook blaw sook sook blaw.

Ian.
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: george garside on August 06, 2009, 03:19:44 PM
I just usually call it a REAL accordion with buttons on both ends especially if there are piano accordionists present. I was playing at a trad music thing in Perth in June and I did point out to the audience that if George Scott Wood hadn't introduced the piano or Italian accordion into this country in 1927 [ I think it was ] and if it hadn't been taken up by George McKelvey [ of Jimmy Shand's band] and May Cameron in her father's band [ Jim Cameron ] in the 1930s and then taken up by the likes of Bobby McLeod [ who started on the melodeon ] then everyone in Scotland would still be playing real accordions.
Description of playing a scale, blaw sook blaw sook blaw sook sook blaw.

Ian.

 & perhaps furthur afield!

george
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: jb on August 06, 2009, 05:33:30 PM
Quote
I play a button accordion.  I suggest everybody else on this forum probably does too?

Sure do Chris...as did that well known Italian accordion player St. Francis of Assisi - a Castagnari Tommy I believe.
AL

St F of A. Isn't he the guy who asked the Lord to make him an instrument?
Title: Re: Diatonic
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 06, 2009, 08:07:46 PM
Was it dry tuning he asked for?
 :D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal