Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on August 09, 2009, 07:22:40 PM
-
hi everyone,
i think its time i started "crossing rows" but just have a few questions,
why would you want to cross rows?
is there an easy way of doing it?
and i would be very gratefull on any info shared on the subject!
all the best
GL
-
Hello Tom. Sorry I didn't make it to Dartmoor this weekend. I caught a ghastly cold at Sidmouth and retired home to the comfort of my own bath and a bottle of Glenmorangie.
I did call in at the Big Chill Festival on the way back on Friday night. It was BIG but not chilled - more like Dante's Inferno meets Woodstock!
Anyway, back on thread - if you wish to continue in your own wonderful Dartmoor stylee (a la Cann - Bazeley - Orchard) forget about crossing the rows. It's strictly up and down the row. Tommy Orchard does have his own unique cross rowing style. He plays the tune on the G row, then on the D row, then on the A row and back again through D to G. He usually repeats the whole process before he grinds to a halt.
Now then, if you want to fit in some clever left hand chord sequences, smooth out your playing and tackle some sexy continental toons then you should be crossing the rows like the proverbial chicken.
It's very easy and only requires a little expeimentation, but to quote from your original post "Why would you want to?"
Hope to catch you soon.
-
hiya rees! i did ask simon ritchie if hed seen you at dartmoor and he said he thought you where going to be about but hadnt seen you since sidmouth!!! now we know why, hopefully it wernt swine flu hey?
i know what you mean about how tom goes across rows, ive already been doing that for a while, i do want to keep the dartmoor style so i will take on your tip! the left hand is just starting to jump about and explore now so i guess il just keep going how im going!
hey i had a tune with bob canns great grandson thomas too, hes flippin good!
hope you feel better soon mate hopefully we will have that tune and a pint one day soon!
-
1. Fingers can move about twice as fast as arms!
2. You can run a block of notes against a single chord.There
are a lot of tunes where you can play quite a long segment
either against G push, or Em pull. It's a different feel.
Once you've mastered this: try same against eg an E bass 'drone'
3. Developing those cross row runs allows to to put in a bass
line against it. A fluent D/G riff is is Em pull => D pull =>
C pull => B push. You have E F# G A B C pull available to
play against that bass run. Six of the seven G/Em scale notes!
Go for it. You'll also get less tired. Can play for longer ... ;)
-
1. Fingers can move about twice as fast as arms!
2. You can run a block of notes against a single chord.There
are a lot of tunes where you can play quite a long segment
either against G push, or Em pull. It's a different feel.
Once you've mastered this: try same against eg an E bass 'drone'
3. Developing those cross row runs allows to to put in a bass
line against it. A fluent D/G riff is is Em pull => D pull =>
C pull => B push. You have E F# G A B C pull available to
play against that bass run. Six of the seven G/Em scale notes!
Go for it. You'll also get less tired. Can play for longer ... ;)
..... but it will no longer sound anything like the Dartmoor style which our Tom has mastered.
-
mastered? no need for niceties rees!
-
Sounds authentic to me.
OK, you may not be Sir Jimmy Shand but you have a perfect grasp of the Dartmoor style.
Keep at it, or as them Cajuns say "Don't let go of the hot potato!" ???
-
thanks mate, i appreciate it! what im thinking of doing is only crossing rows for certain notes to try and get the left hand jumping around more if you know what i mean???
-
I cross rows when it makes sense and does not break the dynamics of the tune. Sometimes a note sequence sounds better with a bellows "hit", sometimes an arpeggio sounds better with all notes produced with a single push or pull. On a 3-row you get lots of possibilities for crossrowing.
-
I learned to play on a Hohner Erica going up and down the rows in a mixture of English morris - Percy Brown East Anglian style. It never occurred to me to play any differently for years.
Then I went to see Andy Cutting (with Chris Wood) fairly early on in their careers. Andy's playing was a total revelation to me (thanks Andy, if you read this!) - why wasn't he waggling the bellows all the time? That was my first introduction to what cross-rowing was all about and I resolved to try to learn the technique and include it in my playing.
That was about 15 years ago, I guess. With further guidance from Brian Peters in his Sheffield melodeon group (thanks Brian!), my playing has since got to the stage where I play both up-and-down the rows and cross-rowing as appropriate for the music. Just because I now use cross-row style for some music hasn't made me forget my 'roots'. I switch to my East Anglian up-and-down the rows style for rhythmic drive and bouncy dance music whenever I want.
-
There's a bit here about Bob Cann's style... (http://www.mustrad.org.uk/reviews/cann.htm)
Where it postulates that the raw energy of his earlier playing career evolved in stages... and as one might expect (from records/broadcast media), picking up some of the 'clipped' Shand style (and tunes) along the way...
Which is a reasonable hypothesis - the longer we're plugging away at doing something, the more we know, and want to know. Some folks postulate Bob was 'got at' by the EFDSS to make his act more polished and 'civilised' for BBC recordings :-\, but I'd reckon a certain amount of this development was through self experiment and free choice.
Not to say Bob 'lost it'... when he swapped to Oscar Wood's 4 stopper, he was quite able to revert to his older style. And this is the trick Steve D picks up on... learn to do things several ways. The ability to chop and change between row based and cross row styles within a tune (or tune set) helps to add interest/drive/variety, whatever you're after...
Ed J
-
Just a further observation (based on the recent thread where we were comparing melodeons with cars).
Learning to play cross-row style is a bit like learning to drive on the right-hand side of the road so you can 'go continental' (:)
It's just that the ferry journey can be a bit of a rough crossing :o
-
No one's yet mentioned the other benefit of row crossing, which is that in a band the others are less likely to moan at you for playing different chords from what is written down! Certainly that's why I started to learn it. The other remedies, like getting them to play the same as you, or turning off the LH mike, or just not playing the left hand, seemed somehow less satisfying.
-
No one's yet mentioned the other benefit of row crossing, which is that in a band the others are less likely to moan at you for playing different chords from what is written down!
Your band has written down chords?
Luxury!
-
quote]
Your band has written down chords?
Luxury!
[/quote]
which may well not be the best ones anyway. Also depends on type of music being played - for 'English' style barndance/ceilidh stuff - jigs - reels - polkas - marches etc I think rhythm is far more important than getting knickers in a twist about left hand chords and anyway if the bass is played with short crisp notes (& chords) not much chordal damage can be done. However with waltzes a moderate degree of row crossing can be very useful to enable nice long left hand chords to fit with long right hand notes and of course with simultaneous right hand chords.
george
-
No one's yet mentioned the other benefit of row crossing, which is that in a band the others are less likely to moan at you for playing different chords from what is written down! Certainly that's why I started to learn it. The other remedies, like getting them to play the same as you, or turning off the LH mike, or just not playing the left hand, seemed somehow less satisfying.
Hah. I play my own chords rather than what is written on the music. There's little that I can do about this, as when playing for ceilidhs my bass takes care of itself.
-
Your band has written down chords?
Luxury!
We keep trying to persuade our guitarist to do that...might help him remember them!
-
Your band has written down chords?
Luxury!
I suppose that for me it all started in the seventies, when my guru, a dapper moustachioed violinist then in his sixties, sadly long departed, who knew what he was doing and whose beautifully transcribed italic pen handwritten manuscripts of standard dance sets to this day still circulate in Essex, used to raise a quizzical eyebrow should a fledgeling musician not fully appreciate the essential lyrical lilt of English country dance music, and insert a stray chord! Not really Bob Cann, perhaps, but nevertheless a different tradition, descended from the musicianship of pre-war jazz and pop. This man would perhaps play 'Kafoozalum' a couple of times, and then when we youngsters had almost managed to follow his scripted chords, we'd find he had drifted off into Stefan Grapelli-like improvisations around the theme, and was quietly smiling to himself at the front of the stage as he wheeled away!
I decided that I wanted to try to overcome the limitations of the box, while holding on to its rhythmic sound, and cross-rowing was one way. A big third row and lots of bass buttons helps too.
-
In the netherlands and france melodeon sheet music usually has tablature indicating the buttons and bellow direction. Of course you can deviate from the tab whenever you like, but at least you get used to both methods. For improvisation with other players I play almost everything on the pull (no bass) with an occasional push note with lots of airbutton (and the 'dutch modification'). Nice way to learn crossrowing I guess.
-
I have a confession to make, which might be regarded as heresy in the English melodeon world. Truth to tell I've always been a bit of an arse about face kind of guy the simple fact is I've never got the hang of playing along the rows.
Somehow my fingers have always fallen into cross row patterns. I've sat down down with tutor books and made my self play along the row, but it doesn't come natural. Keep promising myself I'll master that difficult along the row stuff............
Like Simon in the earlier post, I end up playing alot on the pull. I do mainly seem to play continental stuff these days so this way of playing suits well. I like funky chords, I like counter melodies and right hand harmony, I like minor keys so cross row is where its at with me.
-
I have a confession to make, which might be regarded as heresy in the English melodeon world. Truth to tell I've always been a bit of an arse about face kind of guy the simple fact is I've never got the hang of playing along the rows.
Yes, I know exactly how you feel. Over the past few weeks, I've been putting specific effort into playing single-row style. It's improving, but still feels far from natural.
-
There's nothing wrong with 'up and down rows' playing. It frankly has a lot more attack than you can achieve cross fingering, albeit at cost of a tired arm after a few hours. While I've worked hard on the crossing, up/down is a very easy way to vary a tune - just switch to along the appropriate row. :|||: ... :Ph
Like many Brits I started this way, and coming into an unfamiliar melody 'by ear' I fall back to it. To anyone who's been only trained cross rowing I feel the same advice applies .. learn both.
-
I have a confession to make, which might be regarded as heresy in the English melodeon world. Truth to tell I've always been a bit of an arse about face kind of guy the simple fact is I've never got the hang of playing along the rows.
Yes, I know exactly how you feel. Over the past few weeks, I've been putting specific effort into playing single-row style. It's improving, but still feels far from natural.
I suggest buying a one row :o
I have just dusted mine off again and am having great fun but requires some unlearning of those clever cross row thingys.
-
I'm one of those who has played crossrow from the start and envies others their facility along rows. But ideally i suppose we should try to stop thinking in terms of "two ways" to play, and aim instead to know/feel our way all around and across the box to make best use of all its various possibilities as the tune demands or the mood takes.
Its really down to knowing your keyboard very well so that you know where everynote is & in which bellows direction. This is just as important for 'by ear' players as for dot readers in the sense that you need to know the road (or roads) that you need to take to progress up or down a scale from wherever you are at a given point in a tune. YOu then have some choice here & there ( on a aDG box)as to which row you choose to play a note on and can drive accordingly tking into consideration what effeect you want to achieve & whether you wnat to ease the bellowing or the fingering at a given point.
There is really not much difference in playing a semitone box as the same appliesi.e. you need to know 'the road' There are someBC players who play on the row in B or C because they havn't realised that by diverting onto the B row they can play in a selection of keys & so havn't learned the 'road' for those keys. Similer on a bcc# - you can do it all on 2 rows but knowing where notes are on the 3rd row can add greatly to the proceedings.
I tend to play mostly ( but not exclusively) on the row on the DG for 3 reasons - I like the built in bounce for dance band work - I like the ease of right hand chords & right hand extra rhythm that is readily available and prhaps most importantly as I also play BC & BCC# it prevents me from having nasty accidents resulting from forgetting which box I am playing!
george ;)
-
My brain is a very odd thing.
I can pay down the row in the G row..but not the D (my brain just make sense of the push and pull being opposite to what I expect), but if I'm in the G row and cross over into the D every so often I'm fine.
As I say...my brain is a little odd.
-
I'm one of those who has played crossrow from the start and envies others their facility along rows.
I think that there's more to it than just that, though. I already know, from cross-row playing, where the notes are in either direction. However, that alone isn't enough - single row playing seems to require a bellows technique that I still find quite tricky. Fairly obviously, it requires a much greater degree of coordination between direction changes and the button-pressing, which is frustrating if you don't ordinarily have to worry about that side of things. It also seems to necessitate a change in how the bass end is used, which again seems frustrating if you're used to having more freedom.
-
Like many Brits I started this way, and coming into an unfamiliar melody 'by ear' I fall back to it. To anyone who's been only trained cross rowing I feel the same advice applies .. learn both.
I first started playing for morris, so playing on the row is ingrained in me. I do a lot of cross-rowing these days, but it often involves me having to learn the "shape" of the tune, especially if it uses the third row, rather than automatically knowing where the notes are. Like Chris, I always end up playing on the row when trying to pick up new tunes at sessions, and I also feel more confident of hitting the right note that way. Mostly, when playing on the row, if you hit the wrong note it will still fit, but if you get it wrong while cross-rowing the results can be bizzare!
Different boxes affect whether its easier to cross-row or not. It's hard work playing on the row on a heavy box, and when I changed from playing a Lilly to playing a Dony I found myself cross-rowing all the time to save my arms from dropping off. Cross-rowing on a small box, however, can sometimes lead you to run out of air, and of course on a 2 row box there are less opportunites to do so anyway.
-
I'm one of those who has played crossrow from the start and envies others their facility along rows.
- single row playing seems to require a bellows technique that I still find quite tricky.
to play fast on the row it is essential that you have the bellows as near closed as possible at all times. This of course depends on the particlar bit of a particular tune you are playing but if you have to open them up for a long run in same bellows direction go back to as near closed asap! The bellwos movement is then done mainly by wrist rather than arm movement which gives much finer control i.e. arm for big course bellow movements - wrist for small fast bellows movements. Try playing the run down in harvest home with or the duke of perth starting by keeping within 3 inches of closed and aiming to get it down to as little as 2 pleats open - doing it this way the bellow don't look as if they are moving - but you could of course be accused of miming!
geor :Dge
-
My brain is a very odd thing.
I think we all knew that already ::)
-
I'm not sure that 'cross/don't cross' is a good distinction, the more I think about it. The thing is to think of all the buttons you've got as being equal! It's all about using them to best effect in a given tune, or part of a tune.
After a large number of years playing, I think I'm just beginning to realise that I'm doing it all wrong, and maybe the best way to learn to play a new tune is to use this discipline: If the tune isn't already given to you, write it down somehow, and then decide what chords you want to play with it. Then decide how to play the left hand first. Next, work out which bits of the tune should be played choppily, and which bits smoothly. This is going to mean some up and down stuff, and some cross-row stuff. Then (and only then), work out how best to play the Right Hand so that it minimises long finger jumps, and achieves the overall dynamic effect you want.
If you do it any other way, the problem that I have found is that you have to unlearn the way you started to play it, and this is just impossible. I have been playing one particular tune for 30 years, and my new band chums say it should have a push Bm chord followed by a pull Em in the B-music, rather than the pull D and push G chords I've been playing for so long. They are quite right, so I decided to re-learn what I could previously play standing on my head. And can I do it? No I can't! The law of brain memory seems to be that the longer you have known something, the longer it takes to unlearn it!
-
As the Green Cross Man would have said
"Only cross when safe to do so!"
(http://img5.travelblog.org/Photos/43669/218699/t/1690060-The-Green-Cross-Code-Man-0.jpg)
-
I agree with Chris as to the process of working out the bass end first (or concurrently). Having said that, sometimes, on better days that is, I realise at the outset that a tune can be played both single row style and cross row. Then it's worth a little extra time to learn it both ways from the outset, so you can vary the repeats as the mood takes you. That brings back a memory of listening to Simon Care playing at a ceilidh (Rose and Castle weekend), he played through a simple tune six times and never once was it the same!
One way of forcing my own hand is to try out tunes I've always played across the rows on the D/G on my four stop. There's no getting away from poor bellows technique there.
Rob.
-
Another thought just came to me (rarity value). Playing Ripple of the Teign on D/G, the tune is pure single row/Dartmoor style on the D row, yet I find I cross row to the extreme when repeating in G. In fact, I think I end up playing in a different mode for the G section! Is that normal?
Rob.
-
I'm one of those who has played crossrow from the start and envies others their facility along rows. But ideally i suppose we should try to stop thinking in terms of "two ways" to play, and aim instead to know/feel our way all around and across the box to make best use of all its various possibilities as the tune demands or the mood takes.
Aye. I started off playing on row and then got the hang of cross rows, I'm thinking that now I should be playing more on row from time to time, rather than crossing rows as a matter of default. I'm hoping that it won't be difficult to effect this, as I know my way around the instrument in every direction now.
-
In fact, I think I end up playing in a different mode for the G section! Is that normal?
I play single row almost exclusively on the D-row (actually C or G for me). Might be due to the reversed 5th button on the inner row. ;) Looking at melodeon sheet music it seems that most of the jumpy tunes are played on the outer row (at least dutch and french tunes; not talking about irish on a C#/D). Playing on the G-row (F or C in my case) gives more possibilities for bass and chords. These work better with crossing so you don't break up the bass runs.
-
I'm one of those who has played crossrow from the start and envies others their facility along rows. But ideally i suppose we should try to stop thinking in terms of "two ways" to play, and aim instead to know/feel our way all around and across the box to make best use of all its various possibilities as the tune demands or the mood takes.
Aye. I started off playing on row and then got the hang of cross rows, I'm thinking that now I should be playing more on row from time to time, rather than crossing rows as a matter of default. I'm hoping that it won't be difficult to effect this, as I know my way around the instrument in every direction now.
Its ok as long as you can play cross-row with the same rhythm of the single row style. I find as I started with single row and only slowly introduced cross-rowing that this helped keep that single row feel, instead of thinking one day that playing across the rows as much as possible is the future. Because it isnt! Oh, looking back, this has all been discussed. I'll stop now!
-
I hate bellows jiggling and I don't like the tune to dictate the chords. I am working on a markup technique that reveals the row crossing requirements. For a d/g with accidentals, The method is this, which is the same in any key playable on a g/d :
1) get two highlighter pens blue and pink. Blue is blow, pink is draw.
2) print out the tune in large on a4 landscape. Preferably with chords.
3) highlight every D note in blue just as far as the stave top and bottom. Also any f nat or g# accidentals. These are notes that can ONLY be played on the press.
4) similarly colour any E or C or C# in pink (also any Eb or Bb accidental) . These notes can ONLY be played on the draw.
5) colour any G , Bm or B chords horizontally in blue. If there is a clash with pink , leave a gap. These are chords that can only be played on the push.
6) colour any Em, A or Am chords horizontally in pink. If there is a clash with blue, leave a gap these are chords that can only be played on the draw.
7) any unhighlighted chords can be coloured to match the majority of coloured notes in the same measure.
8) any unhighlighted notes can be coloured the same as the associated chord in the same measure.
9) anything that is left can be coloured to minimise air button use.
Now find which notes are on which row for the relevant coloured blocks. You will not have any choice except for E and D. choose as appropriate. If you need to change bellows direction for a clash, just lift you bass fingers. It sounds like clever syncopation but it is a necessity.
I can now see patterns and riffs coverin arpeggios, runs and ornamentations.
Let me know what you think
-
I hate bellows jiggling and I don't like the tune to dictate the chords.
I suspect some people will get no further than your opening statement. It could be misread. Do you mean that you don't like jiggling the bellows yourself, or even when some highly skilled exponents do it?
Secondly, tunes always dictate the chords don't they? At that's why providing a substitution chord is so rewarding to the ear. Perhaps you mean you don't like only having the chords available if you have chosen to push or pull based on on-the-row style options.
Sorry to be a pest, but I suspect that it might stop the thread in its tracks if we don't establish these points.
-
I was always under the impression that chords were meant to accompany a melody....so how can a tune not dictate the chords? Ahhhh I see P&T has worked out that the class idiot would ask a question....
-
Good point. I mean my own bellows jiggling. I am principally a guitarist so I am finding it difficult to discoordinate my hands, which is essential for squeezebox playing . (And is why I don't play keyboards very well.)
Yes the tune dictates the chords, but when you have a note that can only be played on the press, you can only use chords on the press, that may be inappropriate.
Personally I love the constraints of the melodeon. But I also like to understand the mathematics / mechanics of the instrument. I admire anyone who plays it naturally and love to hear single row and row crossing styles, with substitution chords etc. But I am not a natural player so I need rules to allow me to know what is possible. When I am comfortable with the rules the I can feel where to bend them.
If my postings are inappropriate here please advise
-
the on the row -v- row crossing debate seems to be never ending , the divide perhaps having more to do with the psychological make up of the player. on the row or should I say mainly on the row melody lead brigade are on the whole a pragmatic lot whereas the cross row correct chords brigade belong to the theoretical camp.
Neither is 'correct' and neither is 'wrong' and in my humble opinion there is room for a bit of both and devotees of either may well benefit from dabbling with a bit of t'other . I do however sometimes think that those who agonise over getting constantly correct bass chords may find that a continental chromatic box with stradella bass would meet their every desire
george >:E ;)
-
But I also like to understand the mathematics / mechanics of the instrument.
But I am not a natural player so I need rules to allow me to know what is possible. When I am comfortable with the rules the I can feel where to bend them.
This ties in with the way I learn - being told to do something is so much harder if you don't understand why. You'll find that you may have to cut bass notes or left hand chords short to allow for a quick bellows change to get to the note you want. Now to get to your other points.
For several years it upset me to find a tune without chord suggestions. I can always work out how to harmonise a tune, but firstly it wouldn't necessarily be close to the original choices, but more importantly it wouldn't give me any indication on whether I should be striving for patterns in one direction or the other, so it is really important for me still to have the chords there at the start of learning a new tune.
The colour coding is something that you will be able to dispense with as you become more experienced, but there are several well know people out there who have done the same - including the great Stephane Delicq.
In some ways it is more straight forward to have to play in the direction for the notes you have no flip to - rather than make choices about which D chord to use, and in fact I often change my mind on these once I've learnt a tune, to help with not running out of air. As a very rough general rule I run out of bellows on the pull in French music, and run out of bellows (shutting the box) on the push on English music: so I might choose to play a pull D chord in English music just to allow for air, and the other way round for French music.
There are many more experienced players here than I am, but maybe it helps that I'm relatively new to the instrument (a few years) too, so that I can see where your struggles are.
Keep asking questions. Good luck
-
Good point. I mean my own bellows jiggling. I am principally a guitarist so I am finding it difficult to discoordinate my hands, which is essential for squeezebox playing . (And is why I don't play keyboards very well.)
Yes the tune dictates the chords, but when you have a note that can only be played on the press, you can only use chords on the press, that may be inappropriate.
Personally I love the constraints of the melodeon. But I also like to understand the mathematics / mechanics of the instrument. I admire anyone who plays it naturally and love to hear single row and row crossing styles, with substitution chords etc. But I am not a natural player so I need rules to allow me to know what is possible. When I am comfortable with the rules the I can feel where to bend them.
If my postings are inappropriate here please advise
Hello and welcome David. I wouldn't worry too much about appropriateness wrt to most threads. Buy and sell seems to be an exception, where off topic posts get deleted. Generally, you should be OK as long as you keep your Kecks on and the post relates to the to the thread topic, at least in a broad sense.
P&T is talking sense. Hope this makes as much sense. From your post I get the impression that you play from music scores, rather than from listening and working things out by ear.
Speaking for myself, I find things seem to work better if I don't get too bogged down by dots and other people's chord choices. I am not blessed with a natural ear, so I am always quite happy to be helped by them, but make the tune my own as soon as possible. I'll nearly always make my melody, fingering and harmony choices by actually playing around with tune, on the box. It may not be "better" but it's definitely more fun that way.
I think you'll find that the sort of decisions you are using notation to come to terms soon come naturally, with a bit more experience. Also, you will find that there are often work arounds. You might also find that up and down the row playing has it's own charm, if you try more of it. It's one of the things that differentiates the diatonic accordion (including chromatic melodeon systems) from the cursed PAs.
-
David, as you are new here, here are some tips for the forum:
1 Someone will persuade you to play a system that they favour: colour them pink
2 Someone will persuade you just to play the damn thing: colour them blue
For every other comment make a judgement depending on whether you are going to run out of hair.
Seriously though, this is a truly remarkable forum with absolute heros chipping in with free and valuable advice. I've learnt much from these pages.
-
David, as you are new here, here are some tips for the forum:
1 Someone will persuade you to play a system that they favour: colour them pink
2 Someone will persuade you just to play the damn thing: colour them blue
For every other comment make a judgement depending on whether you are going to run out of hair.
Seriously though, this is a truly remarkable forum with absolute heros chipping in with free and valuable advice. I've learnt much from these pages.
;D ;D ;D
Very true. Personally, I love the passion people have for their way of doing things.
-
I think this is an interesting approach - and my view on melodeon rules is there aren't any !
Mainly playing a 2.4 D/G with very useful reversals - C, D, and E, and with G pull and Em push chords as well, I often change between playing cross row and up and down - and choosing between doing runs on the pull, push or both. I tend to notate some tunes where I have come across the best combinations for me (and often revisit them or go back to up and down the row - particularly when playing for Morris or ceilidh).
I often wonder how I would have approached playing if there had been a forum like this (or even tutors to teach me), forty years ago. Probably I would be a much better player ! I just try to keep learning and the forum is such a great way to share experiences, tunes, techniques and ideas.
Julian
-
Many thanks for your kind replies. My thoughts on written music is that I regard the regular treble and bass clef double stave as "Tab for the piano". My guitar performance (Classical, folk and rock) was much improved by the increase of "Guitar tab", particularly the publication of tabs for the three early albums of Ralph McTell (1976). Stringed instrument tabs are not new. Early lute music was in tabulature form. I think this stems from the fact that a note on the piano can only be played with one particular piano key. There is no ambiguity. Stringed instruments can play the same notes in different ways for convenience or timbre. For a beginner, the way that this is done in reality is a boon to progress. The same issues are the same for melodeon. There are optional ways to play the same note and this changes by style. I am making much better progress making my own "melodeon licks" similar to "guitar licks" that I can memorise easily.
-
I think I basically use a combination of both row-crossing and bellows-jiggling, depending on the tune I'm playing. I prefer to play cross-row but there are certain tunes where that's just not possible all the time so versatility in being able to do both is often useful. I can't vamp basses to save my life - I sound like a parody of a melodeon player and I've never really got the hang of it! That has informed my playing style quite extensively as I don't often have those rhythm breaks between the fundamental and chord to make a quick bellows change to keep on the same row. My style of playing means working out what fingering I'm going to use and planning ahead so I don't run out of fingers which can be a bit time consuming but it's the way I'm happiest playing. It does give me the benefit of being able to have a bit more flexibility in using chords which might not usually be available if I was playing up and down the row though, so swings and roundabout being what they are.....