Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on August 07, 2009, 04:05:40 PM
-
What about this (http://www.victormorris.com/node/1059) as a cheap way into BCC#?
AL
-
Not as cheap as this (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1768.0.html), which has one more voice and many more basses.
-
Al,
Without stradella bass, think chocolate teapot, ashtray on motorbike, etc.
-
Al,
Without stradella bass, think chocolate teapot, ashtray on motorbike, etc.
Agreed - but it's not a lot different to the plethora of BC boxes out there - just has an extra row in C# as well. So pretty good for a lot of ITM etc?
AL
-
Without stradella bass, think chocolate teapot, ashtray on motorbike, etc.
... pretty good for a lot of ITM etc?
Al,
Indeed so, there's some great Irish music being played on B/C/C# boxes with 12 diatonic basses here, although they wouldn't be common. I got Mengascini to build three of them, to special order, only 4 years ago.
-
I've got a hohner compadre in A/D/G and i am generally impressed with what you get for the money. Only criticism I have is that its bigger than I'm used too!
-
Stephen
Were they decently made and fairly priced
ie worth doing again ????
-
Al,
Without stradella bass, think chocolate teapot, ashtray on motorbike, etc.
totally agree with Bill. I have expressed my views more than once on BCC# with 'melodeon bass' in my opinion similar to new laid cowshit - to be avoided at all costs!
george ;D
-
Not as cheap as this (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1768.0.html), which has one more voice and many more basses.
Whilst in no way acting as a salesman for Walthams trichord + I agree with him that in principle ( I havn't seen or tried it) it is a far better proposition than the new hohner with melodeon bass - Trichords like old ericas are eminantly restorable & are a lifetime proposition. I wish I had never sold mine as even with the standard 12 stradella it was far superior to anything with sook an blaw basses
george
-
totally agree with Bill. I have expressed my views more than once on BCC# with 'melodeon bass' in my opinion similar to new laid cowshit - to be avoided at all costs!
george
Just out of interest then George - what's your opinion of B/C melodeon?
AL
-
totally agree with Bill. I have expressed my views more than once on BCC# with 'melodeon bass' in my opinion similar to new laid cowshit - to be avoided at all costs!
george
Just out of interest then George - what's your opinion of B/C melodeon?
AL
for me the best of the bunch woulld be the hohner double ray delux 3 voice with 12 stradella bass as this provides a very light box with both ends well able to cope with CGD & A. To me , and many others, the 8 bass BC boxes are fine as a treble instrument if you have no great expecttions from the bass end
george
-
B/C with 12 stradella bass was how I got into B/C/C#. It was a no-name box found for £11 in a junk shop - in tune too! What I really need is that Casali 48 that W sold! Tony.