Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: bearwhisperer on January 28, 2018, 11:21:16 PM

Title: G/C high notes
Post by: bearwhisperer on January 28, 2018, 11:21:16 PM
I have a G/C Sandpiper at Micheal Usui's shop for tuning and possible conversion to 4th button start with low notes and accidentals at chin. (21 button box). I would then loose the b5, d6 and e6 at the high end. (a5 is still available on C row). I would like this box mainly for the French tunes, and I am now searching scores to see how badly these notes might be missed. As I don't have many score sources, perhaps some of you with much French tune experience could offer comments?
Thanks in advance!
George
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 28, 2018, 11:56:40 PM
I use those notes all the time. I have the option of an L bank of reeds, which I don't know if the Sandpiper has that (I believe its MM), so that may explain why the kneeward octave is my homespace, but I think that's true of most French players. I don't see the benefit of a 4th button start for French music.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: bearwhisperer on January 29, 2018, 12:30:39 AM
Thanks for links Gary. The Sandpiper is MM. I am new to this and have a limited tune list so far. I find that I'm using the e3 at the start of the G row a lot, and that's why I am considering 4th button, as I am also without accidentals as it is now. I have not actually used any of the other low notes that I can remember. I have tried grabbing the low E on the bass side and it will work, but it seems desirable on the row.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: bearwhisperer on January 29, 2018, 12:53:03 AM
Gary, your mention of L reed made a light go on in my poor old brain. In mentioning e3, I realize that I am playing these tunes an octave low. This is, I guess, because of the MM sound. I had talked with Micheal about LM reeds for the Sandpiper, perhaps I should think more about this? I could then replace the low notes with the accidentals.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Gary P Chapin on January 29, 2018, 01:03:45 AM
Only one of my boxes is LMM (the Mory). The other two are MM, and I play them the same way, with home leaning kneeward. They sound great. Yeah, they're higher pitched, but not at all compared to a DG. They're in the same range as a violin. LM is a great sound ("bandoneon"), and is something to think about. I think of you disadvantage your upper octave for a 4th button start -- and you want to play French music -- you will regret the decision. Other than my Mory, my chin end buttons are  (1) accidental (2)5th/7th (3) Tonic/2nd.

I don't mean to be "telling you what to do." Please take this advice in the spirit offered,

Gary
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: AirTime on January 29, 2018, 01:38:24 AM
I take it your GC has low notes & not accidentals?  I doubt it's worth replacing the M reeds with L reeds on the Sandpiper .. or making it 4th button start. There are many, many tunes that do not require accidentals, so you might just stick with what you have for now. Ultimately, you're probably going to want to add a box (or two) ... that's the sad reality of melodeon playing. At that time you may be in a better position to weigh your musical interests & choose accordingly.

FWIW: I have a 4th button CF Sandpiper.  On a CF I don't miss the high notes at all.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 29, 2018, 01:55:58 AM
I have a G/C Sandpiper at Micheal Usui's shop for tuning and possible conversion to 4th button start with low notes and accidentals at chin. (21 button box). I would then loose the b5, d6 and e6 at the high end. (a5 is still available on C row). I would like this box mainly for the French tunes, and I am now searching scores to see how badly these notes might be missed. As I don't have many score sources, perhaps some of you with much French tune experience could offer comments?

As others have said, converting a G/C box with conventional 11+10 button layout to 4th button start is not generally recommended because you lose those notes you have mentioned at the high (knee) end, and you will need them for French music, particularly the A5 and B5.

Unlike playing a D/G or C/F box which is mainly centred around the low octave (chin end), a G/C box is normally played in the higher octave (knee end), particularly for French music, which is generally too muddy-sounding at the chin end. So - I would recommend you persevere and learn to use the upper octave. It might seem a bit strange at first but it's something you soon get used to. This will save you having to get the box converted and also keep its resale value better should you decide to sell it at some point in the future.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: smiley on January 29, 2018, 02:44:46 AM
My D/G Sandpiper is tuned fairly dry and the higher notes sound a bit harsh to me nowadays. If this is the case with your G/C then I'd be seeing how it sounds with the MM reeds tuned more to 'swing tuning', which should give you a 'smoother' tone.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Steve C. on January 29, 2018, 01:30:51 PM
As long as Michael still has it, might consider taking out the thirds (if it does not have a stop).  He'll give you a good deal while he has it open...
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Tufty on January 30, 2018, 12:11:31 AM
I once owned a G/C Sandpiper which came 4th button start from new. It was a pain! Springs kept breaking and 4th button start just does not work on a G/C (I don't even like it for D/G but I accept that I am a dinosaur). I would leave it as is but get the thirds taken off, with a stop if possible, otherwise just tape them off.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: arty on January 30, 2018, 06:22:12 AM
[quote author=Steve_freereeder link=topic=21776.msg261926#msg261926 date=1517190958                 a G/C box is normally played in the higher octave (knee end), particularly for French music, which is generally too muddy-sounding at the chin end.
[/quote]

“Too muddy sounding at the chin end”.....goodness, what have you been listening to? Both my G/C boxes sound rich, clear and velvety at the chin end. I can’t imagine why you say such a thing, unless they have been tuned too wet, of course, in which case, everything sounds muddy.

The beautiful thing about a G/C box, is that you play ALL of it, there is no dusty end. Don’t change your box to 4th button start Bearwhisperer, you will regret it. I use every note on my G/C’s and I wouldn’t change a thing. The only thing I would say - make sure your G# accidental is on the ‘push’. I say this because, when I received one of my boxes the G# was on the ‘pull’ for some reason and I had to get it changed. In French music, the G# is very common and, in my experience, it has to be on the ‘push’.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on January 30, 2018, 07:31:48 AM
a G/C box is normally played in the higher octave (knee end), particularly for French music, which is generally too muddy-sounding at the chin end.

“Too muddy sounding at the chin end”.....goodness, what have you been listening to? Both my G/C boxes sound rich, clear and velvety at the chin end. I can’t imagine why you say such a thing, unless they have been tuned too wet, of course, in which case, everything sounds muddy.
OK, sorry - perhaps I was a bit overgeneralising.
I suppose what I meant was if you play French music on a G/C in the same way that you might play a D/G, i.e. using the chin-end fingering positions, it will sound too low. To play any music at the pitch it is meant will necessitate using the knee-end part of the range, and I guess that what I was trying to emphasise.

Perhaps 'muddy' was the wrong word to use. I do agree about the lower octave sounding velvety, and tunes which deliberately descend into that part of the range can sound gorgeous. Stephane Delicq's La Femme de Marbre (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnLJxbcr7yo) is a good example.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Anahata on January 30, 2018, 08:38:24 AM
Even as a major fan of 4th button start for D/G, I also don't recommend it on G/C for exactly the reasons Steve described earlier: the G/C system is expected to be played more in the high octaves and you need those knee-end notes.

Perhaps it would work if you had a 23 button keyboard, so you can have the low notes without losing the high notes.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Rob Lands on January 30, 2018, 10:32:37 AM
The Pariselle standard model made at Halsway for G/C is second button start and it play so well in the top register. The only problem - going back to my 4th and 3rd button start D/G's
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: fc diato on January 30, 2018, 12:26:40 PM
Just to second (3rd, 4th, 5th ...) those who advise not to go with 4th button start.  When I started playing, it took me some time before I hit tunes that needed those high notes - and I too wondered why those were even there on the box - and now use them regularly. You will regret it, no doubt.
What Airtime says makes much sense ... it does take time to figure out what you will need and want.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: Howard Jones on January 30, 2018, 01:09:38 PM
My Loffet G/C sounds superb in the lower octave, especially on the LMM setting. However it only suits some tunes, and most of the time I play it in the upper octave.  Strangely, when I first got it, it immediately felt entirely natural to play in the upper octave, despite decades spent playing D/G at the chin end.

Another vote not to change to a 4th button start - it's great for D/G, but unnecessary for this. 
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: AirTime on January 30, 2018, 10:24:07 PM

“Too muddy sounding at the chin end”.....goodness, what have you been listening to? Both my G/C boxes sound rich, clear and velvety at the chin end.
[/quote]

I think it has to be a consequence of listening too much to DGs!  I my experience, most English tunes sound great on a GC, while the opposite (French tunes on a DG) may be unpleasingly squeaky. My own preference for all-round functionality & sound is AD or BbEb.

BTW: If I'm not mistaken, all Sandpipers come with a stop for 3rds. My Sandpiper has performed faultlessly since I bought it (second-hand), although, admittedly, I haven't been using it to belt out Morris tunes.
Title: Re: G/C high notes
Post by: bearwhisperer on January 30, 2018, 10:45:05 PM
Thanks for great response! You've been a great help in my buying my boxes initially, and now in continuing the journey.
I'm leaning strongly towards leaving 3rd button start but removing low notes for standard accidentals. As I mentioned above, I've mistakenly been playing some french tunes an octave low due to playing them on the chin end of my Beltuna Sara D/G, which is a more enjoyable box to play on. It's a 21+2 three voice, so the French tunes don't do to badly on it. But still, Em is not Am, and I would still like to have the G/C box to learn from score without having to transpose. I also understand that putting a lot of cash in a Sandpiper will not net much return. I notice a big difference in build quality from my Beltuna and my Saltarelle. That said, I still like the box a lot and I'm sure that Michael will be able to coax the little box to put out all that it can. It already has a thirds stop. Looking forward to learning to use every button on every box I can find!
Thanks!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal