Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: hibbs3 on August 07, 2009, 10:33:42 AM
-
I was thinking about getting a nice hand crafted one row box, and I've heard many good things about Messerviers - well built, with exceptionally powerful sound. Now that's just by word of mouth, so I wanted to know if any of you fine people had any experience with these sort of boxes. From the clips I've heard, they sound great! I'm trying to stick within Canada (shipping, duty etc.), so Quebec seemed the obvious place to start. ;-)
-
If you do a search on 'Messervier' and 'Bouchard' you will find numerous threads about Québec 1-row boxes.
-
I'm thinking along the same lines........I plan on going to Montmagny this year and doing some serious looking and, hopefully, buying.
J
-
Why don't you talk to Yves, Ryan? He knows Messervier well, as well as Raynald "Mélodie" Ouellette and other Quebec makers. Mind you he might try to nudge you in the direction of a Sagné 10- or 15-key ;) and that would be a very good choice as well.
-
Off topic but have you heard Frans VanderAa's 1 row?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e3eiGt1tjLo
Sounds good to me.
-
Off topic but have you heard Frans VanderAa's 1 row?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e3eiGt1tjLo
Sounds good to me.
I don't want to be rude, but I thought that sounded terrible! Not the box, but the sound quality is dire, the fiddles sound as if they are being played inside a blanket. I would not want to judge any instrument on that recoding.
Why not listen to the sample on Frans's website? (http://www.accordionmaker.com/melodeon/!boot.php?taal=uk&muziek=aan)
-
I was thinking about getting a nice hand crafted one row box, and I've heard many good things about Messerviers - well built, with exceptionally powerful sound.
They are great boxes. You should try to visit Mr. Messervier and his son, if possible. You'll get to hear them play, then you'll play for them on their accordions (accompanied by Marcel Jr on piano), and then you can decide whether to buy.
I decided for Mélodie (located right down the road), and they really are very different boxes, but their is no question in my mind that both builders are making great boxes if you want to play a one-row box. The choice is really driven by personal preference -- in my case, a combination of the ergonomics of the box and the sound. (I simply find the Mélodie more comfortable to play for extended periods of time, and I prefer the sound.) If I could afford it I would love to have both.
Cheers,
Andy
-
I would buy the Melodie for the absolute latest in technology and ergonomics and tone production
I would buy a Messervier for the traditional look, the longevity and history of the maker and the specific purpose of the box..
Either or both.