Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on August 13, 2009, 01:44:06 PM

Title: The wrong way round?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 13, 2009, 01:44:06 PM
In a moment of boredom I've just tried playing my little D/G the wrong way round. In other words the buttons on the left hand and bass in the right. Discovered it makes so much more sense for the notes to start low and as you work up the fingerboard they rise in pitch. Maybe it's my piano background. What do you reckon?
AL
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: Owen Woods on August 13, 2009, 02:52:56 PM
In a moment of boredom I've just tried playing my little D/G the wrong way round. In other words the buttons on the left hand and bass in the right. Discovered it makes so much more sense for the notes to start low and as you work up the fingerboard they rise in pitch. Maybe it's my piano background. What do you reckon?
AL

For the left hand you would expect the low notes to be at the bottom, i.e. furthest away from the chin. For the right hand you'd expect the low notes to be at the top, i.e. closer to the chin.
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: brianread on August 13, 2009, 03:50:33 PM
In a moment of boredom I've just tried playing my little D/G the wrong way round. In other words the buttons on the left hand and bass in the right. Discovered it makes so much more sense for the notes to start low and as you work up the fingerboard they rise in pitch. Maybe it's my piano background. What do you reckon?
AL

Exactly the point I make all the time, however i suspect that the offset between the rows is the "wrong" way round making cross rowing a bit more of a problem.
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: Accordion Dave on August 13, 2009, 07:29:13 PM
There is a Tejano accordionist, Michael Salgado who plays his piano accordion upside down. In other words he plays the piano keyboard with the left hand. The right hand operates the bellows.

I believe that he ignores the bass buttons which is common in Tex-Mex music.
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: AndyShear on August 13, 2009, 08:39:14 PM
Been playing " the wrong way round " since I started, being left handed , and to me yes it seems to be the right arrangement , low notes at the bottom high at the top. But then I have known no different.

"Exactly the point I make all the time, however i suspect that the offset between the rows is the "wrong" way round making cross rowing a bit more of a problem"

Never found this the case , if you think about it tunes go up and down [ so assuming we are talking about cross rowing],so whats easier for a box the right way up is harder on a box the other way up , and whats harder for ......is easier , you get the idea .
The only time I found it a problem was when I played the PA then the angle of the bases did affect the way you have to hold your hand.
The only problem I've incountered playing what people tell me is upside down is if a box has stops on top or in my case the bottom of the treble end,but that does leave you getting one with leavers on the back which are good for switching mid flow which I couldn't imagine being an easy opperation with the other style of stops.
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: RGF on August 13, 2009, 09:23:50 PM
Al,

If you work, literally, "UP the fingerboard" on your piano, I'm left wondering how, exactly, you have the instrument positioned in the room!  :o

Bob
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: jonm on August 13, 2009, 10:41:36 PM
I play both piano accordion and melodeon left handed. The only problems I have encountered are reaching Hohner air buttons with the little finger and closing the stops on a one-row while playing it on the knee!!
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: triskel on August 14, 2009, 12:25:56 AM
Al,

If you work, literally, "UP the fingerboard" on your piano, I'm left wondering how, exactly, you have the instrument positioned in the room!  :o

Adds a whole new meaning to "upright" piano...  :o
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: brianread on August 14, 2009, 11:05:32 AM
I play both piano accordion and melodeon left handed. The only problems I have encountered are reaching Hohner air buttons with the little finger and closing the stops on a one-row while playing it on the knee!!

Most of my melodeons have an added air button at the (new) "top" (thanks to Rees quite a few years ago suggesting that), which makes it ok for me.  Stops on a one row are a problem however - they have a habit of closing unexpectedly.
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: brianread on August 14, 2009, 11:07:26 AM

"Exactly the point I make all the time, however i suspect that the offset between the rows is the "wrong" way round making cross rowing a bit more of a problem"

Never found this the case , if you think about it tunes go up and down [ so assuming we are talking about cross rowing],so whats easier for a box the right way up is harder on a box the other way up , and whats harder for ......is easier , you get the idea .
The only time I found it a problem was when I played the PA then the angle of the bases did affect the way you have to hold your hand.
 

True - perhaps I'll have to find another reason for my cross-rowing being not all it could be.
Title: Re: The wrong way round?
Post by: HallelujahAl on August 14, 2009, 11:20:55 AM
Yes, I found cross-rowing in fact to be a little easier as invariably it was my smaller fingers moving underneath my larger fingers to the outer row and back again. Much easier.

Ok I still find it difficult to play as I'm not left-handed. But the thought is there that maybe inverting the reedblock might make more sense?
AL
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal